Carol Reeves

7/5/26Jonathon Critell

Google Review

We are forever grateful for Carol and can honestly say we wouldn't be in either of our homes without her. We first hired her when we were moving to Columbus from out of town. We didn't know the area at all, but Carol knows the ins and outs of every single neighborhood in the city and guided us perfectly. We trusted her so much that we just used her again for our second home purchase.
She brings over 30 years of experience to the table, and it shows. Carol has this rare ability to take a naturally stressful process and actually make it fun. She truly puts her clients' interests first and goes well beyond the extra mile every single time. If you want a realtor who has unmatched expertise and genuinely cares, Carol is the best in the business.

5/10/26Norm Hyslip

Google Review

Carol Reeves is so knowledgeable, kind and detailed! It's been a pleasure working with her at The Glenridge Village , Newark, OH!

11/25/25Tonya Moses

Google Review

It was a great experience working with Carol and I’m so glad she went to bat for me. She knew what I was looking for found the perfect home for me. Carol kept me informed, step by step, during the entire purchasing process. I highly recommend her to anyone looking to sell or buy a new home.

5/8/24Michelle Fry

Google Review

Carol and team are excellent at what they do. They go above and beyond in helping their clients and Carol has years of experience to fully represent her clients - her transactions are always smooth and if there are any bumps that come up as real estate can have, you can bet she takes care of it for her clients. She gives exceptional service and representation.

5/5/24Kire Milenkovski

Google Review

Great job selling the property in the Hunters Ridge Subdivision.

11/2/22Karen Matt

Google Review

We are Cleveland natives who are relocating to Columbus and recently purchased a home there with the help of Carol and her team. We were very pleased with how accommodating they were with our crazy schedules and even scheduled our closing remotely to help reduce some of our traveling back and forth! Both Carol and Susan were very knowledgeable about the market and the neighborhoods surrounding Columbus to help us in our search. They returned calls and e-mails promptly. We found them very approachable and easy to deal with. Prior to our experience both of our daughters purchased homes in the area with their help. Obviously they were pleased as well!

1/6/22Sam Albanese

Google Review

My wife and I were first introduced to Carol Reeves back in September, 2020. From the moment we met Carol we knew that she was a unique realtor. Clearly Carol is a seasoned professional. When we would want to connect with her, she was timely, courteous, thoughtful, knowledgeable, and most of all she made us feel like family. We all know that when you are trying to find the right home in the best location the experience can be very frustrating. That said, every time we had questions and called Carol, she was quick to respond and listen. Now because we live in Maryland the opportunities to connect in person are limited so we had to continue to coordinate our time with Carol so that we maximized our trips. Then it happened…Carol let us know that a great new community was developing and she sent us some information and the community is Evans Farm in Lewis Center, Ohio. As soon as we saw the information, we let Carol know that we wanted to move forward. Building a home is something that we never experienced first-hand and Carol by far has been a GREAT partner in the selection, design, and frankly, our ambassador. Update, July 2021 we locked in our lot with 3 Pillar Homes and started the process. Now our home is not yet finished, primarily due to supply chain issues, however, my wife and I are extremely excited that soon we will be living at Evans Farm. In closing, Carol Reeves made what frequently is considered one of the most stressful situations, that is, moving and looking for a new home almost painless and stress-free. Clearly there are many realtors in the business and we would rank Carol Reeves at the very top of the list. Thank you, Carol, for all that you continue to do for our family and the time and care that you continue to provide for us. Sam and Linda.

10/3/21Vincent Riegler

Google Review

Friendly Staff
Great Home Selections

3/4/21Jennifer Park

Google Review

carol was great to work with and she was extremely responsive. carol was always happily answered my questions and provided options and data to help me make my decision and alleviate any concerns

8/24/20Karen Louden

Google Review

Carol Reeves has been our real estate agent for approximately 10 years. We have purchased through Carol rental property as well as our personal residence. We have closed 11 deals with her. Carol, in our opinion, is the perfect agent. She is a real estate professional that is knowledgeable, patient, respectful and above all gets the job done!
We highly recommend using Carol Reeves for your real estate needs.

8/6/20Linda Peck

Google Review

Carol is an outstanding realtor....one you can trust. She always looks out for your best interest. She's quick to respond and has a great deal of construction knowledge which is super beneficial in evaluating homes. We would strongly recommend Carol!

2/6/20Tammy Stahl-Garber

Google Review

If I could give Carol Reeves 10 stars I definitely would!
Not only did she have our home in contract on the FIRST DAY, she interviewed a Realtor in Pittsburgh on our behalf who turned out to be equally fabulous!

2/5/20Erika Druzina

Google Review

Carol is simply the best. Going through this process with someone as honest and genuine as her, made for a great experience. It was a big learning experience being first time home-buyers, and she really did have our best interest in mind. She made sure we were comfortable with our options and gave great advice. She gave us confidence in our decisions and was always readily available by phone or email to talk. I wouldn’t want to work with anyone else!

8/15/19Christopher Potts

Google Review

Top notch agent that know what she is doing. It was an absolute pleasure to work with her.