New Carlisle, OH Homes for Sale under $400,000

This Home is What Dreams are Made of! Discover a truly exceptional residence where storybook charm meets contemporary luxury, creating an enchanting haven unlike any other. This delightful property has undergone a complete renovation, meticulously finished in 2025/2026, ensuring every detail reflects modern living and superb comfort. The extensive updates include a brand-new HVAC system with new

Kevin Johnson RE/MAX Alliance Realty

Lot 4 - 23.991 Acres Nearly 24 Acres of Privacy & Prestige in Shaw Meadows A rare opportunity to own nearly 24 acres in the sought-after Shaw Meadows community. This expansive homesite offers a private, open setting complemented by natural tree borders--an ideal canvas for a custom luxury home designed to your exact vision. Exclusively available with D.A. Bowman Construction, a premier custom

Dustin Leis Leis Realty

Spacious tri level on a half acre lot with open farm field to the rear. A rural street of like homes conveniently located to the schools. Shopping within minutes in various directions. Low maintenance brick and vinyl exterior. Four bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and formal and casual living areas. Excellent, moist, hot water heat with central air added to the home at main level and upper level. Lower level

Marcia Moore Coldwell Banker Heritage

This occupied multi-family property is a fantastic addition to any investor's portfolio, currently generating $3,035/month in rental income. All four units will be tenant-occupied, providing immediate cash flow from day one.The property features a desirable unit mix of two 2-bedroom, 1-bath units and two 1-bedroom, 1-bath units, appealing to a wide range of tenants. Each unit includes a range,

Sunil Dhingra Always Sunny Realty, LLC

Discover the stunning Newcastle, a new ranch-style home nestled within the Reserve at Honey Creek community, offering an unparalleled living experience. This residence features three bedrooms and two baths across 1,635 square feet of modern, thoughtfully designed space. The open layout, adorned with elegant laminate flooring, provides an abundance of room, creating a perfect environment for both

James McKinney D.R. Horton Realty of Ohio Inc

Welcome to peaceful country living! This charming 3-bedroom, 2 full bathroom ranch sits on 2.78 acres of serene rural landscape, surrounded by picturesque cornfields and offering the privacy you’ve been looking for.Step inside to find a freshly updated interior featuring new LVP flooring throughout and a fresh coat of paint, creating a clean and inviting space ready for your personal touch.

Ana Krohn eXp Realty

Nestled in a vibrant community, this property at 312 W Jefferson St is ideally positioned to enjoy local amenities and the charm of New Carlisle. The strategic location provides easy access to key areas, enhancing its appeal for tenants and owners alike. Discover an exceptional investment opportunity in the heart of New Carlisle, where convenience meets potential. This expansive multi-family

Julie Hay Howard Hanna Real Estate Serv

Lot 3 - 23.991 Acres A Private, Tree-Lined Setting for a One-of-a-Kind Luxury Estate Discover the perfect blend of luxury, land, and lifestyle with this 23.991-acre homesite in Shaw Meadows. Featuring beautiful tree lines running through the property, this lot offers a unique, nature-inspired setting ideal for a private custom estate. Offered exclusively with D.A. Bowman Construction, this

Dustin Leis Leis Realty

Lot 2 - 23.991 Acres Expansive Acreage with Dual Road Frontage for Your Custom Estate Vision Welcome to Shaw Meadows--where luxury living meets wide-open space and refined country living. This impressive 23.991-acre homesite features frontage along both Agenbroad Rd and Dayton-Brandt Rd, offering exceptional flexibility for access, layout, and design of your custom-built home. Exclusively

Dustin Leis Leis Realty