Carol Lehman

6/27/26Beth Shirk

Google Review

Carol was fabulous! She helped my husband and I purchase our first home together. Energetic, friendly and organized, Carol was able to help us find a home in the area we wanted to live and made the buying process less stressful for us. I would highly recommend Carol, and the whole Hostetter Team!

6/3/26Ed Hungerford

Google Review

Carol from Hostetter Realty made it so easy for a first-time buyer like me to find a house! I was feeling daunted by the house hunt, and Carol was recommended to me. She provided me with everything I needed to know and was punctual about communication. Even when we encountered what could have been serious setbacks, Carol saved the day. Thank you, Carol!

6/2/26Sarah Lapp

Google Review

I had the privilege of working with Carol on a home sale in Lancaster. She was very responsive and organized and it made the whole transaction very smooth. I would definitely recommend Carol’s services!

5/21/26Clayton Lehman

Google Review

We had an awesome experience! She answered all our questions with confidence!

5/9/26Loren Martin

Google Review

Carol Lehman, and her team at Hostetter Realty, was absolutely great to work with. She helped us find a wonderful home and navigate and strategize to be the successful offer, and then listed our former home with outstanding results in its marketing, multiple offers, and sale. We could not be happier. Her knowledge, experience, savvy, professionalism, responsiveness and winning personality is excellent. She is great to work with.

5/9/26Beth Martin

Google Review

Hostetter Realty and Carol Lehman and team were excellent to work with during our buying and selling process. They are experts in the field as well as caring and personable.

4/30/26Denise Zimmerman

Google Review

Carol was so helpful as we sold our house. Very organized and kept us informed in the process. Settlement went very smooth. Thank you Carol for your help!

4/30/26Karli Horning

Google Review

Working with Carol is the best! She makes the process go smooth and was always easy to get ahold of when I had questions.

4/20/26Gina Petrick

Google Review

Carol and her team provided excellent customer service! Carol’s knowledge, patience, and integrity is unmatched. I would definitely recommend Carol Lehman/Hostetter Realty for your real estate buying or selling needs.

4/19/26Ann Laukhuff

Google Review

Carol is an amazing person. She was so helpful selling my house. I would highly recommend her.

4/18/26Lea Rivera

Google Review

Carol was exactly the realtor we needed in this tough market! We trusted the reviews and gave her a call once we realized we needed someone well connected and a true expert of the area we were specifically looking to land in (Pequea Valley SD or Conestoga Valley). She did not disappoint! She jumped into action for us on a home we wanted to make an offer on and ensured we were knowledgeable on our offer, it was strong & met our demands with the sellers wishes. In less than 12 hours we found out we got the house! It was quick, seamless & stress free. We can't wait to move into our new home ❤️ Thank you to Carol & the team helping our dreams come true!

4/8/26GM

Google Review

Carol helped my son buy his first house. Her follow up after the sale was top notch!

4/8/26Kevin Friedel

Google Review

Carol helped me buy my first home. She made the process easy and less stressful, even helping me negotiate a new roof. The home inspector missed a minor plumbing issue and Hostetter covered it for me.

3/16/26Daniel Skinner

Google Review

Carol was an amazing realtor to work with. She went out of her way to make sure all my needs we met while searching. She made sure the entire home buying experience went as smoothly as possible. 100% would recommend using her!

2/26/26Jesse Rohrbaugh

Google Review

Carol was amazing to work with! She is so knowledgeable and patient and really takes her time with you to find the best house. As a first time home buyer, she helped me find lenders I could trust to make the closing process as easy as possible.

1/23/26Brittany Cornwell

Google Review

My husband and I worked with Carol to buy our first home. She was so kind and helpful throughout the whole process! Her experience and organization made everything go so smoothly.

1/23/26Ethan Cornwell

Google Review

Loved working with Carol all the way through the process of getting our new home!

1/18/26Carson Lehman

Google Review

My wife and I worked with Carol and her team to purchase 2 homes. Her experience and ability to negotiate is Excellent! She cares deeply for her clients and advises them as she would her own family. We highly recommend working with Carol.

12/5/25Dennis Fleming

Google Review

11/4/25Josh.Candace Hahn

Google Review

Carol was a pleasure to work with. She is responsive in her communication and is knowledgeable in the restate realm.

10/20/25Kara Sweigart

Google Review

Always a smooth and positive experience working with Carol. She is responsive professional and reliable. Highly recommend!

10/15/25Kate S.

Google Review

Carol was incredibly helpful in helping us to buy our first home! She was knowledgeable and knew the important things to look for as we did walk throughs. She was quick to respond and easy to work with. She also has a lot of connections in real estate. She was so kind, and I am so grateful to have worked with her! If you are unsure who to use as your realtor for buying/selling, choose Carol.

10/15/25Drew Tuckey

Google Review

10/10/25Jeanine Smith

Google Review

I recently had the pleasure of working with Carol Lehman with Hostetter Realty to sell my home and the experience was top notch. She was professional, knowledgeable and genuinely invested in helping me achieve the best outcome. I couldn’t have asked for a better realtor to represent my interest. Thank you!

9/6/25Julio Torres Araud

Google Review

8/26/25Ryan Pendergast

Google Review

Carol and her team pulled off the impossible for us. We had a 2nd child on the way, and were looking to sell, buy, and move with a 4 month deadline of having our 2nd. Carol and team worked to make sure we got every showing appointment we could, listed and negotiated fairly and diligently, and managed to get over asking for sale, under asking for the buy, and we had a 2 month overlap of being able to move out as we transitioned jobs and family. Truly a remarkable experience and so grateful for their work and belief in being able to get us into our dream home.

8/24/25Lauren Rogers-Sirin

Google Review

Carol is an excellent realtor. She worked hard to find me my dream home. She helped me find a good mortgage company as well. She gives great advise and I felt that she had my best interests in mind. I highly recommend working with her

5/23/25Daniel Wagner

Google Review

5/18/25Josh Lewis

Google Review

We loved working with Carol. She came recommended from my sister-in-law who had also worked with Carol to get her house. Carol was clear in explaining what to expect from our house buying experience every step of the way and was available if we ever had questions. She's professional and friendly, and gave us great advice for getting the home we wanted. My wife and I would definitely recommend working with her on finding their forever home.

1/23/25Joe Sciame

Google Review

Carol was an exceptional collaborator. She promptly addressed all my inquiries and instilled a profound sense of comfort throughout our working relationship.
Thank you again, Joe.

1/16/25Scott Umble

Google Review

Working with Carol has been a fantastic experience. She goes above and beyond in whatever she's helping me with and brings a happy and positive attitude no matter what the situation is. I highly recommend working with her if you get the chance.

1/10/25Daria Chmyl

Google Review

I can't recommend Carol Lehman highly enough for her thorough market insights and outstanding client relations! A top-notch professional who excels in every way! Her unparalleled knowledge and commitment ensure a smooth and successful journey for every client!

1/4/25Zach Strothers

Google Review

I have the pleasure of being in a business group with Carol and it was clear to me when I first met her, that she not only enjoys her work, but is very knowledgeable on the subject as well! If you are looking for a realtor who is professional, great at communication and knowledgeable in her field, contact Carol right away!

12/31/24Duane Martin

Google Review

Carol was wonderful to work with, she looked out for our best interest and kept us informed and made buying our rental property a smooth process!

12/30/24Ginnette Overly

Google Review

Carol Lehman and Greg Hostetter went beyond our wildest expectations. As a team, they helped us buy and sell - a completely seamless process. They held our hand the entire time, fought for us to find the perfect home, and made sure every step of the way we felt secure and confident. We could not, without exception, provide a more exceptional recommendation for Carol and Greg. You will be well cared for with Carol and Greg.

8/30/24Evan Duffy

Google Review

Carol and Greg are both great, they know what they’re doing and they will advocate for you throughout the home buying (or selling) process.

7/9/24R S

Google Review

Carol’s connections and experience gave us a smooth home buying process.

5/23/24Doug Hummer

Google Review

Carol was outstanding to work with. She communicated throughout the entire process and was always willing to go the extra mile. I would strongly recommend her to others.

5/2/24Marilyn Denlinger

Google Review

Carol did a terrific job in a real short window of time to help us put a specialized bid in on a house that was successful. We're thankful for her expertise and job well done.

3/27/24Michele Fisher

Google Review

Carol went above and beyond all our expectations. She is extremely knowledgeable, professional, and is passionate about finding her clients the best property for their needs. We always felt comfortable asking any questions we had. Carol always had our needs and wants in mind and helped to educate us along the way. She helped us with both the buying and selling process. Her bubbly personality allowed us to even have fun and share some good laughs! Her entire team was so responsive and easy to work with. In this challenging market, we were happy to work with one of the BEST! We would highly recommend Carol, and her whole team, for your real estate buying/selling needs.

2/29/24Lee Beal

Google Review

Carol, thank you so much for your assistance!

2/12/24James Detwiler

Google Review

Carol Lehman was great to work with. She quickly found a property that met our needs. She is very knowledgeable professional who is a blast to work with!! I have been very well taken care of.

2/12/24Sierra Detwiler

Google Review

1/12/24Lowell Zimmerman

Google Review

Carol is an excellent realtor! Quick to respond and very helpful. Highly recommend

1/4/24Rose Mosemann

Google Review

Carol is a fantastic agent to work with in the real estate business! She'll work tirelessly to get the job done! I highly recommend her and the team at Hostetter Realty!

1/1/24Wada Lafleur

Google Review

12/7/23Bradyn Hackman

Google Review

Carol and her team was a huge help with the purchase of my new home. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy/sell their property. It was a smooth and easy transaction, and with Carol's years of experience, she did a phenomenal job representing me as a buyer.

12/1/23Michael Rohrbaugh

Google Review

Awesome experience working with Carol and Greg. Could not have asked for a better team, absolutely seamless transition selling our house and buying new home with them.

12/1/23Amy Rohrbaugh

Google Review

Absolutely fantastic!! Carol and Greg are amazing at what they do, always going above and beyond. Extremely knowledgeable and dependable…highly recommended.

11/30/23Nick Stoltzfus

Google Review

8/26/23Rebecca H

Google Review

I've worked with Carol three times. She is a Godsend. She is thorough, can answer any question, has great follow through and is very pleasant the whole time. I highly recommend her to help with your real estate needs.

8/25/23Abigail Eby

Google Review

Carol and her team are fantastic to work with when buying a home. Highly recommend.

7/11/23Jonathon Martin

Google Review

We appreciated Carols knowledge and years of experience in Lancaster county. She helped us craft a strong offer in a competitive market and get the house of our dreams!

5/30/23Sarah Spangler

Google Review

Carol is so wonderful to work with - she made the entire process of buying my first home very easy. I definitely recommend Carol & Hostetter Realty!!

5/25/23Matt Andriani

Google Review

Amazing person and experience, highly recommend!

5/25/23Kayla

Google Review

Carol was a huge help in getting my grandmother's home sold. She not only went above and beyond to work with the buyer's realtor and some speed bumps we had to deal with but also helped deal with a difficult realtor in another state. Her experience and knowledge definitely showed since our first meeting with her. More than grateful to her and her team for all of their hard work and kindness!

5/6/23Lindsay Henry

Google Review

Carol helped me so much in purchasing my first home. I appreciate her experience and her willingness to answer all of my questions!

3/21/23Molly Adams

Google Review

Carol was amazing to work with!! She helped my husband and I find the perfect home in this crazy market. She was very knowledgeable and was doing what was best for us. We plan to work with her in the future. Thank you, Carol!!

3/12/23Alison Sachs

Google Review

I live out of state and Carol made selling my Aunt’s home stress-free! Her knowledge of the market and varied industry connections helped discover and address several issues that could have been quite troublesome. Carol and her team were very communicative throughout the entire process. Most importantly, Carol earned my trust and got me top dollar on the house sale. Thank you Carol and Team! Job well done! Happy Client! ❤️
-Alison Gery Sachs

3/7/23Zachary Abate

Google Review

Working with Carol was an excellent experience! She was knowledgeable and helpful every step of the way. She went above and beyond as we looked for properties and navigated buying a home in a different state than we resided in. She was instrumental in connecting us with other professionals to make the process of buying a home as seamless as possible. We would not hesitate to work with Carol again!

3/6/23Patty Roye

Google Review

Carol is very professional and helpful through the whole Real Estate process.

2/9/23tamara tilton

Google Review

Carol has so much knowledge and experience in the real estate market. Her efforts made the sale of my mom’s home so easy.

2/9/23Luke Berg

Google Review

Knows real estate and very helpful.

12/28/22Lindsey Martin

Google Review

Carol was wonderful to work with! She answered all our questions and walked us through the process of selling our home so smoothly. When offers came in she explained everything to us and made sure we understood all the details. We highly recommend using Hostetter Realty when selling (or buying) your home!

12/9/22Karen Gingrich

Google Review

Carol helped me navigate the whirlwind of both buying and selling homes within a weeks time. She is very personable, knows the market well and was very attentive to any questions I had. I highly recommend her!

11/9/22Rebecca Forbes

Google Review

Carol was excellent to work with - so knowledgeable about the available options, truly knows the value of homes, and so flexible with timing. She is the type of realtor that’s perfect for both an experienced and first-time homebuyer. She really went above and beyond and I would recommend her to anyone!

11/8/22Erin Witman

Google Review

Always amazing to work with! Will go above and beyond to help you buy or sell!

10/27/22Ruthie M

Google Review

What a blessing Carol and her team have been to us throughout the entire process of selling our home! She is professional but fun, showed genuine interest in us and in detail, and used her knowledgeable experience to give us great guidance from beginning to end. Carol as well as her office staff were positive, prompt and courteous in all our communication! Thank you Carol for an exceptional experience! We highly recommend you!

9/23/22Aimee Nolan

Google Review

Carol is amazing! She knew what we needed, and she made our home buying dreams come true! The absolute best!!!

8/23/22Jo Meservy

Google Review

Carol made our transition such a great experience. She was always available to answer our questions, and consistently looked for information we might not have thought to look for ourselves. We highly recommend her!

8/5/22Debbie Lutgen

Google Review

We are from KS looking for a place for our son and daughter in law to live. I found Carol on the internet.....she is absolutely the best!! She is genuinely as interested in getting the best possible place for our son as we are!! She helped us get a rental, even though that was in OUR best interest and not hers!!! I feel like we have found not only a real estate agent who will help My son buy a house in the Future but we have made a good friend for life! She is the best! Look no further!!

7/25/22john smucker

Google Review

Does a great job of quick follow through.

7/8/22R R

Google Review

Carol is excellent! She does a great job - she set up a profile for us to view homes in our price range. She was quick to answer our questions and/or find out what we wanted to know. She was great at staying in contact with us. Highly recommend.

6/30/22John Burns

Google Review

Carol gave us great service and handled last minute snags without batting an eye. She made the home buying experience easy. Highly recommended!

5/27/22Lori Messner

Google Review

Well player on there part. Always kept us informed of what was going on. Scheduled time for showings that worked for us. Sold our house on a timely matter

5/18/22Matt kulp

Google Review

Carol serves her clients with the utmost integrity and vast experience. She will work hard for her client, and has skill to get the deal done! I highly recommend that if you are in the market to buy or sell a home, give Carol with Hostetter Realty a call first.

4/28/22Alyssa

Google Review

Carol was amazing during the entire process of buying our first home. She is very experienced and was always there to answer any questions we had. She is so easy to talk to and went above and beyond during the whole process. We are so thankful we had her to guide us through everything as we are first time home buyers. She made the process as easy as possible for us and we could not have done this without her. I highly recommend Carol!

4/9/22Michelle Brubaker

Google Review

Absolutely loved working with Carol Lehman she is professional knows her job well and always ready to show me the place and very knowledgeable plus has a great personality 😀

4/8/22Liza Minner

Google Review

I have known Carol for many years and think of her as one of the top agents in the county. First agent I think of when a client I am working with is in need of a realtor!

3/18/22Chelsa Burfield

Google Review

Carol is the absolute best! She was on top of everything during the entire process of buying our home. She is an experienced, knowledgeable realtor and I highly recommend her to anyone who is looking to purchase a house. We are so grateful for such a smooth home buying experience from beginning to end, especially considering the tough housing market that we are in today. Thank you so much Carol.

2/19/22erasmo morales

Google Review

Carol was amazing. She was very knowledgeable. She made the house hunt and buy process painless and fun. Pointed out things we may have missed during walk thoughs. She was available for questions. I highly recommend Carol.

2/19/22Brittani Morales

Google Review

Carol is simply the best! We went through a veiw realtors and ended up in connection with Carol and honestly it's the best thing we did! She is hard working, knows her stuff, is so easy to talk to and connect with! Working with her is simply a dream! You won't find a better person!

Hurry though because I'm trying to get her to move to FLORIDA with us in a few years!

2/12/22Sara Colby Realtor

Google Review

Realtor to Realtor, Carol is a pleasure to work with. She is both professional and personable. She is an expert in the local real estate market. Carol strives to make every transaction smooth and successful.

2/11/22Victoria Steffy

Google Review

Carol is a multitasker, and has time for everyone. She greatly helped my daughter and sister with all their mortgage questions and needs. She has a wealth of knowledge and awesome connections to the best and helpful people. To top it off, she has the most professional, yet fun personality you can find!

2/10/22Tonya King

Google Review

Carol Lehman is the most professional and friendly realtor! She will go above and beyond to make sure that you find your perfect home. She is extremely thorough and responsible, with an incredibly quick response time. She is friends with everyone, and extremely well connected in the community. I highly recommend her services!

2/10/22Heidi Smucker

Google Review

Carol is a great realtor, she is very knowledgeable in her field and works extremely hard for her clients. I would highly recommend Carol for your real estate needs.

2/9/22Connie Dienner

Google Review

Carol has been our realtor for years. She’s helped us find a space for our non profit organization and sold our home in a matter of days, and had been a realtor in this area for many years! She is knowledgeable, nice, and aggressive at the same time, which is needed in this market. Carol is the best of the best!! I highly recommend using her! You won’t be disappointed!

2/9/22Lisa Henry

Google Review

Carol values each client’s personal story & ambitions as it relates to finding the very best home for them.

1/30/22Gladys Martin

Google Review

Recommend! She helped sell our home and it couldn’t have gone better!

1/30/22Michael Martin

Google Review

Professional service and appreciate the help Hostetter and Carol always provide! Highly recommend for residential and investment properties!

1/27/22Kim Finkey

Google Review

We had a great experience working with Carol Lehman! She was very helpful, professional and knowledgeable! She will spend a lot of time with you until you find the perfect home or in our case the perfect cabin. I would definitely recommend giving Carol a call if you are searching for real estate!

1/27/22Kay G

Google Review

Carol and her team,are amazing !!!
They are on top of all the Details
Thanks Carol and Greg

1/26/22dina stoltzfus

Google Review

Excellent local professional agent!!! Highly recommend!

1/26/22Cathryn Shupe

Google Review

Carol made the process of selling my home super easy. She was always available and responded promptly to any questions. I very much appreciated her friendly and professional manner. The office staff kept me well updated. It was great working with such an experienced team.

1/25/22Happy Happy

Google Review

Carol does a wonderful job!!

1/15/22Christopher Adams

Google Review

Carol was excellent helping us relocate across the country, fielding issues we didn't consider. She is a local expert in the area. Highly recommend her service.

12/31/21Austin Nolt

Google Review

12/22/21Jonas Fisher

Google Review

12/20/21Randy Hepler

Google Review

Carol has represented as a seller a year and a half ago and as a buyer this month. She is very professional and knowledgeable. She is very detailed and a great advisor and negotiator to get you the best value when selling your home and in helping you purchase your home in this competitive real estate market. She knows what it takes to get a contract as well as close the sale all the way through settlement.

Carol also has a plethora of contacts with contractors for any home repair or remodeling needs. I would recommend Carol for anyone selling or buying a home. Also Hostetter Realty is a family owned agency and Carol like all the brokers and agents at Hostetter has the utmost character and integrity.

12/2/21Connie Bletcher

Google Review

Carol is a skilled real estate professional that goes the extra mile for her clients. Her warm and fun personality is a joyful bonus. ❤

12/2/21Kyle Todd

Google Review

Carol was always responsive and helpful when we were looking to buy a house, not to mention she knows how to negotiate! She is a straight shooter who always works in your best interest. Her years of experience definitely show. Highly recommend!

11/19/21craig martin

Google Review

Top notch all around. Worked hard to make sure our closing happened on schedule.

11/19/21Jessica Brady

Google Review

We had a wonderful experience buying a house from Carol. She was very informative and it genuinely felt that she tried to find a home that fit our needs and budget. She was punctual and straight forward about each property witch made the process easier. We very happy with our purchase and had a great 1st time home buying experience.

11/11/21Robert Reynolds

Google Review

The process of selling our home was virtually painless from beginning to settlement everything went extremely smooth. Would highly recommend Carol and the Hostetter group.

11/10/21Cliff S.

Google Review

Carol and the team and Hostetter Realty are top notch in every way. We were kept in the loop during the whole process and our every question/need was taken care of promptly. Worked with them on several properties and plan to continue! Thanks so much!

11/5/21Craig Solt

Google Review

It was a pleasure working with Carol and Greg to sell our house. They were easy to work with and responsive to all our questions through out the process from our first meeting to closing. We definitely recommend them and will use them again should the need arise.

10/29/21Sally Sauder

Google Review

Great folks to work with! Thanks for everything you did for us! Highly recommend!

10/25/21Cheryl Rost

Google Review

Carol is such a pleasure to work with! She’s a true professional. She works hard to make sure that her clients achieve their dream and she does it with honesty, integrity and compassion.

10/24/21Greg Kirkwood

Google Review

Carol has years of experience that is a huge advantage for her clients. Her negotiation skills will ensure her client's interests are first and foremost.

10/23/21Pam

Google Review

Carol, Greg and the team know what they are doing. They treat you like family and watch out for your interests. I would highly recommend Hostetter Realty.

10/22/21Olivia Weaver

Google Review

I really enjoyed working with Carol Lehman! She made sure I had a great home buying experience and was very responsive to all my questions. I would highly recommend!

10/15/21Sarah Pannebakker

Google Review

Carol & her team made what could have been a stressful experience an absolute seamless and pleasant one. Buying a home should be fun and exciting and that’s exactly what Carol and her team did for our family. Carol stays in constant contact with you and makes you feel like family. Thank you Carol for your help and support in buying our family a home.

10/14/21Kevin Pannebakker

Google Review

Carol and her team made our home buying experience seamless and very pleasant. Her passion and professionalism is second to none. We definitely appreciate everything she did for us and would highly recommend her to anyone.

10/14/21Lindsey Sweigart

Google Review

We loved working with Carol! She is so knowledgeable and does her best to find a place that best suits you. She is flexible and went beyond what we could’ve asked. We would definitely recommend her to anyone in the area!

9/17/21Brian Conroy

Google Review

Carol helped the whole way through and was great to work with. This has been a long journey... THANK YOU CAROL..

9/1/21Leon Martin

Google Review

As a first time home buyer I had a lot of questions but Carol always took the time to explain everything to me.

8/31/21Erica Adams

Google Review

Carol is the best! She helped connected with us from across the country to figure out our needs, went to properties to do virtual walk throughs with us before we arrived locally. She truly listened to our needs and goals and looked for just the right homes to meet our requirements. She went above and beyond to help coordinate vendors and workers, introduced us to local tradesmen for projects we wanted to accomplish, and helped calm nerves during ever step of our cross country moving adventure. Carol is a great Realtor and person - she truly cares about the people she works with.

8/18/21Mallory Weaver

Google Review

Carol is professional and so patient and kind. What could have been a stressful and painstaking experience was so much easier to navigate with her at the helm. Buying or selling a house is a big decision and you need someone you can trust. Carol is the woman for the job!

7/28/21Shawn Rogan

Google Review

Carol was an absolute pleasure to work with, particularly with the challenges of the current housing market. She is very patient and takes the time to get to know her clients and getting a feel for what they are looking for. We tell everyone that we talk to about our new home the great experience we had with Carol and Hostetter Realty!

7/25/21Sean Reese

Google Review

Carol helped us become first-time homeowners and we couldn’t have been happier with her! We were so impressed by her professionalism and attentiveness to our needs. She was understanding of our needs due to having a special needs daughter, and she quickly became well-liked by all of our children. She gave us great advice in each showing without being pushy or overselling. We would recommend her to anyone in the Elanco area needing a realtor!

7/23/21Barb Brown-Young

Google Review

7/23/21Kate Skinner

Google Review

We had a great experience with Carol Lehman from Hostetter Realty. She made buying a home and selling ours a very smooth process. Thanks so much!!

7/15/21Jamie Hendricks

Google Review

My husband and I were first time home buyers so naturally we had a lot of questions and were initiated very intimated by the current competitive market. We also both work odd hours full time so we were afraid setting up times for showings and so on would be difficult to coordinate with any realtor. We were referred by a friend to Carol and could not be more grateful for this because she truly made the entire experience so much more smooth and stress-free than we were anticipating. Not only is she so kind and ready to help answer any questions we had, but she was extremely responsive and made herself available as much as possible. She is trustworthy and honest, we never felt like she was trying to ‘sell’ us on anything and could always tell she really had our best interest in mind even if it meant passing on a house. We closed on our dream home today and can truly say it would not have been possible without Carol. Wish I could give more than 5 stars!

7/14/21Jonathan Boyd

Google Review

Carol did an awesome job of not only selling our house but also Helping us purchase a New house.

7/14/21Maria Boyd

Google Review

Carol was easy going and got things done. Always optimistic and just a pleasure to work with. She definitely goes above and beyond for her clients.

7/9/21mike skinner

Google Review

6/18/21Kim Weller

Google Review

Carol, thank you for guiding us in our search for a home. We appreciate your patience, expertise, professionalism, and your honesty. You were encouraging when I was feeling like we would never find a home. You took time to get to know us and what was most important to us in a new home and didn’t hesitate to gently pull us away from homes you knew weren’t right for us. You called the other week just to say hi and let me know you were thinking about me ~ thank you! You are amazing at what you do…thanks so much for everything!

4/27/21Lisa Zook

Google Review

The market right now is hot! Carol made sure I got to see homes in a timely manner. She helped me find my dream house and paid attention to what I needed and wanted in a home. She walked me through my questions and encouraged me tremendously along the journey. I would highly recommend!

3/26/21Hannah Dimon

Google Review

Carol was amazing with helping us buy our first home in the crazy pandemic market! She made everything painless and advocated for us!

3/11/21Laura Rivera

Google Review

We've been working with Carol since the beginning of the year to buy our first house. The market is super competitive right now! We were outbid about 30-40k on the first house we put an offer on and weren't even able to put in an offer on another house. We were starting to lose hope, but Carol kept telling us the right house would come. She was right! We found a home for sale by the owner. It was his mother's house, who passed away a few months ago, and he wanted to sell to a family. After we saw the house, we spoke with Carol in the driveway and she asked if we were interested. We were and so she went inside and spoke to the owner. He said he would honor our offer. Carol and us rushed home to get the paperwork ready and signed. We got confirmation that night from Carol that that house is ours. The whole process with Carol was very smooth. She works with Caliber Home Loans and Regal Abstract. While signing today at closing, the whole process took about 30 minutes! Very smooth and easy. Carol has other connections to make purchasing a home easy, e.g. homeowners insurance. Before purchasing our house, Carol was very patient and answered all of our questions. She would also point out things that looked odd on houses, which we really appreciated. Carol is very professional and has a plethora of experience in the realtor industry! My mother-in-law used Carol and recommended her to me and we'd recommend her too! 👌😊

3/4/21Meshak Junior

Google Review

2/7/21Crystal Detwiler

Google Review

Carol made selling our home a breeze. Her communication was very helpful and to the point. Being a fun person to work with also made the entire process very enjoyable for both my husband and I. Highly recommend!

12/23/20Derek E Martin

Google Review

Carol was a great realtor! She made the house buying experience super easy. Whenever I had a question she was always very quick with a response. I will definitely use her again if I ever need to buy another house.

12/23/20Dorothy Martin

Google Review

My husband and I cannot recommend Carol and her team enough! Every step of the way Carol helped us through. Her expertise made us confident in the home we eventually purchased. Carol’s wisdom, knowledge, and experience were things that helped up navigate through houses and find our perfect home! From start to finish of our first-time home buying experience we received A+ service! We would highly recommend Hostetter to our friends and families! If you are looking for the best, go no further!

Thank you Carol! You have no idea how much we appreciate you and all of your hard work!

12/16/20Jill Cramer

Google Review

I've used Carol to sell two houses and buy one and I couldn't be happier with her!!! She made suggestions to set and stage both houses to sell - and they both sold quickly!!! She was unbelievable in finding us the perfect house to buy too!!! As she got to know us, and what we needed and wanted in a house, she was amazing - working non-stop to find us just the right house to call home! Any questions we had we're answered quickly and accurately. She is crazy good at what she does and makes you feel like you are her only client (when obviously she has a lot of clients she's working just as hard for)!!! If you're ever looking to buy and/or sell a house, I would recommend Carol, and her entire team above anyone else!! They are awesome!!!! And we absolutely LOVE our new home!!! Thanks Carol....Amy and Shirley! You guys are the BEST!!!!!

11/22/20amber murray

Google Review

I had the best experience working with Carol. She is very respectful, honest and a hard working woman. I was always kept aware of things, as well as having Carol so responsive with my calls to any of my questions! I sold my first home in under a week, I could not have asked for a better person to work with. I definitely will be recommending Carol on the Hostetter Realty Team to help any of my family and friends selling or buying 💕

10/28/20Betty Diller

Google Review

10/2/20Renee M

Google Review

Carol and her team are amazing!! Carol is very professional and knowledgeable! She is responsive, helpful and friendly. We had a great experience working with her. Our house sold in 6 days. Carol, Greg and their team made it a smooth process. We would absolutely refer them to anyone buying or selling a house!

9/30/20Justin R

Google Review

We purchased two homes and sold two homes with Carol. All four experiences were great. We couldn't have better things to say about her or recommend her more. Carol is a real professional that knows the business and gives great advice. She always seemed a step ahead of everything. And she always treated us like we were friends or family. We are very thankful someone told us that we had to call Carol when we started house hunting, and our friends were glad we recommended her to them as well.

9/2/20Melissa Byers

Google Review

Carol Lehman and her team are amazing! They have worked with several of my clients that I've referred to them. The latest client, sold their house within 1 week of putting it on the market and for 35k over the asking/advertised price. Carol and her team are knowledgeable and they care... that makes dealing with them so satisfying. Highly recommend.

9/2/20Zoe Horan

Google Review

Carol is a wealth of real estate information. I recommended her to a friend with a unique and difficult home selling/buying situation and it went very well. Exceeded all expectations. I so look forward to the opportunity to allow her to sell my home when I am ready.

8/27/20Bill Raup

Google Review

Carol Lehman gives outstanding service and sells your home fast. With years of full-time experience in the real estate industry, she goes above and beyond to sell your house or find you the right home. I highly recommend her and is second to none as a top realtor in Lancaster County!

8/12/20Shelleen Weaver

Google Review

Carol Lehman gives her undivided attention to her clients. She is quick to respond, professional, and attentive. I’ve recommended her to others, and they’ve thanked me after working with her as well.

8/11/20Darius Razgaitis

Google Review

Carol's the best! We loved having her as our agent - we trusted her all throughout the process and felt in good, knowledgable hands.

8/5/20Shirley Mast

Google Review

This team has helped our family (including our kids) buy five homes over the years. Every time the experience has been above and beyond our expectations. This team is superb!

8/5/20Leighann Walsh

Google Review

Carol and her team are fabulous to work with. The experience and knowledge they bring to the table help people get the best deals possible.

It has been an honor to work with them and I will continue to refer clients to her and the team!

8/4/20John Martin

Google Review

Working with Carol has been a wonderful experience, She is very responsive and worked very hard to make sure we were represented very well through our purchase. It has been a pleasure and would highly recommend Carol for all your Real Estate Needs.

8/4/20Cheryl Fuller

Google Review

Carol was amazing thru my entire process. Thru the delemas of Covid. I bought the house unseen (pics only) I trusted Carol and she didn't steer me wrong. I dont know how I would have ever gotten thru this process without her. Absolutely wonderful realtor.

8/4/20Kevin Le

Google Review

Was a pleasure to work with, Carol helped my growing family find our dream home!

8/4/20Doug & Shirley Dosch

Google Review

Carol is great to work with!

4/3/20Clayton Lehman

Google Review

4/3/20Amy Martin

Google Review

4/3/20Carson Lehman

Google Review

4/3/20Abigail Lehman

Google Review