$632,704Average Value$254Average Price per Sq Ft15Homes For Sale
Old Northside preserves its past with pride
The only neighborhood in Indiana that was once home to an American president, Indianapolis’ Old Northside has successfully preserved the houses and charm that made it the city’s prominent place of residence in the second half of the 19th century. That includes the house of Benjamin Harrison, who left here to serve as the nation’s 23rd president from 1889-93 before returning to Indianapolis for the remainder of his lifetime. Between its grand Victorians and modern custom builds on old lots, plenty of nearby modern amenities make this one of Indy’s most popular places to live more than a century after its original heyday. "The thing I love most about the Old Northside neighborhood is you can live, work and play all within a unique historic area of our city," says resident Shay McCoy.
The Old Northside's location just north of downtown Indianapolis makes it a desirable area.
Take a tour of the Benjamin Harrison Presidential Site in Old Northside.
1/2
Newer custom builds join stately Victorians
It’s called Old Northside for a reason – many of its homes have been here a very long time. But the median age for an Old Northside home is only 69 years because of the number of post-2000 custom builds on old lots. Condos around 600 square feet in size range from $155,000-$162,500, while larger condos have sold between $220,000-$552,500. Houses range from $234,000-$1.49 million.
Homes in Old Northside boast beautiful and unique colors.
New modern homes can be found scattered throughout Old Northside.
1/2
A presidential home and plenty of urban greenspace
The Benjamin Harrison Presidential Site, housed at his Italianate-designed home, isn’t just for history buffs. “Unless there’s a private event booked, the grounds are always open to the public,” says Presidential Site special events and marketing manager Lindsey Beckley. “People tour the gardens or do yoga on the lawn. We encourage our neighbors to come and enjoy the space.” Great Oak Commons – designed as an homage to Victorian-era parks and meant for “contemplation or reflection” -- adds to the neighborhood’s historic feel. So does Shawn Grove Park. Though its playground is modern, the picnic pavilion is designed to mimic the neighborhood’s Victorian homes. In the neighborhood’s southeast corner, Frank and Judy O’Bannon Soccer Park and O’Bannon Playground, named for Indiana’s late 47th governor and his wife, provide another outdoor outlet in the neighborhood.
Take a tour of the Benjamin Harrison Presidential Site in Old Northside.
Shawn Grove Park includes two playgrounds in the Old Northside neighborhood.
1/2
Herron High is Indy's top-rated public high school
Herron High School, the top-ranked public high school in Indianapolis and in the top 1% nationally for college prep, is just across 16th St. From the Old Northside. Herron High has an A-plus rating on Niche. Herron Preparatory Academy, opened in 2021, is adding a grade level each year. It will serve K-6 students in 2024 before expanding to K-8 for 2026 and beyond. Center for Inquiry School 27, which has a C-rating on Niche, currently serves the neighborhood at the full K-8 level.
Center for Inquiry School No. 27 is in the heart of Old Northside.
Herron Preparatory Academy currently serves K-6 students and is next to the children's museum.
Herron High School is a public charter high school located near the Old Northside neighborhood.
1/3
Historic venues offer cultural events
Benjamin Harrison Presidential Site hosts several community events, including an Easter Egg Roll tradition he brought back to Indy from the White House. Other annual events include the Juneteenth celebration, an Independence Day Social every July 4th and the Wicket World of Croquet tournament each August. The croquet event, now 30 years old, features 48 teams decked out in all-white attire. The Indianapolis Propylaeum, located in the neighborhood since 1923, was founded by leading women’s rights activist May Wright Sewall and continues with its mission today. The Propylaeum hosts various regular programs ranging from front-porch concerts to seminars about local historical preservation efforts. Harrison Center, a 65,000-square foot community center, is dedicated to serving the city via art, music, education and grassroots activism.
Multiple ways to get around Old Northside
Laid out shortly following the Civil War, Old Northside is a walker-friendly neighborhood. The 25-mile-long Monon Trail runs along the neighborhood’s eastern boundary, and there is a Pacers Bikeshare station adjacent to the trail at O’Bannon Soccer Park. IndyGo buses serve the neighborhood with routes along 16th St. As well as Central Ave. And with direct access to Interstate 65, all of Indy is within easy reach by automobile.
The Old Northside is conveniently located near downtown Indianapolis.
IndyGo is the public transportation system serving the Old Northside neighborhood.
1/2
16th Street provides array of dining
Tinker Street restaurant, opened along the neighborhood’s 16th Street boundary in 2015, features a rotating seasonal menu and was named one of USA Today’s eight best places to eat in the Midwest. Two essential Indy coffee shops – PROVIDER Coffee & Cocktail Lounge and Foundry Provisions – are also on 16th St. Gallery on 16th, which features a Mediterranean-inspired brunch menu, is another popular way to start a day. And one of the neighborhood’s longest-running mainstays is Greg’s Our Place, a pioneering LGBQT bar in operation since 1980. Throughout the year, Our Place also hosts events benefiting multiple community non-profit organizations. A Kroger on 16th St. is the neighborhood's nearest grocery store.
Provider Coffee Co is a great place to stop before work for a coffee and after for a cocktail.
Provider Coffee Co is in the heart of Old Northside.
1/2
Auto theft is a concern
The neighborhood receives a 7 of 10 score in the CAP crime measurement index. Motor vehicle theft is ranked as the highest concern, rating 8 of 10.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Nathaniel VanPelt,
an experienced agent in this neighborhood.
Parks in this Area
JTV Hill Park
Picnic Area
Trails
Playground
Shawn Grove Park
Picnic Area
Playground
Frank and Judy O'Bannon Old Northside Soccer Park
Monon Trail
Bike Trails
Trails
Herron-Morton Place Historic Park
Martin Luther King Memorial Park
Great Oak Commons
Picnic Area
Trails
Multi-Purpose Field
Transit
Airport
Indianapolis International
29 min drive
Bus
College Ave & 13th St
Bus
16th St & Central Ave
Bus
College Ave & 16th St
Bus
Central Ave & 13th St
Bus
Delaware St & 16th St
Bus
Delaware St & 14th St
Bus
Central Ave & 16th St
Crime and Safety
1 - Low Crime, 10 - High Crime
Old Northside
US
Homicide
5
4
Sexual Assault
6
4
Assault with Weapon
6
4
Robbery
8
4
Burglary
9
4
Motor Vehicle Theft
8
4
Larceny
9
4
Crime Score
8
4
Source: WhatIsMyCrimeRisk.com
Old Northside Demographics and Home Trends
On average, homes in Old Northside, Indianapolis sell after 142 days on the market compared to the national average of 49 days. The median sale price for homes in Old Northside, Indianapolis over the last 12 months is $457,500, down 4% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
A modern, historic gem awaits you. Fully remodeled in 2016, this home offers the perfect blend of comfort and modern, wrapped in with a nostalgic, historic feeling. If hardwoods tickle your fancy, then you'll be delighted to walk them throughout the first floor (and as an added touch, the island is also made out of walnut). Keeping the original vibe in the home, you'll notice the original,
Rare opportunity to own a lot in the coveted Old Northside! This 40x155 lot offers the perfect canvas to build your dream home. Enjoy the convenience of being close to Mass Ave, the Monon Trail, Bottleworks District, and all that Downtown has to offer. Situated within the historic preservation district, this property combines modern potential with timeless charm. Don't miss your chance to make
Priced out of the Downtown market? This charming end-unit townhouse in the sought-after Old Northside could be your perfect opportunity! Even better - there are no HOA fees! Beautifully updated with a full interior remodel just 9 years ago and recently refreshed with new paint, this home is truly move-in ready. The main living area features gleaming hardwood floors and a cozy corner gas log
2 BR, 2.5 BA end-unit townhouse in the Old Northside Historic District with no HOA fees. A covered front porch welcomes you into a bright main level with an updated kitchen and dining area. The living room features a fireplace and built-in shelving. Upstairs, both bedrooms boast private full baths and walk-in closets. Outside, a larger fenced backyard with patio provides a quiet retreat, plus
Tucked away in the charming Old Northside historic neighborhood, the Maryden Apartments offers a quaint setting and a convenient location near Indianapolis’ best dining, nightlife and attractions, making it ideal for those who crave an urban lifestyle with a side of quiet. Each artfully-styled apartment in this stately, early 20th-century building has been redesigned with you in mind, blending
Beautiful 1st floor apartment located in the Historic Old Northside. Two bedrooms, two baths and hardwood and tile floors throughout! Tall ceilings, tons of natural light and storage galore. Quartz countertops in kitchen and baths, slab brown modern cabinets, stainless steel apples. plus laundry room in unit. Kitchen island, pendant lighting and separate pantry. Private storage in basement plus
Urban and hip renovated apartments walking distance to downtown Bottleworks, grocery and coffee shop! Distressed hardwood floors, quartz countertops, warm brown slab cabinets, ss appliances plus custom honeycomb up-down blinds! Laundry facilities in lower level basement plus private storage for each unit. Garden plots on a first come first serve basis. Bike storage plus new recreation room
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Nathaniel VanPelt,
an experienced agent in this neighborhood.
Average Home Value
Source: Public Records
Property Mix - Square Feet
This Neighborhood Has More Renters
Demographics
Total Population
2,303
Median Age
35
Population Density
14 ppl/acre
Population under 18
18.2%
Below the national average
23.8%
Population over 65
8.6%
Below the national average
19.1%
Finances
Median Household Income
$58,292
Below the national average
$71,702
Average Household Income
$93,972
Education and Workforce
High School Graduates
95.6%
College Graduates
69.3%
Significantly above the national average
34.1%
Advanced Degrees
28.5%
Above the national average
13.3%
% Population in Labor Force
78.3%
Weather
Annual Precipitation
41''
Average Winter Low Temperature
22°F
Average Summer High Temperature
85°F
Annual Snowfall
13''
Area Factors
Very Bikeable
Bike Score®
73/ 100
Very Walkable
Walk Score®
78/ 100
Good Transit
Transit Score®
53/ 100
Source: Walk Score
Source: Walk Score
Sound Score® measures the noise level of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
