Paul Shay Real Estate Agent - CENTURY 21 Scheetz

1414 E New York St, Indianapolis, IN Pending $414,900 - co-listed by Paul Shay — Pending $414,900 • Co-Listing Agent

Paul Shay co-listing agent for 2307 Saddle Dr, Shelbyville, IN - sold for $380,000 — Sold $380,000 • Co-Listing Agent

1504 N Park Ave, Indianapolis, IN For Sale $3,290,000 - co-listed by Paul Shay — For Sale $3,290,000 • Co-Listing Agent

Paul Shay buyer's agent for 1557 Rosebank Dr, Westfield, IN - sold for $715,000 — Sold $715,000

2026 N Talbott St, Indianapolis, IN For Sale $819,000 - co-listed by Paul Shay — For Sale $819,000 • Co-Listing Agent

Paul Shay

Indianapolis IN

CENTURY 21 Scheetz

53 Closed Sales

$20.9M Total Value

$205K - $1.5M Price Range

$394.6K Average Price

Prior 5 years

About Paul

Home Types: House, Condo, Townhouse, MultiFamily, Lot/Land, Co-op

Years of Experience: 4

Transaction History

1 Year
2 Year
5 Year

Seller Deals
Total Deals	10
Total Value	$3,909,800
Average Sale Price	$390,980
Price Range	$180K - $620K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	3
Total Value	$1,790,000
Average Sale Price	$596,667
Price Range	$490K - $715K

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	19
Total Value	$6,706,400
Average Sale Price	$352,968
Price Range	$93K - $620K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	6
Total Value	$2,926,500
Average Sale Price	$487,750
Price Range	$70K - $715K

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	35
Total Value	$12,323,900
Average Sale Price	$352,111
Price Range	$93K - $650K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	18
Total Value	$8,591,400
Average Sale Price	$477,300
Price Range	$70K - $1.5M

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Paul is Experienced In

Paul's Open Houses

Co-Listing Agent

$819,000

Open Sun 12PM - 2PM
- 5 Beds
- 3.5 Baths
- 3,523 Sq Ft
2026 N Talbott St

Indianapolis, IN
This stunning custom home in Herron-Morton features 5 bedrooms, 3 1/2 baths, and a completely finished basement. That's just for starters! The main floor is a great place for entertaining with such features as a bar area, wine refrigerator, gas fireplace, and hardwood floors. There is also a spacious main floor bedroom option. The kitchen is appointed with quartz countertops, stainless steel

Paul Shay CENTURY 21 Scheetz

Paul's Active Listings

Co-Listing Agent

$3,290,000
- 8 Beds
- 9.5 Baths
- 9,147 Sq Ft
1504 N Park Ave

Indianapolis, IN
Welcome to the VonHake-Rau house in the historic Old Northside! This completely renovated Queen Anne style home sits on a half-acre lot. Highlights are a main home featuring 4 beds 5 1/2 baths, and elevator, a completely renovated 2100s.f. carriage house that has been converted to a 3 bed 3 full bath two story home w/elevator, and finally, a rare for downtown 4 car garage with an 1,100 s.f. one

Paul Shay CENTURY 21 Scheetz

Co-Listing Agent

$224,900
- 2 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,746 Sq Ft
25 E Minnesota St

Indianapolis, IN
Charming bungalow style home in the Old Southside! This nicely updated 2 bed 2 bath home features a main floor bedroom, spacious living room, exposed brick, and tall ceilings! Kitchen features stainless steel appliances. Upstairs has a spacious primary suite. The fenced in back yard is a great space. This home also features a 2 car garage which is hard to come by in the area. Great location to

Paul Shay CENTURY 21 Scheetz

Co-Listing Agent

$414,900
- 4 Beds
- 4 Baths
1414 E New York St

Indianapolis, IN
Great income producing opportunity with this Holy Cross Duplex! Each side is a 2 bed 1.5 bath with completely fenced backyard, charming front porch and one car garage for each unit. This home is well cared for as the current owner has recently replaced the roof within the past two years, both furnaces, and a water heater! Just steps from King Dough Pizzeria, LaParada, and Highland Park. Just 5

Paul Shay CENTURY 21 Scheetz

Recently Sold

$518,000

Sold May 29, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,024 Sq Ft
609 Pomeroy St

Indianapolis, IN
- 3% Below List
- $256/SF
- 57 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $525K
Paul Shay CENTURY 21 Scheetz

$459,000

Sold Apr 7, 2025
- 4 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,449 Sq Ft
11185 Beardsley Way

Fishers, IN
- 10% Above List
- $187/SF
- 4 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $431K
Paul Shay CENTURY 21 Scheetz

$445,000

Sold Feb 14, 2025
- 2 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 1,980 Sq Ft
1835 Livery Way

Indianapolis, IN
- 6% Below List
- $225/SF
- 144 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $441K
Paul Shay CENTURY 21 Scheetz

$305,000

Sold Jun 14, 2023
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,652 Sq Ft
405 Lincoln St

Indianapolis, IN
- 4% Below List
- $185/SF
- 9 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $321K
Paul Shay CENTURY 21 Scheetz

Agent License: Indiana RB17001493

Paul Shay

(859) 710-6573

Homes for Sale by City

Paul Shay

About Paul

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Paul is Experienced In

Paul's Listings and Deals

Paul's Open Houses

Paul's Active Listings

Recently Sold