$226,083Average Value$149Average Price per Sq Ft19Homes For Sale
Summer homes into forever homes
Sheffield Lake has long been a destination for lakeside living. The community became a popular stop on The Lake Shore Electric Railway for its Lake Erie beach access, which invited vacationers and commercial fishing to the area. Residential streets started with summer homes in the early 20th century, and permanent residency increased as neighborhoods were filled with new developments. Sheffield Lake is primarily residential and neighbors connect as they enjoy the outdoors and attend events. "Everybody knows one another," says Beth Collins, public services professional at the Lorain Public Library's Domonkas Branch. "You take care of your neighbors, you talk to your neighbors, and there's a lot of community support."
Some Sheffield Lake homes on Lake Erie have their own private beaches.
The observation deck at Sheffield Lake's Shell Cove Park is often used for weddings or family outings.
1/2
Lake Erie recreation and weather patterns
Dense pockets of trees stand throughout the city, and shale cliffs line Lake Erie's shores. Five parks have lakefront access, allowing visitors to swim, boat, fish and jet ski on the water. The city plans to expand these parks with more bike paths, pedestrian boardwalks, piers and offshore protections. Sheffield Lake's public boat ramp is one of few in the surrounding communities that does not charge to use the launch. Ferndale Park has the Storybook Trail, a library project that helps kids practice their literacy skills while exercising. Picture books in mounted frames are placed along the path and are rotated monthly to keep kids coming back. Living on the lake comes with several weather considerations. Snow can be unpredictable, and intense storms impact the county. "We had the tornado last year [2024] that was very damaging, and you just don't know what spring and summer will be like in terms of precipitation," Collins says. Insect populations also spike in the warmer months. "We get midges and Canadian soldiers on the lake," Collins says. "For a week or two, they are just on everything, so if you've never lived by the lake before, it can be a startling experience."
Fernadale Park, in Sheffield Lake, features a storybook trail, walking path, and a playground.
Sheffield Lake Boat Launch is open to the public and is free to use.
1/2
Custom homes in The Buckeye Cove Lake Front Development
Residents live in split-level homes, Cape Cods, ranch-style houses and compact bungalows. Treadway Ponds is one of the city's newest subdivisions, offering attached townhomes built in 2023. The Buckeye Cove Lake Front Development is under construction and has some custom home designs. The median home price in Sheffield Lake is $195,000, less than half the national median.
Split-level homes in Sheffield Lake often have attached garages and wide driveways.
Sheffield Lake's Treadway Ponds is a quiet subdivision that borders Richelieu Park.
1/2
Big county parades and craft nights
The annual Community Days festival has attracted thousands to Sheffield Lake for over 50 years. It spans four days, offering everything from carnival games to a fireworks display. The festival's parade is one of the largest in Lorain County, with as many as 80 participating groups. "It was honestly devastating the couple of times we were rained out. People were really disappointed," Collins says. Smaller events also have loyal attendance, including movie nights and food truck days, and the library sees a lot of support from the community. "Our craft nights fill up really fast. There's always waitlists to get into them," she says.
Taking Highway 6 all the way to Cleveland
Sidewalks make the city walkable, and bike lanes on either side of Highway 6 provide safe passage for cyclists. Highway 6 stretches along Lake Erie, connecting to big cities like Cleveland in roughly 20 miles. The city annually resurfaces residential roads, which helps keep congestion down. Avon Hospital at Richard E. Jacobs Campus is roughly 8 miles away, while Cleveland Hopkins International Airport is 21 miles away.
School district serves both Sheffield Lake and Village
Students attend the Sheffield-Sheffield Lake School District, which serves both the city and Sheffield Village. The district has a C-plus rating on Niche and has over 1,600 students spread across five schools.
The Sheffield-Sheffield Lake School District has earned a C-plus rating from Niche.
Brookside High School students can participate in a variety of athletic programs.
1/2
Retail stores and employment in Avon
The city has about 50 businesses. Most stand independently throughout the community rather than cluster into shopping centers. Larger retail corridors are a few miles away in the neighboring city of Avon. There are few major employers inside the city, but a large industrial park with manufacturing companies sits just outside Sheffield Lake.
Sheffield Lake's Henrietta Honey is a perfect place to find a handcrafted gift.
Avon Commons, near Sheffield Lake, is the main shopping center with over 40 stores and restaurants.
1/2
Sheffield Lake police addressing crime
According to the FBI, Sheffield Lake saw a significant increase in violent and property crime between 2022 and 2023. The Sheffield Lake Police Department is expanding its force to improve response.
Written By
Isabel Butler
Photography Contributed By
Nile Vincz
Video By
GL Moses
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Chad Schneider,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Sheffield Lake, OH sell after 25 days on the market compared to the national average of 50 days. The median sale price for homes in Sheffield Lake, OH over the last 12 months is $209,450, up 10% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
This beautiful split-level offers an open floor plan with vaulted ceilings in the living room and stylish laminatehardwood floors. The space flows seamlessly into a spacious eat-in kitchen featuring ample granite countertops andnatural sunlight, white soft-close cabinets, and sleek stainless steel appliances?perfect for everyday living andentertaining.Enjoy the privacy of a large,
Discover the possibilities at 729 Kenilworth Avenue in Sheffield Lake! This 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath bungalow offers 1,417 square feet of living space, providing a solid foundation for someone ready to bring their own personal touches and style. Inside, you’ll find multiple living spaces, an eat-in kitchen with included appliances, and a versatile bonus room that could serve as a mudroom, office, or
Welcome to this spacious 3-bedroom, colonial home, featuring 2 full baths, along with a fully finished basement. This home offers a 2 plus car garage and separate room off the garage with its own access door that leads to a room/office or storage area. On the main floor there is a formal living room that is currently being used for the children's play area. A formal dining room, eat in kitchen
Prepare to be moved! Welcome to 511 Sunset Avenue, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054, a two-story home offering serene lake views and modern comfort just steps from the private Mizpah Beach Club. From the second floor to much of the first, lake views are a prominent feature throughout the home. This thoughtfully designed home greets you with a bright and open layout, where natural light dances across
Serene and relaxing apartment living starts at Portside Apartments in Sheffield Lake, Ohio. Close in proximity to Lake Erie, residents can enjoy the comforts of lakeside living while being a short drive away from Cleveland. Highway 6 and Interstate 90 are your gateways to fun and excitement around our small city. Amazing restaurants, intriguing shops, and exciting entertainment attractions are
Welcome home to The Perch, the only Lakefront High Rise in Sheffield Lake, Ohio! This beautiful lakefront community has convenient access to the I-90, I-80 (the Ohio Turnpike), public transportation, Crocker Park Mall and Great Northern Mall. Nestled alongside the serene shores of Lake Erie, you'll never want to leave! Our newly renovated apartment homes offer studio, one and two bedroom
At the Preserve, our goal is to make you feel at home. Our brand new single-story apartments offer the amenities of a private home without the stress. Each of our luxury homes features two bedrooms, two full bathrooms, a two and a half car garage and seven spacious closets. Our beautiful and convenient location is just 25 miles west of downtown Cleveland and minutes from Avon, Westlake, Elyria
Walk Score® measures the walkability of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
