$793,176Average Value$519Average Price per Sq Ft21Homes For Sale
Friendly community on the Great South Bay
We all make the occasional spelling error, but for one clerk in the 1800s, a mistake turned the name of the hamlet in which he lived from the proposed “Seaville” to the name it still bears today: Sayville. Situated on the Great South Bay directly across from Fire Island with a regular ferry service to the popular vacation spot, living in Sayville is a bit like being on vacation year-round. “Sayville has a strong sense of community and is highly sought after by homebuyers and visitors alike for its beaches, parks, boutique shops and many options for dining,” says Joanne Sturchio, an associate broker at Douglas Elliman Real Estate and a longtime Sayville resident. “Our residents care about our town, and we care about each other. Many take great pride in their volunteerism in our schools or with one of our many groups that keep our town beautiful and thriving.” It’s this environment that makes so many people settle down for the long haul. “Families tend to stay,” Sturchio says. “They sell and buy, upsize and downsize, and often the next generation buys locally as well. I’ve been selling homes in Sayville for over 24 years. My husband and I purchased our first home in Sayville nearly 38 years ago, raised our two children here and, in years to come, would be happy to retire here.”
Sayville Residents can take a day trip to Fire Island from one of the many ferry launch points.
Sayville is a beautiful hamlet situated on the Great South Bay.
1/2
Sayville Marina Park, nearby Fire Island
Sayville Marina Park’s small beach is a popular place to relax on the sand or swim in the water close to home. Boaters can dock their boats at the marina there — one of four in the community. On dry land, the park offers tennis and pickleball courts, a picnic area and a huge playground. Sans Souci County Park’s 316 acres are laced with nature trails, making it a go-to hiking spot, and Islip Grange Park offers a collection of historic buildings alongside athletic fields where local teams play baseball and lacrosse. Cherry Avenue Dog Park is also popular for its friendly regulars, though it gets quite muddy when it has rained recently. Dogs love that, but they might need a bath when they get home!
Fire Island, and more specifically Barrett Beach Park, are popular destinations, accessible only by boat or the Sayville Ferry — a trip that takes about 30 minutes. “There’s no cars over there, so it’s super unique,” says Joan Brandmeier, a licensed real estate salesperson at Keller Williams who has 10 years of experience selling in the area. “They’ve got their own picnic tables, and it’s this really nice, quiet, not very occupied bay beach and ocean beach.”
Soak up some sun and relax by the water at Sayville Marina Park.
Spend the day playing with your dogs at Cherry Avenue Dog Park in Sayville.
1/2
Fixer-uppers from $500,000
According to Brandmeier, many of Sayville’s homes are older and feature shaded front porches. Some Victorians date back to the late 1800s, though there are also plenty of homes built in the past decade. Most homes are colonials, but Cape Cods, ranch-style, and hi-ranch homes also make appearances. Home prices typically fall between $600,000 and $800,000. Landlocked fixer-uppers can dip into the $500,000 range, and updated waterfront homes can easily break $1 million and climb to around $1.5 million.
Cape Cods and Dutch Colonials line the streets of Sayville.
Victorian homes are a unique and breathtaking style of home throughout southern Sayville.
1/2
Weekly outdoor concerts, Apple Festival
During the summer, residents flock to Rotary Park on Wednesday evenings for concerts at its pavilion, but Islip Grange Park features as the backdrop for most of the community’s many events. The Spring Festival is held there, as is the popular Apple Festival in late October. “It’s a huge craft fair with music all day,” Brandmeier says. It also features apple-based deserts, amusement park rides, a petting zoo, pony rides and a scarecrow contest. In September, a Pet Costume Parade bestows the best-dressed dog with a trophy.
Enjoy a game of pickleball at Islip Grange Park in Sayville.
The Common Ground is a lovely park located very close to Sayville's downtown.
1/2
Shopping and dining on Montauk Highway
“Our town is thriving with several wonderful restaurants to choose from, a beautiful variety of boutique shops, farm stands, museums, a golf course and our very own Loughlin Vineyard,” Sturchio says. “My husband and I have lived in Sayville for over 38 years and rarely leave town to enjoy a nice afternoon or evening out with friends.” Loughlin Vineyard is a longstanding family-owned staple with a peaceful atmosphere. “You’d go there on a nice afternoon for a glass of wine, and you could bring a picnic basket with you,” Sturchio says. In Sayville’s walkable downtown, Five Points Café offers burgers and the occasional live music performance, the latter of which is common in town, and Aegean Café is known for its gyros. Friends often meet for drinks at The Portly Villager, which has been operating since 1783 — longer than Sayville has had its name. A little further out, The Cull House and The Shed Restaurant are also popular spots. “The Shed is an absolutely amazing place with specialty cocktails,” Brandmeier says. “The thing I like is called the Figgin’ Fresh. I can’t even describe to you what it tastes like, you probably couldn’t get it anywhere else.” It’s easy to spend hours exploring local boutiques and shops in the little downtown, and Sayville Theater has the latest movies. Stop & Shop, Target and Lidl provide essentials close to home.
Grab your popcorn and enjoy a film at The Sayville Theater.
Enjoy a tasty sandwich and an ice cold beverage at The Portly Villager in Sayville.
1/2
Music education at Sayville High
Most children attend the Sayville Union Free School District, which gets an A from Niche. They can attend Cherry Avenue Elementary School, which has a B-plus, Sayville Middle School, which has an A-minus, and Sayville High School. The high school is a National Blue Ribbon School with an A from Niche. The National Association of Music Merchants has named it a Best Community for Music Education for 14 years in a row. A small portion of children in Sayville instead attend the Connetquot Central School District, which Niche also gives an A.
Sayville High School has 880 students in grades 9-12.
Sayville Middle School has 619 students in grades 6-8.
1/2
LIRR to New York City, highways to Montauk
“We are equidistant from Manhattan and Montauk. We’re right in the middle,” Sturchio says, noting that both are about 60 miles away. “You’ve got June, July, August, September and part of October to really enjoy the beaches, Fire Island, Montauk, the Hamptons and the North Fork. I would never leave Long Island in the summer. You don’t leave Long Island and go on vacation in Aruba in the summer months. You stay here and enjoy everything that it has to offer.” From Sayville Station, the train reaches Manhattan in just under an hour and a half. With Montauk and Sunrise Highway running through the hamlet, traveling by car is also a breeze.
Written By
Dwight Loew
Photography Contributed By
Jake Gold
Video By
Mark Tilley
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Suzanne Lebohner,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Sayville, NY sell after 35 days on the market compared to the national average of 53 days. The median sale price for homes in Sayville, NY over the last 12 months is $725,000, up 2% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Very spacious and beautifully maintained Ranch home with 4 Bedrooms, 1.5 Baths, Basement and Garage. New cesspool and waste line from 2021! Mint home with fully-fenced yard! Move Right In!
Amazing Opportunity to have The Seller who is an Amazing Builder to Build this Brand -New Exquisite Modern Farmhouse on this Beautiful Lakefront 1.20 Acre Property in the Heart of Sayville for you. All Approvals in place right now for this Stunning 3,800 sgft House to be Built! Building Plans are for a Two Story Home with Eat in Kitchen, Living Room, Dining Room, Den, Study Room, 4 to 5 Bedrooms
Don't Miss this Awesome Opportunity to Purchase this Amazing Lakefront Vacant Property Over 1 Acre for Sale in the Heart of Sayville with All Approvals in place right now for you to Immediately build your 3,800 SqFt Luxury Contemporary Dream Home! Building Plans are for a Two Story Home with Eat in Kitchen, Living Room, Dining Room, Den, Study Room, 4 to 5 Bedrooms with 4.5 Baths a Full Basement
Land for sale on a desired SOM desirable block. Preliminary drawings done. Needs a road frontage variance. All septic credits in place. Elevated property, well above water table. Residential zoning. Close to town and shops. AS is
Welcome to this beautifully maintained end-unit condo located in a desirable 55+ gated community. Enjoy the convenience of an elevator with access from the basement to the second floor. This spacious home features a formal dining room, a warm and inviting family room with a gas fireplace, and eat-in kitchen with granite countertops and sliding doors leading to a private patio-perfect for relaxing
Beautiful 4 bed 1 1/2 bath on a quiet Sayville street. Featuring new updated 200 amp electrical service; newer (2023) HW heater and washing machine; windows replaced seven years prior; hardwood floors on both levels; gas cooking and heating; new dishwasher; 5 ceiling fans 3 of which are new; crown moldings; partially finished basement. Pool is a gift. Great house in a great location.
Nestled gracefully along the shimmering bayfront of Fire Island Pines, 231 Bay Walk is a rare offering—an architecturally significant estate on a large lot, designed by acclaimed architect Gary W. Stluka with a reverence for both serenity and sophistication. A Pines resident himself, Stluka designed many of the community’s most distinctive properties—but this one stands as one of his best. With
Charming Beach House on the West End of the Grove on a quiet, lovely walk! 4 bedrooms, open living dinning with wood burning stove. Bright, sunny, private deck...located just 4 houses off the beach!!
Beautiful South Sayville Tudor in very sought after area.4 Bedroom 3 1/2 Bath.Full Size Kitchen with nice barn door pantry,Formal Dining Room with built In China Cabinets,Formal Living Room with Fireplace,and Sunroom.New beautiful wood floors on first floor.Detached 2 car garage with oversize driveway.Full unfinished basement with laundry area.New air conditioning systems,radiant heat,updated gas
Perched high on the secondary dune on a corner lot we are pleased to offer Pines Bluff Overlook Guest House for sale. Comprised of 6 private guest suites all with ensuite baths. The many amenities include ,Apple TV, Central Air Conditioning, Fireplace, Heat, Hot Tub, Ocean Views, Outdoor Shower, Pool, Roof Deck, Wet Bar & Wifi.
Oceanfront Escape in Cherry Grove Wake up to the sound of the waves and sweeping Atlantic views in this rare oceanfront home in Cherry Grove, Fire Island. Just a short walk from the ferry and village restaurants, this three-bedroom, three-bath coastal retreat offers the best of beach living. Spanning 1,784 square feet, the first floor welcomes you with an open-concept kitchen and dining area that
Fairfield Courtyard At Bohemia. Lovely park like setting, spacious one and two bedroom garden apartments. View our signature style in our newly renovated residences with quartz countertop/backsplash, white wood shaker style cabinetry with LED under-mount lighting, tile plank flooring, stainless appliances, crown/base molding, gray premium carpeting, gray wall paint, high-hat lighting,
Ask About our Amazing rent Specials. Beautiful Courtyard, Kitchen Cabinetry With Dishwasher & Microwave. Heat, Hot Water & Cooking Gas Included. A/C. Some With New Terraces. Detached Garages Available. Minutes To The L.I.E. Exit 72 And Local Transportation. Prices/policies subject to change without notice.,
UPPER UNITS Receive $1200 Off One-Time With Move-In By 2/15/26* And 15- Or 24- Month Lease With No Increase* $99 Security* *Restrictions Apply. Fairfield Knolls At Sayville ~ a Knolls Boutique Brand 55 And Over Luxury Rental CommunityOur luxury comfortable residences homes feature gourmet kitchen with granite counters and kitchen floor, stainless appliances, Tuscany cabinetry two-tone gray
Fairfield Plaza South At Sayville is newly renovated by Fairfield Properties. Ledgestone exterior, high-end interiors with luxury amenities. Bosch washer and dryer, quartz counters and backsplash, shaker-style wood cabinetry, luxe vinyl plank flooring, ceiling fans, woodgrain two-inch slat window treatments, air-conditioner, gray wall paint with white crown molding and high-hat lighting. At the
*Ask About Our Rent Specials*. Restrictions Apply* Granite Kitchen Floor/Countertop! Gold Series Stainless Steel Appliances! Washer/Dryer! Tuscany Cabinets with LED Lighting. Hi-Hat lights/Ceiling Fans, 2-Tone Paint/Crown Molding, Carpet. Granite and Marble Bath/Granite Vanity top. Frameless Shower/Some Stall. Central Air. Some terrace. Free Clubhouse/Fitness/Activities/Jitney Bus Trips/Events.,
Great location in a garden setting within walking distance of downtown Sayville Village on Main Street with its trendy shops, foodie fare local events and more. Easy access to Sunrise Highway, Southern State Parkway and the Long Island Railroad, Sayville and Ronkonkoma Stations.Our property is conveniently located near historic Sayville Village. The beautiful grounds feature outstanding
Great Sayville location minutes to historic Sayville Village Main Street. Private entry, -one and -two bedroom apartments with gas heat and hot water included in the rent.Near Long Island Railroad Sayville station. Convenient to Lakeland avenue and Montauk Highway. Near ferry to Fire Island.
Near downtown Sayville Village, Main Street shops and restaurants.Professional landscaping. Apartments with tuscany cabinets, granite counters, stainless appliances. Some carpet, some with vinyl plank floors. Some0 with outdoor terrace.
Ask About Our Outstanding Specials*: Tuscany Kitchen Cabinets W/ Stainless-Steel Appliances, Granite Kitchen Countertop & Backsplash, Granite Floor. LR Carpet, 2 Inch Faux Woodgrain Window Treatments, Crown & Base Moulding. Views Of The Renown Great South Bay! Close to Water, Parks, Shopping and Dining. Prices/Policies Subject To Change without Notice.
Walk Score® measures the walkability of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
