A casual, friendly nautical hamlet on Long Island’s south shore
East Islip, a hamlet on the south shore of Long Island, is the kind of place that is hard to let go. And given that it is surrounded by water and green spaces and offers attractive homes, great schools and invested residents, it’s easy to understand why. “We’re a very casual, very friendly town,” says Debbie Carpluck, a Realtor with Keller Williams Realty Elite who proudly boasts that she is East Islip born and raised. “Living on the water gives it that nautical feel. It’s a great vibe. As my mother likes to say, ‘We’re a community of homing pigeons and boomerangs.’ Many of us East Islip graduates come back to stay in the community we grew up in. It’s such a special little place.”
Most property sizes in East Islip are spacious with yard space for your family to enjoy.
East Islip was established in 1683.
1/2
Several non-profits organize community events
Because so many residents are intimately connected to their town, it results in an active and engaged population. “We’re a very charitable community,” Carpluck says. “We do a lot of work with EJ Autism, one of the many foundations started by community members, as well as For the Kids and Taylor’s Hope.” The Jigsaw Run is an annual community event put on by EJ Autism, a non-profit started by an East Islip family of two autistic boys. For the Kids is a non-profit formed by a group of East Islip volunteers that helps raise money for the school district. Taylor’s Hope Organization was formed by the parents of an East Islip girl who has been battling cancer since she was diagnosed at age 8. The non-profit organizes events such as an annual Blue Ribbon Dinner and holiday toy drive to support children battling cancer and raise funds for and awareness of histiocytosis. Those efforts are just a part of a constantly active community. “We have carnivals at Brookwood Hall Park, and the Chamber of Commerce puts on a lot of summer concerts there,” Carpluck says. “Oh, and we have a huge St. Patrick’s Day parade on Main Street. It’s one of our best events, and people come out after a long winter to see their friends. There’s always something going on.”
Wide variety of housing ranges from the low $400,000s to more than $2 million
Divided into appealing subdivisions such as Deer Run and Country Village, the primarily residential hamlet offers a wide variety of homes along picturesque neighborhood streets where it is not uncommon to see white picket fences gracing large front yards. Cape Cods, Colonials, raised ranch and traditional split-level homes are common among a varied collection of established housing, which features a large number of modern renovations. The typical home includes a private driveway on a spacious lot, and newer homes also come standard with attached garages. The hamlet’s largest and most expensive homes are near the water. Prices typically range from the low $400,000s for an established home inland to more than $2 million for the largest luxury homes with waterfront access. Alternative options include condominiums at Foxgate and townhouses at Hecksher Estates typically priced in the mid-$400,000s. The hamlet also includes co-op living units starting in the mid-$200,000s at Bel Laurel, a 55-plus community.
Newly renovated neo-colonial style home in East Islip.
Big neo-colonial style home in East Islip.
1/2
Students can attend top-rated public schools in and around the community
The East Islip Union Free School District is rated A-minus by Niche. John F. Kennedy and Timber Point elementaries, both B-plus-rated schools, are located in the hamlet. East Islip Middle and East Islip High schools, both rated A-minus, share a campus in Islip Terrace, the hamlet’s neighbor to the north. “Schools are the biggest draw for this area,” says Carpluck, who adds that sports and music are what the schools are known for. Former NFL quarterback Boomer Esiason is an East Islip High graduate. The East Islip Music and Arts Program develops creative talent through music ensembles, theater performances, visual art and photography. In 2023, the National Association of Music Merchants Foundation recognized the district’s music instruction and curriculum with a “Best Community for Music Education” award. St. Mary School, a PK-8 Catholic institution located in the hamlet, offers a private educational option.
East Islip High School serves students in East Islip.
East Islips Public Library is open to residents of East Islips.
1/2
Recreational options are plentiful among the community’s natural landscape
East Islip offers more access to the natural landscape than your typical Long Island hamlet. Boaters can operate out of marinas located along Champlin Creek and on the hamlet’s southern edge at East Islip Marina Park. Both locations provide easy access to the open waters of Great South Bay. The park also includes Town Beach, a fishing dock, a playground and athletic fields for softball and lacrosse. Next door is Hecksher State Park, a sprawling recreational complex whose amenities include 4 miles of paved trails for bike riders and nature lovers, a disc golf course, a skate park, picnic areas, canoe and kayak launches and several bayfront beaches. The South Shore Nature Center, a 200-care preserve is an added natural attraction. Brookwood Hollow Park, anchored by a historic mansion, is home to more athletic spaces and children’s playscapes along Champlin Creek.
Brookwood Hall Park in East Islip has many activities include this playground.
Knapps Lake is a common fresh water fishing hole for all local of East Islip.
1/2
Main Street offers an array of locally owned businesses
The hamlet’s Main Street is a notable attraction, a convenient commercial corridor that runs through the heart of town. “We have some wonderful businesses,” Carpluck says, “from grocery stores to gourmet markets to coffee shops, and they’re all locally owned.” Several popular dining destinations are concentrated along the corridor. Hometown Cafe is a highly rated American eatery that serves up comfort food favorites in a charming diner-style atmosphere. Vinnie’s Mulberry Street is a traditional Italian restaurant that features brick oven pizzas and classic Italian dishes. Shandon Court, an Irish restaurant known for its Sunday brunch and live music, is a hamlet institution. Entertainment options along Main Street include Bayway Arts Center, whose theatrical performances and concerts highlight a busy year-round schedule of events, and East Islip Lanes, which offers fun for all ages with competitive bowling leagues and late-night “Rock N Glow Bowl” on Saturdays.
Inside Shrmipy's Burrito Bar you can find extensive menu that will fit your taste buds.
East Islip Nutrition is located in the Heckscher Shopping Center in East Islip Nutrition.
1/2
Nearby rail stations provide easy access to commuter travel
The Great River and Islip rail stations provide quick and easy access to commuter train travel through neighboring communities and into New York City. Union Station is about a hour and 15 minutes away by train. John F. Kennedy International Airport in Queens is located about 35 miles west and can be accessed via Sunrise Highway, which runs along the hamlet’s north side or the Southern State Parkway, located about a mile north. For additional public transportation, Suffolk County Transit bus stops are conveniently located on Main Street and Carleton Avenue.
The Great Neck Train Station is shared by the surrounding areas including East Islip.
Crime
The CAP Index gives the hamlet a 2-out-of-10, which translates into a “low crime” rating. Based on bestplaces.net’s scale of 1 to 100, the hamlet’s violent crime rate is 8.7, well below the U.S. average of 22.7, and its property crime rate is 21.2, below the national average of 35.4.
Written By
Hannah Rainey
Photography Contributed By
Peter Scifo
Video By
Hunter Severtson
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Stephen Orlando,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in East Islip, NY sell after 35 days on the market compared to the national average of 50 days. The median sale price for homes in East Islip, NY over the last 12 months is $630,000, down 3% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Move right into this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 2-bath split-level home in the heart of East Islip’s Conlu Park. The vaulted-ceiling master suite offers privacy and comfort, complemented by an updated kitchen with granite counters, stainless steel appliances, and gas cooking. Enjoy a spacious yard perfect for entertaining, featuring a children’s playset, video surveillance system, and
Welcome to 133 Adams St E, a beautifully renovated home in the heart of East Islip! This stunning 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers the perfect blend of modern finishes and comfortable living. Step inside to find a bright, open-concept main level with gorgeous flooring, recessed lighting, and a seamless flow between the spacious living room, dining area, and chef's kitchen featuring white shaker
Welcome to your next home in the heart of East Islip! This spacious 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath colonial offers the perfect combination of comfort, convenience, and outdoor enjoyment. From the moment you arrive, you’ll appreciate the pride of ownership and well-maintained features throughout. Step inside to find a bright, functional layout with ceiling fans in every room, ample closet space, and a full
Welcome to 133 Adams St E, a beautifully renovated home in the heart of East Islip! This stunning 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers the perfect blend of modern finishes and comfortable living. Step inside to find a bright, open-concept main level with gorgeous flooring, recessed lighting, and a seamless flow between the spacious living room, dining area, and chef's kitchen featuring white shaker
Welcome to your next home in the heart of East Islip! This spacious 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath colonial offers the perfect combination of comfort, convenience, and outdoor enjoyment. From the moment you arrive, you’ll appreciate the pride of ownership and well-maintained features throughout. Step inside to find a bright, functional layout with ceiling fans in every room, ample closet space, and a full
Welcome to Bel Laurel. East Islip's 55+ Co-Op Community Centrally Located To Main Street, Shopping & All Major Highways. Immaculate Main Floor Unit ( Approx 785 sq ft) . Primary Bedroom is 13' x 13' with a 6'x 6' Closet. Updated Central Air & Gas Heating System. Washer/Dryer Located In Full Bathroom. No Pets Allowed In Complex. Low Monthly Maintenance Fees Of $454.05 Includes Taxes.
1-Bedroom $2295* Plus 24-Month No Increase!* $99 Security Deposit Special* *Restrictions Apply* Great location in the top-rated East Islip school district. Gas cooking, heat and hot water are included in the rent. Private entry, spacious one-Bedroom and two-bedrooms. Convenient on-site laundry center. Large apartments. Some with separate dining room and washer-dryer, some vinyl plank
Luxury One Bedroom Duplex, Two Bedroom and Three Bedroom Villa Style Apartment Homes.We feature central air-conditioning, some with vinyl plank floors/hardwood floors, some carpet, eat-in kitchen with tuscany-style kitchen cabinetry, stainless steel appliances and ceramic tile kitchen floors. Crown and base molding, updated lighting fixtures and terraces in a park-like setting. Close to Great
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
