

About Donna
Business Philosophy
I'm committed to providing quality service to my clients. I will dedicate myself to honesty, integrity and enthusiasm with a sincere effort to meet all of my clients needs.
Education and Training
30 Years Experience
USAA/Affinity Certified, Accredited Marketing Specialist, Accredited Buyer Broker Agent, Accredited Relocation Specialist, USAA Certified. Member: National Association of Realtors, Connecticut Association of Realtors and The New Haven Board of Realtors.
Awards and Designations
Million Dollar Club
Producers Club
Sterling Club
Connecticut Magazine 5 Star Realtor
Areas of Expertise
New Homes
Waterfront Properties
First Time Home Buyers
Investment Properties
Community Involvement
Leukemia Society
Immune Deficiency Foundation
Cancer Society
ALS (Lou Gehrig's Disease)
Lupus Foundation
Boys and Girls Village
Wheat of West Haven
Beth El Shelter
West Haven Community House
Personal Background
After marrying my husband Joseph, I sold a successful business I owned for 5 years. We moved to the New Haven area where we resided for 12 years with our two children. In 1998 we moved to Milford where, we enjoy a beachfront community. Personal interests are skiing, boating, going into the city to enjoy the theater and dance choreography.
Testimonials
Donna Tartagni was an awesome agent! As a several time homebuyer, both in and out of state, I have to say Donna's professionalism stood head and shoulders above any other agent I have worked with. Donna was my selling and buying agent during a recent transaction, she was responsive and reachable at all times, made herself available for all aspects of the transactions and provided valuable knowledge and advice. In the past I never put much value in using a buying agent and would usually go right to the listing agent (for potentially better negotiation and less layers of players), in this case Donna showed how flawed this concept can be and helped hold together a deal and ensure my best interest. I never felt alone through the transactions which got to be a bit overwhelming at times.I can not say enough about the support she provided. She is an asset to your company! - D. Soli
My experience with Donna was during the sale of one house and purchase of another. I originally came across Donna while working with another realtor, who didn’t show up for a showing of a listing that Donna had. During that showing I found Donna to be very professional and polite and to answer my questions in a forthright manner. I then worked with her later when I decided that I wanted to start looking at properties and put my house up for sale. I should tell you that I expect a lot from the realtors I’ve worked with and Donna was always very professional and thorough. - E. Bryant
Transaction History
- 1 Year
- 2 Year
- 5 Year
Neighborhoods Donna Has the Most Experience In
Donna's Listings and Deals
Donna's Reviews
7/22/21Thomas O'Neil
Very good broker. Donna and her associates took us to see several houses until we found the right house for us. She was patient, and got us the right home. She also negotiated a good deal when it came time to purchase.
In selling our home, she did an excellent job of guiding us through the process and we wound up with an off $40k over asking.
Very knowledgeable of the market and gave us excellent advice through the entire process. We felt very comfortable contacting her and she answered all of our questions in a timely manner. When she didn't have an answer, she got us in touch with the people who had the answers to our questions.
An excellent experience and an excellent broker.
3/12/21Don Hurley
Donna Tartagni found my wife and I the the perfect home! I would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a professional realtor who puts her clients first and gets positive results. She is a very knowledgeable agent.
3/12/21Sandi Hurley
I have known Donna Tartagni for over 30 years. In that time she has assisted me in the sales and purchases of 5 homes. She has always been my go-to real estate agent. Whenever I needed her, she was always there, taking the extra steps that most realtors don't...like answering my calls and emails promptly, really listening to my needs, and ALWAYS putting my best interest FIRST. She is always updated on what's going on in the market and her recommendations on my home sales/purchases have always been highly favorable. She is a top-notch realtor who knows her stuff. I would highly recommend Donna to anyone who is looking to do any real estate transactions. Buying or selling a home can be very stressful and Donna T makes it easy. Thanks Donna, your the best!
