13

Recently Sold Shelter Island, NY Homes

Section Image
  • 1 Rebel Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    $975,000 Sold May 20, 2025

    1 Rebel Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • 2 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,472 Sq Ft
    • Built 1981

    Last Sold Summary

    • 20% Below List Price
    • $662/SF
    • 174 Days On Market

    Current Estimated Value $1,522,000

    Last Listing Agent Debra Von Brook Binder Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

    1 Rebel Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
  • 44 Saint Mary's Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    $3,500,000 Sold Feb 11, 2025

    44 Saint Mary's Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • 3 Beds
    • 4 Baths
    • 3,225 Sq Ft
    • Built 1985

    Last Sold Summary

    • 10% Below List Price
    • $1,085/SF
    • 28 Days On Market

    Current Estimated Value $2,810,220

    Last Listing Agent Michael Brennan Douglas Elliman Real Estate

    44 Saint Mary's Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
  • 3 Sea Gull Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    $1,950,000 Sold Mar 14, 2025

    3 Sea Gull Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • 3 Beds
    • 2.5 Baths
    • 1,650 Sq Ft
    • Built 1953

    Last Sold Summary

    • 1% Below List Price
    • $1,182/SF
    • 322 Days On Market

    Current Estimated Value $2,369,670

    Last Listing Agent Cynthia Barrett Brown Harris Stevens Hamptons

    3 Sea Gull Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
  • /9

    $795,000 Sold Oct 10, 2025

    33B S Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • 2 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • Built 1950

    Last Sold Summary

    • 11% Below List Price
    • 142 Days On Market

    Last Listing Agent Shane Donahue The Agency Hamptons

    33B S Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
  • 7 Gazon Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    $2,650,000 Sold Oct 16, 2025

    7 Gazon Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • 3 Beds
    • 2.5 Baths
    • 1,901 Sq Ft
    • Built 1955

    Last Sold Summary

    • 8% Below List Price
    • $1,394/SF
    • 130 Days On Market

    Last Listing Agent Terry Thompson Douglas Elliman Real Estate

    7 Gazon Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
  • 5 Wade Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    $1,450,000 Sold May 30, 2025

    5 Wade Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • 3 Beds
    • 3 Baths
    • 1,854 Sq Ft
    • Built 1967

    Last Sold Summary

    • 3% Below List Price
    • $782/SF
    • 20 Days On Market

    Current Estimated Value $1,538,168

    Last Listing Agent Rosanna Piazza Signature Premier Properties

    5 Wade Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
  • 7 Westmoreland Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    $4,350,000 Sold Oct 31, 2025

    7 Westmoreland Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • 6 Beds
    • 4.5 Baths
    • 4,957 Sq Ft
    • Built 1901

    Last Sold Summary

    • 1% Above List Price
    • $878/SF
    • 18 Days On Market

    Last Listing Agent Carl Gambino Compass Greater NY LLC

    7 Westmoreland Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
  • 18 Dickerson Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11786

    $2,500,000 Sold Feb 11, 2025

    18 Dickerson Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11786

    • 4 Beds
    • 3.5 Baths
    • 2,774 Sq Ft
    • Built 1973

    Last Sold Summary

    • $901/SF
    • 16 Days On Market

    Current Estimated Value $2,478,200

    Last Listing Agent Michael Brennan Douglas Elliman Real Estate

    18 Dickerson Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11786
  • 104 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    $4,950,000 Sold May 30, 2025

    104 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • 5 Beds
    • 5.5 Baths
    • 4,040 Sq Ft
    • Built 2023

    Last Sold Summary

    • $1,225/SF
    • 14 Days On Market

    Current Estimated Value $4,985,281

    Last Listing Agent Debra Von Brook Binder Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

    104 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
  • 12 Terry Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    $2,799,000 Sold Nov 14, 2025

    12 Terry Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • 5 Beds
    • 4.5 Baths
    • 4,200 Sq Ft
    • Built 2015

    Last Sold Summary

    • $666/SF
    • 24 Days On Market

    Last Listing Agent Debra Von Brook Binder Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

    12 Terry Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
  • 8 Wheeler Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    $660,000 Sold Dec 02, 2025

    8 Wheeler Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • Land
    • 1.2 Acres
    • $550,000 per Acre

    Last Sold Summary

    • 17% Below List Price
    • 99 Days On Market

    Last Listing Agent Nicholas Planamento William Raveis New York LLC

    8 Wheeler Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
  • 1 Deer Park Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    $1,050,000 Sold Jan 24, 2025

    1 Deer Park Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • 3 Beds
    • 3.5 Baths
    • 2,460 Sq Ft
    • Built 1993

    Last Sold Summary

    • 40% Below List Price
    • $427/SF
    • 153 Days On Market

    Current Estimated Value $1,580,126

    Last Listing Agent Debra Von Brook Binder Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

    1 Deer Park Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964
  • 5 Country Club Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    $1,250,000 Sold Feb 07, 2025

    5 Country Club Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    • 3 Beds
    • 2.5 Baths
    • 2,380 Sq Ft
    • Built 1986

    Last Sold Summary

    • 25% Below List Price
    • $525/SF
    • 304 Days On Market

    Current Estimated Value $1,555,756

    Last Listing Agent Tina Marika Kaasik Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

    5 Country Club Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average home price in Shelter Island, NY?
Homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY have an average home price of $3,045,096.
What is the average time to sell a house in Shelter Island, NY?
The houses for sale in Shelter Island, NY spend an average of 58 days on the market.
What is the number of active homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY?
There are 19 active homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY.
How many homes have sold over the last 12 months in Shelter Island, NY?
12 homes have sold in Shelter Island, NY over the last 12 months.

Home Trends in Shelter Island, NY

Housing Trends

Median Sale Price
$2,225,000
Median Single Family Sale Price
$2,724,500
Average Price Per Sq Ft
$1,195
Number of Homes for Sale
19
Last 12 months Home Sales
12
Months of Supply
19.00
Median List Price
$2,495,000
Median Change From 1st List Price
6%
Median Home Sale Price YoY Change
11%
How to Buy a Home How to Finance a Home How to Sell a Home