$348,125Average Value$251Average Price per Sq Ft3Homes For Sale
A true community vibe outside Downtown Madison
Despite its name, Dunn’s Marsh is actually a landlocked Madison suburb set immediately south of the Highway 14 interchange and west of a nature preserve. Half a dozen big box stores and local eateries lie scattered across Route 18, no more than three-quarters of a mile from the farthest home. Downtown Madison isn’t much farther, a mere five-mile drive away. “It's a cozy neighborhood with a great community center and park,” says Realtor Jake Johnson of Keller Williams Realty. Dunn’s Marsh’s close-knit vibe is more than a cliche; it’s proven. An eclectic makeup of renters and owners participate in community events with a love for their shared green spaces. The city has made efforts in recent years to accommodate prospective buyers at lower price points. Crime is far lower than it was in previous decades, and the area is starting to see new growth all around.
Malborough Park is centrally located
Since Marlborough Park anchors the community geographically and recreationally, kids often venture there after school to climb on the playground or compete in a game of horseshoes. Gardeners will love getting their hands dirty in the community garden on the weekend or finding a taste of nature along the forested trails. Serious hiking enthusiasts head across Seminole Highway to the trails at the University of Wisconsin–Madison’s Arboretum, which spans over 1,200 acres. The hilly terrain that winds through woodlands to marshlands and prairies makes it great for watching wildlife, offering glimpses of turkeys or sandhill cranes. On the other side of Dunn’s Marsh, Allied Park and the adjacent Belmar Hills Park have picnic tables and shelters that make them popular for neighborhood cookouts. To give back, folks can donate to the food pantry or volunteer in the same building as the Boys and Girls Club of Dane County. The neighborhood association frequently hosts events like community meals or seasonal celebrations such as pumpkin carving. Other group activities include a day at the AMC Fitchburg 18 movie theater or the 18-hole Nakoma Golf Club.
Marlborough Park is a great place for a stroll.
Belmar Hills Park is a nice place to go to appreciate nature.
1/2
Biting into a burger at Badger Tavern
Refueling after the park is easy at Badger Tavern Bar and Grill, an old standby serving burgers and cheese curds. The atmosphere is friendly and full of regulars who know the servers and cooks by name. For lunch on the go, stop by Gino’s Italian Deli for a counter-service sandwich and grab a take-and-bake lasagna for dinner later. Other local and chain restaurants can also be found along US Highway 18, with plenty of bars to catch the Badgers game on TV. “There’s also a shopping center along the highway with a Home Depot, a Latin supermarket and some antique stores,” says Johnson. Head three miles south to pick up groceries at Target or Aldi.
Badger Tavern in Dunn's Marsh is a popular spot for lunch or dinner.
Gino's Italian Deli is known for its fine Italian food.
1/2
A mix of rentals, older homes and newer, affordable construction
Most of Dunn’s Marsh’s housing is contained inside five streets, forming a residential pentagon. “There's a unique mix of long-term rentals, newer construction houses, and older single-family homes. There’s something for everyone,” says Johnson. About half of the neighborhood’s housing is apartment complexes clustered at its southwest corner. These buildings vary in unit count and height, with everything from duplexes to established low-rise communities. Winding cul de sacs encircle Malborough Park, the neighborhood’s largest. Mature trees line the sidewalks, accompanied by cars parked comfortably along the wide streets. Ranch-style and split-level homes rest on neat lawns with wooded backyards. Due to its proximity to Downtown Madison, prices for both owners and renters have increased in recent years. To bring in new home buyers, the city undertook a housing project. “It was a housing development built in conjunction with the city of Madison,” says Realtor Tony Antoniewicz of Re/Max Preferred. “It was a way to put people in brand new homes at a very reasonable price if they qualify because of income. You could also pay cash since it wasn’t income-restricted.” Buyers can get a three-bedroom, vinyl-sided ranch-style home for between $250,000 and $420,000. Split-levels are less common and priced a bit higher, ranging from $365,000 to $400,000.
There are a variety of townhouse developments in Dunn's Marsh.
Dunn's Marsh has a quiet suburban feel to it.
1/2
Attending class in Dunn's Marsh schools
Students start out at Stoner Prairie Elementary, an A-minus-rated school according to Niche. Savanna Oaks Middle scores an A-plus, and Verona Area High earns an A from Niche. The high school offers more than 25 athletic programs and 50 student-run clubs and activities, so there are plenty of ways for students to get involved.
Stoner Prairie Elementary School is part of the Verona School District.
Verona Area High School is a highly rated, public school located in Verona, WI.
1/2
Getting around Dunn's Marsh
Three Madison Metro bus stops serve residents in this neighborhood, all on the west side. Although the five-mile stretch takes 35 minutes to reach Madison, rush hour traffic has little to no impact on the duration of the commute. This route runs along Madison Avenue and ends just outside Camp Randall Stadium.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Dunn's Marsh, Madison sell after 22 days on the market compared to the national average of 52 days. The median sale price for homes in Dunn's Marsh, Madison over the last 12 months is $323,825, down 5% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Showings begin Friday 09/12/2025. Meticulously maintained ranch home hitting the market for the 1st time since 1976. Quiet location in a semi cul de sac so no thru traffic. All new appliances in the recently updated kitchen (cabinets and counter tops), Beautifully refinished hardwood floors throughout, all new paint, New roof 2020, AC 2018, Windows 2018, bath remodel 2018. If you are looking for
Charming cape cod in Madison's popular Nakoma Park neighborhood with classic charm & modern updates. This meticulously maintained 3+ bedroom, 1.5 bath home features built in storage, new energy-efficient windows (2024), updated 1/2 bathroom in upper level (2023), Solid hardwood floors, finished lower level/bonus room. Wrap-around deck plus large backyard with deck made for relaxing and
Opportunity to own multiple cash flowing assets. An attractive mix of fully rented 4-bedroom duplexes, along with a traditional 8-unit building. Whether you're just getting started, or looking to add to your portfolio, this is a unique opportunity. For Sale: Five buildings, totaling 16 units, on five parcels. Marketed as package, not to be sold individually. Addresses: 4610, 4538, 4530, 4534
Design for efficiency. This cozy first floor condo may be the best priced condo in the entire county! Conveniently located with easy on, easy off of Verona Rd with the southwestern bicycle path in the back yard and the Boys and Girls Club on the other side of the adjacent park, there is plenty of opportunity without needing to travel across town. This 2-bedroom unit has carpet & tile, SS
Roll into the Derby! These exciting BRAND-NEW luxury affordable homes are on the site of the former Fast Forward Roller Skating Rink.The Derby features 1, 2, and 3-bedroom apartment homes in a 4-story building with underground parking and detached garages for resident convenience. Individual entrances are available for 1st and 2nd floor 3 bedroom homes. High-end amenities include a
1,500 square foot private contractor garage space on shared property available for rent. Room for storage, work, and more, as well as an office built out in the interior makes this a can't-miss opportunity on Madison's near-west side for anyone looking to expand their business into their own space. Property conference room and bathroom in main building is shared with multiple tenants. Lease
Sound Score® measures the noise level of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
