Sibley Poland

8/21/25Amy Yersavich

Google Review

Sibley Poland was a great help to me in selling my late father's condo. Because the condo was part of my Dad's Trust, quite a few questions came up- questions I haven't dealt with in previous real estate transactions. Sibley was very responsive and if she didn't have the answer, she often researched it on her own and got back to me with the answer or next steps - very helpful to someone who is the Executor of an estate, working, babysitting a granddaughter for a month and has no time! I would highly recommend Sibley for any real estate transactions you become involved in!

8/19/25Tiffany Borden

Google Review

Sibley helped me with my second home buying experience and helped the extire way. Even though you realtor isn't selling the house, having a local experienced realtor is the way to go and Sibley has so many resources in the county.

6/8/25Angelita Lopez

Google Review

She help us buy a house in 2022 and then she help us sell it 2025. She helps us a lot. She was very kind and explain the process to us.

5/30/25Vandemic Vans

Google Review

We've used Sibley on several transactions, both buying and selling. She is great! If you love in Mount Vernon and you need a top agent look no further than Sibley!!

5/30/25Becca Clements

Google Review

As first-time home buyers relocating from out-of-state, we were nervous about navigating such a big decision from a distance, but working with Sibley made all the difference! She is kind, knowledgeable, and incredibly responsive. She helped us understand the local market, answered all of our (many!) questions with patience and clarity, and guided us through each step of the process with confidence.

Because we couldn’t always be there in person, Sibley went above and beyond - sending detailed videos, providing honest insights during showings, and helping us evaluate pros and cons we might have missed. We always felt like she had our best interests at heart, and her local expertise was invaluable.

Thanks to Sibley, we found a home we love and felt fully supported every step of the way. We’re so grateful and can’t recommend her highly enough!

5/30/25Marina DiMario

Google Review

I have used Sibley few times for the past decade. She is very professional & knowledgeable. She has gone above & beyond in making sure we were happy. I would recommend her again & again.

9/4/24Karol Hofius

Google Review

Sibley Poland with Red One Realty was a pleasure to work with! She was very professional and knowledgeable and helped us find our forever home! She was always available night and day for our many questions. She made this process go so smoothly. We highly recommend Sibley!!

7/30/24Catherine Colopy

Google Review

Sibley went above and beyond to assist my husband and I with the purchase of our first home. She made the process feel so smooth and easy. Whenever we had questions, she made sure to get us answers quickly. We felt very secure working with her throughout the entire process. She even made time in her busy schedule to write and submit an offer for us the day she returned from vacation. We cannot thank her enough!

7/29/24Janice Watts

Google Review

I was so thankful to have such a good realtor as Sibley pulland. She went above and beyond for me in the sale of my home. I would highly recommend her to others who are interested in either buying or selling. Thank you, Sibley

7/29/24Karen Blair

Google Review

2/3/24Karen Park

Google Review

Will call them back

8/17/23Nav A

Google Review

Knowledgeable and professional,
we highly recommend Sibley if buying or selling your home!

3/12/23A T

Google Review

It's good to see a realtor genuinely looking out for her clients' best interest. Someone who is knowledgable, professional, listens and presents facts about the property and the current market in the area. All the tools a buyer needs to make a sound decision without adding any pressure. She understands that buying a house during these market swings are pressure enough for her clients. Which is why she is completely transparent and honest when asked for an opinion or advise. I've bought many properties through Sibley and will continue to do so to expand my investment portfolio. I also recommended her to many of my family and friends. because I was confident that she won't let them down and It's nice to see that in proof through their positive reviews for her.

2/8/23Jared Young

Google Review

9/22/22Brett McMurray

Google Review

1st time home buyers. Very helpful! Positive experience, I would definitely recommend Sibley to anyone looking to buy a home!

9/15/22jay studebaker

Google Review

Sibley worked very hard to assure that we got into the right home at the right price and also marketed the home we were selling very well to maximize our profits. We highly recommend her!

9/15/22Paul Snyder

Google Review

Couldn’t ask for a better realtor she helped me buy my first house 13 years ago and helped me purchase multiple properties since then. She always has the answers I am looking for and if not she gets them quickly she goes out of her way for her clients and I will always call Sibley for any real estate needs

6/26/22Tracy Wiebenga

Google Review

My Husband and I first met Sibley at a random Zillow listing we were interested in. We didn’t have a realtor at the time and Sibley was the one to answer the random call. Talk about lucky for us. We had a want/need/wish list for our future home. Sibley nailed all 3. Not only did she find our dream home, she also helped us find contractors to get our house ready for sale. She did everything! She made it so smooth and easy. She went above and beyond for us. We fell in love with Sibley so much a friendship was born. Sibley doesn’t rest for her clients. There are no weekends or days off for Sibley. She cares that much for her Clients. She is the Ace card in the deck. You want to work with Sibley Poland. She’s 5 massive stars!!

3/10/22Brian Byers

Google Review

Highly recommend. Sibley was with me every step of the way to ensure superior service. Most of the time I felt as if I were associating with a friend rather than just a real estate agent.

2/25/22Seth Ziegman

Google Review

2/25/22Kent WoodwardGinther

Google Review

Rarely have we worked with a real estate professional as thoughtful and caring as Sibley! She always goes above and beyond her duties and ensures her clients are taken care of. We can't imagine working with anyone else as future needs arise.

2/25/22marty parker

Google Review

Wow! I have done a number of real estate transaction and I have to say Sibley went above and beyond what all of my other realtors do. She didn't flinch when I asked to see more properties and then rushed to set up the next appointments. She patiently kept at it until we found the perfect home! Double High Five!

2/24/22Jean Arnold

Google Review

Sibley was awesome, and she was always available for any questions or concerns I had.

2/24/22Stephen Organ

Google Review

Sibley was professional, responsive and provided excellent advise throughout the sale of our home.

6/15/21Michael Dopson

Google Review

This lady did all I requested and anticipated needs ahead of my asking. If she could walk on water her shoes would not get wet.

6/15/21Barbara Emler

Google Review

6/15/21Travis Born

Google Review

6/15/21Michael VanZant

Google Review

Sibley is the best! From first conversation to showings/multiple offers to sale, her experience and intuition served us well. She is a pleasure to work with, is responsive, kind, and gracious. We recommend Sibley to any and everyone who is buying or selling a home!

6/3/21Mark Ray

Google Review

One of the best realitor's there is.very friendly know's her stuff would not hesitate to use her again.

4/16/21Nick Blanchard

Google Review

3/17/21Mari Jean

Google Review

Sibley was beyond amazing during the stressful times of selling my grandfathers home! She did well beyond her job at helping with situations that we came across! She is also very responsive and fast at getting back to you!

11/7/20Christina Bagarolo Shupp

Google Review

10/24/20Zach Banks

Google Review

I purchased my home with Sibley in 2017, I am currently working with her again to find my next home! She has been a fantastic realtor an is very personable an knowledgeable! Definitely recommend if looking to buy a home or sell your current home!

10/24/20Michael Brady

Google Review

Incredible knowledge and complete understanding of the real estate world. Communicates great and is super easy to work with. Can’t recommend highly enough. If you want someone that will help you through every step of the real estate process, understand your needs and care about the end results then Sibley is the perfect realtor for you!

10/8/20Brittany Peppers

Google Review

Sibley was fantastic! She made buying our first home so easy. She was super helpful and very quick to get back to you if you had any questions. Best agent ever! ❤️

10/1/20Jacqueline McAllister

Google Review

Sibley did a great job listing my house: the pictures and online presentation were BEAUTIFUL! This was especially important with COVID--many people only want to see a house if they feel it's worth their while. She also did a great job with all of the paperwork. I definitely recommend her!

10/1/20Jeremiah Denuit

Google Review

9/30/20Leah Burd

Google Review

Sibley was amazing! She really went out of her way to help us find our home! She is very knowledgeable, professional, and kind! I recommend her to everyone!

9/30/20Bob Landgrave

Google Review

Sydney Poland is the best real estate agent I have ever dealt with in my entire life I would trust her to find me at home to help me purchase a home and it’s exactly what she did and for that my wife and I are so grateful Bob and Peg Landgrave thank you so much!!

9/12/20Julie Wojciechowski

Google Review

Amazing to work with! Communication was wonderful definitely there to help

7/30/20Jack Stewart

Google Review

Relocating from out of state, we were in need of an seasoned agent to help guide us in both the local area and market. Sibley was more than professional and helpful in finding us our new home and following through to closing. We always felt like we were in good hands with our purchase and would highly recommend her to our friends and family.