$515,181Average Value$198Average Price per Sq Ft3Homes For Sale
Historic Bloomington neighborhood with ties to American icons
Elm Heights is synonymous with the Vinegar Hill Historic District, which got its name from the odor of the dying orchards that once existed there. That fact, however, tells only one piece of this neighborhood’s story. Known for its limestone industry, Indiana supplied the quarried rocks for famous landmarks like the Biltmore Estate in Asheville, North Carolina, and New York’s Empire State Building. Elm Heights drew many industry figures, including family members who introduced the limestone trade to Indiana in the 1800s. While Elm Heights doesn’t have anything on the scale of the nationally renowned structures, those who developed the neighborhood sought to give residents a taste of the iconic projects Bloomington and Indiana helped build. Today, many remain drawn to this community's highly diverse architecture and century-old houses with limestone craftsmanship. “The architecture in some of these homes is just stunning. You just don’t see it every day,” says Tracee Lutes, broker-owner of Re/Max Acclaimed Properties. “They are filled with character and beautiful woodwork. Just so much character.” The neighborhood offers more than historic homes and classic architecture. Diverse dining options are nearby and in downtown Bloomington, which also puts on events throughout the year, and neighboring parks provide recreational opportunities.
The Monroe County Courthouse is the center of downtown Bloomington near Elm Heights.
The Sample Gates form the western entrance to the Old Crescent section of the IU campus.
1/2
Ornate houses spanning a wide range of architecture
This neighborhood, located a few blocks from downtown Bloomington and Indiana University, is split into distinct east and west sides. Students who rent apartments or smaller houses live on the west, while the historic district and its homes are on the east. Greek, Tudor and Colonial Revivals, American Foursquare, Art Deco and even Spanish Colonial are a few of the styles here. “The houses are quite ornate, and the thing that’s cool is that everything’s different. It’s not a ubiquitous kind of thing,” says Angela Van Rooy, Bloomington’s neighborhood services program manager. One house on East First Street has a gargoyle and stonemason carved into its exterior, while many yards have fixtures like small groups of limestone pillars. A historic designation also protects the homes’ distinct looks, and any planned alterations require approval from the city’s Historic Preservation Commission. The smaller single-story homes here range between $250,000 and $450,000, while many of the larger houses sell from $500,000 to $850,000.
This Colonial Revival home is in the eastern part of the Elm Heights neighborhood.
This is a newly renovated Craftsman style home in the Elm Heights neighborhood.
1/2
Within a short walk of downtown Bloomington’s diverse dining scene
Residents here can start their day at the Crumble Coffee and Bakery, where they can grab a warm beverage and one of many freshly baked pastries. More breakfast options like egg-topped avocado toasts are found at the Inkwell Bakery & Cafe. The Elm serves upscale fare in an elegant space decorated with nature-themed art and pottery. Patrons can start with oysters or share a charcuterie and cheese board before moving on to main courses like steak frites — steak and fries — and chicken roulade. Downtown Bloomington is within walking distance and contains eclectic dining options and a bar scene. Asian cuisine includes ramen bowls at Yatagarasu - Bloomington and curry dishes at the Siam House. The menu at the Marco & Polo Eurasian restaurant includes organic yogurt mixed with honey and a variety of lamb dishes. In addition to its wood-fired pies, Da Vinci Pizza and Pasta serves fettuccine and penne plates topped with parmesan flakes. The Orbit Room hosts live music and has pinball machines. Kroger offers a grocery shopping option, and there are boutiques and local art galleries in the Fountain Square shopping center, which is a few blocks from the community.
The Inkwell Bakery & Cafe is popular for IU students in Elm Heights.
The Elm was opened by Bloomington natives Dave and Martha Moore in Elm Heights.
1/2
Summertime fun at Bryan Park Pool and scenic walks at Dunn’s Woods
Elm Heights borders the neighborhood of Bryan Park, which is home to a green space of the same name and the larger of the city’s two public pools. The pool's main attraction is its spiraling water slide. The park also has a new playground and offers more adult-oriented equipment like bars for outdoor calisthenics. At Dunn’s Woods on the IU campus, walkers explore the small forest on a red brick path and pass by landmarks like the Rose Well House and the sitting statue of former IU chancellor and president Herman B. Wells. With its distinct stone portals and tiled roofing, the Rose Well House serves as both a charming backdrop and venue for weddings and proposals.
The Rose Well House was built over a cistern on the IU campus in 1908.
Dunn's Woods is a small forest in the Old Crescent part of the IU campus.
1/2
Highly rated public schools and private alternative in Harmony School
The neighborhood is home to the Harmony School, which operates in the historic building that formerly housed Elm Heights Elementary School. Serving pre-kindergarteners to 12th graders, the private school emphasizes outdoor learning, community service and activities like archery classes for older students. It earns an A Niche score. The neighborhood is a few blocks from Binford and Rogers elementary schools, which receive A and B-plus grades respectively. Binford carries the distinction of only serving kindergarteners to second graders. Students may then attend Jackson Creek Middle School and Bloomington High School South, which both receive A grades. Known for its STEM focus, BHSS’ extracurriculars include a robotics club.
Harmony School is a highly rated, private, alternative school located in Bloomington, IN.
Bloomington High School South has 1,650 students in grades 9-12.
The student-teacher ratio at Jackson Creek Middle School is 13 to 1.
Rogers Elementary serves 312 students in grades K-2.
Sixty six percent of students at Binford Elementary are at least proficient in math.
1/5
Close to major events like 4th Street Arts Festival
During Labor Day weekend, tens of thousands of people turn out for the annual 4th Street Arts Festival in downtown Bloomington. The event showcases works by well over 100 artists from across the country and features both live music and spoken word performances. In October, international musicians take over the downtown during the Lotus World Music & Arts Festival. Genres featured include Indian, African and Irish folk music.
Just a few miles from 45/46 bypass
Several Bloomington Transit bus stops exist in Elm Heights. The neighborhood is less than 2 miles from the State Road 45/46 bypass, which passes by major institutions like the IU Health Bloomington Hospital. The bypass also goes to Interstate 69, which serves as the commuter route to Indianapolis. Bloomington residents going on out-of-state flights go to the Indianapolis International Airport, which is about 52 miles from the city.
The IU Bloomington Hospital is just a few miles from the Elm Heights neighborhood.
Bloomington Metro Transit has stops near the IU campus just north of Elm Heights.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Are you familiar with the Elm Heights neighborhood?
to let others know what life in this neighborhood is like.
Crime and Safety
1 - Low Crime, 10 - High Crime
Elm Heights
US
Homicide
6
4
Sexual Assault
4
4
Assault with Weapon
5
4
Robbery
4
4
Burglary
6
4
Motor Vehicle Theft
6
4
Larceny
4
4
Crime Score
5
4
Source: WhatIsMyCrimeRisk.com
Elm Heights Demographics and Home Trends
On average, homes in Elm Heights, Bloomington sell after 72 days on the market compared to the national average of 53 days. The median sale price for homes in Elm Heights, Bloomington over the last 12 months is $585,000, up 17% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
LOCATION, LOCATION! Nestled in between Swain and Eagleson, this mid-century modern home, inspired by architect Frank Lloyd Wright and his Prairie Style homes, features California redwood paneling inside and cedar outside. Just 3 neighborhood blocks to Indiana University campus and Jacobs School of Music yet SO private. Wood floors, walls of windows and an amazing upstairs suite that is perched
This cozy and well-maintained 2-bedroom, 1-bath home is located just minutes from Indiana University and Bryan Park. Whether you're looking for your first home, a smart investment, or a place to downsize without giving up outdoor space, this one is worth a look. Inside, you’ll find 816 square feet of comfortable living with hardwood flooring throughout that adds warmth and character to the space.
Welcome home to 1113 E Wylie St. in Classic Elm Heights! This traditional 4 square home offers all the charm of yesteryear with all the modern conveniences you wish for today. The main level offers a south facing sun room, large family room with woodburning stove, open kitchen and dining areas, 1/2 bath, and a mud room. The upstairs has 3 generous bedrooms and a full bath. The bonus is that
Available August, 2026! This 3 bedroom home features a bonus room, full basement and a one car garage. The main level features hardwood flooring, a large living room, eat-in kitchen, 2 bedrooms and a full bath. Upstairs, there is a large bedroom, loft and full bath. This is ideally located 2 blocks south of the IU campus!
Adorable apartments located near all that Bloomington has to offer. It is just minutes from Kirkwood Ave and Indiana University.Our upper level homes are located in a private common area that only the residents will be able to access. We accept dogs and cats. We do not have a weight or breed restriction for dogs. 24 Hour emergency Maintenance Available
This stunning all-brick Tudor style home offers 3 bedrooms and 2.5 upgraded baths with high-end finishes, anti-fog front-lit mirrors, and a tile walk-in shower. Hardwood floors flow throughout the home, complemented by a beautiful kitchen with a quartz island and updated appliances. Enjoy a spacious living room with a glass-stone remote fireplace, a formal dining room, and a study with built-in
Sound Score® measures the noise level of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
