$328,106Average Value$211Average Price per Sq Ft59Homes For Sale
A small Western New York town with an outsized impact on American food culture
Hamburg, a suburb just south of Buffalo, New York, may appear at first glance to fly under the national radar. The quiet residential streets and picturesque views of Lake Erie are underscored by a type of Western New York hospitality that does not boast of itself but is certainly felt throughout the area. “For the first-time buyer coming here, or the third-time buyer, they’re going to find we are a community that cares,” says Anne Kader, a second-generation associate broker with Metro Roberts Realty and a lifelong area resident. However, this modesty is accompanied by a jovial atmosphere that is unlike any other.
The National Football League’s Buffalo Bills play Sunday home games in Hamburg, and tailgates at the stadium are famous for rowdy and extravagant celebrations. “Buffalonians are very passionate people. We’re very happy-go-lucky and laid back,” adds Mary Kosmider, licensed real estate salesperson with Metro Roberts Realty, who works with Mrs. Kader. This passion extends to food, and Hamburg may just be among the most enthusiastic in this regard. As the story goes, the hamburger was invented here at the Erie County Fair in 1885, going on to become America’s most enduring sandwich. This creation is celebrated annually at Burgerfest in the center of town.
Outside of football tailgates and culinary festivals, this city is known locally for its slow-paced lakefront energy. Both the central village and the surrounding town have a CAP Index Crime score of 3 out of 10, indicating lower crime rates than the national average of 4. Whether enjoyed with cheese, onions, a Kosher pickle or a cold draft beer, anyone who has sunk their teeth into a burger can thank the little city of Hamburg.
Hamburg
Rodneys in Hamburg is a popular hang out spot for locals.
1/2
Single-family homes are predominant throughout Hamburg
Cape Cods with colorful shutters and stately brick Colonial Revivals line Hamburg’s well-landscaped streets. Midcentury ranch-style homes, with both traditional and Craftsman architectural details, can be found speckled throughout the town and the village as well. More recent modern traditional builds have been added to the mix, many featuring large garages and paved driveways. Prices tend to range between $300,000 and $700,000 for single-family homes, with prices rising depending on number of bedrooms, lot size and proximity to Lake Erie. Townhouses and condos in the area’s 55-plus communities can cost anywhere from $180,000 to $250,000.
Home costs in Hamburg fluctuate, generally commanding higher-than-list prices during the summer and dipping around or below asking in the winter months. The area sees heavier lake effect snowfall than other parts of the Buffalo region, meaning buyers should be aware that the larger square footage comes at a recurring cost. Those looking to escape Buffalo city taxes should also keep a careful eye on property lines when shopping. “Remember, if you’re in the village, you’ll have an extra tax,” says Anne Kader. “Depending on where the cutoff is on your property line, you could find yourself paying four taxes instead of three - your school tax, town tax, county tax and then a village tax.” This extra fee provides access to additional amenities.
The annual snowfall in Hamburg is 188 inches.
1/2
The town and the village of Hamburg are served by different school districts
The Frontier Central School District serves the town of Hamburg, which scores an overall B from Niche. Frontier High School, which serves the entire town, rates a B-plus. Students in the village of Hamburg are zoned for schools in the Hamburg Central School District, which receives an overall B-plus. Hamburg High, the only high school for students in the village, also earns a B-plus. Faith-based institutions such as Saint Francis High offer private alternatives for young men.
Frontier Senior High School in Hamburg has 1350 students.
1/2
Burgerfest, the Erie County Fair and football Sundays with the Bills
One of Hamburg’s biggest claims to fame is a quintessentially American culinary creation. “The town claims the invention of the hamburger,” says Tom Patton, a retired ironworker and a lifelong area resident. “They’ve got a whole festival for it every year in July. They call it Burgerfest, and there are burgers all over the place.” This one-day celebration of perhaps the most famous American food features live music from local bands, a classic car show and street vendors lining Main Street in the Village of Hamburg. Other popular events include the Hamburg Music Festival, a massive outdoor concert that takes place in late spring, and Hamburg Oktoberfest, which puzzlingly occurs annually on the third weekend of September.
The Erie County Fair, the reputed birthplace of the original hamburger, has been held in Hamburg since 1868 and is among the largest county fairs in the country, routinely drawing over 1 million visitors. The event lasts for 12 days every August and features livestock competitions, a wide lineup of food and the James E. Strates Show Midway carnival.
On autumn and winter Sundays, blue-clad locals descend upon Hamburg in droves, clogging the roads around Highmark Stadium and leaping onto collapsable tables in the arena parking lot, regardless of weather conditions. “During football season, especially at home games, we have the Bills Mafia. It’s party central,” says Kader. “Everybody’s into it, whether we’re at the game or at home. The stores on Sunday are mobbed. Everybody gets into football.” The New Highmark Stadium, located right across the street from the old one, is set to open for the 2026-27 season, so fans will not have to make significant changes to their Sunday routine.
1/2
Village shops and Friday fish fry on Lake Erie
McKinley Mall, located on McKinley Parkway, offers an array of over 50 shops, including bookstores, a pet adoption center and a Wegman’s and Aldi. Everyday necessities and home goods can be purchased at Quaker Crossing along Milestrip Road, home to the nearest Target. Many locals will head to Buffalo and Main Streets in the center of town to take advantage of the village shops. “The Village of Hamburg is so cute. It’s like a Hallmark movie down there,” says Mary Kosmider. “They really built it up. They have restaurants, shopping, boutiques and all kinds of things. It’s my place to go to relax.”
Local business owners have opened restaurants along New York Route 5 to take advantage of waterfront views of Lake Erie. Since 1949, diners have flocked to Hoak’s Lakeshore Restaurant for their signature sandwiches and Friday evening fish fry. “Fish fry on Fridays still goes on here,” says Anne Kader. “You’ll hear people ask one another, ‘Where do you go for your Friday fish fry?’ It’s practically religious. I mean, it’s what I was raised on.”
1/2
Hamburg Town Park is exclusive for locals
The Lake Erie waterfront is a popular place for locals to fish, windsurf and relax on the beach during the summer, and for ice fishing and skating when the lake freezes in winter. The most frequented access point in the area is Hamburg Town Park Beach, which requires proof of residency in the town to use. The park is open all year, but only sees significant traffic when swimming is comfortable. The Lakeview Road Recreation Area, located just off U.S. Route 90, is the site of a former U.S. Army missile base that has been converted into a local sports hub. The facility features a BMX track, the town ice rink, several baseball diamonds and a golf course.
1/2
Public transit offers an express bus for Hamburg
New York Route 5 runs along the lakefront and can be used to make the 13-mile trip to Buffalo or the 30-mile trip to the American side of Niagara Falls. Interstate 90, which also runs north to Buffalo, cuts through the center of the town. The Niagara Frontier Transportation Authority (NFTA) services the area, offering a Hamburg Express bus line directly between the Village of Hamburg and downtown Buffalo, a trip that takes roughly an hour.
Written By
Hugh Taylor
Photography Contributed By
Stefan Ludwig
Video By
Christine Tranchina
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Jerry Thompson,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Hamburg, NY sell after 28 days on the market compared to the national average of 50 days. The median sale price for homes in Hamburg, NY over the last 12 months is $315,000, up 7% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Showings begin June 27th at 10am & offers are due by July 9th at 3pm. Open House Sunday June 29th from 1-3pm.Welcome to your dream home nestled on over 3 acres of serene countryside, where nature meets comfort and convenience. This beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 1.5-bath home offers the perfect blend of rustic charm and modern updates.Step inside to find two spacious bedrooms on the
Nestled in the heart of the picturesque Village of Hamburg, this beautifully cared-for 3 bedroom, 2 full bath home offers timeless charm and modern comfort. Step onto the inviting front porch and enter a home designed for effortless flow, where clean sightlines stretch from front to back, bathing the interior in abundant natural light and highlighting exquisite woodwork throughout. The
Located in the heart of Hamburg Village, this well-maintained home is just steps from schools, restaurants, the farmers market, the movie theater, and more. Enjoy sweeping views from the garage-top balcony of a backyard oasis with a heated pool, mature rose bushes, lawn space, a pool shed, and multiple entertaining areas—including a bar, awning, and outdoor TV. Inside, the spacious kitchen
In area if "Fine Homes'! 100 Frontage with generous depth of 284' - almost a rectangular shape (see survey) angles at back line. Sewer was not installed but was approved by ECWD No.2 on 4/2024. Located next to 6184 Versailles.
Located in the Marrano's Mission Hills patio home community in Hamburg. MOVE IN READY! Easy living lifestyle with HOA that provides snow removal and lawn care. Situated on a lot that backs up to woods (conservation area)Two bedrooms, the primary has a WIC and primary bath with ceramic tile shower. Island for entertaining in the kitchen along with beautiful cabinetry to the ceiling, a ceramic tile
Location, Location! Pride of ownership welcomes you to 57 Dudley in the Village of Hamburg. Starting with the spacious enclosed front porch, perfect for relaxing with your morning coffee. Foyer with slate floor invites you inside where the charm and character is apparent. This gem boasts beautiful natural woodwork and gleaming hardwood floors throughout. The living room offers a woodburning
New build! Beautifully landscaped and providing luxurious amenities, Eagle Ridge Commons offers a serene setting with views of the lake that is ideally located to everything you love about the Buffalo, New York area. Located in Hamburg, NY, Eagle Ridge Commons is minutes from Lake Erie, the Village of Hamburg, shops and restaurants, Hilbert College, High Mark Stadium, and I-90. After a day at the
This magnificent home on one of the most spectacular parcels of land in the Southtowns, is an oasis from everyday life. Picturesque views out every window, either of the creek or the gardens. The newly finished kitchen includes a bright eating area with spectacular views, the full bath on the 2nd floor is also newly finished with massive soaking tub and walk in shower. The Living Room and Family
Welcome to Sherwood Meadows Apartments and Townhomes3750 Heatherwood Drive Hamburg, NY 14075We offer 1, 2 and 3 bedroom condo-style apartments custom built with the highest standard of quality. The same amenities and finishes as our townhomes. Don't pay exorbitant rent to live in a apartment community with no privacy. Sherwood Meadows has genuine luxury and reasonable prices designed
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
