$3,771,718Average Value$1,138Average Price per Sq Ft13Homes For Sale
A private-beach suburb near Asbury Park
On the Jersey shore, next to the Atlantic Ocean, is Allenhurst, a beach borough that’s a little more than a quarter square mile in size. Stately houses, many built in the early 1900s, and a compact row of locally owned businesses on Main Street solidify the neighborhood’s suburban atmosphere. However, the area’s coastal twist makes it more of a seasonal destination than a commuter community. “I think it’s probably 60% summer and 40% year-round residents,” says Nelson Cunha, an agent with over 20 years’ of experience in the surrounding New Jersey markets. While New York City is 60 miles away, Asbury Park, less than 2 miles south, is a convenient neighbor for nights out, concerts and drinks on the boardwalk.
The beach in Allenhurst is among the most picturesque on the Jersey Shore.
The Allenhurst neighborhood's primary draw is the clean and quiet New Jersey beaches.
1/2
Early 20th-century Colonials by the seashore
Allenhurst has a well-maintained collection of prewar single-family houses with detached garages and manicured yards, thanks in part to local ordinances. “Allenhurst has a rule that you can’t knock down any house built before 1970,” Cunha says. “And if you’re fixing up, it has to look the way it was.” Colonials with porches are the most common, with Craftsmans at the lower end of the market — going down to $1 million — and expansive Victorian mansions at the higher end — going up to $12 million by the beach. Across these styles, most houses are priced between $2 and $5 million. At the south end of Main Street, a townhouse development may be replacing vacant buildings owned by the Jersey Central Power & Light company. “But besides that, there won’t be any more development because there’s no vacant land,” Cunha says.
One of the many Colonial-style houses on Allenhurst streets.
Find unique variations of Colonial-style and Cape Cod homes in Allenhurst's suburban streets.
1/2
Cabanas, swimming and beachy kid-friendly activities
The Allenhurst Beach Club controls access to the local beach. Residents get a discount on their annual membership, and nonmembers can buy day passes, although they aren’t allowed to use the beach cabanas or swimming pool. The Beach Club also runs a youth summer camp, trains junior lifeguards and holds morning yoga classes. Kayaking is permitted, but surfers need to go south to the more lively Asbury Park Beach to catch waves.
The beach in Allenhurst is open all year round for those brave enough to withstand the elements.
Allenhurst residents love swimming in the ocean.
1/2
Green waves for Labor Day
Since 1943, one local Allenhurst family has dyed the water along the shore lime green every Labor Day weekend. It began as a birthday celebration and has become an annual tradition to cherish the final days of summer. For a more modest affair, the Allenhurst Garden Club hosts a biannual Porch and Garden Walk to raise money for their ongoing tending of community flower gardens.
Locally owned eateries and a seaside bistro
To feed Allenhurst’s 500 or so residents, Main Street, on the west side, has a collection of casual restaurants. The Butchers Steakhouse and Deal Lake Bar + Co. serve American classics as well as ahi tuna nachos, and Cravings Bakery has fresh pastries and cappuccinos for dessert. Residents can also browse locally owned shops for antiques, home goods and apparel. On the east side, Mr. C’s Beach Bistro has ocean views with craft cocktails and a full dinner menu. For groceries, a Wegmans supermarket 3 miles west is the most convenient option.
Locals love the friendly service at Serpico's in Allenhurst.
Cravings in Allenhurst is a Bakery/cafe specializing in customized cakes & deserts.
1/2
Student commutes to West Long Branch
With no schools of its own, Allenhurst has an agreement with the town of West Long Branch, 4.5 miles north, to allow local kids to attend their public schools. Betty McElmon Elementary teaches preschool through fourth grade, and the Frank Antonides School teaches fifth through eighth grades. Both have a B grade from Niche. Shore Regional High School has an A-minus grade.
Betty McElmon Elementary School's teachers receive an A- from Niche.
Welcome to Frank Antonides School.
1/2
NJ Transit and Jersey’s longest highway
The Allenhurst New Jersey Transit station is part of the North Jersey Coast Line. Residents can take trains farther south down the shore, or north to reach Newark Airport or head into Manhattan. The Garden State Parkway, a major road which has an onramp 7.5 miles inland, connects with I-95 to provide access to New York City and Philadelphia.
Hop on the train to NYC directly from Allenhurst.
The Garden State Parkway is located outside of town to take you to NYC or further south.
NJ Transit is conveniently located in Allenhurst to commute to NYC or southern shore points.
1/3
Photography Contributed By
Steve Cuttler
Video By
Kyle Garrity
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Allegra Cojab,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Allenhurst, NJ sell after 38 days on the market compared to the national average of 55 days. The median sale price for homes in Allenhurst, NJ over the last 12 months is $2,012,500, up 78% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Superb location! Timeless style meets serene water views. Steps from the ocean and lake. Beautifully designed and decorated with a warm and sophisticated ambiance throughout. The inviting front porch offers the perfect setting to entertain while enjoying the incredible surroundings. The second floor offers an outside balcony with additional views of the ocean. The backyard offers an additional
Mary Beth LanaganDiane Turton, Realtors-Spring Lake
Set in the Jersey Shore's top rated beach enclave, 309 Hume Street is a compound comprised of four residences; a single family detached home in the front, unit A, followed by Unit B garage cottage one bedroom 1 bath living room and kitchen; leading to the two family residence (Units C and D) which are two bedroom residences each. All units are fully rented, some month to month basis; there is a
Your very own beautiful beach house available for this summer! Stunning colonial one block to Allenhurst beach & beach club. Move right into this stylish home w/high ceilings,hdwd floors & great taste throughout! Bright Gourmet style kitchen with top of line appliances,quartz counters,center island & breakfast bar,formal DR,LR w/fireplace & a powder room to complete the 1st floor. 3 spacious but
An architecturally refined, fully renovated waterfront residence set on Deal Lake, just one block from the beach, offering an exceptional opportunity for elevated coastal living in Loch Arbour. This expansive first-floor residence features 2 bed and 2.5 baths, stunning water views from the walk-out private patio, convenient parking in the private rear lot, and a rare private one-car garage with
An architecturally refined, fully renovated waterfront residence set on Deal Lake, just one block from the beach, offering elevated coastal living in Loch Arbour. Located within a boutique elevator building, this expansive full-floor residence features 4 bedrooms and 3.5 bathrooms, with convenient parking in the private rear lot. Filled with exceptional natural light, the home offers multiple
Come and see this gorgeous seashore colonial with a stunning pool and cabana. As you step onto the wrap around front porch you will smell the ocean breeze. This home offers a gorgeous state of the art kitchen with top of the line appliances, stone counters and custom cabinetry. This home boasts a stunning foyer with grand staircase. Large den and dining room designed with a gorgeous modern
Last Call to get into the charming coastal town of Allenhurst in time for the Summer of 2026.Renowned for its welcoming front porches, this classic Allenhurst residence promises to impress with refreshing ocean breezes sweeping down the street ,adding an extra touch of comfort. The community also boasts an impressive beach club, train station & a vibrant main street filled with dining & shopping
Spacious and stylish, this 3,246 SF home offers an open floor plan designed for modern living. The vaulted great room with recessed lighting flows into a chef's kitchen featuring stainless steel appliances, ample counter space, and sleek cabinetry. The huge primary suite includes a home office, two walk-in closets, and a Jack & Jill bath with separate sinks and toilets. A first-floor BR with a
Amazing home in West Allenhurst with beautiful views of the lake and has a new in ground pool. This house boasts a great white kitchen with stainless appliances. Gorgeous space for entertaining in your dining room, living room and den overlooking the lake. Stunning primary suite with beautiful bathroom. Finished basement with housekeepers' quarters. Come and see this beautiful home today.
LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION! Adorable Allenhurst Beach house, Charming front porch , 3 large bedrooms and 1.5 baths, Enter into your lovely formal living room with original built ins, a working fireplace , open to the formal dining room with a lovely picture window, Large eat in newer kitchen with stainless steel appliances and granite countertops, large pantry closet, sliding door from the
An architecturally refined, fully renovated penthouse residence set on Deal Lake, just one block from the Atlantic Ocean, offering elevated coastal living in Loch Arbour. Situated within a boutique elevator building, this expansive full-floor penthouse features 4 bedrooms and 3.5 bathrooms, soaring vaulted ceilings, and convenient parking in the private rear lot. Filled with exceptional natural
Upon entering this stunning Colonial home, you are greeted by a dramatic two-story foyer that sets the tone for the impressive space throughout. The home offers seven generously sized bedrooms and five full bathrooms, ideal for comfortable living and entertaining.The main level features a large living room and formal dining room with an open-concept layout, perfect for gatherings. The eat-in
SUMMER RENTAL- $15,000 FOR FULL SEASON (not offered on monthly basis.) Beautiful second floor apartment in Loch Arbour just 3 blocks to the pristine beach. Quiet and high class neighborhood. The space has a large eat in kitchen, nicely sized bedrooms, and a big living room. Close to many top notch restaurants and all that the Jersey Shore has to offer. Fully stocked, furnished and includes washer
WINTER RENTAL!! Charming 4-bedroom, 2-bath home in desirable West Allenhurst. The first floor has been beautifully renovated and features a new eat-in kitchen with stainless steel appliances, perfect for everyday living and entertaining. A spacious dining room offers plenty of room for gatherings, while the cozy den with seating area provides a warm and inviting place to relax. Step outside to a
Luxurious SUMMER Rental located in the heart of Allenhurst. This gut renovated colonial home is complete with high ceilings, open concept living/ dining room and kitchen, gourmet kitchen with peninsula and center island, hardwood floors throughout. The main house has 7 bedrooms, 6.5 bathrooms. The two story pool/ guest house is complete with a fully equipped kitchen, living area, bike room.
Summer Rental | Memorial Day-Labor Day, $70k. Spend a full summer season at this charming Allenhurst home. Ideally located a block from the beach & boardwalk. This charming coastal retreat is designed for relaxed shore living. Comfortable gathering spaces, indoor & outdoor, create an easy flow for entertaining, while quiet corners invite you to unwind after sun-filled days at the beach. Featuring
WINTER RENTAL Rare opportunity to live a block and a half from the ocean. This Loch Arbour home is being offered as a winter rental. Ocean and Lake views from front porch welcoming as you enter front porch area into dining room and living room combination. Large kitchen, three generous size bedrooms on the first floor and a fourth bedroom on the second floor plus plenty of space for home office
SUMMER RENTAL Available June and July 2026. Rare opportunity to live a block and a half from the ocean. This Loch Arbour home is being offered as a summer rental. Ocean and Lake views from front porch welcoming as you enter front porch area into dining room and living room combination. Large kitchen, three generous size bedrooms on the first floor and a fourth bedroom on the second floor plus
SUMMER RENTAL-Stunning coastal retreat in charming West Allenhurst! This beautifully maintained home offers 2 spacious bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, blending comfort with coastal elegance. The lower level features a generous living room filled with natural light, seamlessly connected to an open, eat-in kitchen perfect for both relaxing and entertaining. You'll also find a stylish and functional
Beautifully updated 2 bedroom 1 bath cottage back house for summer rental 2026 in prime location of Loch Arbour. Consists of new kitchen , wood floors , bathroom , living room, basement and parking. Home walking distance to lake, beach , stores and houses of worship.Available June 15th 2026 to Labor Day 2026!
Summer Rental!! Beautiful Fully Furnished 6 bedroom home in the heart of West Allenhurst. Beautiful sun room, side yard, full 2 car garage. Close to all shopping, House of Worship, beaches and local transportation. You don't want to miss this opportunity!
ANNUAL RENTAL! RARE OPPORTUNITY in Allenhurst! Available March 2026! Enjoy living in Prime Location, all together - 5 bedrooms 2 full baths mother/daughter ranch style home! main level has 3 full bedrooms and a full modern bath, newer modern , eat in kitchen, with stainless appliances , granite counter tops, open to Large Living room , 2 bedrooms and one full bath on lower level, a large den
WINTER RENTAL AVAILABLE SEPT 7, 2026 - JUNE 7 , 2027 ! Enjoy this mother daughter , ranch style home in prime Allenhurst location! 5 Bedroom 2 baths , main floor has living room, open to newer eat in kitchen, 3 full bedrooms one bath, lower level has a large den/family room and 2 additional rooms and full bathroom! Large gated yard, plenty of parking, detached garage, all this near public
SUMMER RENTAL! Available May - Labor Day! possibly sooner! Mother/Daughter opportunity! 5 bedrooms 2 full baths ranch style home! main level 3 bedrooms 1 bath full eat in kitchen, large living room, lower level large den or family room 2 additional bedrooms and another full bath! Large private gated back yard, All close to the Allenhurst beach club, many places of worship, public transportation,
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
