As the home of the U.S. Open, Old Bethpage is a golfer’s dream. The hamlet is home to Bethpage State Park, which contains five golf courses, including the Bethpage Black Course, known throughout the world for its difficulty. Multiple U.S. Open Championships have been held there, as well as a PGA Championship, the Barclays and soon the 2025 Ryder Cup. Living here gives residents the chance to play on famous courses and be right in the middle of the action when major competitions come to town. These competitions are weekslong events for the hamlet’s residents. Aside from this, Old Bethpage is a quiet town with a thriving park system. “It’s very suburban — heavy trees, seclusion,” says Alan Jurmain, a licensed real estate salesperson at Daniel Gale and Sotheby’s International Realty. “It’s more of a quaint village and much smaller. But it has all the access and conveniences of getting to the city, getting on the highways.” Fittingly for such a small, quiet town, the CAP Index crime score is 1 out of 10, which is lower than the national average of 4.
Manicured lawns & open backyards are a draw for families looking to plant roots in Old Bethpage.
Play a round at Bethpage State Park.
1/2
Fixer-uppers from $600,000
The homes in Old Bethpage have more land than their counterparts in Queens or Brooklyn, with Jurmain saying that lots average around 6,000 square feet. He also notes that finished basements are common. “It just expands the footprint of the house,” Jurmain says. “A lot of families might have their mom or another relative living downstairs, and it just makes that doable.” Small Cape Cods or split-levels in need of restoration start around $600,000, while a five-bedroom new construction can climb to about $1.8 million. “A lot of people are buying the older homes for $500,000 or $600,000 and knocking them down, then building what people affectionately call McMansions,” Jurmain says. “That creates even more demand for first-time homebuyers because all of the large homes are not in their price range and a lot of the properties that they might buy for $500,000 or $600,000 are being bought by builders and investors, knocked down and turned into big houses.” Even homes selling in the upper $800,000 range might need a little work here and there, says Philip Donnellan, an associate broker at Deans R E & Moving Homes who has sold here for 18 years. Completely renovated homes cost in the range of $1 million.
Larger colonial homes can be found on larger plots of land throughout Old Bethpage.
Some smaller Cape Cod style homes can be found in Old Bethpage.
1/2
A-plus for Old Bethpage Elementary
According to Donnellan, the Plainview-Old Bethpage Central School District, which Niche gives an A-plus and places among the top 25 school districts in New York, is a huge draw to the neighborhood. Children can attend Old Bethpage Elementary School, which has an A-plus, Howard B. Mattlin Middle School, which has an A, and Plainview-Old Bethpage John F. Kennedy High School. At the high school, which is a National Blue Ribbon School with an A-plus from Niche, students can participate in robotics, writing and a-cappella clubs.
H.B. Mattlin Middle School has 772 students with a student-teacher ratio of 11 to 1.
John F. Kennedy Middle School in Bethpage has 695 students in grades 6-8 with a ratio of 10:1.
1/2
Bethpage State Park, Old Bethpage Village Restoration
Aside from its golf courses, Bethpage State Park’s 1,477 acres provide playgrounds, picnic areas and basketball and volleyball courts as well as hiking, biking and equestrian trails. There’s even a field for polo. The Bethpage Bike Trail, which stretches over 13 miles and runs through the park, is particularly well-known. Residents also enjoy visiting the Old Bethpage Village Restoration, which is a 209-acre living history museum that consists of a restored 19th-century village with 18 historic buildings, including an old general store, inn, doctor’s office, church, blacksmith shop and a farmhouse where sheep are still kept and sheared just like they were in the 1800s. “They have people dressed up in the period clothes and all that; it’s pretty cool,” Donnellan says. “It’s very popular.” Haypath Road Park is a popular daily-use space, offering a playground alongside a basketball court, tennis courts and a couple of baseball fields where local teams sometimes play.
Live through history on over 200 acres at the Old Bethpage Village Restoration in Old Bethpage.
Watch as a local blacksmith demonstrates the process of crafting tools at the Long Island Fair.
1/2
Shopping and dining in Old Bethpage
Old Bethpage has two very small retail centers where residents can grab essentials or stop for a meal. Pete the Greek is known for its chicken or lamb souvlaki platter and lemon potatoes, while Dake Korea offers staples like bibimbap and Villa Monte is a go-to for pizza. Han’s Natural Farm offers fresh produce and ShopRite provides groceries close to home in a shopping center with a few more dining options. “It’s a true bedroom community. There’s really not a lot of nightlife or anything,” Donnellan says. “People go over to Plainview for their restaurants, they go to downtown Farmingdale, and they go to Bethpage proper because that has a vibrant downtown and vibrant nightlife.”
Villa Monte in Old Bethpage serves up mom and pop style Italian cuisine.
Han's Natural Farm in Old Bethpage offers residents farm to table groceries.
1/2
Major highways, LIRR’s Bethpage Station
Old Bethpage has easy access to the Seaford-Oyster Bay Expressway, Bethpage State Parkway and Long Island Expressway, making it easy to travel nearly anywhere on Long Island. From the Long Island Rail Road’s Bethpage Station, which is just under 4 miles away, the train reaches Pennsylvania Station in about 45 minutes.
Spring Fest, golf events
Every year, the communities of Old Bethpage and Plainview come together for Spring Fest, which features carnival rides, craft vendors and face painting. Big golfing events at the Bethpage Black Course bring plenty of activity. Some residents enjoy sticking around for it, but Donnellan says that others take a couple of weeks off work and go have fun elsewhere while renting their homes out for a little extra money.
Be a willing participant at the carnival at the Long Island Fair.
Walk through the tunnel of light at the The Great Jack O'Lantern Blaze.
1/2
Written By
Hannah Rainey
Photography Contributed By
Johnny Milano
Video By
Kyle Garrity
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Sheryl Hecht,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Old Bethpage, NY sell after 51 days on the market compared to the national average of 49 days. The median sale price for homes in Old Bethpage, NY over the last 12 months is $1,162,500, up 37% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
A model home which is magazine worthy located in prestigious Country Pointe, Plainview. Designed to enhance daily life, this stunning Cambridge model offers the finest in upgrades curated with today's lifestyle in mind. This 2-bedroom, 2 bath home features panoramic views through its oversized windows and abundance of natural light. Features include a designer living room with custom white oak
Welcome to 4 Haven Lane! This spectacular new construction 5 bedroom, 6 bathroom Old Bethpage Colonial sits mid block and is zoned for the Plainview-Old Bethpage school district. Enter the home in a double story foyer that leads to an open kitchen and family area. The home features a new custom kitchen with new gas appliances, a walk in pantry, custom mudroom off the garage, new security camera
Welcome to this beautifully renovated 4-bed, 1.5-bath colonial on a spacious 10,001 sq ft corner lot in Farmingdale. Featuring new siding, roof, windows, kitchen, and gas boiler/water system. Refinished floors, updated electric, and a 6-zone sprinkler system. Vaulted ceilings and finished basement. Move-in ready with modern upgrades and room to entertain indoors and out!
Welcome to 14 Battle Row in Old Bethpage – a true gem nestled in a private enclave! This home is the epitome of timeless elegance, starting with its stately brick exterior that invites you in through a gracious two-door entry. Step into the marble-floored foyer, where you can immediately sense the warmth and sophistication this home offers.Inside, you'll find a formal dining room and living room,
Located in Farmingdale Village. Near the LIRR, at the heart of Farmingdale Village. Close to Farmingdale State University, routes 110 and 135 and Melville.
Split-Level Home for Rent in Old BethpageLocated within the highly acclaimed Plainview School District, this freshly painted split-level home offers 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. Enjoy a private backyard—perfect for relaxing or entertaining. This well-maintained home combines comfort, convenience, and top-tier education in a desirable neighborhood.A must-see schedule your tour today!
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
