$691,271Average Value$477Average Price per Sq Ft15Homes For Sale
Year-round beach community that moves at a slower pace
The Highlands is a year-round coastal community that hugs Sandy Hook Bay. This small enclave is literally minutes from some of New Jersey’s best beaches, while also offering high-speed NYC commuter ferries.
This Monmouth County borough has long been a working-class beach town, with 4,600 residents living within 1.4 miles.
Despite its name, much of the Highlands is in a flood zone and Superstorm Sandy destroyed 1,400 homes and most of the downtown businesses in 2012. But the tight-knit community has since rebuilt, and homes have been steadily increasing in price through the years. Despite the flood risk, Susan Natale, an experienced agent with Coldwell Banker who raised her family nearby, has noticed an influx of transplants from the NYC area. “People can work from home and have the flexibility of being near beaches, while having easy access to ferries and NYC,” she says.
Commuters can take a short Ferry ride from the Highlands to New York City.
The Highlands is surrounded by beautiful beaches such as Sea Bright.
1/2
Multiple beaches including Miller Beach, plus the Henry Hudson Rail Trail
Beaches are the main attraction here, and the Highlands is home to a number within walking and biking distance. Snug Harbor Beach is small, but features soft white sand, calm bay water and a new skate park. Miller Beach draws families since it offers bathrooms, showers and lifeguards. It’s also popular with anglers and surfers. Highlands Beach in Sea Bright is located on a narrow strip along Sandy Hook Bay, a local favorite since not only is it less crowded, but it’s also free. There are a handful of marinas in town too.
Sandy Hook Gateway National Recreation Area is just over the causeway and includes pristine, protected beaches as part of a National Park. Nearby Sea Bright offers private beach clubs.
Huddy Park is the town gathering spot, a small green space with a gazebo and playground. It’s also the backdrop for community events. There are plans to open a new Overlook Park on Navesink Avenue.
The Henry Hudson Trail is a popular 24-mile rail trail that starts in the Highlands. The wide stretch follows former railroad tracks past scenic stretches of wetlands, streams and more.
Hartshorne Woods spans part of the Highlands and offers 812 hilly acres with hiking and biking trails overlooking the Navesink River.
Secluded Snug Harbor Beach is a little get away in the heart of the Highlands.
The Highlands own Huddy Park provides a gathering space in the middle of town.
1/2
Newer construction, smaller lots and water views
Due to Highland’s compact size homes are on small lots. It’s highly walkable with sidewalks and views of Raritan Bay. Many homes within the town’s flood zone have been rebuilt, with the first floor lifted on top of a garage to mitigate future flooding. Flood insurance is required for many homes.
Natale describes this as a beach bungalow town, but new styles are also a mix of Dutch colonials and cape cods with dormer windows. There are a sizable number of condos and townhomes, starting around $300,000 for a one-bedroom condo and going for as much as $1.6 million for a two-bedroom waterfront townhome. Small single-family homes on equally small lots start around $400,000. Water views can start around $380,000 for a one-bedroom condo and $750,000 for a roomy three bedroom.
The median price is $590,000.
Raised Bungalows on small lots dot the Highlands neighborhoods.
The Highlands has waterfront condos throughout the borough.
1/2
Clam Fest and year-round events
Highlands has hosted the Annual Clam Fest for almost 30 years. This weekend-long celebration is held at Huddy Park, complete with live music, kids' activities and all things clams. Fireworks at Snug Harbor Beach cap the festivities. Year-round events include Pride Fest, Seaport Craft Show, Taste of Highlands, St. Patrick’s Day and Howl-O-Ween.
Local waterfront restaurants and nearby shopping
A small number of restaurants line Bay Avenue like The Chubby Pickle, a popular dive bar for burgers, fried pickles, trivia and live music. Bahrs Landing is a waterfront institution dating back to 1917 and known for its fresh seafood and laid-back atmosphere. Dock Donuts serves homemade doughnuts along with cold brew and frozen lemonade by the water.
For basics, Super Foodtown is next door in Atlantic Highlands, along with additional shopping along First Avenue and Route 36. Additional supermarkets and big box chains are 15 minutes away in Middletown.
Highland's residents and visitors can stop by Dock Donuts for a little treat near the beach.
The Chubby Pickle is a popular dive bar located in the Highlands.
1/2
Henry Hudson Regional School serves 7th to 12th graders in the community
The district is small, with an eight-to-one student/teacher ratio for all grades. Public school students attend Highlands Elementary School, rated a B-minus from Niche, for kindergarten through sixth grades. They continue to Henry Hudson Regional School for seventh through 12th grades, which Niche rates a B plus.
Henry Hudson Regional High School
Aerial view of Highlands Elementary School.
1/2
NYC commuter ferries
The Seastreak ferry provides 40-minute ferry rides to Lower Manhattan, along with scenic views and an onboard bar. Route 36 is a main corridor, but shore traffic gets very heavy in the summer.
Commuter ferries leave from the Highlands taking an easy ride to Manhattan,
Ferries provide a scenic ride to start the commuters day.
1/2
Flooding is a major concern
According to the site Risk Factor, the majority of the Highlands is at extreme risk for flooding within the next 30 years. The borough recently received a $12 million federal grant that will go toward green infrastructure and stormwater mitigation projects.
Video By
Kellan Beaver
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Suzanne Nadwodny,
an experienced agent in this area.
Agents Specializing in this Area
Pamela Girard
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Fox & Roach - Rumson
On average, homes in Highlands, NJ sell after 39 days on the market compared to the national average of 53 days. The median sale price for homes in Highlands, NJ over the last 12 months is $547,450, up 11% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Experience elevated craftsmanship and contemporary luxury in this brand-new two-unit home, offering roughly 1,700 square feet of impeccably finished living space, including a full walk-out basement. Rebuilt from the ground up, every detail reflects refined architecture and modern sophistication.This exceptional two-bedroom, one-bath duplex spans two levels, featuring a fully finished
Experience premier coastal living in this upgraded 3BR, 3.5BA Harborside townhome with 4 private decks and sweeping Sandy Hook Bay views. The master suite offers vaulted ceilings, a private balcony, custom walk-in closet, and spa-like bath. Owners enhanced the home with a custom laundry room, pantry, built-in desk, garage storage, EV charger, and smart motorized shades. The open-concept main
Welcome to 51 Matthew Street—your Highlands coastal escape just steps from the NYC Seastreak ferry and the waterfront! This charming 2-bedroom home offers bright, easy-living spaces and an updated kitchen with newer appliances. Live moments from beaches, marinas, parks, and downtown Highlands' restaurants and cafes - all within walking or easy bike ride distance, and with effortless commuter
On top of the world — and in a world of your own.High above the coast in the exclusive enclave of Monmouth Hills, this 1.5-acre lot offers the ultimate in seclusion and sophistication. Backing up to more than 700 acres of Hartshorne Woods Park, it feels like a private estate, yet it's just minutes from ocean beaches, the high-speed ferry to NYC, and some of the Shore's top dining spots. Approved
Charming Restored Home with Stunning Water Views at the Jersey Shore..... Welcome to this beautifully restored coastal gem, where exceptional design and craftsmanship meet the serene beauty of the Jersey Shore. Situated just steps from the shimmering shores, this home boasts breathtaking water views that will leave you mesmerized from sunrise to sunset. Set on a beautifully manicured lawn with
Experience elevated craftsmanship and contemporary luxury in this brand-new two-unit home, offering roughly 1,700 square feet of impeccably finished living space, including a full walk-out basement. Rebuilt from the ground up, every detail reflects refined architecture and modern sophistication.This exceptional two-bedroom, one-bath duplex spans two levels, featuring a fully finished
Pristine WATERFRONT Beach front living a few steps from the sand! ALL UTILITIES & private high speed WIFI INCLUDED PRIVATE beach cottage w/ amazing water views of Sandy Hook Beach and NYC skyline. Newly renovated, fully furnished, fresh and stylish w/ Beachy decor. Cottage can accommodate 4 people. Located in a friendly community w/ plenty of outdoor space. Just a few blocks to Seastreak Ferry,
Christine Morford
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Fox & Roach - Rumson
Winter RentalFully furnished winter rental with STUNNING views of NYC,Sandy Hook,and the Raritan Bay. This property is located high and dry in Highlands away from any possibilities of flooding. Enjoy the ocean breeze from the front porch or the back deck. BBQ grill available for use. Three large bedrooms and plenty of room for extra storage. Kitchen with recently updated appliances and
Fully furnished 2-bedroom detached carriage house apartment available as a winter rental. Enjoy a private, spacious porch and the convenience of a Wi-Fi extender included. Located just steps from the beach, yet far enough to offer a peaceful and private living space.
Walk Score® measures the walkability of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
