Recently Sold Casey Key Homes

Auction Property. AUCTION BIDDING OPEN: Bidding ends 6/26. Previously listed at $6.445M. Current high bid $4M. An architectural masterpiece awaits on Casey Key, where traditional Gulf Coast charm meets bold contemporary design in this magnificent 2018-built waterfront estate. Spanning 6,335 square feet of refined living space, the residence captivates with soaring ceilings and dramatic

Joel Schemmel PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

This is a studio unit on Casey Key, at a beachfront development directly on the sands of the Gulf. Completely renovated, featuring an on-site rental management office. Historical rental data available. Only 26 units, Gulf of Bay development with boat slips available to rent for your stay. Ideal for a getaway or gathering potential income while not staying at the beach. Comes turnkey furnished,

Dennis Girard PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

DIRECT BEACHFRONT BEING SOLD AT LAND VALUE! Best beachfront value on the barrier island. This 1.1-acre property on Casey Key features an impressive 100 feet of direct beach frontage, boasting endless sun-kissed days and breathtaking sunsets right from your own backyard. The allure of this property lies in its value - priced to sell below current appraisal. Rarely does an opportunity to own such a

Nicole Hammons-Dovgopolyi MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY

Experience the epitome of refined coastal living at 924 Casey Cove Drive, where elegant architecture meets breathtaking natural beauty on exclusive Casey Key Barrier Island. This immaculate waterfront estate boasts 246 feet of pristine shoreline offering mesmerizing 180-degree Intracoastal views—a perfect setting to witness dolphins playfully dancing at sunrise, spectacular crimson sunsets, and

Andrea Stultz ENGEL + VOELKERS SARASOTA

Step into this sprawling 3-bedroom, 3-bath beach house, perfectly positioned on a generous third of an acre on the tranquil Casey Key. With over 3300 square feet of living space and a refreshing saltwater pool, this two-story home epitomizes the relaxed beach lifestyle. Upstairs, the space was untouched by the storms and features two oversized bedrooms, each with ample closet space and private

Beth Helvey MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY

An amazing opportunity to purchase on Casey Key directly on the Intracoastal Waterway with 100 feet of waterfront and deeded beach access across the street. Walking distance to public beach, North Jetty as well as the restaurants just across the bridge. This home has been in the family for 47 years and now it can be yours. 2 large en-suite bedrooms on opposite ends of the house plus a half bath

John Mooney RE/MAX ALLIANCE GROUP

Discover an extraordinary opportunity to own a stunning bayfront estate on the breathtaking shores of Casey Key. Nestled along 121 feet of prime waterfront, this 3-bedroom, 3-bath residence invites you to embrace the best of coastal living. Whether you choose to update, expand, or design a brand-new architectural masterpiece, the possibilities are endless on this expansive property. Casey Key is

Lee Brewer RE/MAX ALLIANCE GROUP

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Welcome to Casey Key, your personal paradise! This home offers unparalleled waterfront living with views that stretch across the Gulf of America and Little Sarasota Bay. From the great room and elevated primary suite, you can enjoy sunrise vistas over the tranquil bay and breathtaking sunsets over the gulf. The design of this home is an ideal blend

Lisa Napolitano PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY

Unveiling a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own an unparalleled slice of coastal luxury. Welcome to Pretiola Sands Estate, a secluded and gated haven sprawled across 1.4 acres of lush grounds, boasting an impressive 200 feet of private shoreline on both the Gulf of Mexico and the Intracoastal Waterway. Experience the awe-inspiring vistas of the Gulf and Bay from every vantage point of this

Kim Ogilvie MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY

Discover the charm of the Dolphin House, a cherished artist’s residence and retreat, now available for you to create your coastal paradise! This unique property boasts over 100 feet of direct beachfront, providing breathtaking views and soothing sounds of the ocean right at your doorstep. Gulf-front living: Enjoy the home as your turnkey retreat while planning the build of your dream residence.

Valerie Dall'acqua PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

Discover a rare gem on Casey Key. This charming, furnished one-bedroom condominium offers an ideal retreat with the added convenience of an on-site rental office. Embrace the beauty of the Gulf of Mexico and the Intracoastal Waterway, where boating is just near your door. This space allows you the potential to earn rental income when you’re not there to enjoy it yourself. Step inside to find

Dennis Girard PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

This bayfront cottage on Casey Key offers a tranquil island escape with panoramic views of Blackburn Bay, lush landscaping, and indoor-outdoor living from a coral-stone patio or spacious waterside lawn. It features over 200 feet of new seawall and dock, ideal for boaters. With no nearby neighbors, it offers ultimate privacy. The low-density development of the island ensures a peaceful setting,

Valerie Dall'acqua PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY