Caroline, NY Homes for Sale

Where the noise drops off and the land opens up, this property gives you the space, privacy, and setting that’s getting harder to find. A mix of wooded land and open green space surrounds you, creating a place that actually pulls you outside—whether it’s walking the land, watching wildlife, or just taking in the quiet. Come inside, where the kitchen, dining, and living spaces are all open and

Alanie Woodin RE/MAX In Motion

Set in the heart of Brooktondale, this beautifully maintained log home offers a rare pairing of rustic character and everyday livability. Tucked back from the road on a paved driveway, the home immediately welcomes you with mature landscaping, established trees, a covered front porch, and a porch swing that seems to invite you to slow down and stay awhile. Inside, cathedral pine ceilings soar

Alanie Woodin RE/MAX In Motion

Situated on 5 acres in Caroline, just off Route 79, this 4-bedroom, 2-bath home offers privacy in a small pocket neighborhood with convenient access to surrounding areas. The property features a spring-fed, stocked pond, an in-ground pool with pool house, a composite deck overlooking the pool area, and a large detached garage. The home offers a flexible layout with multiple options for bedrooms,

Rebecca 'Reba' McCutcheon Howard Hanna S Tier Inc

They just don’t make them like this anymore! Built in 1937, this charming Dutch Colonial is filled with the timeless details that give an older home its unmistakable warmth and personality. Original woodwork, hardwood floors, classic light fixtures and hardware, and beautiful glass door handles are found throughout, creating a sense of history at every turn. The main level offers a retro kitchen,

Michele Smith Re/Max Plus

Enjoy the best of both worlds at this versatile two-family property set on 1.03 acres just outside Brooktondale. Ideal for owner occupancy, multigenerational living, or investment, the property features two spacious 2-bedroom units. The two-story unit offers 1.5 baths, an updated kitchen, and open living space, while the second unit provides convenient single-level living with an open kitchen and

Kyle Steele Howard Hanna S Tier Inc

Welcome to 25 Goodrich Hill Road, a one-of-a-kind country property tucked into a private setting in Caroline. Set on 4.39 acres with a beautiful pond, open lawn, garden space, and wooded surroundings, this property offers room to spread out, enjoy nature, and take in wide-open countryside views.Inside, the home is filled with character and offers a flexible four-bedroom layout with generous

Karen Hollands Howard Hanna S Tier Inc

Enjoy the best of both worlds at this versatile two-family property set on 1.03 acres just outside Brooktondale. Ideal for owner occupancy, multigenerational living, or investment, the property features two spacious 2-bedroom units. The two-story unit offers 1.5 baths, an updated kitchen, and open living space, while the second unit provides convenient single-level living with an open kitchen and

Kyle Steele Howard Hanna S Tier Inc

Experience serenity in this beautifully built two bedroom, two full bath contemporary home nestled in the forest, surrounded by Shindagin Hollow on one side and conservation land on the other. Located only 15 minutes from Cornell, this stunning, custom built home features stained glass windows, open floor plan with maple kitchen cabinets, oak wood floors and new windows. Lofted primary bedroom

Jill Rosentel Warren Real Estate of Ithaca Inc. (Downtown)

Amazing value-add and sweat equity opportunity in the heart of Ellis Hollow! Tucked high into the woods with a hillside vista and an unmatched sense of privacy, this 4 bed 2 bath home is ready for its new owner(s). Cathedral ceilings compliment a spiral staircase that leads to 3 upstairs bedrooms and a sizeable bathroom. First floor boasts floor to ceiling glass, fireplace, laundry hook ups, full

David Barken Howard Hanna S Tier Inc

Welcome to this charming home situated on a spacious double lot in the heart of Caroline. Conveniently located near local amenities, with an easy commute to Ithaca or Binghamton and just minutes from over 5,000 acres of Shindagin Hollow State Forest, offering endless opportunities for outdoor adventure. Step inside through the entryway and into a bright, welcoming kitchen that flows nicely

Alanie Woodin RE/MAX In Motion

ONE OF A KIND. Exquisite 4 BR, 2 Bath Arts & Crafts Home in the Town of Caroline/Brooktondale area -- built in 1998 by a master builder. Enhanced with over $200,000 in custom upgrades between 2022 and 2025. Superior craftsmanship and premium materials. Peace and Privacy on 9.57 Acres. Sunrise and Sunset views! Fenced garden with hazelnut trees, blueberries, currants, blackberries, veggies &

Laurel Guy Warren Real Estate of Ithaca Inc. (Downtown)

Fantastic opportunity to own nearly 10 acres of rural real estate, manufactured building with additions, a massive pole barn with heat and electric service that is close to state land. Reside year round or use as recreational escape. Property is close to Ithaca, Cortland, Spencer, and the Finger Lakes region of New York State. Priced to sell, so do not hesitate to schedule a tour.

David Wahl Warren Real Estate of Ithaca Inc. (Downtown)

Not visible from the road! Tucked onto 3 acres, this log home built in 2004 has total visual privacy, but is only minutes to Cornell and downtown Ithaca. Three bedrooms, two baths, with a spacious primary loft big enough to add an office area overlooking the living room, this home has character to share. Beautiful warm wood envelopes you, cathedral ceilings soar, the decks outside overlook the

Hilda Moleski Warren Real Estate of Ithaca Inc. (Downtown)

Three parcels come together here, forming a single stretch of ground defined by variation in both cover and contour. The land carries a steady sense of purpose—suited for hunting, recreation, and long-term stewardship. A well-managed timber stand spreads across the acreage, composed of both hardwoods and softwoods, all enrolled in a NYS 480a forestry management plan that reflects deliberate care

Timothy Kent Listing by Whitetail Properties Real Estate, LLC