$376,090Average Value$214Average Price per Sq Ft47Homes For Sale
Developing village amenities outside of Buffalo
Established as a town in 1833 by an act of the New York State Legislature, Lancaster is a town located just 14 miles east of Buffalo and is an outer ring suburb of the city. The area is home to multiple large parks, a Niche A-minus rated school district, and is starting to see some developments in its downtown village area. “It is a big town with many people, but everyone knows everyone,” says Lisa Myers, a real estate salesperson with Keller Williams Realty – Lancaster, who was raised in the town. “I know I may be a bit partial to it, but it has that hometown feel. They have done a good job of revitalizing the village area over the last three to five years, and more events and things are happening there.”
Winding suburban subdivisions
A suburban town, Lancaster has multiple subdivisions foot or bike, close to home. Homebuyers have their pick of the litter in terms of architectural styles, including ranch-style, craftsman, farmhouse and colonial revival. Property lots are lined closely but feature well-kept yards, driveways, and a garage. Prices range from $165,000 to $732,000, but buyers can expect a four-bedroom ranch to sell for almost $300,000, while a five-bedroom Colonial Revival will rise to around $500,000. “The market is stable, and we still see multiple offer situations. There is still a bit of an inventory shortage in Lancaster, which is driving up the prices,” Myers says.
Lancaster's residential neighborhoods are expansive and well maintained.
Homes in Lancaster sport tidy lawns and neat landscaping.
Lancaster homes feature a wide variety of newer homes.
1/3
Lancaster Central public schools
Children attend the Lancaster Central School District, which scores an A-minus on Niche and serves 5,427 students in the town and village of Lancaster, the town of Cheektowaga, the town of Elma and the village of Depew. One potential school path is Hillview Elementary for kindergarten through third grades, William Street School for fourth through sixth grades, Lancaster Middle School for seventh and eighth grade and earn their diplomas from Lancaster High School. According to Niche, the elementary and high schools earn an A-minus, while Will Street and the middle school score a B. Lancaster High offers 20 dual enrollment classes that allow a pathway for students to earn college credit while concurrently earning high school credits.
Lancaster Middle School is located in a former High School building.
Lancaster High School is a highly rated public school for students in grates 9-12.
1/2
Scheduling senior shuttles and Broadway Buffalo commutes
While there is no public transportation in Lancaster, the town does offer senior citizens (60+) residents a shuttle van service through the town's senior center. Interested locals must schedule appointments for rides, and while it is free of charge, donations are encouraged. Known as Broadway, U.S. Highway 20 is one of the main thoroughfares in Lancaster and takes commuters into Buffalo. The Boulevard also has an on-ramp to Interstate 90, heading into downtown Buffalo.
Lancaster is a scenic town set on the Cayuga Creek.
Boutiques and restaurants on Central Avenue
Residents have multiple options for grocery shopping, including a couple of Tops Friendly Markets, Wegmans and Aldi. Central Avenue in the village has become a locally owned retail destination with small boutiques, including fashion stores like the New York Store, Juls and Jane, or the Gilded Maple home goods store. Lancaster has plenty of places to choose from for a meal out on the town. Whether it’s a burger from The Yelling Goat, a slice of pizza from 99 Brick Oven, a sit-down Italian Meal at Frank’s Grill or a sandwich and a beer at Skoobs Village Grill.
Lancaster residents can choose from several grocery stores, including Aldi.
The New York Store is one of the premier clothing stores in Lancaster.
1/2
Sprawling paths and country clubs off Cayuga Creek
On the banks of the Cayuga Creek, Como Lake Park is 534 acres and is run by Erie County. Locals can use the park for multiple types of recreation across all seasons. In the summer, residents can fish the creek, play a round of disc golf, hike or bike through some of the trails, picnic or use one of the playgrounds. In the winter, its trails are the perfect place for cross-country skiers, and its sloping hills provide a place for children of all ages to sled. Walden Pond Park has seven softball fields, a t-ball field, four sand volleyball courts and another multi-use field for youth sports. For an additional cost, residents can join Lancaster Country Club, founded in 1925, which features an 18-hole golf course, swimming pool complex, and other social activities.
Lancaster has several disc golf courses available in nearby parks.
Lancaster Country Club offers 18 holes on a scenic course by Cayuga Creek.
1/2
A night at the opera and village events
Housed in a historic 1897 structure, the Lancaster Opera House is one of the country's few remaining Town Hall Opera Houses. The venue remains active and hosts plays and concerts throughout the year. The Village of Lancaster has started to host more events annually, including a Fall Festival, which supports the high school football team. The event features a photo booth, horse rides, vendors, food trucks and live music.
Historic Warren Hull House
The town is home to Warren Hull House, the oldest surviving structure in Erie County and is fully restored. Interested parties can only tour the home by appointment and learn what life was like 200 years ago in Erie County.
Written By
Tina Davis
Video By
Edward Pokoj
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Kathy Anderson,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Lancaster, NY sell after 27 days on the market compared to the national average of 49 days. The median sale price for homes in Lancaster, NY over the last 12 months is $340,817, up 8% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Don't miss out on one of Juniper Townhome's last brand new 2 bedroom homes! The 2 bedroom, 2.5 bath Winston townhome design features a 2-story Foyer filled with windows for lots of natural light, an open Family Room/Kitchen/Dinette layout, 1st floor Primary with attached bath & WIC, 1st floor laundry, attached 2 car garage, and full basement. Upstairs you'll find loft space (perfect for a home
Don't miss out on one of Juniper Townhome's last brand new 2 bedroom homes! The 2 bedroom, 2.5 bath Winston townhome design features a 2-story Foyer filled with windows for lots of natural light, an open Family Room/Kitchen/Dinette layout, 1st floor Primary with attached bath & WIC, 1st floor laundry, attached 2 car garage, and full basement. Upstairs you'll find loft space (perfect for a home
Excellent investment and owner occupant opportunity in the Village of Lancaster, NY! Downstairs tenant is month-to-month paying $1600 since November 2023. Upstairs tenant moved out May 17th and was paying $1500 per month. Upstairs is ready to move in. Lancaster school district. Next to Saint Mary’s high school. On a wraparound street so the neighbors are the only traffic. Large backyard porch and
Welcome to this beautifully expanded 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath Cape Cod home, featuring a brand-new second floor addition completed in 2023. Situated on a generous half-acre lot, this property offers modern updates, classic charm, and ample space both inside and out. Step inside to find a sunlit living room with hardwood floors and a cozy wood-burning fireplace—perfect for relaxing evenings. The large
Marrano's 1st floor Primary Suite design, the Winston is now under construction in the FINAL building that the Juniper Townhomes community will offer. With an expected Fall completion, this home features 2 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and an expanded Loft space that is perfect for a Home Office or Hobby Room. This home also has convenient 1st floor Laundry, a bright 2-story Foyer, full basement for
Marrano's 1st floor Primary Suite design, the Winston is now under construction in the FINAL building that the Juniper Townhomes community will offer. With an expected Fall completion, this home features 2 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and an expanded Loft space that is perfect for a Home Office or Hobby Room. This home also has convenient 1st floor Laundry, a bright 2-story Foyer, full basement for
PARK LANE APARTMENTS in Depew, New York include high-speed internet & cable TV, hardwood-inspired flooring, have pet-friendly floor plans, available garages, and air conditioning. Park Lane East 1, 2 & 3-bedroom apartments include the luxury of a private entrance & tiled foyer, European-styled kitchen, in-home laundry, tall ceilings, large walk-in closets, patios & rent includes high-speed
Hard to find first floor Open-floor plan 2 bedroom apartment with attached garage! Each unit has 1 garage space. All walls freshly painted, gorgeous cherry stained oak hardwood in the LR was just refinished, brand new carpeting in both bedrooms too! Pretty gas fireplace makes the LR extra cozy. Laundry hook upsright off the kitchen! Master adjoins split full bath (so it feels private). Walk-in
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
