$173,832Average Value$117Average Price per Sq Ft6Homes For Sale
Small-town living in Frewsburg
Hidden amongst the Allegheny foothills, Frewsburg is a sleepy hamlet tucked along Conewango Creek in the Town of Carroll. The hamlet's name stems from its founders, the Frew family, who settled in the area after venturing north to start a sawmill business powered by the waterways.
Today, essential establishments line a small Main Street. The post office and grocery store are within walking distance for many residents, while a mix of home styles on modest lots sit close together. "Frewsburg is one of the many communities in the county that embraces small-town easy living," says Rachel Willow, a licensed real estate salesperson with five years of industry experience. Farther east, residential roads give way to swaths of farmland that butt up against South Valley State Forest's rugged terrain. Abundant hiking trails, campgrounds and scenic waterways add to the region's appeal, offering a close-knit community with year-round recreation.
The Dinner Bell in downtown Frewsburg, NY, offers classic American dining in a cozy small-town setting along Main Street, a favorite landmark in Chautauqua County.
Frewsburg, NY, is a welcoming hamlet in Chautauqua County known for its community institutions and scenic Allegheny foothills location.
1/2
Afternoons along Conewango Creek
Frewsburg Town Park is a large green space that boasts access to a narrow stream called Frews Run for a dip in the creek. A playground with swing sets and a sandbox entertains children of all ages, while a covered pavilion with tables attracts picnickers. Sports facilities include basketball courts and baseball diamonds that host Little League practices and games.
Conewango Creek and Frews Run are natural borders for most of the hamlet. Kayaking, canoeing and fishing are popular pastimes, and over 25 miles of exploration await along the Marden E. Cobb Waterway trail.
Residents are also close to the Audubon Community Nature Center, where 570 acres of wetlands give way to miles of hiking trails, picnic areas, a natural play space and an aviary for birds. The center features interactive exhibits, year-round day camps and guest lecture series.
More trails await about 10 miles away throughout the South Valley State Forest. South Valley encompasses 4,227 acres of rugged terrain and scenic views open to the public for hiking, hunting, trapping, fishing and cross-country skiing. South Valley borders the Allegheny Reservoir, also known as Kinzua Lake, to the east and is home to Onoville Marina Park for year-round boat storage and seasonal renters. Chautauqua Lake is also 10 miles away for sailing and sunbathing along the waterfront.
Western New York's year-round recreation includes ice-fishing, snowmobiling and skiing, with nearby retreats like Holiday Valley Resort and Peek'n Peak Resort less than 35 miles away.
The Marden E. Cobb Waterway Trail near Frewsburg offers scenic hiking routes and historic Whipple-truss bridge views.
Snowmobiling trails around Frewsburg deliver winter adventure in Western New York's scenic countryside.
1/2
Bungalows, colonials and ranch-style homes
Residential streets in the heart of the hamlet feature modest lots with a range of home styles, including bungalows, bi-levels and the occasional Dutch Colonial. However, colonial- and ranch-style homes dominate the landscape and are priced from the low $100,000s to the mid $200,000s. As of 2024, over 20 to-be-built lots are for sale along Carroll Street, with modern ranch-style homes starting in the $300,000s before additional upgrades. A handful of 21st-century modern homes and properties on acreage can sell into the mid $300,000s, while homes that need some TLC can sell for less than $100,000. Frewsburg earns a CAP Index crime score of 2 out of 10, compared to the national average of 4.
Frewsburg's housing market includes bungalows, colonials, and ranch-style homes, appealing to diverse architectural tastes.
Well-maintained homes are a hallmark of Frewsburg neighborhoods, showcasing pride of ownership in Chautauqua County.
1/2
Essentials on Main Street
Several local businesses line Main Street, including a bowling alley and an axe-throwing venue. Haggy's Hatchet House, where beer and axes mix, is the community's newest establishment. Long-timers include The Dinner Bell, an American restaurant known for its hometown-style brunch and welcoming atmosphere. Down the street, Frewsburger Pizza Shop is known for its wings, subs and signature taco pizza. A crowd favorite is the Philly steak pizza, topped with beef steak, a blend of cheese, green peppers and onions. In 2021, Frewsburger opened an adjoining ice cream shop that sells ice cream cones, shaved ice, flurries and sundaes.
Tops Friendly Markets and a liquor store sit across the street, while other small businesses include an appliance store and antique shops for unique finds. Main Street is also home to other essential establishments such as a post office, library and multiple houses of worship. A lone Dollar General sits on the outskirts of town, while additional grocers and big-box stores are 10 miles away in Lakewood. "If you live in one of the county's rural areas, Lakewood is where you'd go for your groceries, Target and other major stores," Willow says.
Downtown Frewsburg features Tops Friendly Markets for convenient grocery shopping, enhancing small-town living in Chautauqua County.
Main Street in Frewsburg is lined with shops and eateries, creating a vibrant hub for small-town living in Chautauqua County.
1/2
Main Street parades and Gala Days
Frewsburg residents can ring in the holiday season the weekend after Thanksgiving with the hamlet's annual Old Fashioned Santa Parade. Main Street brims with enthusiasm as decked-out floats are pulled by horses and tractors. Other small-town events include an annual Easter Egg Hunt at the Frewsburg Central High School football field, community-wide lawn sales in June and the annual Frewsburg Fire Department's Gala Days. Every June, the Fire Department's largest fundraiser includes a parade, carnival rides, games, live music, food and fireworks displays.
An active school community
According to Niche, the Frewsburg Central School District scores a B and is the fourth-best school district in Chautauqua County. Pre-kindergarteners through sixth graders may attend Robert H. Jackson Elementary, which earns a B. Seventh through twelfth graders may attend the B-minus-rated Frewsburg Middle and High School. Students and faculty often give back to the community through food and clothing drives, such as collecting goods for the Frewsburg Food Pantry or clothes for patients at UPMC Chautauqua.
The Chautauqua Institution, the region's crown jewel, hugs the banks of Chautauqua Lake 25 miles away. "It's a world-renowned institution," says Jerod Zahn, a real estate salesperson with ERA Real Estate who has lived in the region for over 50 years. CEOS, former Presidents and influential thought leaders have all visited the institution. The summer season draws in tourists from across the county, including thousands of creatives and lifelong learners who descend upon the institute for nine weeks of summer programming.
Frewsburg Central School stands out among Chautauqua County districts for its strong academic programs, safe campus environment, and active community involvement, making it a cornerstone of education in Western New York.
Frewsburg Junior/Senior High School emphasizes academic excellence and community engagement in Western New York.
Robert H. Jackson Elementary School in Frewsburg is recognized for its safe campus and strong educational environment.
1/3
Getting around on Route 60
The Chautauqua Area Regional Transit System provides bus service to Frewsburg residents, connecting commuters to Jamestown and the metro area. The community is home to one bus stop at Frewsburg Town Hall. U.S. Route 62, the community's Main Street, runs through town. Jamestown's UPMC Chautauqua is 6 miles away via Route 62 and New York State Route 60. Erie International Airport is about 70 miles west via Interstate 86, and Buffalo Niagara International Airport is approximately 80 miles north via Interstate 90.
Public transportation in Frewsburg includes a CARTS bus stop at Town Hall, connecting residents to Jamestown and beyond.
Frewsburg sits at the crossroads of U.S. Route 62 and NY Route 60, providing easy access to Jamestown and regional destinations.
1/2
Written By
Lillie Duston
Photography Contributed By
Jonathan Coon
Video By
Tyler Newbold
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Daniel Terhune,
an experienced agent in this area.
On average, homes in Frewsburg, NY sell after 52 days on the market compared to the national average of 53 days. The median sale price for homes in Frewsburg, NY over the last 12 months is $130,000, down 15% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Set on over 7 acres on the outskirts of the ‘burg, this charming four-bedroom raised ranch offers plenty of room to grow! Located next to the elementary school, this property offers a secluded, countryside feel while still being close to the amenities of town. Inside, the home offers the convenience of single-level living, and there is a full basement with an exterior walkout. The eat-in kitchen
Prime 1.8-Acre Lot with Two-Story Garage in Desirable Frewsburg NeighborhoodWelcome to an exceptional opportunity in the heart of Frewsburg! This 1.8-acre parcel is perfectly situated in a quiet, sought-after area surrounded by well-maintained homes, offering both privacy and a strong sense of community.The property features a spacious two-story, four-car garage—already equipped
Welcome to 605 Guernsey Hollow Road, natures paradise! This 3 bed, 1 bath home sits on 3.3 lush acres in the Frewsburg school district. Just minutes from Onoville Marina and 100+ acres of state land, it's a nature lovers dream. 10 Minutes from the PA border. Cozy up by the wood burning fireplace or gather around the scenic campfire area. Features 3 outbuildings with plenty of storage options, a
Walk Score® measures the walkability of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
