11

Plymouth, NY Homes for Sale

Section Image
  • /93

    $1,199,000

    • 4 Beds
    • 3 Baths
    • 3,800 Sq Ft

    213 Jones Peck Rd, Smyrna, NY 13464

    This stunning country home was built in 2015, clearly with taste and quality throughout for the discerning new owner. Beautifully situated, well back from the road and offering commanding views from the huge wrap around covered porch of its 8 acres of mostly open meadows, this spacious 3800 sq. ft. home features 4 bedrooms and 3 full baths with 1st floor 10 foot ceilings, while the 2nd floor and

    John Myers WHITETAIL PROPERTIES REAL ESTATE LLC (NY)

    213 Jones Peck Rd, Smyrna, NY 13464
  • /53

    $199,000

    • 3 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,700 Sq Ft

    188 Reservoir Hill Rd, South Plymouth, NY 13844

    Charming 3 Bedroom 2 Bath manufactured Ranch Style home on almost 4 acres. The kitchen is wide open with tall cabinets and a Large Built-in Island, plenty of storage underneath as well as a huge walk in pantry, Stainless Steel appliances. Step down into a wide open floor plan to living room making entertaining easy well prepping in the kitchen, Living room and Kitchen have a cathedral ceiling

    Josh Buell WHITETAIL PROPERTIES REAL ESTATE LLC (NY)

    188 Reservoir Hill Rd, South Plymouth, NY 13844
  • /126

    $949,900

    • 4 Beds
    • 6.5 Baths
    • 4,896 Sq Ft

    1921 County Road 16 Unit LotWP002, Plymouth, NY 13832

    "The Preserve" is an extraordinary home where Adirondack style meets Yellowstone - on 36 +/- acres with 2 barns, grass field, woods, natural pond & feeder trout stream. Built in 2005, this 4896 sq. ft. stick frame home features massive log pillars, 12" half-log western ponderosa pine siding, 4 oversized bedrooms, 6.5 baths, huge dining room, 2 living rooms and a truly gourmet kitchen. An

    Josh Buell Whitetail Properties Real Estate

    1921 County Road 16 Unit LotWP002, Plymouth, NY 13832
  • /27

    $119,000

    • Land
    • 32.59 Acres
    • $3,651 per Acre

    0WP State Route 26 Unit LotWP001, Plymouth, NY 13832

    With over 32 acres of woods adjoining 3,090 acres of the Muller Hill State Forest, you can own this perfectly situated property with ready access to thousands of pristine acres for the avid outdoor enthusiast at a very affordable price. The land is heavily wooded, with two natural springs, and features a mix of hardwoods, predominantly maple, and an east-facing slope, making it ideal for maple

    Josh Buell Whitetail Properties Real Estate

    0WP State Route 26 Unit LotWP001, Plymouth, NY 13832
  • /136

    $1,250,000

    • 4 Beds
    • 6.5 Baths
    • 4,896 Sq Ft

    1921 County Road 16, Plymouth, NY 13832

    "The Preserve" is an extraordinary home where Adirondack style meets Yellowstone - on 150 +/- acres w 2 barns, 17+/- acres of ag fields, 2 ponds, feeder trout stream and woodlot with timber. Built in 2005, this 4896 sq. ft. stick frame home features massive log pillars, 12" half-log western ponderosa pine siding, 4 oversized bedrooms, 6.5 baths, huge dining room, 2 living rooms and a truly

    Josh Buell Whitetail Properties Real Estate

    1921 County Road 16, Plymouth, NY 13832
  • /53

    $131,500

    • Land
    • 52.33 Acres
    • $2,513 per Acre

    Reservoir Hill Rd, South Plymouth, NY 13844

    52 Acres with Stream, State Land Access & Hunting Setup Located in scenic Chenango County, this 52-acre parcel offers a rare combination of natural beauty, privacy, and outdoor recreation. A running stream flows through the property, providing a reliable water source for wildlife and enriching the diverse habitat. The land features a balanced mix of forest and open space, ideal for hunting,

    Thomas Dziekan Future Forest Properties LLC

    Reservoir Hill Rd, South Plymouth, NY 13844
  • /50

    $131,500

    • Land
    • 52.33 Acres
    • $2,513 per Acre

    0 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13832

    --- **52 Acres with Stream, State Land Access & Hunting Setup Located in scenic Chenango County, this 52-acre parcel offers a rare combination of natural beauty, privacy, and outdoor recreation. A running stream flows through the property, providing a reliable water source for wildlife and enriching the diverse habitat. The land features a balanced mix of forest and open space, ideal for hunting,

    Thomas Dziekan Listing by Future Forest Properties LLC

    0 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13832
  • /50

    $429,000

    • 4 Beds
    • 3 Baths
    • 3,192 Sq Ft

    186 Bates Wilson Rd, South Plymouth, NY 13844

    This spacious 3,100+ square-foot contemporary home offers comfort, style, and room to grow. As you approach, you’re greeted by serene views of two large ponds that set a peaceful tone before you even step inside. The main level features an open-concept layout that seamlessly connects the kitchen, dining area with a cozy gas fireplace, and an expansive living space complete with a built-in

    Karen Cammarata Listing by Howard Hanna

    186 Bates Wilson Rd, South Plymouth, NY 13844
  • /18

    $32,000

    • 3 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 1,346 Sq Ft

    454 County Route 16, Plymouth, NY 13832

    *****All Investors! All Future Homeowners! ***** Welcome To 454 County Route 16. This Domicile Has A Big Front And Backyard. There Is Ample Storage Space Throughout The Dwelling. This Residence Falls Within The Norwich School District! Did I Mention The Picturesque Scenery? The List Does Not Stop! This Hidden Gem Is Just Waiting To Be Polished. Cash. As Is.

    Amjad Mughal M J J Realty

    454 County Route 16, Plymouth, NY 13832
  • /27

    $119,000

    • Land
    • 32.59 Acres
    • $3,651 per Acre

    0WP State Route 26, Plymouth, NY 13832

    With over 32 acres of woods adjoining 3,090 acres of the Muller Hill State Forest, you can own this perfectly situated property with ready access to thousands of pristine acres for the avid outdoor enthusiast at a very affordable price. The land is heavily wooded with two natural springs and features a mix of hardwoods, predominantly maple, and an east facing slope, making it ideal for maple sap

    John Myers WHITETAIL PROPERTIES REAL ESTATE LLC (NY)

    0WP State Route 26, Plymouth, NY 13832
  • /13

    $89,000

    • Land
    • 22,442 Sq Ft
    • $172,748 per Acre

    199 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815

    Discover your own private lakeside escape with this rare 0.52-acre property offering over 140 feet of direct lake access. Perfectly situated, the lot features a unique peninsula that extends into the water, an ideal spot for fishing, relaxing, or soaking in the surrounding beauty. A dock is available, making it easy to enjoy boating, kayaking, or simply unwinding by the water’s edge. This

    Michael Arcuri Listing by Assist2Sell Buyers & Sellers 1st Choice

    199 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815

Why Live in Plymouth

Plymouth, NY, offers a rural lifestyle amidst forested hills and quiet backroads. The community lacks a town center and stop lights, relying on state Route 23 to connect its neighborhoods, including Kirk, Sherburne Four Corners, South Plymouth, and Stuart Corners. Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate Plymouth Reservoir, which is popular for largemouth bass fishing and features a hiking loop that connects to the 9-Mile Truck Trail in Pharsalia Woods State Forest. Other nearby state forests, such as Pigeon Hill and New Michigan, provide additional recreational opportunities. The Wolf Mountain Nature Center to the north offers a chance to observe gray wolves, coyotes, and foxes in their natural habitat. Housing in Plymouth consists mainly of rustic cabins, ranch-style homes, and farmhouses, with some lakeside cottages near the reservoir. Most residents own their homes, and properties range from compact cabins to expansive farmhouses on large plots of land. While local retail is limited, residents often travel to nearby Norwich, 5 miles south, for dining, groceries, and entertainment. Norwich features cafes, pizzerias, grills, and bars, as well as the Northeast Classic Car Museum and UHS Chenango Memorial Hospital. The annual Chenango County Fair in Norwich is a highlight, offering stock shows, tractor pulls, and carnival rides. Plymouth is car-dependent, with Route 23 providing access to larger cities like Syracuse, 50 miles away, and further travel options from Syracuse Hancock International Airport.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average home price in Plymouth, NY?
Homes for sale in Plymouth, NY have an average home price of $372,011.
Are home prices dropping in Plymouth?
Yes, home prices in Plymouth are down 7% in the last 12 months.
How many homes have sold over the last 12 months in Plymouth, NY?
5 homes have sold in Plymouth, NY over the last 12 months.
What are the most popular zip codes in Plymouth, NY?
The most popular zip codes in Plymouth, NY include 13815, 13832, 13464, 13844 and 13460.
How much do you need to make to afford a house in Plymouth?
The median home price in Plymouth is $159,500. If you put a 20% down payment of $31,900 and had a 30-year fixed mortgage with an interest rate of 6.37%, your estimated principal and interest payment would be $800 a month plus property taxes, HOA fees, home insurance, PMI, and utilities. Using the 28% rule, you would need to make at least $34K a year to afford the median home price in Plymouth. Learn how much home you can afford with our Home Affordability Calculator.
How are the schools in Plymouth, NY?
Plymouth, NY has highly rated public and private schools. Some of the best schools in Plymouth based on Niche Grades are Valley Heights Christian Academy, Sherburne-Earlville Senior High School and Norwich High School. Browse all the schools in Plymouth, NY to learn more.

Home Trends in Plymouth, NY

Housing Trends

Median Sale Price
$149,000
Median Single Family Sale Price
$89,000
Average Price Per Sq Ft
$214
Number of Homes for Sale
4
Last 12 months Home Sales
5
Months of Supply
9.60
Median List Price
$159,500
Median Change From 1st List Price
21%
Median Home Sale Price YoY Change
-4%
How to Buy a Home How to Finance a Home How to Sell a Home