$229,792Average Value$109Average Price per Sq Ft23Homes For Sale
Family-owned farms in this small Indiana city
Plymouth is a small city of 10,000 people in Marshall County, Indiana. It’s best known for hosting the annual Marshall County Blueberry Festival, which attracts an estimated 500,000 attendees each Labor Day weekend for sporting events, live entertainment and lots of blueberry-flavored treats. The rest of the year, Plymouth is a simple farming community, attracting residents with its rural feel and small-town sense of community. “I live on 5-acres, and I love the country feel of everything,” says resident and Realtor Morgan Katzenberger. “You can drive anywhere in Plymouth and find a roadside egg stand or veggie stand. It’s an up-and-coming community, but we still know and appreciate our roots, support each other and support small businesses. There’s a lot of internal community support being from a smaller town.” In addition to the city's agricultural roots, today Plymouth is also known as a major manufacturer and distribution hub, thanks in part to its location near major interstates, railways and airlines. Seven major companies, including American Containers Inc. and Zentis North America, LLC, a food transport company, have their headquarters based in Plymouth, and the city is also less than 125 miles, or about a 2 hours' drive, from Indianapolis.
The Italianate and Renaissance Revival Marshall County Courthouse overlooks Plymouth.
Plymouth is a rural community with many modern day amenities such as Woodbury Golf Course.
1/2
The best of both worlds for buyers in Plymouth
“In town, there’s a lot of housing options,” Katzenberger says. “There’s lots of new development happening, whether that’s subdivisions or apartment rentals. When it comes to country living and acreage, there’s a lot of farmland around here and rural areas, people living on 20-plus acres. It’s the best of both worlds.” Plymouth features ranch-style, farmhouse and New Traditional homes with a median price of $225,000, which is about $180,000 below the national median. “The values for homes are really good, but there are still a lot of options for first-time homebuyers too,” Katzenberger says.
Contemporary frame ranches and new traditionals dot the streets of Plymouth.
Farmland surrounds new traditional and apartment subdivisions in Plymouth.
1/2
Auto Park Sports Complex, LifePlex and the Susan Bardwell Aquatic Complex
Plymouth has nine community parks, one public rec center and one public pool. Auto Park Sports Complex is a 30,000-square-foot indoor sports center with basketball, volleyball and pickleball courts. LifePlex is a gym with an indoor pool, basketball court and fitness lessons. The Susan Bardwell Aquatic Center has an indoor pool with open swim times and lessons.
Auto Park Sports Complex is an indoor sports center that also hosts events in Plymouth.
Visit the modern Susan Bardwell Aquatic Center in Plymouth year round.
1/2
Plymouth Community School Corporation and Marian University’s Ancilla College
The Plymouth Community School Corporation earns a B-plus rating from Niche and serves nearly 3,200 students. The district operates four public elementary schools, two middle schools and one high school. Plymouth also has two private school options: St. Michael Catholic School for preschoolers through eighth graders and Grace Baptist Christian School for preschool through high school aged students. Marian University’s Ancilla College is also located in Plymouth and offers eight unique degree programs, including in the areas of agriculture, nursing and education.
St. Michael's Catholic School is a private school in Plymouth serving K-12 students.
Plymouth High School is a public school with football, soccer and track teams in Plymouth.
1/2
Dining in downtown Plymouth
“Downtown Plymouth has a lot of classic character and charm with mostly original buildings,” Katzenberger says. “There are a lot of smaller family-owned businesses, like boutiques, floral stores, jewelry stores. It’s a good mix. There are a couple of staple restaurants that have been here for a while.” She recommends The Brass Rail, a cozy bar and grill serving steak and seafood options, and Mila’s Mini Market, a family-owned Mexican restaurant. “It’s really small, but man, their food is good,” she says. Opie’s Deli & Office offers a flexible space for patrons to enjoy a meal or get some work done. “We’ve even had real estate meetings in there,” Katzenberger says.
The charm of Christo's Family Dining in Plymouth is seen in both the food and building style.
Opie's Deli & Office in downtown Plymouth has a classic small-town feel.
1/2
Weather and the Plymouth Police Department
Plymouth typically experiences high temperatures in the 80s in the summer and lows in the teens throughout the winter. Plymouth does experience issues with flooding, especially those communities that fall along the Yellow River.
FBI data shows that the Plymouth Police Department has seen a steady decrease in property crime since 2017, while its violent crime rate has remained about the same.
U.S. Route 30, Marshall County Public Transit and the Fort Wayne International Airport
Plymouth is located 68 miles northwest of Fort Wayne and 95 miles southeast of Chicago. U.S. Route 30 runs east to west through Plymouth and U.S. Route 31 runs north to south, just east of the city limits. The county does not offer widespread public transportation options, but the Marshall County Council on Aging does provide on-demand door to door bus service for destinations within two hours of the city including South Bend, Fort Wayne and Indianapolis. When traveling out of town, residents typically fly out of the Fort Wayne International Airport, 73 miles southeast.
Marshall County Blueberry Festival
Each Labor Day weekend, Plymouth hosts the Marshall County Blueberry Festival, a free four-day celebration of Marshall County’s agricultural history — in the late '60s Marshall County was responsible for one third of the state's blueberry production. Today, the festival combines sports competitions for kids and adults with an antique car show, a 5K and 15K, a parade and live performances. “It’s bigger and better every year,” Katzenberger says. She notes that visitors can try a variety of blueberry-flavored treats like pie, ice cream and cheesecake and that the festival raises funds for scholarships and local organizations. The star of the show is Blueberry Hank, a mascot designed by a Marshall County art teacher in the 1970s. “Kids love Hank,” Katzenberger says. “They do different scavenger hunts throughout the year where they hide him in different businesses, and kids try to find him.”
Written By
Ellen Daly
Photography Contributed By
Eric Lynch
Video By
Luke Basinger
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Rhonda Hurford,
an experienced agent in this area.
Agents Specializing in Plymouth, IN
Sara Williams
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Northern Indiana Real Estate
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Plymouth, IN sell after 47 days on the market compared to the national average of 55 days. The median sale price for homes in Plymouth, IN over the last 12 months is $225,000, up 13% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Move in with confidence. Instead of budgeting for a roof, furnace, air conditioner, flooring, paint, lighting, or bathroom updates, you'll enjoy a home where those major improvements have already been completed! This exceptionally well-maintained Tall Oaks condo lets you spend your time enjoying the four-season room, finished basement, and open living spaces—not planning your next renovation.
Wow, this property offers 5 bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms; approx. 3660 square feet of finished living space; the great room has a wood burning fireplace for those cool winter days; there is a 4 season's room that overlooks a wooded area with abundant wildlife; attached 2 car garage; 200 AMP electric service; gas furnace and central air conditioning; if you want privacy, yet close to Plymouth,
This lot is zoned commercial and is located on busy West Jefferson Street, Plymouth, IN. the lot is 99' X 300' and has frontage on both West Jefferson Street and West Madison Street; there is presently a house on the property which gives you the option of using it as a business office or you can remove the house and build your own building. This is a rare opportunity to purchase a commercially
4 Acres of property with this listing on Pine (Pioneer) Road. This custom built house offers 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, 2352 square feet on the main level and you could finish the basement if you wish additional square footage. The house sets back a lane and has a country atmosphere, yet it is within minutes of shopping, schools and parks. If you are looking for a country property at the
Vacant wooded corner lot featuring city utilities and beautiful mature trees. Nestled in a quiet neighborhood, this property offers the perfect setting to build your dream home while enjoying natural surroundings.
This beautiful home on Dee Drive has a new metal roof and is located on a wonderful, wooded lot; this is a great home that has cathedral ceilings and a gorgeous entry foyer; there is a loft area that has a walkway that overlooks the living room and the dining room; the kitchen was totally updated in 2024 featuring Hickory cabinetry and brand new appliances; there are 2 wood burning fireplaces;
Small town living in Tyner, John Glenn School system, 3 bedrooms and 1 full bathroom, large family room with a fireplace, plus a nice living room, vinyl exterior, Gas Furnace & Central Air Conditioning, NIPSCO gas & electric service, detached 2 car garage, Price reduced to $176,000.
This 2 story house has 4 or 5 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms; there is a 3 season's room that overlooks the back yard that is totally fenced for privacy; 2 city lots give you plenty of room for gardening or just relaxing; the living/great room has a gas log fireplace; the roof is new and the attic has been recently insulated, which makes the house more efficient to heat and cool; there is an
This ranch is situated on 14 acres and borders a DNR property; the house has only had one owner and features 3 bedrooms and one bathroom; the basement is partially finished which allows additional living space; the roof is only 7 years old, and the furnace and central air are only 8 years old; the attached garage is 26 X 24, there is a pole barn for additional vehicle storage, hobbies or
If you are looking for a country property with privacy, this is it! You can watch the wildlife roam the fields from almost any direction. The house offers 2200 Sq. Ft. on the main level with 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms; you could convert the 2nd kitchen/dining area into a 3rd bedroom suite if you wish. The basement has 2 finished rooms for additional living space to do your crafts or projects.
Welcome to 12357 Diamond Dr., Plymouth, IN, offered at $369,900! This well-maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath home sits on a spacious .51-acre lot and offers 1,679 sq. ft. of main-level living space plus a full basement with approximately 410 sq. ft. finished. Built in 1996, the home features an attractive brick and vinyl exterior, an open floor plan, cathedral ceilings, ceiling fans, and comfortable
Welcome to this spacious and beautifully designed home, perfectly situated on a quiet cul-de-sac with a generous yard for relaxing or entertaining. The first floor offers both functionality and comfort, featuring a two car garage, convenient laundry room, and a well appointed kitchen with a dining area. For more formal gatherings, enjoy a dedicated dining room, while the inviting family room with
6.68 Acres of property next to the US 30 Bypass and the Plymouth Airport; this property is zoned BP, Business Park, and lends itself to many potential uses. The buildings will be removed, and the property will be sold as a vacant parcel; NIPSCO gas and NIPSCO electric; City Water and City Sewer. If you have been wanting to develop a highly visible property you will want to look at this parcel of
Centennial Crossing, in Plymouth, IN is a brand-new premier housing community conveniently located near Centennial Park with beautiful views offering great amenities to benefit the city of Plymouth, IN.
This two bedroom/one bathroom apartment is tucked away off Jackson Heights in a quiet area—perfect for getting away from the noise of South Michigan Street.Inside, you’ll find a dedicated dining room and a laundry area with washer and dryer hookups. Step outside in the summer and enjoy your own back patio, ideal for relaxing or entertaining.All of this is just minutes from everything
Spacious One-Bedroom Living in the Heart of PlymouthDiscover a well-sized 1-bedroom, 1-bath apartment offering approximately 1,025 square feet of comfortable living space at 225 W Jefferson St in Plymouth, IN. With a practical layout, central air conditioning, and an unfurnished interior ready for your personal style, this apartment provides a clean foundation for everyday living. Built in 1972,
2-bedroom, 2-bathroom apartment with 3 additional rooms! With central heating and AC, spacious kitchen, living room spaces and bedrooms. It features a formal dining room, laundry room equipped with washer and dryer, and a great room perfect for entertaining guests! Our requirements are simple: a 590+ Credit Score, 2.5X the monthly income, and no evictions or felonies within the past 7 rent with
Spacious One-Bedroom Living in the Heart of PlymouthDiscover a well-sized 1-bedroom, 1-bath apartment offering approximately 1,025 square feet of comfortable living space at 225 W Jefferson St in Plymouth, IN. With a practical layout, central air conditioning, and an unfurnished interior ready for your personal style, this apartment provides a clean foundation for everyday living. Built in 1972,
2-bedroom, 2-bathroom apartment with 3 additional rooms! With central heating and AC, spacious kitchen, living room spaces and bedrooms. It features a formal dining room, laundry room equipped with washer and dryer, and a great room perfect for entertaining guests! Our requirements are simple: a 590+ Credit Score, 2.5X the monthly income, and no evictions or felonies within the past 7 rent with
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
