$377,704Average Value$201Average Price per Sq Ft16Homes For Sale
Rural privacy, caring community and outdoor space to hunt and fish
Forty miles outside of Downtown Cincinnati, the rural neighborhood of Fayetteville includes the Village of Fayetteville and the community of Lake Lorelei. The community of Fayetteville has a population of just 312 people, but the bonds between those people are strong. “Because it’s so small, everyone knows everyone. You'll always see a friendly face around,” says Realtor Christine Behm with Comey & Shepherd Realtors and over 30 years of experience. Residents support local businesses and have become a part of a tight-knit town that brings everyone together at community events. Over in Lake Lorelei, residents enjoy a gated community with a private lake and 23 miles of private roadways. Just like Fayetteville, the community that comes with living there is something that draws people in. “We’re a small city in ourselves here,” Chris Kwiatkowski, the Director of Operations at Lake Lorelei, says. “We had a tornado here in 2021. The community came together. People really care about each other.” Whether living in Fayetteville or Lake Lorelei, residents of this neighborhood get rural privacy, outdoor space to hunt and fish and a community that cares about one another.
Fayetteville has plenty of game and land to hunt.
Fayettesville
1/2
From ranch-style and bi-levels to A-frame homes near Lake Lorelei
Homes within the Lake Lorelei gated community come as ranch-style, bi-level and A-frame homes, some with views of the 1,118-acre lake. Home prices near the lake start at $125,000 for a 3-bedroom bi-level home and can go for as much as $880,000 for a spacious, 4-bedroom waterfront ranch. Homes in the Village of Fayetteville come ranch-style and bungalows and have sold for between $40,000 and $600,000. Overall, houses in the neighborhood can have up to a few acres and mature trees shading backyards. Many homes date back to the early to mid-1900s, which explains why some have detached garages. With how spread out the neighborhood is, residents rely on vehicles to get around. As for crime, the CAP Index gave the area a Crime Score of 1 out of 10, the lowest score a neighborhood can receive.
Fayettesville
Fayettesville
1/2
From hunting and fishing options to outdoor amenities in the Lake Lorelei community
For outdoor recreation, residents can head to the Fayetteville Community Park, which has a playground for kids and a basketball court perfect for a pickup game with friends. For a sprawling nature preserve, locals can visit the Indian Creek Wildlife Area to hunt and fish or work on their aim at the shooting range. Hunters and fishermen can also head to Della Gates and Edward Charles Bott Wildlife Area, which has two ponds for fishing and waterfowl hunting. Residents who live in Lake Lorelei have access to even more outdoor amenities, including the use of the lake. They can play a round of mini golf on the putt-putt course, a pickup game at the basketball court and relax on one of the two beaches that include playgrounds.
Hunting and fishing is a common pass time in Fayetteville.
Fayettesville
1/2
From SheBrews Coffee to Pike Street Bar & Grill
For a locally owned café, coffee aficionados visit SheBrews Coffee, which serves pastries in a bright interior setting ideal for a morning pick-me-up. The longstanding Pike Street Bar & Grill doubles as a breakfast place in the morning and a pub hangout spot where people play pool in the evenings. “It’s a community treasure. The building is from the 1800s with an interesting history and the food is delicious,” Behm says. At Skyline Chili, locals enjoy classic cheese hot dogs, especially the Greek chili that the chain restaurant is best known for. At Dollar General, residents can stock up on groceries and household items. For a more traditional grocery shopping experience, Kroger in Blanchester is the best option, an 11-mile drive north.
Start your morning in Fayetteville with a coffee from SheBrews Coffee.
Fayetteville
1/2
Fayettesville
Future Farmers of America program at Fayetteville-Perry High School
Students in the area attend the Fayetteville-Perry Local School District, which earned a C-plus grade from Niche. Starting in kindergarten, children attend Fayetteville-Perry Elementary, which earned a C-plus grade from Niche. In sixth grade, they move on to Fayetteville-Perry Middle/High School, which received a B-minus and offers a Future Farmers of America program to help students develop as leaders through agricultural education.
40 miles from Downtown Cincinnati
Residents of Fayetteville can drive to Downtown Cincinnati via U.S. Route 50, a 40-mile drive. For weekend adventures in the city, visit the Cincinnati Zoo & Botanical Garden or the Cincinnati Art Museum. No public transportation is offered in Fayetteville. The Cincinnati/Northern Kentucky International Airport is a 48-mile drive away. Mercy Health Clermont Hospital is 17 miles away for those needing medical attention.
Fayettesville
Fayettesville
1/2
Fayetteville and Lake Lorelei community events
The Fayetteville-Perry Library allows neighbors to gather for children’s programs like story times, adult programs including book clubs and special events like a family Halloween party. Fayetteville’s community events often celebrate holidays and Fayetteville Fire and EMS. At the Fireman's Festival & Parade, locals bring their kids to play on inflatables, grab drinks and snacks from food trucks and watch the cornhole tournament. The fire department and EMS also host a trick-or-treating event with a costume contest, snacks and prizes. Residents of the Lake Lorelei community can attend a variety of events. “We have clubs and committees that hold a bunch of things,” Kwiatkowski says. “We have a beginning of summer party. There’s always something going on.” The community also has a fishing tournament every other Tuesday and fireworks night throughout the summer.
Fayettesville
Fayettesville
1/2
Written By
Kevin Haswell
Photography Contributed By
Nick Janning
Video By
Alexander Wong
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Bryan Vance,
an experienced agent in this area.
On average, homes in Fayetteville, OH sell after 31 days on the market compared to the national average of 57 days. The median sale price for homes in Fayetteville, OH over the last 12 months is $305,000, down 5% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Welcome to this beautifully designed modern ranch home located in the gated community of Lake Lorelei in Fayetteville, Ohio. Offering 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths, this home features a sleek, open-concept layout with a spacious kitchen and center island that flows seamlessly into the large living area, perfect for everyday living and entertaining. Enjoy the ease of one-floor, low-maintenance
Lake front view! (2 Parcels = approx. .08 acre, nearly an acre). Ideally situated in Lake Lorelei. 204' of shore line. 2,400 sq ft living space total. Picturesque, panoramic setting for nature lovers. Attractive Lake A-frame/Chalet Architectural design. Lots of charm and character. *present owner invested approximately $200,000 in renovations & improvements including the following updates &
Just steps from the beach and clubhouse in Lake Lorelei! This 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch in the gated Lake Lorelei lake community places you right in the heart of the lake lifestyle. The open floor plan features a spacious great room with stone fireplace flowing into the dining area and kitchen, ideal for everyday living and entertaining. Hardwood floors highlight the entry, dining area, and
Just move in this new completed construction home at Lake Lorelei. 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, high quality new construction home. Full unfinished LL with 2 full egress windows, ready for you to finish if needed. Tankless HWH! Oversized garage, flexible floorplan, perfect area attached to primary suite you could use as an office or lounge area. Do not miss the chance to own this beautiful home!
Gorgeous home with 2 primary suites. One of the Primary suites is on the first floor. 4 Bedrooms/3.5 Bathrooms on 3 lots. Covered front porch. Custom built shed for your golf kart. Kitchen island, open concept All windows are Anderson windows . The home has leaf and gutter guards. Home is in the gated Community at beautiful Lake Lorelei. Everything is very well maintained. Plenty of storage.
Unique opportunity to build the house of your dreams at Lake Lorelei. Two adjoining lots that are mostly cleared but partially wooded and ready for you to make your own. Enjoy all that Lake Lorelei has to offer.
Welcome to your brand-new home in the scenic Lake Lorelei community! This thoughtfully designed 1,600 sq ft home offers 4 bed & 2 full baths, combining modern comfort with energy efficiency. Built with 2x6 exterior walls and R-21 insulation, plus an efficient heat pump system, this home is designed to keep utility costs low year-round. Inside, you'll find durable and stylish luxury vinyl plank
Great lot to build your dream lake house on. Public access cove just across the street. Enjoy everything the lake has to offer! 2 beaches, Playground, Boating, and Fishing to your hearts content.
To Be Built on lot 235-236 Schlitz! Choose one of the 3 Floor Plans shown or Bring us your own plan for review & consideration! Now is the time to choose your personalized features & options! Room sizes vary depending on floor plan.
Welcome to your private retreat on over 12 scenic acres, featuring two large ponds (approx. 1 & 3 acres) that creates a peaceful, picturesque setting. Fish from the 1 acre pond that is stocked. This spacious home offers over 3500 sq ft with 4 bedrooms & 2.5 baths, perfect for comfortable living & entertaining. Enjoy beautiful views from the screened-in porch while surrounded by mature trees &
Escape to your private ranch retreat on 5.0+ secluded acres! This charming 3 bed, 2 bath home features a lovely oversized living room and a small barn perfect for horses or livestock. Enjoy the quiet beauty of mature pine trees, a fenced yard/pasture, and an electric-fenced track through the woods. Room to roam and live the farm life! Incredibly hard to find move-in ready acreage within 45
Fabulous water front location! Enjoy wonderful lake views from the dock, deck or 14 x 14 screened porch! Relax in the living room with views of the water & warmth from the electric fireplace. 4 bedrooms, 2 full, updated baths. The full waterproofed basement offers additional living or game space plus plenty of area for storage. Lovingly cared for! Newer Furnace/Heat Pump & Water Heater.
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
