Barbara Bodnar

2/2/26Samvidaananda Saraswati

Google Review

Barbara is a wonderful realtor. Her expertise and experience really shows. She explains every step along the way clearly, and she was available to answer my questions whenever I needed her. I especially appreciated her steady good humor and her kindness throughout the process. She's a professional in every sense of the word and I highly recommend her (and Nathalie- they're a great team!) to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

10/29/25Linda Sampson

Google Review

Barbara is AWESOME!!!

9/8/25Mike Libertini

Google Review

Super knowledgeable and communicative professional! Barb was super helpful and extremely knowledgeable with this co-op sale. A complicated process made easy with Barbara’s help and expertise!

8/29/25Peter Raider

Google Review

Barb has been one of my closest and dearest industry friends for over 20 years.
We have collaborated on many transactions and when it comes to Yorktown/Peekskill she is the absolute best broker there is!!

8/29/25Ryan Mann

Google Review

Barbara is an exceptional professional with deep knowledge of the Westchester and Putnam County markets. If you are looking for a gifted real estate agent, Barbara is your gal!

8/28/25Jose Fuentes

Google Review

2/18/25michele rabasco

Google Review

Barbara was very knowledgeable of the market and she was always available to answer questions.. Barbara truly went above and beyond in every way to make the sale of our loved one's home as seamless and stress-free as possible. From the very beginning, she demonstrated an exceptional level of care and dedication. She and her assistant took beautiful, detailed pictures of the property and were always available to meet with us in person, offering their expertise at every step. Throughout the entire process, Barbara’s consistent and clear communication kept us informed, making us feel supported and confident. Her professionalism, kindness, and commitment to ensuring everything went smoothly were truly outstanding. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience!

11/12/24Jennifer Robinette

Google Review

Truly amazing job selling my townhouse! It was listed Friday morning and we had an offer by the following Tuesday. Thanks to Barbara's diligence and the depth of her experience in real estate, the selling process moved along swiftly. We were able to close on the sale 42 days from the offer date with a buyer who was getting a mortgage - a process which usually takes 60-90 days in NY!

11/11/24Mary H

Google Review

Barbara deserves 10+ stars! Barbara provided invaluable help during the course of the selling process. She knows her business and how to over come obstacles. There were a few times when I encountered what I considered major roadblocks to completing the sale - Barbara was right there, she knew who to contact due to her longstanding relationships with members of the community. She knows her market - I wanted to sell at what I thought was a good price, she said wait a week and she was right. She is straightforward, smart, and has her finger on the real estate market.
I highly recommend her!!!

11/10/24Kathy Brehm

Google Review

I am so happy Barbara Bodnar was my realtor ! Barbara is kind, smart , and empathic (to name just a
few attributes!) Barbara explained every step of the real estate process as we went through it.
Barbara went above and beyond to be sure my real estate transaction was successfully completed -
my family and I are very happy and grateful. Barbara is the best !

10/30/24Bob Seidenberg

Google Review

I have been a Realtor for over 20 years. I consider myself to be a professional. I also consider Bartbara as a professional as well, In this day and age it's very seldom we find someone like her who will give the first class service she does to both seller and buyer.
Barbara also got "asking price" for the apartment as well.
Give her your listing!!

7/22/24Diane A

Google Review

Great agent. Barb is a great agent who helped us everystep slong the way. Not only did she work with us on various options, helped us find a contractor, and keep us informed at every step, but also got us above asking price! She has high ethics and knows just about everybody! Highly recommend.

4/21/24Jess

Google Review

Barbara made the selling process easy! I am so happy with my experience using Barbara as my agent. She made the process very easy and my apartment sold quickly for over the price I was hoping for.

11/1/23Kathy

Google Review

Barbara was so fantastic to work with. She went above and beyond to help me rent my apartment. Barbara was always positive and professional. I'm so grateful I chose Barbara to be my realtor!

10/28/23Eric R

Google Review

Barbara was the best! She took the time to explain the small details with me. She has the ability to see issues I would never had thought of and had the solution at her fingertips. I cant say enough good things about Barbara, she is truly great.

8/10/23Robert Frost

Google Review

8/9/23S Manning

Google Review

Professional with team approach. Barbara is a knowledgeable real estate pro who worked with me through every step of the selling process. If you are looking for someone to be on top of everything and then some, I suggest you give Barbara Bodnar a call.

5/16/23Sal Lagonia

Google Review

I have had the pleasure of working with Barbara on numerous real estate transactions and her professionalism and attention to detail is second to none. When the project is more difficult, she rises to the occasion and steps up to work extra hard. I highly recommend this business professional as one of the best in the field.

4/12/23Richard Bellew

Google Review

Barb was our broker for a commercial property over a long stretch while we explored various alternatives uses. Her help throughout was very important and her professionalism with the buyer's broker helped seal the deal.

3/4/23Catherine Corbi

Google Review

I came to know Barbara when she sold a coop unit to a friend of mine. Barbara is extremely helpful, knowledgeable and responsive to her clients. She will go above and beyond and make sure you are kept up to date during the process. I have now recommended her to a family member who will be listing her property. I know she will be in good hands and well taken care of.

9/4/22Denise Denison

Google Review

Barbara was AMAZING! She is very professional, knowledgeable, informative, and is the best advocate for her clients. It was a pleasure working with Barbara!

8/24/22ScottRachel Carpenter

Google Review

Where do we begin? The short version is we met Barb trying to buy our first house. Our experience was so incredible as first time home buyers that 10 years later we immediately called Barb when it was time be first time home sellers! That speaks volumes of the level of trust, accountability, and service we found in Barb that 10 years later we still wanted her services. Barb stays connected with all her clients through social media, email, social event invitations, and more. She always remembers you - and she always remembers your family story. We always received the best care from Barb and her team (Thanks, Nathalie!) but also the additional contacts/service vendors she recommended. We had NO IDEA what we were doing either as buyers or sellers - but we learned so much through Barb and her partners. Barb is incredibly communicative, timely, and honest. We were sad to leave the area because that means we have to find someone else to entrust our future home buying/selling experiences. Thanks, Barb, for everything. - Rachel & Scott

8/22/22Lease Administration

Google Review

8/15/22Julia DalCeredo

Google Review

Barbara is the absolute best! Not only did she help me and my fiancé find our dream home, but she is the most personable, funny, cheerful person in the business. It is very obvious that Barbara loves what she does, and she is great at it, too! She and her assistant, Nathalie, are always extremely responsive and communicate very effectively at every step along the way. Barbara is the most skilled real estate broker I have had the privilege to work with, and she cares so deeply about each of her clients, which is obvious in the work she puts into everything she does. Barbara is 5/5 stars – we highly recommend her!

8/10/22Lesley W

Google Review

7/25/22jodi darling

Google Review

Barbara is amazing, very knowledgable and dedicated. Attention to all detail and proactive on her client's behalf. Selling a co-op is complicated, so having someone who knows the market inside out, and is familiar with all the players is just what i needed, and Barb is best at this game! Highly recommended.
Barb, thanks for being there every step of the way with me, and giving 100%! You're the best!

6/7/22Timothy True

Google Review

We used Barbara for the purchase of a condo in Peekskill, NY. Such a smooth deal. From being organized and thorough with walk through’s, being a great Shepard for the negotiations, to getting us to the closing- she was the best real estate agent we have ever used. Thank you so much Barbara for everything. I highly recommend Barbara Bodner for your real estate needs.

3/19/22Laurie Leitch

Google Review

Barb is a true gem…knowledgeable, efficient, and personable. She handled every detail of our home sale process with skill. We received multiple offers on our house and she guided us through the process of selecting the best offer. And, she’s fun to work with, too!

9/25/21Ronald Fechter

Google Review

Barbara is a model agent and a person of real integrity. She worked tirelessly in our interests as buyers and with total commitment to every detail of the purchase process. I cannot imagine a more perfect agent. Her many positive reviews on realtor.com have been justified for us by her actual work product. She is a consummate professional.

9/11/21Susan Palmiotto

Google Review

9/6/21Chris Long

Google Review

Detail oriented, always there for you, advocating for ALL of her clients! Barbara leaves no stones unturned when it comes to her clients! Truly a diamond in the Real Estate rough! I highly recommend Barbara's services for both listing and buying homes!

10/1/20Daniela Kinane

Google Review

5 stars don’t do justice to the magnificent job Barbara and her team has done for us. Always so professional and well informed about the whole selling/buying of a home takes. She walked us through every step as first time homebuyers and we couldn’t ask for more. Her kindness and professionalism made us feel comfortable and confident when we had a very long road to go. She just doesn’t sell houses she helps to make dreams come true. Forever grateful with her and her team for making possible for us to live in our dream home.

7/14/20Cheryl Dresner

Google Review

4/19/20Butch Gilbert

Google Review

2/17/20Ernie Dufek

Google Review

My real estate transaction experience with Barbara Bodnar and Caldwell Banker was very good. The entire process including setting a selling price, the house photographes, the marketing and showing of the property were all done very professionally. The results of the process were excellent. The house was sold within 2 weeks and over the asking price. We received a number of valid offers and were able to ask for highest and best offer. If I were in the market of selling another house in the area, I would definitely use Barbara Bodnar as my realtor.

1/3/20Peak Performance Realty

Google Review

barb is the best!
she spent so much time helping me with the sale of my moms house and was always on top of things with a great attitude.
she was a true professional from start to finish.
she fights hard for her client and is very knowledgeable with all aspects of the sale.

i would recommend her to everyone thinking of buying or.selling a property in her area..

1/1/20Alyssa David

Google Review

I have worked with Barb three times now. She helped me purchase my first home, and then when it was time, sell that home and purchase my second home. Barb is incredibly knowledgeable and was always willing to spend time to talk out any questions I had. Barb always responds quickly and just generally makes the process go smoothly. I would definitely work with her again and have recommended her to several friends!

1/9/19Leylan Jones

Google Review

1/8/19Francis Odenigbo

Google Review

We have worked with Barbara for 7 years going to eight years for purchasing and selling houses. We enjoyed the friendly and cordial relationship that we shared with Barbara during all these years. We are always excited to mention her to new Clients.

10/30/18Jenn MacIntyre

Google Review

This was our first experience selling. Barb’s knowledge and experience made it a breeze. We always felt well informed and confident in our decisions thanks to her expertise.
When it came time to purchase, Barb was so helpful and proactive in helping us stay on top of everything. She went above and beyond! We highly recommend her as an agent.

10/15/18John Cleary

Google Review

Best agent ever. Great business woman always returns calls and always follows through made our experience easy no hassle.honest....

8/21/18Patrice Ho Sang

Google Review

Barbara Bodnar is a consummate professional who knows her business inside and out. My family and I have worked with her for quite a few real estate transactions and would work with her again in a heartbeat. She is knowledgeable, attentive, courteous and makes you feel as if you’re her only client. I cannot recommend her enough.

7/19/18Blueeyeadonis Hawke

Google Review

Barbara was a pleasure to work with. Her experience and professionalism helped me sell my apartment quickly and with no problems, and her friendly and personable nature allowed us to be in communication whenever I needed to be. I can not recommend Barb highly enough.

4/12/18Jesse & Lauren

Google Review

Barbara goes above and beyond for her clients! Thorough, Trustworthy and Tech Savvy! Whether you are buying or selling she is the realtor for the job!

2/9/18Elaine S

Google Review

We had a stellar experience with Barbara. From beginning to end, she was responsive, listened to our desires, and followed up in a timely manner. She was on top of things throughout the entire process, even anticipating next steps and coming up with solutions. Bottom line - if you are looking for a professional who puts her clients' needs first, call Barbara!

6/14/17Jessica Bacal

Google Review

Barbara Bodnar is not only highly intelligent, experienced, diligent, and motivated, but also compassionate, a quality not always characteristic of realtors. With a background in social work, she brings intuitive understanding of the dynamics involved in every buy/sell transaction, and that innate ability invariably enables the proceedings to advance to closing, no matter what drama seems to threaten the hoped for happy ending. As a real estate lawyer, I have found her to be a delight to work with and a formidable presence on which one can comfortably rely.

5/29/17Jeannette Koster

Google Review

Barb is a great realtor. She is a hands-on professional -- she visited us several times during the process of renting out our house, spending a lot of time with us. She gave us excellent advice on upgrades, pricing, staging, and negotiating. She is also an absolute pleasure to work with -- she is matter-of-fact, responsive, calm, reassuring, knowledgeable, and warm.

5/23/17Rose Cipollone

Google Review

I have used Barbara twice as my real estate agent. She is extremely professional and very knowledgeable. Whether you are buying or selling your home you will not be disappointed. I am definitely using her services again.
I sold two places with Barbara and both sold within 3-4 days.

4/3/17Steven Trend

Google Review

I asked Barbara for a referral to a realtor down south. Barbara was quick to return my call, asked appropriate questions so properly understand my needs and followed up. Barbara Bodnar and I are in a business organization where she consistently demonstrates her caring attention to detail and professionalism. She is as diligent and thoughtful as any professional.

4/3/17ERNIE DUFEK

Google Review

Selling our condo and buying a house in Cortlandt Manor was a very pleasant experience. Both transactions were handled professionally and expeditiously. I would recommend Caldwell Banker and Barbara Bodnar in particular for your real estate tranactions. The only people I would deal with.

3/30/17M Staiano

Google Review