$443,379Average Value$224Average Price per Sq Ft8Homes For Sale
Convenience in and near the neighborhood
With the retail and dining-filled stretches of both Hertel Avenue and Main Street running through Central Park, this self-sufficient neighborhood has many conveniences less than 15 minutes east of the Niagara River and U.S.-Canadian border. The area’s residential curb appeal is complemented by classic home designs, with some influenced by premier architects like Frank Lloyd Wright. “I remember growing up as a kid in North Buffalo and walking the streets of Central Park thinking, ‘I want to live here one day,’” says John Heffron, a longtime resident and real estate salesperson with Gurney, Becker & Bourne. Additional proximity to Delaware Park and its attractions means residents are never far from the great outdoors.
Schickluna in Central Park offers some of the best bicycle repair services in Central Park.
Lexington Co-op in Central Park is the perfect neighborhood grocery store.
1/2
Classic homes along Central Park streets
Colonials primarily dot the tree-lined streets of Central Park, though other architectural designs are also mixed into the landscape. "There's some very attractive Victorians spattered throughout," Heffron, who's lived there for over a decade, says. "There's colonials, some brick homes, some wood frames and many have been incredibly well-maintained. A lot of these properties stay in families for a very long time." Other eclectic styles here include Tudors, American Foursquares and Cape Cod influences, and many were built before 1950. Residences are set back from the street, allowing for sizable front yards, and other accents include bay windows, balconies and tall chimneys adorning the roofs. Prices typically fall around $800,000, but could be between $600,000 and $700,000 for smaller homes or as high as $1.5 million for more stately properties.
American foursquare style homes like this one in Central Park usually have four rooms on first and second floor.
If you are looking for a large and unique home, Central Park is filled with them, just like this victorian style house.
1/2
A two-school pipeline for education
Students in Central Park can attend P.S. 80 Highgate Heights Elementary School from pre-kindergarten through eighth grade, located a few minutes east of the neighborhood. Receiving a grade of C-minus from Niche, Highgate Heights has a student-to-teacher ratio of 11 to one. From there, enrollment graduates to Middle Early College High School, one of just two educational institutions within Central Park. Scoring a B with Niche, it ranks highly in student athletics and offers such sports as cross country, basketball and soccer.
Highgate Heights Elementary in Kensington is receiving funding valued at over $4 million.
Middle Early College High School is a magnet high school in Buffalo, NY.
1/2
Parks in and nearby to get outdoors
The most prominent green space in the Central Park neighborhood is Shoshone Park, which offers such amenities as a baseball field, a playground and a basketball court alongside a roller hockey rink. There’s also a planned indoor facility for the park, slated to be completed at the end of 2024 and the only one of its kind in the area. A turf field, batting cages and more for the community are within the plans for the building. "Shoshone Park has always been a mainstay of the neighborhood," Heffron says. "I grew up playing baseball there and there's been a lot of nice improvements. It's also still very walkable to Delaware Park, which is less than a mile away." A short drive southeast, the immense Delaware Park spans more than 300 acres and features Hoyt Lake, the Buffalo Zoo, the Buffalo History Museum and numerous athletic fields and facilities. Portions of Minnesota Linear Park and McCarthy Park are also within Central Park’s boundaries.
A hub of shopping and dining along Hertel Avenue
Hertel Avenue is the heart of Central Park and its surrounding area’s retail and shopping scene, lined with a number of restaurants, markets and more. Grab a morning beverage fit for Superman at Daily Planet Coffee or some inspired frozen treats at Lake Effect Ice Cream, or head a little further west down the road to Dash’s Market for groceries. Further down Hertel, chow down outdoors at the Moor Room or settle into an inviting barroom atmosphere at The Wellington Pub. Kostas Family Restaurant and Ristorante Lombardo are other stops along the avenue, and nearby establishments include Phat Catz Restaurant & Bar, the Howling Rooster Restaurant & Bar just north and more general needs at the Lexington Cooperative Market. "Hertel is the main hub for shops, restaurants, bars, shopping day spas, delis -- you name it, that's where it is," Heffron says. "I call it the 'underrated Elmwood Village' in that it's plenty busy, but not overly populated.”
Spot Coffee in Central Park usually has some people working or meeting each other.
Lake Effect Artisan Ice Cream in Central Park offers unique flavors like Whiskey Brown Sugar and Butterbeer.
1/2
History, sports and film on display
Along with its outdoor amenities, the nearby Delaware Park has a number of internal attractions that bring visitors in. The Buffalo History Museum’s Parthenon-esque design houses three floors of showcases paying homage to the area’s history in culture, politics, sports and more. The Buffalo Zoo, also in Delaware Park, was founded in 1875 and has an assortment of animals including wild cats, bears and marine life. Other local stops include areas where residents can break a sweat at boxing gyms and Terrie’s Workout Center. The North Park Theatre has operated for more than a century and shows current and past releases, while Gutter Pop Comics is along Hertel Avenue. Football fans can head about half an hour south to get to Buffalo Bills games.
North Park Theatre is a historic movie theatre that has recently been renovated.
The Buffalo History Museum in Central Parkshowcases local history and can be rented for events.
1/2
Bouncing around Buffalo
Hertel Avenue is the trendy shopping and dining landmark in Central Park, but Main Street – also known as Route 5 – also runs diagonally through the neighborhood. The University of Buffalo is just northeast, and along Main there’s a number of other restaurants and storefronts. To the south, an interchange of Route 33 and Route 198 connects to Rochester via the former and close to the river via the latter, which is also known as the Scajaquada Expressway. "Public transportation almost isn't necessary because it's so walkable," Heffron says, "and people say you can be anywhere in 20 minutes. The main highways and thoroughfares are very easy to get to. Everything is right there."
Central Park is situated just north of this city highway intersection of Route 33 and 198.
There are buses running along Central Park on Main Street and there is a line on Hertel Avenue.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Are you familiar with the Central Park neighborhood?
to let others know what life in this neighborhood is like.
Central Park Demographics and Home Trends
On average, homes in Central Park, Buffalo sell after 33 days on the market compared to the national average of 55 days. The median sale price for homes in Central Park, Buffalo over the last 12 months is $386,500, up 10% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Bring Home Happiness in this classic Buffalo Colonial w/ all of the original character & a whole lot of room to grow, set on a tree-lined block in one of the city's most desirable neighborhoods. A wide covered front porch w/ tongue & groove ceiling is the perfect spot for morning coffee & meeting the neighbors. This home is ideal for buyers who want space to spread out, character that can't be
Welcome to 229 Carmel Road, a three-bedroom, one-bathroom home offering comfortable living, a desirable North Buffalo location, and the opportunity to create something special. With a spacious layout, private outdoor space, and convenient access to Hertel Avenue, this home offers a welcoming setting in a neighborhood known for its restaurants, shops, parks, and community amenities.Step
Welcome home to your new loft in Buffalo! Located on the fourth floor in the Bethune Lofts, this beautiful space is ready for you to call home. High ceilings, a fireplace and windows giving natural light are highlights of the living area. One bedroom and half bath are located on the first floor, while a full bathroom and bedroom are located upstairs. There is a fitness center and laundry center
Welcome to Bethune Lofts, where historic industrial character meets modern city living! This spacious 1-bedroom, 1-bath condo showcases soaring ceilings, exposed architectural elements, oversized industrial-style windows, and hardwood floors throughout the main living space. The open-concept kitchen features sleek cabinetry, solid-surface countertops, a tile backsplash, stainless steel
Single Family Residential Lot Available. Dimensions to be 50x110. Located in Buffalo's Central ParkNeighborhood, On the Corner of Main St & Woodbridge Ave.
Charm & Opportunity in North Buffalo NY!Welcome to 112 Carmel Road. Nestled in one of Buffalo’s most vibrant, high-demand neighborhoods, this classic 1920s double offers an exceptional opportunity for both savvy investors looking to add a high-performing asset to their portfolio or owner-occupants wanting a spacious home where a tenant helps pay the mortgage.Boasting an incredible 92/100
WELCOME TO 2776 MAIN ST, 3 UNIT BUILDING! North Buffalo Three Unit on a NICE yard, with a two-car garage. Low maintenance exterior. Two spacious LOWER 1br Apts. with surprising features to start with gleaming Hardwood Floors in each unit, yet easy to manage apartments with some original moldings, woodwork. Big, bright, traditional second floor apartment has original woodwork, hardwood floors, a
Welcome to 32 North Drive, a beautifully maintained and thoughtfully updated 4-bedroom bungalow in a highly sought-after North Buffalo neighborhood! Filled with charm and character, this home has been lovingly cared for while receiving numerous improvements both inside and out. Beautiful French doors add to the home's classic character, while the updated kitchen features refreshed cabinetry, a
Experience modern loft living in the historic Bethune Lofts with this stylish 1-bedroom, 1-bath condo offering 750 square feet of updated living space. Located at 2917 Main Street, Unit 108, this desirable first-floor unit blends industrial charm with contemporary comfort in one of Buffalo’s most sought-after loft communities. Inside, 14-foot ceilings, exposed ductwork, and oversized
Welcome to this beautifully maintained 4th-floor unit in a prime North Buffalo location! Unit 404 offers the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and low-maintenance living just steps from the University at Buffalo South Campus, the NFTA Metro Rail, and the vibrant Hertel Avenue corridor. This bright and inviting condo features a spacious open living and dining area filled with natural light, a
Excellent investment opportunity in highly desirable North Buffalo! Situated on a prominent corner lot at the intersection of Starin and St. Lawrence, 575 Starin Ave is a well positioned 16 unit apartment complex consisting of four buildings, offering an attractive opportunity in one of Buffalo’s most stable and sought after rental markets. All 16 apartments are spacious two bedroom units, each
The Rails Apartments, located on a former railroad spur, is a minimalist and chic hub where residents find not only a place to call home but also a community that encourages connection and an active, fulfilling lifestyle. We believe in the power of simplicity and elegance and strive to reflect that in every aspect of our property. We are committed to offering comfortable, well-thought-out spaces
ALL UTILITIES AND OFF STREET PARKING AVAILABLE!East Morris Avenue Apartments is located just off Main Street on E. Morris St in a quiet, quaint neighborhood. Kitchens include dishwasher, stainless steel appliances, and plenty of cabinets. Multiple closets in the apartment are great for storage. Coin-operated laundry is available in the basement for your convenience! All utilities are
Enjoy utilities included in this beautiful 2-bedroom apartment in the heart of Buffalo’s desirable Parkside neighborhood! Apartment FeaturesSpacious 2-bedroom, second-floor apartmentHardwood floorsAbundant natural lightUpdated kitchenGas, electric, water & garbage includedIndividual lockable storage unit in the basementWasher & dryer in basement — no coins
Duplex/Townhouse like unit. Each side has 2 bedrooms & full bath on 2nd floor; Kitchen, dining area, lvg. rm. on 1st floor; full private basement with laundry hook ups & glass block windows. Large fenced yard; 2.5 car garage with auto. garage door openers; Lawn care, driveway snow plowing, water, sewer, garbage fee included. Great Location in North Buffalo close to SUNY UB South Campus,
One bedroom UPPER apartment available in prime North Buffalo location (Hertel & Main). Minutes to the University at Buffalo South Campus. Steps to all amenities: shopping, parks, restaurants, nightlife, & public transportation. Brand new carpeting in living room & bedroom. Bonus room at the entry could be used as a coat room, office, or for storage. Fully applianced kitchen has tons of cabinet
2 Bedroom + Office Heat Included Upper Apartment on Hertel Ave Available September 6Apartment features: 2 bedrooms + separate office 1 bathroom Heat included 1 off-street parking space Approx. 1,000 sq.ft. Convenient access to bus and Metro Rail Close to shopping, groceries, parks, and bike trailRent: $1,450/month, heat includedNo
Welcome to this beautifully situated three-bedroom, one-bathroom lower apartment on a quiet, desirable street in Buffalo’s Parkside neighborhood. This spacious and inviting home offers a comfortable layout featuring a bright living room, dining room, kitchen, three bedrooms, and a versatile bonus sunroom that provides additional space for a home office, reading area, or relaxation.The
Beautiful 2-bedroom upper located in nice area. Apartment features 2 spacious bedrooms, remodel bathroom, updated kitchen with appliances, living room, and off-street parking.
Three bedroom LOWER apartment available in prime North Buffalo location (Hertel & Main). Minutes to the University at Buffalo South Campus. Steps to all amenities: shopping, parks, restaurants, nightlife, & public transportation. The living room & dining room feature beautiful original woodwork, built-ins, & decorative fireplace. Updated kitchen with granite countertops, new cabinets, stainless
Spectacular Kitchen with 2 Bedrooms in North Buffalo!Your new home is functional, beautiful, and convenient featuring two bedrooms with hardwood flooring, updated bathroom, exceptionally large living space, and fully renovated kitchen with quartz countertops, island, and stainless steel appliances! Experience closet/storage space galore, laundry hook-ups in the basement, plus a designated
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
