Jay O'Neil

Jay O’Neil is a Founding Member of Encore Sotheby's International Realty and is the top-tier producer for Indianapolis's premier real estate firm, Sotheby's International Realty.

When selling your luxury real estate, not just any licensed broker will be able to do the job. Working with a real estate professional with years of experience in listing and selling luxury properties makes all the difference. Given your choice, why not work with the very best? This will save you time, money, and leave no question when it comes to how smoothly any and all of your transactions will go.

Jay is consistently recognized as Encore Sotheby’s International Realty’s top producer, a distinction only granted to the top performer – put simply, one of the best! With over 25 years in experience listing and selling properties exclusively in Carmel and Indianapolis Jay knows exactly what it takes to get your luxury property sold as well as what it takes to find your luxury property that meets your highest standards.

Jay lives in Carmel with his wife Martha. They have three adult sons who were raised in Carmel, affording him intimate first – hand knowledge of the area, school systems, sports and park programs. When not selling real estate, Jay enjoys traveling, golfing and spending time with his grandchildren. Jay is proud of his longstanding membership in the Rotary Club of Carmel.