$2,286,602Average Value$655Average Price per Sq Ft9Homes For Sale
A spacious, residential Westport community
A quiet suburb about 3 miles outside of downtown Westport, Coleytown offers large, luxury homes on generous lots. With a CAP Index Crime Score of 1 out of 10, the area is known for both its peaceful atmosphere and for being the home of late cinema icon, Paul Newman, who lived on a large, secluded property here. Realtor Jillian Klaff says the area is “not as congested as downtown Westport and has a more country feel in a beautiful section of town with its own flavor.” Klaff, currently with Coldwell Banker, has sold homes around Westport for 30 years and says homebuyers choose Coleytown over other neighborhoods for its expansive layout. “Properties are on 1 or more acres, but it is not too far from where all the action is. Residents enjoy all the special activities along with the rest of the town,” she adds. With highly rated schools, outdoor recreation and dining options within a few miles, the area offers a sense of privacy without having to travel far for amenities.
Sprawling residential lots in Coleytown
Coleytown homes often bear colonial or contemporary architecture, but homebuyers can also find large Cape Cods, luxury modern ranch styles and split levels. Homes tend to start at $735,000, which will generally secure around 2,400 square feet, three bedrooms and three bathrooms on just over 2 acres of land. Average prices range from $1.5 million to $4 million, though some newer, customized homes can surpass $10 million. “There are estate properties and antique homes here for people who favor bigger and more private lots, with room for pools and/or tennis courts,” Klaff says. Homes in the million-dollar price range tend to have added amenities like pools, outdoor entertainment spaces and spa areas. Properties often sit far from the roads and tucked under towering trees, which adds a layer of privacy and a sense of seclusion. Streets typically don’t have sidewalks, and residents may have to walk lengthy driveways to check their mail.
Coleytown’s colonial homes surrounded by trees is perfect for family living.
There are many styles of homes in Coleytown, CT.
1/2
Highly rated public education in Coleytown
Students in Coleytown are zoned for Westport Public Schools, which is recognized by Niche as the No. 1 district in Connecticut. With an A-plus rating overall and individual A-plus ratings across the board for clubs, teachers and college prep, the district is a major draw for homebuyers with school-aged children. The area's youngest learners start their academic journeys at Coleytown Elementary School, which has an A-plus rating on Niche and is the No. 4 elementary school in the state. Coleytown Middle also earns an A-plus and sits right next to Coleytown Elementary School, ensuring an easier carpool experience. Students can then transition to Staples High School, which scores an A-plus and ranks No. 2 in the state by Niche. This state-of-the-art high school has a massive campus with on-site athletic amenities.
Coleytown Elementary School is a top choice school for students located in Coleytown.
Coleytown Middle School serves students in grades 6th through 8th in Coleytown.
1/2
Hiking and water activities in Coleytown
There are numerous outdoor recreation spots in the area, including the Newman-Poses Preserve, an homage to Paul Newman that has trails across a variety of environments, such as wooded sections and small bodies of water. Larger rivers, like the nearby Saugatuck, provide places for swimming and fly fishing. Two popular country clubs, Aspetuck Valley and the Patterson Club, are also within a few miles. Klaff says that many residents opt to join Longshore, about 7 miles away, as well, which is a private town-owned facility with an 18-hole golf course, pools, tennis and pickleball courts. Sailing school is also available at the Longshore Inn, which is under renovation. Compo Beach is another well used spot that sits about 7 miles away and features a playground, sandy waterfront space and a food, beverage and ice cream pavilion.
The Longshore Sailing School is at the southern tip of Longshore near Coleytown.
Newman Poses Nature Preserve in Coleytown offers scenic trails and abundant wildlife.
Coleytown residents enjoy peaceful afternoons by the Saugatuck River with scenic views.
1/3
Shopping and dining on Post Road and in Saugatuck
Most dining options are on Main Street, Post Road and in the Saugatuck area. The Porch at Christie's is a closer local spot serving breakfast, lunch and sweet treats from its bakery. This casual restaurant often experiences an early-morning rush, with patrons grabbing their breakfast and chatting with neighbors. For groceries, shoppers can head about 4 miles to Lily’s Weston Market, which also has a butcher counter and prepared food bar. Trader Joe’s, The Fresh Market and Whole Foods are within 5 miles on Post Road. The closest Walmart is about 7 miles away, and retail stores, like Mitchells and Pottery Barn, have locations at The Village Center shopping mall.
The Fresh Market, south of Coleytown, is a beloved spot for fresh produce and unique finds.
Hudson Malone's is a local restaurant and bar for Coleytown that serves wonderful food.
1/2
Enjoying Westport traditions
Coleytown residents often head to downtown Westport for a variety of events and activities. Klaff mentions some popular traditions, such as Fourth of July fireworks at Compo Beach and the Memorial Day Parade downtown. The Temple Israel of Westport is a Jewish hub in the neighborhood that hosts events, such as golf nights and book clubs. Live music venue, Levitt Pavilion, hosts a free summer concert series and is about 3 miles from Coleytown.
Westport Train Station, 4 miles south of Coleytown, offers easy access to neighboring cities.
Coleytown transportation health care options
Merrit Parkway, one of the area’s main thoroughfares, is located along the southern border of Coleytown. Klaff says that a buddy bus is available to take commuters to and from the train station in Westport at peak times, though there is no public transportation. Tweed New Haven Airport is the closest major hub for air travel, about 33 miles away. For health care, Coleytown residents can head to Post Road for specialty clinics, and Bridgeport Hospital offers general care about 14 miles away via Interstate 95.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Coleytown, Westport sell after 53 days on the market compared to the national average of 52 days. The median sale price for homes in Coleytown, Westport over the last 12 months is $2,205,000, up 27% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Experience the elevated ease of modern luxury in this brand new SIGNATURE Home by SIR Development, Westport's most respected ground-up RE developer with 30+ years and 300+ completed homes. SIR carefully selects each property, designs every detail, and handpicks all finishes delivering a 100% complete, turnkey home. Perfectly positioned on a quiet, walkable street, this 6-BR, 5.2-bath residence
Single Family with legal accessory apartment. New 5 bedroom septic system- just installed and new furnace and hot water heater in apartment. Let your imagination soar in creating your ideal situation. The main house and the accessory apartment each has a fireplace, The main house has 3 bedrooms and the apartment 2 bedrooms and each has 2 full baths. Hardwood Floors, laminate floor, vinyl floor,
Come see the latest CCO Habitats new construction home - located at the end of a private road - 1 Hubbel's Lane - and buffered by non developable land for privacy. Only one mile to downtown/Main Street (.6 mile to Coffee An' for the best donuts in town!!) with sidewalks to make the stroll even easier! Walk the other way, and you're 1.5 miles from the newly renovated Coleytown school district.
Expected for completion Fall 2025, this striking architectural design meets refined luxury in a meticulously crafted 9,200+/- sq ft, 6-bedroom, 6 full, & 3 half bath new residence. Showcasing the collaborative excellence of AR Luxury Homes w/ interior design by Mary Beth Woods & architectural vision by Donald William Fairbanks, this exceptional property represents the pinnacle of modern
Amazing opportunity to live in desirable Coleytown neighborhood. Spacious Ranch with an open kitchen/living floorpan and light filled sunroom (extra 322 sqft not included in total footage) 3 bedrooms, and 2 full baths with pool. Flat yard walking distance to elementary and middle school. Wonderful chance to move right in, renovate and update or even potentially build new. A+ location! House is
A rare offering, this remarkable Frazier Peters stone home is a masterful blend of historic character and timeless elegance, set impressively at the top of Charcoal Hill on 2.3 breathtaking acres of fully-gated privacy. Obsessively maintained and reimagined by the current owners, the home was designed with Peters' signature use of native stone, rich wood, and artisan detail, making the residence
Property Id: 2122340Fabulous retreat from the city at a family compound like no other. Poised on 2.42 private acres, this Connecticut country home is beautifully renovated and surrounded exquisite landscaping. Relax on the covered front porch the terrace, gather with friends by the outdoor fireplace and roast smores by the firepit. A heated pool and spa, pool house, treehouse, zipline,
Flexible Long-term FURNISHED rental: $9500 yearly or $10500 short term FURNISHED. ALSO AVAILABLE UNFURNISHED SEE MLS#24126749. Fully remodeled, turn-key home on a premier estate property at the end of a cul-de-sac. Modern styling blends with a captivating private setting to create a unique oasis. Two acres of park-like property, abutting the Paul Newman-Poses Preserve, offer rare serenity in a
Flexible short-term UNFURNISHED rental: $8,750 yearly or $9,500 short-term. ALSO AVAILABLE FURNISHED SEE MLS# 24126753. Fully remodeled, turn-key home on a premier estate property at the end of a cul-de-sac. Modern styling blends with a captivating private setting to create a unique oasis. Two acres of park-like property, abutting the Paul Newman-Poses Preserve, offer rare serenity in a
Sound Score® measures the noise level of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
