Neighborhoods in Wyoming County, NY

Bennington

Eighteen miles southwest of Batavia, Bennington is a quiet town offering rustic seclusion and single-family home prices below the national median. “People are drawn to the area because it is still very rural,” says Joanne Rosenthal, town clerk. Shopping and dining options are limited, but farm stands are a common sight. “People … put their
- Average Value
  
  $327K
- List Price
  
  $74K - $789K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  5 Listings
Bennington
Orangeville

Orangeville offers a rural lifestyle outside of Buffalo defined by open landscapes and agricultural roots. Home to about 1,300 residents, the town is dotted with working wind, dairy and produce farms, creating a strong sense of connection to the land. “Orangeville is very rural and not as developed, but it has potential,” says Alyssa Cutcliffe, a
- Average Value
  
  $280K
- List Price
  
  $37K - $875K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  5 Listings
Orangeville
/24
Sheldon

Sheldon, 30 miles from Buffalo, is a country community with roadside farmstands and open space. “This is a nice rural farm area,” says Melissa Haenle, a resident and agent with WNY Metro Roberts Realty, who has worked in the industry for 11 years. “We don’t find many properties that go on the market in Sheldon. They're usually over an acre lots,
- Average Value
  
  $276K
- List Price
  
  $40K - $484K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  0 Listings
Sheldon
Java

Among the gently rolling hills of farmland and woods of Wyoming County is the town of Java, where people live in hamlets or close to Java Lake in the Java Lake Colony. “It has a small private lake for kayaking, but people are starting to discover it,” says Brenda Bacon, an experienced Realtor with Howard Hanna Real Estate Services who also lives
- Average Value
  
  $257K
- List Price
  
  $73K - $827K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  2 Listings
Java
Arcade

Arcade is at the convergence of three counties, providing access to Olean, 34 miles away, and Buffalo, 42 miles away. “We’re in an area where three counties come together. It's called the tri-county area,” says Brenda Bacon, associate broker with Howard Hanna Real Estate Services. Bacon lives in the area and has worked here for 40 years. “So, you
- Average Value
  
  $252K
- List Price
  
  $144K - $537K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  3 Listings
Arcade
Covington

Covington is a small rural community in Wyoming County with few businesses or parks, but plenty of space for acreage. Properties are spread out across forested landscapes, but surrounding villages provide a sense of close-knit community. “Even though they might not be able to see their neighbor next to them, when they go into the town, they’re
- Average Value
  
  $246K
- List Price
  
  $48K - $340K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  0 Listings
Covington
Attica

Eleven miles southwest of Batavia, Attica is a bucolic town encompassing the village of the same name with single-family home prices below the national median. "It's a nice town," says Lori Koerner, a real estate agent at S.A.W. Commission Cutters with over 13 years of experience. "It's a hilly area — it's country." Village streets are lined with
- Average Value
  
  $234K
- List Price
  
  $144K - $504K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  5 Listings
Attica
Castile

Located midway between Buffalo and Rochester, Castile is a small rural community of less than 3,000 people in Wyoming County. The town includes the village of Castile and a few small hamlets. Encircled by fertile farmland, Castile offers a slow pace of life just a few minutes away from the beauty of Letchworth State Park, a scenic and sprawling
- Average Value
  
  $233K
- List Price
  
  $54K - $880K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  6 Listings
Castile
Eagle

Not every person who moves to the Finger Lakes region of New York is looking for a vacation home on the water. Some people prefer life in a quiet town like Eagle in Wyoming County, where there are homes surrounded by rolling farmland and tucked along residential streets in the village of Bliss. “It’s a quaint, small town,” says Brenda Bacon, a
- Average Value
  
  $237K
- List Price
  
  $226K - $781K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  2 Listings
Eagle
Wethersfield

With rolling farmland and vast woodlands, Wethersfield offers rural living in Wyoming County, about 45 miles from Buffalo. Residents enjoy country living, remote farm properties and plenty of wide-open green space, although it’s a commute to dining and shopping destinations. Agriculture is the main driver of the local economy, including several
- Average Value
  
  $227K
- List Price
  
  $51K - $565K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  0 Listings
Wethersfield
Middlebury

Middlebury, 15 miles north of Batavia, is a pastoral town centered around the quiet village of Wyoming. “It very much feels like the old-school Mayberry,” says Alex Nobles, associate pastor at the First Baptist Church of Wyoming. “[You] say ‘Hey’ to your neighbors because you know them, and your grandma knows them.” Founded in 1812, the town is
- Average Value
  
  $216K
- List Price
  
  $150K - $762K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  1 Listing
Middlebury
Pike

Pike is one of many tiny town centers in the rolling forests and pastures of western New York. Despite its size, it gets a decent number of visitors because of its proximity to Letchworth State Park, acclaimed as the Grand Canyon of the East. “Quite a few people stay here to go to Letchworth,” says Billy Proietti, the general manager of Letchworth
- Average Value
  
  $208K
- List Price
  
  $68K - $912K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  4 Listings
Pike
Warsaw

Between the urban energy of Rochester and Buffalo , Warsaw embodies small-town life with just over 5,000 residents who form a close-knit community amid rolling fields and a historic core. Though rural in character, the town’s modest downtown serves as a hub for connection, its streets coming alive during local festivals and art shows, as well as through the
- Average Value
  
  $197K
- List Price
  
  $55K - $631K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  7 Listings
Warsaw
Gainesville

In the early 1800s, Gainesville established itself as a farming community in upstate New York. Today, its residents still enjoy the rural life about an hour from Buffalo and Rochester . “If you’re a person of city life, it’s not your area," says David Granger, who has lived in Gainesville for more than 50 years. "It’s more of a mind-your-own-business
- Average Value
  
  $188K
- List Price
  
  $53K - $397K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  1 Listing
Gainesville
Perry

Centered on a colorful Main Street district and bordered by Silver Lake, Perry is a small community in western New York, offering a quieter, rural lifestyle compared to larger cities. “We’re in New York, but it’s nothing like New York City,” says Charles Flynn, an associate real estate broker with more than 10 years of experience. “It’s more like
- Average Value
  
  $185K
- List Price
  
  $28K - $527K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  6 Listings
Perry

New York Wyoming County

Neighborhoods in Nearby Cities

More About Living in Wyoming County

Homes in Nearby Cities

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.

Homes.com Licensing Information

§ 442-H New York Standard Operating Procedures

New York Fair Housing Notice

TREC: Information about brokerage services, Consumer protection notice

California DRE #01937601

Contact Homes.com Brokerage