$573,692Average Value$388Average Price per Sq Ft27Homes For Sale
Wyandanch's revitalization efforts
Two words that sum up Wyandanch’s spirit are resilient and enthusiastic. Barely more than a decade ago, the Babylon, Long Island, community was down on its luck. But was it out of the game? Not a chance. Since before 2013, town leaders have been working on a revitalization effort, eventually bringing thousands of square feet of housing, retail and office space to a community formerly known for being an economic blight. “Slowly but surely, Wyandanch is recovering its footing,” says Edmond Ryan, owner of Ed Ryan Real Estate Group in Islip. “It’s going through an incredible resurgence right now.”
Wyandanch has a welcoming sign to the neighborhood.
Wyandanch Village combines many attributes to create a great neighborhood.
1/2
Old and new homes in Wyandanch
Since Wyandanch is still in a state of growth, residential real estate costs are favorable to homebuyers who are looking for a good deal. Like a lot of communities in the middle of Long Island, Wyandanch experienced a housing boom after World War II, when towns on the south and north shores of the island were approaching population density and real estate costs were going up. In a sense, the community is an exurb of Suffolk County towns like Bay Shore, Babylon and Lindenhurst. Most of the housing stock in Wyandanch consists of hi-ranch, colonial and Cape Cod-style homes, ranging from $350,000 to $500,000. However, several new homes are under construction and prices start at nearly $575,000.
Wyandanch has a variety of house styles and sizes.
Manicured lawns are the norm in Wyandanch.
1/2
Prepping for college at Wyandanch Memorial High School
There are three public schools in Wyandanch. Teachers at La Francis Hardiman Elementary School earned a B rating from Niche. The website GreatSchools gave Milton L. Olive Middle School an eight out of 10 for student progress. Every year, Wyandanch Memorial High School hosts a college fair that’s attended by dozens of representatives from colleges, universities, trade schools and branches of the military. The school also invites Suffolk Community College to present students with a financial aid seminar.
Wyandanch Memorial High School is a top school located in Wyandanch, NY.
Milton L Olive Middle School is dedicated to achieving academic
excellence for all scholars.
1/2
Downtown's new dining scene
“It’s been great watching Wyandanch blossom,” says Ryan, a licensed real estate broker. “They’re in the process of sprucing up downtown and entrepreneurs are opening restaurants and retail stores on the ground floor of Wyandanch Village.” One of those eateries is Island Jerk, which serves Caribbean cuisine, such as a curry chicken plate with rice and plantains and oxtails with boiled dumplings.
Less than 2 miles away is a large supermarket, ShopRite of Deer Park. And 3 miles from Wyandanch is the Tanger Outlets of Deer Park, a large outlet mall with scores of national retail stores and restaurants, including Old Navy Outlet, Dick's Sporting Goods Warehouse and restaurants like Chipotle Mexican Grill. There’s also a movie theater.
For authentic Caribbean Cuisine in Wyandanch, check out the Island Jerk.
Great retail shopping at Tanger Outlets is just minutes from Wyandanch.
1/2
Access to LIRR
It’s no coincidence that Wyandanch Village was built next to the Long Island Rail Road. Town leaders wanted to make it easy for locals to commute to and from New York City boroughs. The renovated train station has an overpass with elevators linking the east and westbound platforms. It takes only an hour to get from Wyandanch to Penn Station in Manhattan.
Ice skating at The Rinx
In the center of Wyandanch Village is a pedestrian park and ice-skating rink. In the winter, The Rinx hosts various events, including an annual holiday show, as well as special fundraisers. Throughout the year, locals flock to the grassy plaza to meet friends, walk their dogs and watch the kids enjoy a day in the sun. Wyandanch Park, on the south side of the community, hosts events like “Wyandanch Family Day,” featuring a parade and vendors. It’s also a great chance for local residents to meet community leaders. During the dog days of summer, kids can cool down on the splash pad at Geiger Park. It’s also a quick drive over the Great South Bay Bridge to Robert Moses State Park on Fire Island — about 12 miles from Wyandanch.
Wyandanch Park is a small local park the community can take advantage of for family fun.
Residents of Wyandanch can enjoy a relaxing view at Geiger Lake Memorial Park.
1/2
Written By
Hannah Rainey
Photography Contributed By
Jeff Rainone
Video By
Amon Parson
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Sergio Balza,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Wyandanch, NY sell after 59 days on the market compared to the national average of 57 days. The median sale price for homes in Wyandanch, NY over the last 12 months is $565,000, up 9% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Welcome to 144 Washington Ave in Wheatley Heights. Thoughtfully Renovated in 2020 and 2024. This 3-bedroom Colonial Style House Showcases a Bright Open-Concept Layout with Remarkable Eat-in Kitchen Equipped with Stainless Steel Appliances (including a dishwasher), Quartz Countertop. Natural Light Fills the Living Space, Creating a Warm and Inviting Atmosphere Perfect for Both Everyday Living and
Exceptional opportunity to own a 40x100 parcel in desirable Wyandanch. This property offers tremendous potential for builders, investors, or end-users looking to create their dream home. Conveniently located near shopping, transportation, and major roadways. Don’t miss this chance to secure a prime piece of land with endless possibilities!
Welcome to 144 Washington Ave in Wheatley Heights. Thoughtfully Renovated in 2020 and 2024. This 3-bedroom Colonial Style House Showcases a Bright Open-Concept Layout with Remarkable Eat-in Kitchen Equipped with Stainless Steel Appliances (including a dishwasher), Quartz Countertop. Natural Light Fills the Living Space, Creating a Warm and Inviting Atmosphere Perfect for Both Everyday Living and
Charming ranch featuring an open floor plan with great flow! Primary bedroom includes a private half bath, plus a spacious den or bedroom and convenient main-level laundry area. Full unfinished basement with outside entrance and full bathroom offers excellent potential. Situated on a nice size property with room to expand or entertain!
Property has not been built!!! Exciting new construction plans available for 83 Arlington Avenue, Wyandanch! This upcoming home will feature modern design, quality finishes, and spacious living to suit today’s lifestyle. Conveniently located near schools, shopping, and transportation, this is a great opportunity to own a brand-new home in a growing community. Don’t miss the chance to customize
Introducing a stunning new construction Colonial designed to impress at every turn. Estimated for completion in August 2026, this beautifully crafted home offers 4 bedrooms but lives like a 5-bedroom, featuring a versatile first-floor office/study with closet space—perfect as a guest suite or additional bedroom.Built by an experienced developer with a proven track record of delivering
Come check out this Move-in ready with masterpiece upgrades throughout. This beautifully updated 4-bedroom 3-bathroom home features a cozy fireplaces, central air, chandelier lighting, and exquisite decor. Modern conveniences meet timeless style for effortless living. Close to the train and shopping malls.
Step into a home where everything feels just right from the moment you arrive. This beautifully refreshed colonial blends modern comfort with everyday convenience. With thoughtful updates completed throughout 2024 and 2025, it offers the ease of “move right in” living—no projects, no delays, just a home ready for you. Picture starting your mornings in a bright, inviting kitchen with brand-new
A truly unique Hi-Ranch in the Heart of NORTH BABYLON offering a Mother/Daughter setup, Already have a permit. Set on an oversized lot tucked away on a quiet residential street with no through traffic and just minutes to major highways. With great curb appeal and a paver driveway, this home makes a striking first impression.Inside, first floor comes with an occupied tenant paying $2500 in
Large 140X100 (14,000 sq ft) vacant lot. Oversized parcel with 140 ft of frontage. Possible 2-lot subdivision potential, subject to local zoning and approvals.Ideal for a builder or investor. Near Transportation, Parks And Shops.
Do Not Miss Out On This Nicely Maintained House!!! Everything Is Mint From Top To Bottom!!! 4 Bedrooms, 2 Full Bathrooms!!! This House Is Turn Key And All You Do Is Have To Move In!!!
Welcome to a great opportunity! This 4 bedroom 1 bath Cape is Set on an oversized lot with ample parking and strong curb appeal, located right next to a dead end street. This home is perfect for someone looking for an investment opportunity ! Look no further! This home does need updating inside. But features a new roof, new siding and new windows . This home is occupied by a tenant who receives
Welcome to this spacious 5-bedroom, 2 full bath home in Wyandanch. Conveniently located with easy access to shopping, transportation, and more. House has been freshly painted all nice size rooms.
Step into a new chapter at Zen Long Island at Wheatley Heights, where your active lifestyle flourishes in a welcoming community atmosphere. Our 55+ adult community lets you embrace each day on your terms while fostering meaningful connections with neighbors. Trade the responsibilities of home maintenance for the freedom to live life exactly as you choose.
Do Not Miss This 3 Bedroom Main Level Apartment! Spacious Living Room/Dining Room Combo, Backyard Access, Driveway Parking & More! Utilities Not Include, To Be Paid By Tenants. All Legal Sources of Funds Accepted.
This beautiful Cottage awaits!! One bedroom, living room, kitchen, and bath room. Private entrance, water is included. Tenants must pay their own electric, and installing cable & internet is ok. This must also be done and paid for by tenants, no smoking allowed. Smoke & Carbon Monoxide detectors are provided by landlord. No pets allowed! All legal forms of income are accepted.
Stacey Hargraves-LucasKeller Williams Realty Greater
Welcome! Newly renovated basement apartment with utilities included (heat, water, and electricity). Features brand-new appliances and a newly renovated kitchen, bathroom, and three bedrooms.Smoke-free home No pets Free Parking (Street)Private Entrance Seeking quiet, respectful adult tenants (up to 4 people) who will help maintain a clean, peaceful living
$2,800 per month
2 Beds
1 Bath
750 Sq Ft
Fully renovated and move-in ready 2-bedroom, 1-bath rental offering modern updates and comfortable living. This beautifully updated home features a brand-new kitchen with stylish finishes, a completely renovated full bathroom, new flooring throughout, and fresh paint from top to bottom. Enjoy the convenience of in-unit laundry, propane gas cooking, and electricity included in the rent. Step
Keep it simple at this peaceful and centrally-located One bedroom Apartment. Private Entrance Free parking and wifi on premises. Utilities included. Kitchenette and office space available for your convenience. Smart TV with Netflix and Prime available. This apartment is ideal for ONE individual seeking ONE YEAR LEASE. Short stay rates available. Ideal for Students, travel nurses, business
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
