Bethany Christian Schools

Bethany Christian Schools

Private Elementary, Middle, High School | Grade 1-12
2904 S Main St,  Goshen, IN
4.2
4.5
276 Students
A-
Niche Grade

School Details

Head of School
Mr Tim Lehman
Student Teacher Ratio
12:1
Average SAT Score
1200
Average ACT Score
30
Average GPA
3.57
Religious Affiliation
Anabaptist

Niche Grade

A-
Academics
B
Teachers
B+
College Prep
B+
Resources/Facilities
B
Clubs and Activities
B
Sports
Source: Niche
Niche Grades

Niche grades and rankings are calculated using dozens of public data sets and millions of reviews. Niche data scientists and user researchers rigorously analyze data and user opinions to assess the key aspects of K-12 Schools, Colleges, and Places to Live. Every month, millions of students and families use the Niche grades and report cards to find the right school or neighborhood.

Niche Grade Details

Academics
Average GPA
3.57
Teachers
Student Teacher Ratio
12:1
Teachers
26
Full Time Teachers
19
Part Time Teachers
7
College Prep
Average SAT
1200
Math
590
Verbal
610
Average ACT
30
Math
31
English
30
Reading
30
Science
27
Four-Year Matriculation Rate
92%

GreatSchools Rating Details

Student Diversity

Male
53.5%
Female
46.5%
White
64%
Hispanic
22.7%
Two or more races
5.2%
Asian or Pacific Islander
4.9%
Black
3.1%

School Rankings

#8 Best Christian Schools in Indiana
Source: Niche

Colleges Students are Considering

Students are most interested in or go on to attend these colleges.
Goshen College 43 Students
Purdue University 29 Students
Indiana University - Bloomington 23 Students
Ball State University 23 Students
Grace College 17 Students
Bethel University - Indiana 17 Students
Indiana Wesleyan University-Marion 13 Students
Indiana University - South Bend 12 Students
Hesston College 12 Students
Valparaiso University 11 Students

What Students Want to Study

Niche users from this school are most interested in the following majors.
Nursing 17 Students
Business 14 Students
Psychology 11 Students
Graphic Design 9 Students
Architecture 8 Students
Social Work and Youth Services 8 Students
Marketing 7 Students
Education 7 Students
Physical Therapy 6 Students
Creative Writing 6 Students

This School’s Reviews

Niche Reviews
4.2 31 Reviews
5.0 Alum
6/27/2023
I was apart of the class of 2023 and I loved Bethany so much! Bethany is a school all about opportunities and learning that is fit for each person.
5.0 Senior
9/11/2022
Bethany has a very supportive community. I love the way that the teachers respect students and the students respect teachers and each other. The schools motto is "known and loved" and I wholehearedly that believe that they live up to this.
5.0 Alum
4/16/2022
I enjoyed the sense of community as well as the student to teacher ratio, allowing students for a greater chance at success. Overall a great school.
GreatSchools Reviews
4.5 15 Reviews
5.0 parent
10/2/2025
Both of my kids attend Bethany Christian School, and it is such a great place! The academic rigor is balanced with a strong sense of community and support. My kids are challenged at school, but they love going to school. Bethany provides them a great place to grow into the people they are becoming a...
5.0 other
9/25/2025
Usually the Members of the community create a school climate characterized by physical and emotional safety, joy in learning, kindness, and positive leadership. Having a good staff supporting students in the best way to be a great environment to learn and work is very important.
5.0 parent
4/20/2025
Bethany has been a wonderful place to go to school. There is so many opportunities that Bethany has for the kids
2.0 parent
4/7/2025
Given the steep price tag, this is a mostly upper-middle class school. Despite the professed values, can be elitist and insular. Administration turns a blind eye to bullying and discrimination. Does have rigorous academic standards that it can enforce given the self selected student body.

Agents Specializing Near This School

See All Agents

Map

Homes for Sale

Homes for Rent

Additional Schools in the Area

Bethany Christian Schools is a private Anabaptist school for students in grades 1-12 located at 2904 S Main St in Goshen, IN. The school has a total enrollment of 276 and maintains a student-teacher ratio of 12:1. Bethany Christian Schools has received feedback and ratings, with a Niche grade of A-. The average GPA is 3.57. Average standardized test scores include an SAT score of 1200 and an ACT score of 30. Discover additional schools in the area, like Goshen High School, Fairfield Junior/Senior High School, St. Vincent de Paul Elementary School, and more. Learn more about what Goshen has to offer, and browse homes for sale and for rent near Bethany Christian Schools.

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.