216

Safest Neighborhoods in Long Island, NY

  • /29

    Merrick

    Merrick, Long Island, features waterfront living with private docks. Norman J. Levy Park offers unique attractions. Merrick Road has diverse shopping. The area has highly rated schools and lower crime risk than average.

    • Average Value

      $919K

    • List Price

      $615K - $1.9M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      41 Listings

    Merrick
  • /41

    Bayville

    Bayville, NY, is a beachfront village on Long Island's North Shore with scenic Long Island Sound views. The community features white-sand beaches, a vibrant culinary scene, and highly rated schools like Locust Valley High School.

    • Average Value

      $913K

    • List Price

      $603K - $3.9M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      27 Listings

    Bayville
  • /28

    Eastern Fire Island

    Eastern Fire Island in Brookhaven is a car-free barrier island with pristine beaches and wilderness areas. It offers hiking, swimming, and boating. East Moriches Elementary and Center Moriches Middle School are highly rated.

    • Average Value

      $896K

    • List Price

      $756K - $1.7M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      2 Listings

    Eastern Fire Island
  • /28

    Gilgo-Oak Beach-Captree

    As a string of communities on barrier islands off the coast of Long Island, life in Gilgo-Oak Beach-Captree slips along at a different pace from life on the mainland. “We love it. We love the beach, we love that it’s a little bit private out here and you’re kind of living in a park,” says Marianne Verzolini, a licensed real estate salesperson at

    • Average Value

      $894K

    • List Price

      $528K - $2M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      5 Listings

    Gilgo-Oak Beach-Captree
  • /31

    Stewart Manor

    Stewart Manor, NY, is a quaint village 20 miles east of NYC with cape cod and Victorian homes. Belmont Park and UBS Arena offer horse racing and concerts. Local businesses line Covert Avenue and Jericho Turnpike.

    • Average Value

      $887K

    • List Price

      $710K - $1.5M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      2 Listings

    Stewart Manor
  • /35

    Hewlett

    Hewlett, Long Island, features diverse housing and Grant Park as a community hub. Broadway hosts local businesses. Highly rated schools include Franklin Early Childhood Center. JFK Airport is nearby, 6 miles away.

    • Average Value

      $886K

    • List Price

      $194K - $1.7M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      32 Listings

    Hewlett
  • /32

    Setauket-East Setauket

    Setauket-East Setauket in East Setauket blends history with waterfront charm. It has highly rated schools, Frank Melville Memorial Park, and eateries on North Country Road. The area is safer than the national average.

    • Average Value

      $885K

    • List Price

      $225K - $3.6M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      45 Listings

    Setauket-East Setauket
  • /32

    Elwood

    Elwood, Long Island features diverse mid-century and newer homes. This area is safer than the national average and offers top-rated schools. Elwood Park and nearby shopping centers provide recreation and convenience.

    • Average Value

      $883K

    • List Price

      $575K - $2.1M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      19 Listings

    Elwood
  • /27

    New Hyde Park

    New Hyde Park in Long Island features highly rated schools and easy Manhattan commutes. Jericho Turnpike offers popular dining, while Memorial Park provides recreation. The area has lower crime risk than the national average.

    • Average Value

      $876K

    • List Price

      $700K - $1.5M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      11 Listings

    New Hyde Park
  • /33

    East Moriches

    East Moriches, Long Island, combines rural charm with suburban living. Waterfront communities offer private beaches and boat slips. The area has highly rated schools, lower crime risk than average, and Terrell River County Park.

    • Average Value

      $874K

    • List Price

      $585K - $2.4M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      20 Listings

    East Moriches
  • /23

    West Islip

    West Islip, Long Island, is a waterfront community with canals and marinas. West Islip Beach and Gardiner County Park are nearby. The area has lower crime risk and highly rated schools, appealing to families and boaters.

    • Average Value

      $873K

    • List Price

      $530K - $3.5M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      33 Listings

    West Islip
  • /29

    Massapequa

    Massapequa on Long Island features waterfront views, beaches, and parks. The area has highly rated schools and a close community. All American Hamburger Drive In is a local favorite. LIRR provides access to Manhattan.

    • Average Value

      $865K

    • List Price

      $600K - $2M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      25 Listings

    Massapequa
  • /28

    Garden City South

    Garden City South in Long Island features highly rated schools such as Washington Street School and H. Frank Carey High School, local shops, parks, and train access to Manhattan. The area is safer than the national average.

    • Average Value

      $865K

    • List Price

      $666K - $1.4M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      3 Listings

    Garden City South
  • /38

    Babylon

    Babylon, NY, is a seaside village of 12,000. The Babylon Village Dock and Argyle Lake Park highlight its marine culture. Highly rated schools serve the area. Deer Park Avenue offers local dining. Manhattan is an hour by train.

    • Average Value

      $859K

    • List Price

      $458K - $2.6M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      28 Listings

    Babylon
  • /28

    South Valley Stream

    South Valley Stream in Long Island blends suburban living with city access. Highly rated schools, Green Acres Mall, and Brook Road Park enhance the area. The Long Island Rail Road connects to Manhattan in 35 minutes.

    • Average Value

      $859K

    • List Price

      $594K - $2.5M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      13 Listings

    South Valley Stream
  • /35

    Village of the Branch

    Village of the Branch on Long Island features a historic district and highly rated schools. This small, incorporated area offers a close-knit community near Smithtown's Main Street, with parks and train access to New York City.

    • Average Value

      $852K

    • List Price

      $656K - $1.6M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      5 Listings

    Village of the Branch
  • /26

    Greenlawn

    Greenlawn, on Long Island, is a suburb with lower crime risk than the national average. It features nature preserves, parks, and a vibrant downtown on Broadway Greenlawn. The Harborfields Central School District is highly rated.

    • Average Value

      $852K

    • List Price

      $531K - $2M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      21 Listings

    Greenlawn
  • /25

    Bayport

    Bayport, on Long Island, features outdoor activities at Bayport Beach and Roosevelt Estate County Park. People's Pub is a local favorite. The area has lower crime risk than the national average and highly rated schools.

    • Average Value

      $851K

    • List Price

      $560K - $1.8M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      7 Listings

    Bayport
  • /34

    Williston Park

    Williston Park, NY, is a family-oriented community with early 20th-century homes and longstanding businesses like Hildebrandt's. It boasts highly rated schools in the Herricks district and local parks for community events.

    • Average Value

      $848K

    • List Price

      $464K - $1.5M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      9 Listings

    Williston Park
  • /24

    Commack

    Commack, NY, 43 miles from Manhattan, has spacious 1960s homes and easy highway access. Hoyt Farm Nature Preserve offers trails and rescued animals. The area has highly rated schools and lower crime risk than average.

    • Average Value

      $847K

    • List Price

      $613K - $1.5M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      45 Listings

    Commack
  • /24

    Carle Place

    Carle Place, Long Island has lower crime risk than the national average. Cherry Lane School and Rushmore Avenue School are highly rated. Charles J. Fuschillo Park and Roosevelt Field mall are notable points of interest.

    • Average Value

      $841K

    • List Price

      $607K - $1.6M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      11 Listings

    Carle Place
  • /32

    Smithtown

    Smithtown, Long Island features highly rated schools and a bustling downtown. The Nissequogue River and nearby parks offer outdoor recreation. Commuters have access to the Long Island Railroad for trips to New York City.

    • Average Value

      $839K

    • List Price

      $551K - $2.3M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      44 Listings

    Smithtown
  • /22

    Wantagh

    Wantagh on Long Island, known as the "Gateway to Jones Beach," has extensive parks, highly rated schools, and a vibrant downtown. The area is safer than the national average and provides train access to NYC from Wantagh Station.

    • Average Value

      $838K

    • List Price

      $630K - $1.8M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      16 Listings

    Wantagh
  • /25

    Salisbury

    Salisbury, on Long Island, features midcentury homes and newer builds. It borders Eisenhower Park for recreation. The area has lower crime risk than the national average and highly rated schools. Local eateries line Carman Avenue.

    • Average Value

      $834K

    • List Price

      $623K - $2.3M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      14 Listings

    Salisbury
  • /35

    Shoreham

    Shoreham, NY is a coastal village with beaches and parks. The Tesla Science Center and Rocky Point State Pine Barrens Preserve are key attractions. Shoreham-Wading River Central School District has highly rated schools.

    • Average Value

      $826K

    • List Price

      $624K - $1.7M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      3 Listings

    Shoreham

Showing Results 101 - 125, Page 5 of 9