$302,211Average Value$162Average Price per Sq Ft7Homes For Sale
Charming historic town along the Susquehanna
The downtown section of New Cumberland might qualify as an old town with its historic Art Deco theater and more than century-old buildings. But its charm and community spirit are timeless. Established in the 1800s as a commercial stop along the Susquehanna River between York and Harrisburg, New Cumberland evolved into a small yet lively community that acts as a stopping point for folks commuting into the busy state capital. A relaxed lifestyle and charming locally owned shops continue to attract a vibrant tapestry of residents to this highly walkable neighborhood. “Everything is welcoming,” says long-time local Christine Leukus, president of the Olde Towne Association. “Our community is becoming more diverse in all kinds of ways.”
New Cumberland overlooks the Susquehana River from Bridge Street.
West Shore Theaters is home to many feature films and live show events in New Cumberland.
1/2
Neighborly shops and eateries on Bridge Street
Across from the local post office, the neon-lit West Shore Theater screens classic movies and hosts live performances by bands and comedians. As one of the community's main assets, the theater also plays a significant role in new festivals and community events highlighting local artists, independent filmmakers and cultural dance groups. Outward from this central focal point on Bridge Street – the community's main commercial corridor – a collection of shops and restaurants buzz with locals indulging in a sweet treat at Hanna’s Ice Cream Shoppe or neighbors catching up over a cold refreshment at Wild Rabbit Pies & Pints. Over the roadway's namesake bridge, folks can quickly travel across Yellow Breeches Creek to shop for groceries and other essentials at Rite Aid, Grocery Outlet, Dollar Tree and Giant.
Hanna's Ice Cream Shoppe provides a classic 50s themed environment in New Cumberland.
Wild Rabbit is a community staple in drinks and food along Bridge Street in New Cumberland.
1/2
Easy access to Interstate 83 and the airport
Between Interstate 83 and the Capital City Municipal Airport, New Cumberland offers easy access to major thoroughfares and transportation. Residents connect easily to the Pennsylvania Turnpike, and the nearby Harrisburg International Airport is only 11 miles away. Though walkability is emphasized, commuters can also rely on buses that service the handful of stops here.
Commute from New Cumberland to Harrisburg over the John Harris Memorial Bridge and Susquehanna.
The Capital City Airport is located in New Cumberland offering smaller transport for locals.
1/2
Traditional single-family homes from the early 20th century
A variety of established homes line the orderly streets of New Cumberland, as old rowhouses mingle with single-family homes from the early 20th century. Townhouses may start at $174,000, and charming cottages and modest ranch homes list between $150,000 and $200,000. Cape Cods, Colonial-inspired examples and foursquare styles are common, while newer contemporary homes are found on the outskirts of town with prices ranging between $280,000 and $720,000.
Some brick colonial revival homes have some pristine curb appeal in New Cumberland.
New Cumberland has Cape Cod homes located near each other and some boast large dormer windows.
1/2
Strong academics in West Shore School District
The West Shore School District serves kids in New Cumberland, earning a B Niche grade with high rankings for teacher quality, academic achievement and college preparedness. Students may attend B-minus-rated Hillside Elementary before advancing to New Cumberland Middle School, which earns a C-plus. B-graded Cedar Cliff High School offers diverse educational and extracurricular programs like JROTC. Students explore various interests, from working with robots in technology-focused classes to propagating plants in the school's aquaponics lab.
Younger students attend Hillside Elementary School.
Cedar Cliff High School serves grades 9-12 with an overall B rating on Niche.com.
1/2
Recreation at New Cumberland Borough Park
Several green spaces and pocket parks offer a verdant respite, while the Susquehanna riverside provides ample opportunity for recreation. However, New Cumberland Borough Park is a neighborhood destination for outside fun. Located on the other side of the creek, the park covers roughly 30 acres of public space with sports fields, playgrounds, picnic tables, and boat ramps.
Children and families love spending quality time at the New Cumberland Borough Park playground.
Playgrounds and walking trails are located at the New Cumberland Borough Park.
1/2
New Cumberland’s famous Apple Festival
The community draws immense crowds each fall for its annual Apple Festival, a popular event that has captivated the town and its numerous visitors for over 37 years. Taking place at the New Cumberland Borough Park on the last Saturday of September, the beloved festival features over 70 food vendors and 200 craft vendors, with musical acts and numerous guests performing throughout the all-day affair. As a lead festival organizer, Leukus says the joyous festival and the community’s recent efforts to create more community events and embrace an inclusive mindset make the festival special.
Written By
Christina von Claparede-Crola
Photography Contributed By
TJ Engler
Video By
Victoria Sharpe
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Devi Pratheesh,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in New Cumberland, PA sell after 15 days on the market compared to the national average of 54 days. The median sale price for homes in New Cumberland, PA over the last 12 months is $298,950, up 9% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Beautifully renovated home showcasing a complete transformation by the current owner. This move-in ready property features all new flooring throughout, a fully updated modern kitchen, and tastefully renovated bathrooms designed with today’s finishes in mind. The spacious living area is highlighted by a stunning built-in fireplace, creating a warm and inviting focal point perfect for relaxing or
Discover 14.74 acres of woodland with approximately 350 feet of road frontage—perfect for your dream retreat or investment. This unique property includes one building right and is conveniently located just minutes from Harrisburg and the turnpike for convenient travel. The hilltop offers potential for stunning panoramic views from your dream home.
Welcome to 327 4th St in the heart of charming New Cumberland! This spacious 3-story semi-detached home offers 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths with solid bones and timeless character throughout. Enjoy generous living space and plenty of natural light. Step outside to your private backyard. Perfect for entertaining, gardening, or relaxing evenings. plus the added convenience of a detached garage.
This home presents the perfect blend of comfort and convenience, making it an ideal choice for any buyer! Upstairs there are three bedrooms, two full bathrooms, and a living room that opens onto the generous dining area off the kitchen, plus direct access to the deck. Downstairs you’ll find a conveniently located half bathroom, laundry area, and the potential for additional living space that
Charming, move in ready home located in the desirable Manor Section of New Cumberland! Enjoy tree lined streets, integrated sidewalks, and unbeatable access to Harrisburg, Hershey, York, and Mechanicsburg. Spend your weekends exploring the revitalized downtown district, home to shops, locally loved restaurants, and the historic West Shore Theater. This spacious two story residence offers
Jennifer HollisterJoy Daniels Real Estate Group, Ltd
Great Value! 4 bedroom, 1.5 well-appointed bathrooms located in Meadowbrook Mobile Home Park. Offering a cozy, inviting atmosphere with plenty of space for everyone. It's a perfect blend of affordability and convenience in the heart of New Cumberland. $650/mo lot rent includes water, sewer, and trash.
Stunning 4-Bedroom Home with Main-Level Primary Suite & Finished Basement! From the moment you arrive, this beautiful 4-bedroom, 21⁄2-bath home impresses with elegant stonework, stately pillars, and a welcoming front porch perfect for relaxing. Step inside to a dramatic 17-foot foyer that sets the tone for the spacious and thoughtfully designed interior. The kitchen features granite countertops,
Kim SmithBerkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty
Beautifully renovated home showcasing a complete transformation by the current owner. This move-in ready property features all new flooring throughout, a fully updated modern kitchen, and tastefully renovated bathrooms designed with today’s finishes in mind. The spacious living area is highlighted by a stunning built-in fireplace, creating a warm and inviting focal point perfect for relaxing or
Investment Opportunity – Lewisberry Rd, New Cumberland This is a long-term tenant-occupied property offering 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms in a 1900-built home located in a highly accessible West Shore corridor. The current tenants have been in place for over 20 years and are paying $1,000 per month. The property has not been recently updated and will require improvements. This is best suited
Welcome to this stunning new build located in the tranquil neighborhood of Timber Ridge. Surrounded by serene natural views, this home offers a peaceful retreat while still providing modern comforts and style.Step inside to an inviting open-concept layout, where the kitchen, living, and dining areas flow seamlessly—perfect for both everyday living and effortless entertaining. Upstairs, you’ll
Welcome to 503 S 3rd Street in Lemoyne, a home that blends character, space, and unexpected charm in one of the West Shore’s most convenient locations. One of the true highlights of this property is the third-floor bonus level, a flexible space that easily serves as an additional bedroom, creative studio, or private retreat. With its cozy fireplace, exposed wood beams, and architectural details,
Looking for a place thats charming spacious, and in a great location? The townhomes at The Falls at Beacon Hill could be just right for you! Our New-Cumberland homes offer generous floorplans, as well as plenty of amenities both at home and within the community.
Welcome to 1550 Bridge Street #A — a charming main-level 2-bedroom unit filled with natural light and practical living space, featuring newer vinyl plank flooring in the spacious living area, generous storage, off-street parking and a dedicated in-unit laundry room with washer and dryer included. Conveniently located near major highways and just minutes from thriving downtown New Cumberland,
At ReVi Harrisburg, we offer the best of flexibility and apartment-style living. Each of our affordable, pet friendly studio and one-bedroom living spaces feature wood-plank style floors, new cabinetry, and a fully equipped kitchen with full-size appliances. Residents can also enjoy the 25,000 sq ft of common area space throughout the property, which includes accessible Wi-Fi, business center,
Great location! One bedroom apartment in New Cumberland. Recently remodeled and it is very bright & clean. Luxury vinyl plank flooring through out. Updated kitchen with new cabinets, countertops and appliances. Roomy enough for a table plus large windows that provide tons of natural light. Nice sized bedroom with updated bathroom and walk in closet. Off and on street parking. Walking distance to
Cape cod in West Shore School District in a great neighborhood. Convenient location close to highway access and walk to stores. 1566 sq ft of finished living area. Hardwood floors and custom blinds! Eat-in kitchen, dining room, living room, two bedrooms, one bath plus office, laundry and plenty of room for storage. Refrigerator, washer and dryer included. Off street parking and level rear yard.
“I lived in Lower Allen for a long time,” says Beth Masland, Realtor with RE/MAX Realty Associates, “It’s a nice, clean area, the folks there keep the neighborhoods looking enticing.” Between Pennsylvania’s bustling state capital and the quiet, burbling creeks and lush green pastures of Cumberland Valley, Lower Allen is a classic American neighborhood born out of post-war suburban sprawl. A mixture of apartment buildings and commercial and industrial zones give way to old-growth trees towering over comfortable homes on wide, quiet, winding roads. It’s also a neighborhood with convenience, at the junction of major routes that allows residents to be in Harrisburg in minutes or access the wider Central Pennsylvania region.
With a mix of Colonial Revivals, ranch-style and split-level homes, midcentury suburban architecture and road design characterize Lower Allen. Featuring off-street parking in carports and garages, as well as space out front for guests to park, these homes generally sit on plots of a quarter- to a half-acre. Most of these homes sell from $175,000 to $350,000. Larger houses from the same era with four or more bedrooms and offering over 2,000 square feet of living space sell for $375,000 to $525,000. In The Cliffs neighborhood, neo-traditional homes with European influence showcase Frederick Olmsted’s signature garden-like residence park design, with many sitting on manicured and partially wooded lots. These four- and five-bedroom homes spread over 6,000 square feet or more and include fireplaces, formal dining rooms, open floorplans, and professional-grade kitchens, regularly selling for $825,000 and up. Homes sell quickly on average, in under two weeks compared to the 44-day national average.
West Shore School District serves Lower Allen, and Masland notes, “There are two high schools within the district, which allows them to compete against each other for sports, and they offer plenty of extra-curricular activities.” Students in Lower Allen start at Highland Elementary School, a school graded as a B by Niche. West Shore has three middle schools, and students from Lower Allen are split between Allen and New Cumberland – the former graded as a B, the latter a C-plus. Lower Allen students come back together at Cedar Cliff for high school, also graded as a B by Niche. The school is located within the neighborhood and is walkable for many students. As Masland mentions, the dual high schools offer unique opportunities, and Red Land versus Cedar Cliff has become one of Central Pennsylvania's most energetic sporting rivalries. Nearby private schools include West Shore Christian Academy, Al-Huda School of Pennsylvania, and Saint Theresa Elementary School and Trinity High School.
With portions of the neighborhood blending into rural areas, living in Lower Allen means being comfortable with being car dependent. Bicycling is generally just a recreational activity, and Capital Area Transit busses have infrequent stops. However, the neighborhood’s location along U.S. Routes 581 and 83, as well as the Pennsylvania Turnpike, make it easy to get around the region by car. Usually under a 20-minute drive, Harrisburg International Airport is 13 miles away, and offers commercial flights throughout the country. While Capital City Airport is closer, service there is limited to charter, corporate and private craft. Penn State Health Holy Spirit Medical Center, 2 miles to the north, provides emergency care for the region.
Capital City Mall brings all sorts of retailers together in Lower Allen. It regularly brings in new retailers as some cycle out, keeping it relevant while many regional malls are dying off. Local dining includes new international favorites alongside long-time favorites. “Brewhouse Grille is a good, low-key spot, a local favorite,” says Masland. Offering locally brewed craft beers and creative, elevated pub food, the outdoor deck can be busy in the warm weather. Just up the road, Flinchy’s offers signature Hot Rock dinners, serving up steak, seafood, and more on a volcanic stone. For groceries, residents head to Weis Markets or to the Trader Joe’s just down the road – it’s the only location of this cult favorite grocery store in Central Pennsylvania.
Along the bends and curves of the Yellow Breeches Creek at the bottom end of the neighborhood, anglers fishing for trout and folks leisurely tubing along the creek are a common sight on warm summer days. The launch from Yellow Breeches Park makes the area convenient for kayakers to enjoy as well. The Hempt baseball fields are home to local Little Leaguers, a well-kept field that includes batting cages for practice. For those looking to hit the links, nearby Liberty Forge Golf Course offers 18 holes with various tee boxes to accommodate different skill levels.
“Some neighborhoods hold block parties,” says Masland, “but everyone goes down to Lisburn Fire Company for their Olde Time festival; they bring in rides and food, live music, it’s a big community event.” A short drive out of town for residents, this four-day festival has been going for seven decades and shows no sign of stopping. Throughout the season, residents might take the short drive towards the city to watch the hometown Harrisburg Senators, a Washington nationals farm team, play ball on City Island.
Property Mix - Square Feet
New Cumberland Has More Owners
Demographics
Total Population
7,931
Median Age
41
Population Density
2 ppl/acre
Population under 18
23.3%
On par with the national average
23.8%
Population over 65
19.3%
On par with the national average
19.1%
Finances
Median Household Income
$73,488
Below the national average
$79,601
Average Household Income
$90,408
Education and Workforce
High School Graduates
96.9%
Above the national average
89%
College Graduates
35%
Advanced Degrees
9.3%
On par with the national average
13.3%
% Population in Labor Force
67.1%
Weather
Annual Precipitation
41''
Average Winter Low Temperature
25°F
Average Summer High Temperature
87°F
Annual Snowfall
14''
Area Factors
Bikeable
Bike Score®®
52/ 100
Car-Dependent
Walk Score®®
49/ 100
Source: Walk Score
Source: Walk Score
Walk Score® measures the walkability of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
