$535,953Average Value$440Average Price per Sq Ft1Home For Sale
A walkable neighborhood near downtown, but slow paced
Some might say that the star attraction of Starr Hill is proximity to Charlottesville’s ever-popular outdoor pedestrian mall. But despite being steps away from the city’s downtown core, it thrives by having an identity all its own. That identity might be best described as urban but approachable, rather than overwhelming and hard to navigate. “This whole area is great for walking and it’s super safe to ride your bike,” says Danny Hugus, a city native and Realtor with the Hogan Group. “It’s very accessible.” Main Street forms the southern border of Starr Hill, and despite the street’s revitalization closer to University of Virginia campus, this portion still evokes an easygoing Southern aesthetic. Exposed brick and faded paint on low-slung buildings almost makes the neighborhood feel frozen in time – as do the businesses, which focus on slower get-to-know-your-neighbor service. But on the western side is Ridge McIntire Road, one of the city’s heavily trafficked modern corridors overlooked by hotels. With sights like Staples and fast-food chains along here, it’s obvious that Starr Hill occupies a unique location: part old Charlottesville, part new.
Starr Hill Brewery, the namesake of the neighborhood, is a popular beer throughout Virginia.
The beautiful Blue Ridge Mountains lie just to the west of Starr Hill and Charlottesville.
1/2
Cottages keep Starr Hill feeling intimate
Because of Starr Hill’s prime location, houses do not go on the market often. But homebuyers can keep an eye out for cottages, which are a common form of housing here. Versions waiting to be fixed up will sell between $350,000 to $400,000. These two-bedroom homes offer single-level living and feature shade trees as landscaping. Multi-story homes, like split-levels from the 1920s, are present in the neighborhood, too. Or homebuyers can opt for a renovated cottage that’s move-in ready, presenting Craftsman features. These will sell in the $355,000 to $475,000 range. Stretches like Brown Street and Cream Street can be sought after since they converge around Starr Hill Park. Plus, their winding nature prevents traffic from passing through, giving a tranquil feeling to an otherwise urban neighborhood.
Beautifully renovated cottages dot the landscape of the Starr Hill neighborhood.
Cozy alleyways define the sparse home options in Starr Hill.
1/2
An array of flavors along Main Street
Dining is one of the neighborhood’s strong suits, particularly because Main Street is a destination lined with options. Everything from Korean to Mediterranean to Southern cuisines is available. Drinks and general happy hour fun occur at Public Fish & Oyster. “I always get the hot lobster roll and a Jameson on ice,” says Diego Anderson, a Charlottesville resident and regular at the restaurant. There’s even a neighborhood butcher at Stock Provisions, which sells locally produced cold cuts and sausages, as well as prepared foods like hummus and pickles. Orzo Kitchen presents a somewhat different concept: Geared toward a lunch crowd, it’s in a sprawling complex with plenty of seating and room for a market containing packaged goods, plus a deli counter.
Public Fish and Oyster has a lively neighborhood vibe on Starr Hill's section of Main Street.
Public Fish and Oyster has a beautiful tree-lined patio on Main Street in Starr Hill.
1/2
Concerts, festivals and runs year round
Events are always near with the downtown mall just steps away. Warm weather brings a free concert series called Fridays After Five, from April through September at the Ting Pavilion, a venue with swaths of grass to sit on. Waterworks Fest stretches from May to June, and focuses on the theater scene with workshops, pop ups and trivia events. Tom Tom Fest in April celebrates the local startup scene. “Holidays are always a good time to catch an event,” says Lori Meistrell, associate broker with Nest Realty. “There are fun runs downtown, like the Santa Run.”
Charlottesville High's award-winning clubs
Trailblazer Elementary receives a B rating from Niche, and offers a 14-to-1 student-teacher ratio. Buford Middle is a B-minus school with a 13-to-1 student-teacher ratio. Charlottesville High earns an A, and is known for award-winning clubs, with both the debate and golf teams taking state championships in 2023. The central branch of the Jefferson-Madison Regional Library, marked by large Jeffersonian columns, is a gentle reminder that the University of Virginia is just a mile away.
Charlottesville High faithfully serves the Charlottesville community.
Located in Starr Hill, Charlottesville High School serves as a central hub for education and community.
1/2
Minimal Starr Hill Park offers a peaceful respite
The neighborhood’s sole green space is Starr Hill Park – a peaceful half-acre best used for catching a breather. But if residents want playground equipment, they can drive over to McGuffey Park, next to First United Methodist Church. This park is also on the small side, but abundant shade trees make it a natural gathering place for those seeking to take a break amid the greenery. Otherwise, Starr Hill is a largely urban landscape. But it’s welcoming to pedestrians, and brings people outdoors.
Starr Hill Park is a pocket park tucked into the eponymous neighborhood near Main Street.
Starr Hill Park offers quiet trails and open fields in the historic Starr Hill neighborhood of Charlottesville.
1/2
Main Street is for walkers, bikers and drivers
If residents don’t choose to walk to their destinations, they can always drive along Main Street, which goes west toward the University of Virginia and east toward hip destinations like Belmont that have popular restaurants like Lampo, a Neopolitan-style pizzeria. Other main thoroughfares like Ridge McIntire Road can take drivers to Route 250, which is a convenient way to explore east end amenities like Darden Towe Park or the Rivanna River. Plus, following 250 east will allow drivers to access Interstate 64, a corridor favored by commuters.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
City life at its best. 97 Walk Score, 85 Bike Score. Walk to UVA or downtown, enjoy the amazing restaurants and shops along West Main Street. Freshly painted throughout. 2 ensuite bedrooms. Open plan living with separate office. Concrete, tile and carpet floors, high ceilings, oversized windows with amazing natural light on two sides allow you to enjoy the sunrise and sunset. Secure entry,
Beautiful fully furnished historic downtown home right off Main Street with off-street parking for 2 cars. 2 Bedrooms and two full baths. Master BR has King Bed. 2nd BR has a double bed. Completely outfitted kitchen with full-sized stainless appliances including dishwasher. Private deck in back for outdoor dining and sunning. This location can't be beat! 14 minute walk to UVA Hospital.
Sound Score® measures the noise level of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
