Nancy Bartlebaugh

1/7/26rocio alvarado

Google Review

9/2/25Dawn Bregitzer

Google Review

When I was referred to Nancy I didn't know what to expect. Buying a home by yourself is a scary and an intimidating process. She exceeded ALL of my expectations! She listened and always gave her honest feedback which is what I needed. I learned so much from her such as water damage & wells & NO creepy basements with SPIDERS! She truly made my experience the BEST! She is not only my realtor but also now my friend. Love you girlie!

2/12/25roger legg

Google Review

We have used Nancy for 3 houses now and she has been great. She keeps you informed at every stage of the process and your house is not for sale very long. We have suggested her to others, and she has done a great job for them as well. We will definitely use her anytime we would need to sell or buy a house, and I would recommend her to anyone.

10/24/24Shawn Straight

Google Review

Nancy is an exceptional realtor. I would highly recommend her!! Selling my house was a stressful thing for me and she made it all so simple and easy. She had a stager and photos done in two days to get my house on the market. Offers came within days! When problems came up with buyers She was always available and had great solutions. If your looking for the best realtor hire Nancy!!

5/18/24Kristin Yanko

Google Review

Nancy Bartlebaugh and Cindy Cobb were superior from the very beginning to the very end. They were always available, and they answered all of our questions. They worked hard to get the very most from our house sale. Highly recommend!!!

5/7/24Steve Orr

Google Review

Nancy met with me the first time on the spur of the moment, yet took two hours to see the home and sit down with me to thoroughly explain the process. I look forward to completing the work with her.

5/1/24Brad Sponseller

Google Review

4/30/24Edvard Hornacek

Google Review

Great to work with

12/29/23Cody Smith

Google Review

Tremendous help. She is a real go-getter and can spot houses before they even go on the market. One of the best real estate people I’ve ever seen. 👍

12/26/23Erica C

Google Review

11/17/23Jamie B

Google Review

Nancy is great!! My wife and I have worked with her multiple times buying and selling, and I wouldn’t want to work with anyone else. She is knowledgeable and professional, while also being personable. She was always available when we needed her and she kept the process moving to meet deadlines. Highly recommend!!

11/16/23Randy Grose

Google Review

Nancy did and execetional job selling our house. Very informative about everything that was involved. She went above and beyond what she needed to do for the transaction. Even after the sale she was there to followup on some remaining items. Great Experience.

11/10/23ANDY TRAN

Google Review

I have been known Nancy for almost 20 years and that is long enough to know a person. I remembered she seats straight on the floor and her back to the wall when we talked about the deal and we laughed so hard. She is like a family member to me. She just helped me bought my dream house. This deal is very complicated and a miracle happens at the last minute. We got the deal. A simple thanks is not enough, so I would like to say God Bless you Nancy. You deserve it.

11/1/23taylor coppenger

Google Review

I cannot recommend Nancy enough. She was so knowledgeable, honest and patient in helping find my family our perfect home!

10/31/23Mathew Lewis

Google Review

Nancy was great! Extremely patient as she made sure we found the house that was perfect for us. She made the entire process as a first time home buyer extremely easy and made sure we understood every part of the process!

10/31/23Kendall Steer

Google Review

10/31/23Wendy R

Google Review

I had the pleasure of working with Nancy, an exceptional realtor, who truly went above and beyond to make the sale of my home a seamless and successful experience. I cannot say enough about the outstanding service she provided. From the very beginning, Nancy demonstrated an impressive level of professionalism. She was always prompt and punctual, respecting my time and schedule. This level of commitment made the entire process run smoothly and efficiently. One aspect of her service that truly stands out is her willingness to go the extra mile. Not only did Nancy help me list my home, but she also assisted me in addressing various issues such as fixing items and some touch up painting tips to enhance the overall appeal of my property. Her dedication to making sure my home looked its absolute best was truly remarkable and undoubtedly contributed to the successful sale.

10/31/23Beth Ann

Google Review

10/31/23Cristan Rockhold

Google Review

Nancy is by far THE BEST with her real estate knowledge forward thinking strategies and expertise in EVERY venue!!! I’ve worked with over 26 realtors and brokers and Nancy by FAR sets the standard. After 3 days listing multiple offers & showings

10/30/23Heidi Norris

Google Review

Nancy has sold multiple properties for us with great success. She and her team are always professional, punctual and in constant contact about what is happening and what to expect. I highly recommend her for any real estate needs.

10/27/23Kathryn Spier

Google Review

Nancy was great to work with! She made the process of selling our house so smooth and easy, and we could tell we were in good hands from the moment we met her. I would absolutely recommend her to anyone!

10/25/23Steve Spier

Google Review

Nancy went above and beyond to help in the sale of our house. I would highly recommend using Nancy as your realtor!

10/6/23Tiffany Wilson

Google Review

I would like to Thank Nancy for the amazing job she did with helping me sell my condo! Nancy is extremely informative, honest, straightforward and helpful. She makes sure you know how the process is going to work and she is right by your side! This was very important to me as it was my first time selling property! Nancy always responds immediately to all phone calls and text messages. Nancy is an amazing realtor and she made sure I was satisfied with my offer and supported me through the end! I would recommend Nancy to anyone selling their property or looking to buy property!

8/10/23Jaden Rudder

Google Review

I had the pleasure of working with Nancy Bartlebaugh as my realtor, and I cannot praise her enough. Nancy's expertise, professionalism, and commitment to her clients are truly outstanding. She went above and beyond to understand my needs, find the perfect home, and negotiate a great deal. Her communication skills and attention to detail kept me informed and confident throughout the process. I highly recommend Nancy Bartlebaugh as a reliable, knowledgeable, and dedicated real estate agent.

8/10/23Kevin Sova

Google Review

Nancy and her team were amazing to work with. Every aspect of the sale of our home went better than we expected.
Kevin & Lori Sova.

7/27/23Shell Cleave

Google Review

I had three rental properties in Akron that I listed with Nancy. The first two sold easily and Nancy took charge of everything for me as I was out of state. She got me great prices and was very professional and eager to help me as I have a severe health issue and needed to minimize my stress.

When it came time to sell the third property, we ran into a big snag that we did not expect. The renters had moved out and squatters took over the house. It took months to get them out but we finally did. Nancy was instrumental in helping resolve the issue and even helped me get the house cleaned out and repaired from the damage the squatters caused. She had the house in contract right away and she worked diligently to ease my fears and protect my property value. She was extremely responsive and represented me aggressively, but she was also kind and sensitive to my unique needs and situation. I trust her completely and recommend her whole heartedly!

Thanks, Nancy!

7/26/23Michael Anderson

Google Review

I found Nancy on the internet, and when I called her I was amazed at the detailed information She provided me over the phone. After my Wife and I interviewed her at our home we knew She was the professional for the job. Nancy Bartlebaugh did an amazing job of selling our home. I got 4 offers in 3 days, with at least 1 more individual being told not to bid because their price was to low, and our home was under contract in 4 days. She is a true analytical, understands the Marketplace, and knows how to get the maximum sale price for your home. She stages your home, does all the necessary photography, and even uses drone technology for optimized and complete viewing of your home. The price we got was over asking price, and Nancy helped us in every way needed all the way through closing.

If your serious about selling your home, call Nancy!

One word "Outstanding"!

7/26/23Matt _____________

Google Review

Nancy is fantastic to work with, she will fights for her client and goes above and beyond to do what is fair for them. One of the hardest working individuals I know. She is who you want on your team.

7/26/23Nick Poorbaugh

Google Review

Nancy is the best you will find. She is honest, hard working and helped us several times in purchasing and selling our homes. Her experience sets her apart from most agents, but it’s her desire to make sure her clients get the best outcome possible that puts her over the top.

7/26/23Joni Bowen

Google Review

We have worked with Nancy to purchase and sell our last two homes and she is a rockstar. She is extremely knowledgeable and helped us write and negotiate an offer that allowed us to purchase our dream home in a highly competitive market. She is responsive, honest and trustworthy. We won’t work with anyone else. I 100% recommend Nancy if you are buying or selling a home and want someone who will work hard for you.

7/24/23Karen Sealy

Google Review

Nancy is a rock star! She told us exactly what we needed to do to get the results we wanted and delivered! Absolutely recommend her to anyone wanting great advice and a smooth process in buying/selling real estate.

5/31/23Selena White

Google Review

Nancy is amazing! She is simply great at what she does, but on top of that, she has a very warm and genuine personality. My husband and I felt heard and she did her ABSOLUTE best to help us find a house that would be our home. And believe me when I say that she hit the nail on the head!!! She effortlessly built a rapport with our family and we can't wait for our sons to give her a call when they are ready to buy a home.

3/31/23Raven Key

Google Review

Nancy was amazing to work with. She was super responsive, knowledgeable, and trustworthy. She had my best interest in mind and made my first time buying a house a breeze.

2/11/23Brock Burkhart

Google Review

Nancy was awesome to work with and took the extra time to gather exactly what we were looking for. Highly recommend!

12/29/22Tyler Brown

Google Review

Nancy is a great real estate agent who will be honest with you and not try to sell you on something with problems. She was a great resource to have and learn from my first time buying a home!

12/13/22Lucilla Lebetter

Google Review

Nancy is not only a friend, but she is the bestest of the best, if you want to hire someone to buy or sell your house!! She amazed me in how professional and savy she was!! She knows that business inside out!! She was extremely helpful and went over and above!
I would highly recommend this beautiful young woman to sell or buy your home.

12/6/22Brittney Martin

Google Review

Nancy is an amazing REALTOR! She sold my house in 8 days (would have been sooner, but negotiations were at play!) She’s very dedicated to what she does! I’ve never met someone so on top of things at nearly every hour of the day. She makes the entire process so smooth. During the process, I needed a plumber and a handy man. She found them both, made the phone calls, and booked it all within moments (w/ my approval). I also got some work done to my house BEFORE I involved her in the sale. She reached out to them for warranties in minutes of me providing her the phone number. She’s crazy organized, thorough, informative, personable, fun to work with, and simply “on it.”
If you’re looking for a REALTOR and you're unsure, she’s it. Just give her a text or call, she’ll answer, she always does!

12/3/22J J

Google Review

If you’re looking for a realtor that will put your needs and wants first, you can’t find better than Nancy. We told her exactly what we were looking for and she helped us find our perfect forever home! She is awesome! Thanks Nancy!

12/2/22Derek o

Google Review

Nancy and her team are the best! Very friendly, prompt to respond to my questions and easy to work with.

12/1/22Lucy Noble

Google Review

11/20/22Tammy Stewart

Google Review

Best͏ Agent Ever!!
Nancy Bartlebaugh is the best agent ever. We could not have done this without her. The energy she brings to the table is amazing. Her knowledge is outstanding. My husband was selling his childhood home after his parents passed away. This was a very difficult process.
for him. She guided us through every step. She answered every question along the way. She went above and beyond and then some. It was truly a pleasure working with her. She has an amazing team. We could have chosen anyone. We chose Nancy Bartlebaugh we put our trust in her. It paid off. She was able to take the burden off of us. So there’s no need to look any further. Choose Nancy you will not regret it!

8/28/22Angelina Le

Google Review

Highly͏ recommended, the best and trustworthy realtor

Thank you for being so wonderful and patient with us during the entire process . You guided us each and every single steps to make sure we are happy with the final. It was a great help to us from the bottom of our hearts . You are not just a realtor but also a good and trustworthy advisor. ❤️

8/22/22Don Coy

Google Review

Nancy͏ made things easy and was great to work with!
Nancy handled all aspects of our real
estate transaction with the utmost professionalism and care. She communicated clearly with all parties involved and made the entire sales process a breeze. I highly recommend Nancy and her team for anyone who is either selling their home or looking for a new one.

8/19/22Jihad Ottallah

Google Review

Professional
Nancy͏ was great throughout our whole buying process, patient, extremely helpful especially since this was our first purchase. Always on time, great communicator, and an all around professional at what she does. Thank you again, Nancy!

8/19/22RTags77

Google Review

I was fortunate enough to have Nancy bring a buyer for one of my listings. The offer was well written, clear and concise. Her buyer was clear to close weeks ahead of schedule. We had great communication throughout the process. I look forward to working with her again in the future.

7/18/22Steve Wern

Google Review

5/17/22קובי

Google Review

5/6/22Ingrid Fields

Google Review

4/12/22Laura Vandervaart

Google Review

I wish I could work with Nancy on every transaction. She does an excellent job of communicating and works HARD for her clients. Thanks, Nancy!

4/8/22Tim Bishman

Google Review

I PROMISE YOU! You will want Nancy representing you with all your real estate needs. She is the most connected, trustworthy, knowledgeable, hard working agent you will find. Believe me! Hire her! It will be the best decision you make.

2/14/22Brianna Davis

Google Review

This was a great experience. Also my first and she was so awesome. I am very thankful for her and her team. Everyone was great!!!

2/5/22Dudley Wilson

Google Review

I 100% recommend Nancy to be your real estate agent. She checks all of the boxes in what you need and want in an agent. It doesn’t matter if you are buying or selling, she’s got you. Our transaction with her by our side was completely seamless! You’ll walk away more than satisfied hands down.

12/30/21Miranda DiMauro

Google Review

I would give Nancy more than 5 stars if we were able to! She went above and beyond, to make sure my family got their dream home. She put in countless hours and last minute showings, to be there for my family. She was professional, hard working and determined. She took the time to understand what my husband and I were both looking for, setting up a customized portal, which was super convenient and easy to use and browse. Buying a house in today’s market was difficult, but nothing was impossible, with Nancy Bartlebaugh! She will make it happen!
She walked us through it all, from start to finish, flawlessly. Thank you Nancy!!!

11/6/21Holland Erb

Google Review

11/6/21Lisa Morris

Google Review

Nancy knew what we needed to help us find the perfect forever home for our family so she connected us with her sister Maureen (Mo) Brown. Mo went above and beyond all of our expectations. She was very honest and forthcoming with us about everything. She made us feel like we were important and not just a commission for her. Because of her we were able to find the perfect HOME for our family! We would recommend Nancy and her team to anyone who's looking for the perfect HOME for their family. We love you Mo!

10/29/21The Legend and the Gamer

Google Review

Maureen Brown was my realtor. She did an amazing job. Very responsive and very knowledgeable. I highly recommend her to anyone wanting to buy or sell a house!

10/26/21Maria Dornack

Google Review

9/28/21Ron Linn-Hammond

Google Review

If you're in the market for an honest agent with integrity and a wealth of knowledge, Nancy is your girl! We've been working with Nancy throughout this insane market and she has been top notch in every regard. It's clear to me that Nancy isn't just looking to sell us on a house. Nancy is trying to find us our home. I can't even describe how refreshing and reassuring that is given how fast houses are moving at the moment. Her knowledge and know how have been a critical asset during our search for a new home. I would highly recommend Nancy Bartlebaugh. Teaming up with Nancy has proven to be the best decision we made when looking for our next home.

9/28/21A Jarzembowski

Google Review

It has been such a delight working with Nancy Bartlebaugh! I know a lot of realtors as I am in the mortgage industry but when we decided to buy a new home, I wanted to work with an agent that I have never worked with before and so we found Nancy. Upon our first meeting we were truly impressed with her vision of selling our home and how she was going to help us find our new home. We have been working with her for almost a year now and she could have sold up multiple homes by now, but she doesn’t just want to sell you a home… she wants to sell you the right home! When we are viewing homes, she looks at everything and points out all the issues that she finds. One time we were viewing a home that we really liked and planned on submitting an offer but when we were viewing the property Nancy found issues. She randomly found a piece of a two-by-four and put it up against the basement wall and found the walls in the basement were bowing in. She advised how big of an issue this could be and we didn’t even give it a second look and decided not to make that offer. Just recently I thought I found the “one”… But after viewing comparable properties in the area there was no way that the home was worth what they were asking, and we knew the home would go probably $20K over asking price. Again, we trusted her, and she saved us from making a big mistake that we would have regretted in the future. We love that she is honest with us and we are just not another home she sold. She always tells us… “We are going to find you guys the perfect home!” and we trust and believe her. All I can say is she is WORLD CLASS, and we are so please that she is representing us as buyers and sellers. Thank you for being so awesome!

9/27/21Laura Coy

Google Review

Nancy and her team are phenomenal! Running a home inspection company it’s easy to spot a great Realtor, especially when every client raves about them. Nancy is professional, personable, detail oriented, an excellent communicator and most importantly she truly cares about the families she’s helping. Nancy doesn’t just provide a service, she provides a peaceful home buying or selling experience. We appreciate the opportunity to work with and learn from her.

9/27/21Brad Lubinger

Google Review

If you're looking for a professional who will guide you through the process of buying or selling a home, you can trust Nancy. She's honest, thorough and dependable. Since we don't buy or sell often...do it the right way and call Nancy. She'll get it done!

9/5/21Stacie Carter

Google Review

You cannot go wrong with Nancy! Above and beyond the best!

8/27/21Jaci Stein

Google Review

Nancy has been my realtor for years. She is always making herself available and if she is unable to assist with something, she will find someone who can. She is very professional, honest and straightforward. Nancy will spend time with you to make sure, either as a buyer or seller, you are happy with the process and ok with moving forward. The tools she has gained along the way has made her an even strong realtor and stand out that much more. I highly recommend Nancy!

8/26/21Colin Fleming

Google Review

7/26/21Matt Clair

Google Review

Nancy was incredible and helped us every step of the way. She was extremely knowledgeable on the best strategy to get the right deal for our house! Definitely recommend her when it’s time to sell your house!

7/3/21Andrew LaVine

Google Review

Nancy is really knowledgeable about the neighborhoods in akron and has a sixth sense for water damage and structural issues. I felt like she really cared about getting us a home that would fit our needs. We are brand new to this city and she really looked out for us.

6/6/21Crystal

Google Review

Nancy has provided me and members of my family with successful real-estate transactions over the past five years. She is consistently thorough, patient, knowledgeable and dedicated in terms of meeting the needs of her clients. I strongly recommend Nancy and her team at RE/MAX.

5/7/21Jaynee Springer

Google Review

Give Nancy a call! You will not regret it!

When our family was ready to begin looking for our home, we did our research, and made a call to Nancy. BEST. DECISION. EVER!!!! Nancy is first-class in her field. Her knowledge and experience in real estate, combined with her straight-forward approach is exactly what you need in today's market! You will not find anyone more dedicated to helping you find your perfect home. I can say without a doubt that if we ever decide to sell and/or purchase another home, she is going to be my first and only call!

4/18/21Andrea Maggelet

Google Review

I would totally recommend her ! She is a great profesional and a very knowledgeable and thrust worthy person ! Will definitely call her next time we need to sell or buy a home

4/14/21Tom Bartlebaugh

Google Review

3/15/21Audrey Noblit

Google Review

I’ve been an agent 32 years and can count on less than one hand the agents I’ve felt were exceptional at what we do, and Nancy is one. From the minute you open the front door of her listings, you are surrounded by beautiful staging that says “welcome”. Her follow through is exceptional. We discovered several wood rotted boards on the deck days before closing which had been snow covered at the time of inspections, and she had it repaired prior to closing. In every way, she is a consummate professional. A true pleasure to work with Nancy.

3/12/21Jason Koenig

Google Review

Nancy is spectacular. I've worked with her twice now, and will call her again.

2/18/21David McInturff

Google Review

We can't say enough good things about Nancy. She brought a motivated and qualified buyer to the table within hours of our posting with a full price offer. She managed every step of the process from inspection to closing, eliminating every potential obstacle along the way. If you are in need of a Realtor, we strongly suggest you give Nancy a call.

2/14/21Jason Kruger

Google Review

I’ve been in the mortgage business for 12+ years and have worked with Nancy on countless transactions. She is always very detailed, great with communication and her clients always have positive things to say about her.

2/8/21Jake Stetler

Google Review

Nancy was a game changer for us in our effort to buy a house. After struggling to see anything that matched our search criteria through other realtors, a friend recommended her. Nancy was able to provide a highly tailored list of the exact homes we wanted to look at and walk through.
She won’t waste your time with bull...ony.

2/5/21Morgan Hayes

Google Review

Nancy is amazing. Seriously one of a kind, so knowledgeable, passionate and driven. I’ve learned so much from her in the years I’ve known and worked with her. She wants the best for her clients and she WILL get the job done. She’s bold, she knows what action steps to take and when. If you’re looking for a realtor, I can’t recommend her enough. Very top quality!!!

2/2/21John Jay Otterman

Google Review

2/2/21Steve Heimberger

Google Review

Nancy made selling our property a breeze from start to finish. She met with us weeks prior to listing and provided feedback as to what steps we could take which would allow us to market the house better and was very responsive throughout the process. Her no-nonsense approach allowed us to get on the market fast and under contract in a matter of days. Very professional and great to work with. Highly recommend!

1/30/21Aaron Huber

Google Review

Nancy impresses me with her knowledge of real estate and houses. The feed back I have received from her clients is that she is gets things done, has a fabulous personality, knowledge, and is very informative. It is always a pleasure to get a call from Nancy!! A lot of people can get to 90% or 95%, Nancy is one of the few that can get to 100%

1/28/21Patrick Lushbaugh

Google Review

Nancy and her team have been invaluable while I have been searching for my very first home. She found me a beautiful house and gave me references to local mortgage companies, making the entire process practically effortless. With her expertise, I have found a home to start building my life. I can't thank her and her team enough.

1/22/21Lucas Popovich

Google Review

Nancy was truly a professional during our time together, always punctual and responsive when we had a showing or just having a simple question. She guided me to buying the perfect house where I am truly happy living. Her knowledge of the area is incredible as well. 10/10 will be going back to Nancy with my next real estate purchase!

1/21/21Emily Nowakowski

Google Review

Nancy is absolutely wonderful to work with! She made buying our first house such a breeze! She was always available to show us any house that came on the market. Nancy was extremely helpful, transparent, and reliable through the entire process. She was honest and upfront which was very important to us since we were new to the home buying process. She really cared about us and understood our needs from the very beginning. We will forever be using Nancy for our real estate needs!

1/20/21ashley urbano

Google Review

I’m so glad we had the pleasure of working with Nancy on selling our rental property! She made the process seamless! Nancy is not only professional but she cares about her clients experience and that alone sets her apart from others. She gets results and is simply the best! Thank you for all of your hard work!

1/19/21Dawn McKeel

Google Review

1/14/21Robyn Gable

Google Review

We tried selling our house By Owner, and we weren't successful. Once Nancy took over, showings started happening continuously. We couldn't get the exposure we needed on our own, Nancy did that for us! She had the house staged, got the word out, and things fell into place quickly. She found an owner that would take care of the home we grew up in and that was the icing on the cake!! Nancy is knowledgeable, professional, honest, and motivated! Our family has had Nancy help us with buying AND selling a few houses and every experience has been EXCELLENT!!!

1/14/21Erin Bahil

Google Review

Nancy is absolutely wonderful to work with. She was very thorough and explained everything in a way that was easy to understand. I would highly recommend her.

1/13/21Lisa Jarvis

Google Review

From the sellers standpoint, it was very carefree. Nancy handles everything very efficiently. I can’t think of a way it could have gone smoother.

1/13/21Hiba Amawi

Google Review

The best real estate agent in the area ! Did several transactions and every time she proved how professional she is ! The one to pick if you are thinking to buy or sell your home

1/12/21Brenda Adamov

Google Review

While living in Arizona I wanted to find a house in Akron. Nancy was amazing! She found what we were looking for and worked quickly to make the deal happen. Nancy also made the paperwork seamless since I was still in Arizona. If you are looking for a realtor to help you find that perfect home...look no further than Nancy Bartlebaugh!

1/11/21Chris Moll

Google Review

There is so much to say about Nancy and RE/MAX, Nancy helped find us our forever home and sold our house at the same time, instead of being stressed and nervous she made the process seamless and exciting, not only did was she a great realtor she became a friend in the process....highly recommended to anyone looking to buy or sell.

1/11/21Jina Gentry

Google Review

1/11/21Heidi Hall

Google Review

Being represented by Nancy Bartlebaugh, of RE/MAX Trends, commands respect. Top buyers have top agents!

1/10/21Barbie Malick

Google Review

12/30/20Sylvia Shrader

Google Review

Nancy is a top quality real estate professional who uses every tool at her disposal to get your home sold! Through her innovative marketing plans, I have seen her accept multiple offers on homes that other agents have tried to sell for a year with NO success! With Nancy’s extensive experience and the team she has built, she will sell your home EVEN FASTER when it is exposed to an exponential number of eager buyers!! You can’t go wrong calling Nancy today!!

12/30/20Trent Smith

Google Review

Sold our house on the first day. Very knowledgeable about the market. I wouldn't hesitate to use her again. If you are looking to buy or sell I highly recommend Nancy

12/15/20Amy Ruggeri

Google Review

Loved working with Nancy!! She’s on top of her game every step of the way. Super great and efficient communication, set expectations that were realistic, went above and beyond for us. If you are looking for a relator that gets the job done, she’s the one you want to be working with!! Sold our house in less than a day and found our dream house and helped us negotiate an amazing deal. We will continue to send business her way for sure!

5/28/19Greg Stearn

Google Review

Top Notch Real Estate Team

5/19/19Shannon Sinnett

Google Review

Nancy is one of the best honest, hard working, reliable, and informational realators I have experienced. She is about quality not quantity. She takes time to sit down with her clients and pin point what the client is looking for. She knows her standard guidelines legally and is willing to put her self out there for her clients. She has sold homes to a diversity of my friends and the experience has always been positive. She pores her heart into her clients and you can tell she loves her job. She is absolutely loyal until the client is happy. It’s nice to have a realator that knows her job and has passion for what she does, thanks Nancy for helping me and friends I know find the home they love and for working so hard to make me satisfied.

1/4/21A & M Violand

Homes.com Review

Nancy was an absolute dream come true when it came to realtors. My.husband and I were looking to purchase our first home together and Nancy was the PEFRECT for us! My husband and I felt Nancy knew exactly what we wanted and provided her insight with every house we walked through. Her knowledge on homes is incredible and will ONLY show you the beat of the best. I will say, I felt like Nancy was my mom because she was so relatable and easy to talk to and work with. We LOVE Nancy!

1/4/21J. Craig

Homes.com Review

Nancy sold our home in a neighborhood full of homes for sale. I have the old neighbors calling, and asking me how I sold so fast!! Nancy kept the process moving, and the end results were great. All said and done, trying to sell a place on your own is a rough road, and not a great idea. I am so happy I called Nancy. She came recommended and now I know why.I would recommend that you call Nancy and just see what she can do for you.

1/6/21Russell Przychocki

Homes.com Review

Sylvia Tonhaeuser, a member of the Bartlebaugh Sales Team, did a good job in guiding me through the entire process from finding a new home all the way through getting the keys. She was professional and timely throughout all interactions.

4/2/20Lisa Poor

Homes.com Review

Nancy was very professional and accessible. She communicated frequently and responded when we called her. She was able to set up opportunities for us to see prospective properties in a very short period of time. Nancy was honest and pointed out any concerns she had with prospective properties. She took the time to get to know us and our preferences. We were able to buy and then sell our previous home shortly afterward. Nancy made the whole process go very smoothly . She is high energy and works hard to find your dream home. I highly recommend her.

1/6/21John and Lindsay Smith

Homes.com Review

Nancy was very good and listened to what we wanted and was very insightful of what the houses need and if it was in our budget. We sold our home, and she didnt let us settle when we bought another. She was up front with us from day one is very knowledgeable about houses and trust her when she says walk away.

1/6/21T M

Homes.com Review

Nancy has been so helpful with the purchase of our new home! She is very attentive and professional, as well as just a genuinely kind person. Buying and selling homes can be so stressful- but working with Nancy has been the complete opposite! We absolutely recommend working with her if you are in the market to buy or sell a home! She’s the best!

1/4/21Pat Didyk

Homes.com Review

I knew she was going to be the one to sell our home from her extensive knowledge of the Ellet area of Akron. She was a delight to work with. Nancy worked energetically for us and was always willing to handle any matters that would make the process easier on us. A wealth of knowledge and a skilled negotiator. She truly had our best interests in mind.

1/4/21Gina Stanificki

Homes.com Review

I'm so fortunate to have received a postcard from Nancy. I had already interviewed two other agents but received her postcard in the mail for another home she sold in our neighborhood. She sells houses ALL OVER ELLET. There was an immediate connection. She staged our home, had a photographer take the pictures and advertised it all over because it was not going to be easy to sell our house. She also helped us buy our forever home in Fairlawn. She still calls and checks on us! I have also referred several sellers to her. She literally knows everything about buying and selling.

1/6/21Tina Osborne

Homes.com Review

This is the second time we have used Nancy to sell a home for us and believe me she rocks. She is the expert in Ellet / 44312. She is no nonsense, gets to the job and has excellent marketing skills.

4/1/20Betsy Bogdanovich

Homes.com Review

Nancy was great and so helpful with my first home purchase. She communicates well and always had my best interest in mind.

1/4/21S. McClain

Homes.com Review

Nancy provided a great service to me. She listened to my goals regarding the sale of my house and provided me with some sound advice on how I could achieve them. She was spot ON! My house sold with my satisfaction!!

1/4/21Brandon Foster

Homes.com Review

Can’t say enough positive things about Nancy Bartelbaugh! She went above and beyond getting my house under contract in about 18 HOURS! When things started to get off track during the inspection, she stood her ground and got things done! A top-notch professional and an admirable person on top of that! Hands down one of the top REALTORS in the AKRON, OH area!