$482,166Average Value$312Average Price per Sq Ft39Homes For Sale
A commutable hamlet with great parks
Long Island is often discussed in terms of north shore versus south shore, but its more landlocked neighborhoods can also be great places to live. Located about halfway between the island’s eastern and westernmost boundaries and halfway between the Long Island Sound and the Atlantic Ocean, Middle Island is a prime example of this. “There are a lot of advantages to living in the center of the island,” says Todd Yovino, a licensed real estate broker and owner at Island Advantage Realty with over 30 years of experience. “For one thing, if you have quick access to major corridors, you can reduce your daily commute by about 15 minutes each leg. Add that up and see how much extra time you have on your schedule each month to do what you want.” Middle Island also has its own charm and provides everything locals need for day-to-day life. “It’s a quaint little place,” says Jacqulene Mitrani, an associate real estate broker at Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty who has sold homes here for four years and lives in the neighboring town of Yaphank. “There’s a lot of stuff to do — there’s a lot of great places to eat, there’s a lot of great trails.”
Artist Lake is a pleasant place to relax, boat, or watch the geese.
Middle Island residents can easily commute via nearby i-495.
1/2
Single-family houses starting at $400,000
Although many of Middle Island’s residential streets lack sidewalks, they tend to be quiet and shaded by trees, making daily walks and bike rides safe and enjoyable. In parts of the neighborhood, colonials, Cape Cods, ranch-style and hi-ranch homes are set back from the streets by large front yards, trees or both. It’s easy to find properties with half an acre or more of land. Home prices are typically between $400,000 and $650,000, though a handful of renovated properties on larger lots can climb over $800,000. Condos, co-ops and townhouses typically start at $200,000 and climb to around $600,000 for a renovated three-bedroom in a gated community.
Come to Middle Island to find affordable ranch style homes.
This Middle Island Colonial was recently renovated.
1/2
Hiking under rare white pines
The Prosser Pines Nature Preserve is home to the only white pine tree forest on Long Island and the oldest concentration of white pines on the East Coast, making it truly unique. The trees, which aren’t native to New York, were brought from Quebec to Brookhaven in the 1800s. These days, locals love hiking under the preserve’s majestic pines. “I bring my kids to Prosser Pines,” Mitrani says. “It’s got these cool things inside the woods that almost look like little huts that the kids crawl into, and it’s an easy 0.7-mile loop. So it’s an awesome place to hang out and take a nice little stroll. It’s kid and pet-friendly.” Next door to the preserve and also shaded by the iconic trees, Cathedral Pines County Park is popular for hiking, mountain biking and camping.
Locals often take their dogs to Middle Island Dog Park, though they need to swipe a “Pooch Pass” from Brookhaven certifying that their dogs are vaccinated and spayed or neutered to get in, or play golf at Spring Lake Golf Club or Middle Island Country Club. Both organizations allow nonmembers to reserve times on certain courses. Just outside Middle Island, Rocky Point State Pine Barrens Preserve offers 3,800 acres where visitors can hike, bike, horseback ride and hunt.
A nice place to take a stroll is Prosser Pines with its tall trees and well maintained trails.
A nice place to take a stroll is Prosser Pines with its tall trees and well maintained trails.
1/2
Career and college readiness at Longwood High School
The Longwood Central School District gets a B-plus from Niche. Children can attend West Middle Island Elementary School, which has a B, before moving to Longwood Middle School, which has a B-plus, for fifth and sixth grades. Kids then move on to Longwood Junior High School, which has an A-minus, for seventh and eighth grades and finish their studies at Longwood High School, which has a B-plus. The high school offers both career and technical education courses, which provide hands-on learning experience on business and technology topics, and a career and college pathways program that partners with local colleges and universities to allow students to take dual credit courses.
Longwood Senior High School is home to the Longwood Lions in Middle Island.
NID 537933 Longwood Sr. High School has a fairly large campus with many well maintained fields.
1/2
Annual carnival rides and fireworks
For over 70 years, Middle Island has held an annual Fireman’s Carnival & Parade in July. The event, which spans an entire weekend, features a parade, carnival rides and games, food and a night with fireworks.
Nearby Long Island Rail Road stations
Middle Country Road, also known as State Route 25, runs right through the neighborhood’s heart and serves as its main thoroughfare. An onramp to Interstate 495 is about 5 miles to the south and reaching beaches on either shore takes 20 minutes. Those who commute to the city can drive to a Long Island Rail Road station in Yaphank, Medford or Ronkonkoma. Some stations run fewer trains during the day, even during rush hour, so it’s wise to study the schedules carefully. From the Ronkonkoma depot, which is 13 miles from Middle Island, the train reaches Midtown in under 90 minutes during peak travel times.
Make commuting to Middle Island easy via the Medford LIRR station.
Middle Island is close to several nearby train stations.
1/2
Bagels and Italian food off Middle Country Road
Middle Island doesn’t have the density of restaurants that some neighborhoods boast, but it still has a solid collection of local dining spots. “There’s a lot of different eateries — you have your little hidden gems,” Mitrani says. Locals often start their days at Bagels 101 or drop by Mac’s Countryside Deli & Catering for a sandwich, and they’ve headed to Lombardi’s for Italian classics since 1977. Walmart and King Kullen provide groceries close to home and the dog-friendly All Island Pet Supplies is the favorite shopping spot for furry members of the family.
Bagels 101 in Middle Island does a good job with this Long Island staple.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Mario Arias,
an experienced agent in this neighborhood.
Parks in this Area
Middle Island Dog Park
Dog Park
Granny Road Park
Baseball/Softball
Basketball
Football
Cathedral Pines County Park
Bike Trails
Camping
Picnic Area
Prosser Pines Nature Preserve
Trails
Nature Center
Bartlett Pond Park
Playground
Gorden Heights Children's Park
Baseball/Softball
Basketball
Playground
Transit
Airport
Long Island MacArthur
28 min drive
Bus
Middle Country Rd & Picasso Way
Bus
King Kullen Shopping Center
Bus
Middle Country Rd & Lakeview Dr
Bus
Middle Country Rd & Yaphank Middle Island Rd
Bus
Middle Country Rd & Wading River Hollow Rd
Bus
Middle Country Rd & Robin Dr
Bus
Middle Country Rd & Swezey Ln
Reviews
Niche Reviews
3.731 Reviews
3.0Niche User
5/3/2015Niche Review
Needs more late night shopping!
4.0Niche User
4/11/2016Niche Review
I do enjoy where I live. I have been living here since I was two years old. We have a very low crime rate and many different schools to get the proper education necessary in the area for all ages.
4.0Current Resident
5/15/2018Niche Review
I have been living in middle island for 19 years so far. I would say that I have not had much trouble at all, it is a very peaceful suburban neighborhood.What I like most are it's vast amount of lakes and large areas of land which are good for playing and relaxing. What I would like to see fixed are the large amounts of pot holes and the broken street lights. This becomes a safety hazard for pedestrians and drivers. Also the lack of street lights makes it very hard to see at night especially for people who walk which makes people very uncomfortable.
3.0Current Resident
1/20/2020Niche Review
Middle Island is a big town with not much going on. The public schools and library are nice but the shopping or other activities are limited.
Are you familiar with the Middle Island neighborhood?
to let others know what life in this neighborhood is like.
Crime and Safety
1 - Low Crime, 10 - High Crime
Middle Island
US
Homicide
3
4
Sexual Assault
3
4
Assault with Weapon
3
4
Robbery
3
4
Burglary
3
4
Motor Vehicle Theft
3
4
Larceny
3
4
Crime Score
3
4
Source: WhatIsMyCrimeRisk.com
Middle Island Demographics and Home Trends
On average, homes in Middle Island, Long Island sell after 46 days on the market compared to the national average of 49 days. The median sale price for homes in Middle Island, Long Island over the last 12 months is $415,000, up 4% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Welcome home to 15 Fairview Cir, located in the beautiful Fairview at Artist Lake Community. This renovated 2 bedroom, 1.5 bath lower level end unit is very private and overlooks the water. It features a spacious living room / dining room, gorgeous kitchen with quartz countertops and stainless steel appliances, a large master bedroom with half bath en-suite, additional ample sized bedrooms and
CONSTRUCTION UNDER WAY!! HOME ALMOST COMPLETED!!! 4 FLAG LOTS AT THE LOCATION!!!!! THIS TO BE BUILT 5 BEDROOM COLONIAL/2 FULL BATHROOMS UPSTAIRS/ ONE FULL BATHROOM ON FIRST FLOOR/ BEDROOM ON 1ST FLOOR/ISLAND IN KITCHEN/CROWN MOLDINGS THROUGH OUT LIVING AREA, HARDWOOD FLOORS THROUGH OUT THE FIRST FLOOR EXCEPT FULL BATHROOM /CAC/200 AMP SERVICE/ 4 HIGH HATS IN KITCHEN/8FT CEILINGS IN AN UNFINISHED
Welcome to 21 West Bartlett Rd. Truly a tucked away paradise. Totally unique tranquil property, offering panoramic views of the onsite natural pond. Relax on the new Trex 60 foot-long deck with two separate sitting areas, surrounded by nature! The split level ranch home features oversized windows facing the pond in a huge cathedral ceiling living area. The enclosed porch is a perfect place to
Magnificent End Unit with Garage, 3 Bedroom 2 Full Bathroom condo, Features Living room, Dining room, Eat in kitchen with SS appliances Granite countertops plenty of cabinets , 1st floor Primary bedroom with Full bathroom, 1st floor laundry, 2 bedrooms upstairs and a 2nd full bath spacious Attic. Large Deck. Brand New Oil Burner.
Enjoy Country Club Living At It's Best! In this beautiful and updated Galaxy Model features 2 bedrooms, 2 full baths, primary bedroom has it's own private bath, bright and airy living room/dinning room combo with cathedral ceilings, EIK with all S/S appliances and granite counter tops with extra cabinet spaces all appliances has a transferable warranty!Beautiful Paved Patio with rollup awning for
Welcome to 310 Fairview Circle. Lower Arden Unit w/1 1/2 bath, also an end unit. This unit faces an open lush green lawn area. Very tranquil. Enjoy it's covered patio for your morning or evening coffee. Master bedroom has 3 closets for plenty of storage. This unit has easy care laminate flooring. Energy efficient kitchen appliances. Conveniently situated a short distance to parking. Residents can
Two-Bedroom Special: Move-In By 6/15/25 Receive Rent Deduction Of -$300 Off* Or Move-In By 6/1/25 Move-In Receive $1200 Off One-Time*and Rent Deduction Special of -$300 Off. Lease For 24-Months At Same Rent as 12-Month Lease!* $99 Security Deposit* *Restrictions apply. Modern and spacious apartments with granite kitchen countertops and bath vanity top, stainless steel
Get BALANCE OF MAY-2025 FREE*! Lease 24-Months At Same Rent as 12-Month Lease!* $99 Security Deposit* *Restrictions apply. Property FeaturesOutstanding Exterior RenovationsProfessionally Landscaped Grounds And PlantingsEntry from Middle Country RoadPaver and Bluestone Walkways ThroughoutLeasing CenterResidence Features~selected apartmentsResidences: One Bedroom, One Bedroom With Den,
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Mario Arias,
an experienced agent in this neighborhood.
Average Home Value
Source: Public Records
Property Mix - Square Feet
This Neighborhood Has More Owners
Demographics
Total Population
10,564
Median Age
47
Population Density
2 ppl/acre
Population under 18
19.6%
On par with the national average
23.8%
Population over 65
24.1%
On par with the national average
19.1%
Finances
Median Household Income
$89,563
Above the national average
$71,702
Average Household Income
$111,559
Education and Workforce
High School Graduates
91.1%
On par with the national average
89.1%
College Graduates
31.7%
On par with the national average
34.1%
Advanced Degrees
14.8%
% Population in Labor Force
65%
Weather
Annual Precipitation
44''
Average Winter Low Temperature
24°F
Average Summer High Temperature
82°F
Annual Snowfall
33''
Area Factors
Somewhat Bikeable
Bike Score®
23/ 100
Car-Dependent
Walk Score®
39/ 100
Source: Walk Score
Source: Walk Score
Sound Score® measures the noise level of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
