Cumberland has lots of newer housing but still has a small-town vibe
Cumberland is a small town that blends historic charm with suburban-style housing development about 15 miles east of downtown Indianapolis . While the community maintains a hometown feel with a quaint downtown district and annual events, its location along the Interstate 70 corridor has made it the focus of homebuilders and a destination for commuters seeking a quieter alternative to city living.
Planned subdivisions are built near major roadways
Homes built in recent years can be found throughout town in planned subdivisions. These settings typically offer spacious lots along walkable streets. Some settings offer more wooded surroundings, and waterfront options are often available. Homes built from the mid- to late 2010s are concentrated on the north side of town near I-70, while the newest homes are concentrated on the south side near U.S. Route 40. This area also includes newly built contemporary townhouses with driveways and attached garages. The newer housing provides a cost-effective option for professionals and others who are otherwise priced out of nearby larger cities. Midcentury ranch-style homes are the most common established option, with most built between the mid-1940s and the late 1970s. Craftsman bungalows stand out among the community’s oldest homes, which also include cozy cottage-style designs. Prices typically range from the mid-$100,00s to $600,000-plus, with a median price of around $255,000.
New housing developments in Hancock County
“What Cumberland as a community strives for is to be independent and have its own identity apart from Indianapolis,” says
Mark Dudley of Re/Max Commercial, who sells homes throughout the area. “They want to concentrate on the advantages of small-town living.” Cumberland’s small-town identity is reflected in its many community events, including:
Blues, Beer & BBQ, a free, one-day concert held in June, July and August
- Community Day, a family event in August hosted by the local police department
- Rocktember, a free, one-day concert in September featuring local and regional acts
- Trail & Treat, an October Halloween celebration along the decorated Buck Creek Trail
- Weihnachtsmarkt, a December market that honors the town’s German heritage
Highway commutes to economic centers Indianapolis, Carmel
I-70 provides a direct route into the heart of Indianapolis, and it connects to the Interstate 465 loop along the way. Interstate 465 provides a convenient commute to Carmel , an economic center north of Indianapolis that is about 20 miles from Cumberland. “People who live there wouldn’t necessarily remain in Cumberland for work … they would probably drive to where they do work,” Dudley says. The Indianapolis International Airport is on the west side of Indianapolis. It is about 25 miles away via I-465. Both downtown and the airport are stops on IndyGo’s Bus Rapid Transit Blue Line, which stops in town along Washington Street.
Students attend school in Marion and Hancock counties
When it comes to school zoning, Cumberland is in a unique position. The town straddles Marion and Hancock counties and encompasses Warren, Buck Creek and Sugar Creek townships. Those living in Marion County are served by the Metropolitan School District of Warren Township. Otherwise, students are served by the Mount Vernon School Corporation or the Southern Hancock County Community School Corporation. The two Hancock County Districts are highly rated. All three allow students to apply for transfers. Transportation is not provided for out-of-district transfers.
Convenient shopping, dining along U.S. Route 40 in and around town
Local shopping and dining options are conveniently located along U.S. 40. Historic Old Town Cumberland is a small stretch along the Washington Street section of the corridor. Sero’s Family Restaurant is a community staple. Old Town stands out for its historic homes, several of which house local businesses. Meijer, Walmart and Target along U.S. 40 are just minutes from the heart of the community. “People like being in the Cumberland area because of the conveniences on the east side of Indianapolis,” Dudley says.
Community parks and trails
Lions Park is the largest of Cumberland’s recreational spaces. It has athletic courts, playscapes, green space and access to the Buck Creek Trail. Walking paths, basketball courts and playgrounds are among the amenities that can be found at Honors Park and National Road Park.
![Matt Pallister]()
Written By
Matt Pallister
![Jonathan Fairfield]()
Photography Contributed By
Jonathan Fairfield
