$1,090,798Average Value$544Average Price per Sq Ft3Homes For Sale
Residents maintain Shrewsbury’s history and natural beauty
With lovingly maintained sycamore trees lining Sycamore Avenue, beautiful historic homes and a wealth of nearby parks alongside a caring community, stepping into Shrewsbury is a little like stepping into a fairy tale. At least that’s how Joyce Fernandes, a longtime resident and Realtor at Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices, describes it. The borough has a sense of historic charm and beauty, and residents work together to maintain that.
“They have a lot of pride in the town, so they’ve taken the time to maintain the integrity of the town,” says Fernandes. This care extends all the way to Shrewsbury’s well-known Sycamore Avenue and the sycamore trees that line it. “They’ve actually won awards many times for the tree commission, because they maintain them and they just really do a nice job with the tree commission.”
Many homes in Shrewsbury have picture perfect entrances
Grab a bike and stroll through Shrewsbury
1/2
Historic homes sell quickly in this well-maintained borough
Once someone settles in Shrewsbury, they rarely want to leave, which means homes don’t often find their way onto the market. When they do, they’re snapped up quickly, so it’s essential to act fast if looking to buy. Although it’s a small area, Fernandes says that home prices vary quite a lot, starting at around the $500,000 mark and climbing up to about $3 million. No matter the price of their home, though, many residents are happy to live in such a beautiful and historic community close to so many amenities, especially given how much love is poured into it by its residents.
Historic colonial homes are founds throughout Shrewsbury
Large tudor style homes on Sycamore Ave in Shrewsbury
1/2
Local school offers personalized education with small student body
Shrewsbury may be full of history, but the town and its citizens both look toward the future by putting a lot of care into its school, Shrewsbury Borough School, which serves prekindergarten all the way through eighth grade and gets an A on Niche. “That’s not that common nowadays,” says Fernandes, whose own children went to the school. “And it’s kind of a nice value because you feel like it’s a private school because it’s such a small population in the town, so the student-to-teacher ratio is well below the state average.” Red Bank Regional High School also has an A.
Shrewsbury Borough School holds Pre-K through 8th grades
Red Bank Reg High School features a state of the art turf football field.
1/2
Well-kept parks and historic sites enrich daily life
The neighborhood’s many parks are just as well-maintained as the rest of it, including places where residents can go to play baseball, basketball and tennis or participate in the community garden at Manson Park. One of the town’s most interesting historical sites is at the Four Corners, where Sycamore Avenue and Broad Street intersect. At this crossroads sit three historic churches and the Allen House, which was built in 1710 before functioning as a tavern during the mid-1700s and playing a role in the Revolutionary War, all of which are still in use today. The house is now a museum outfitted to match its time as a tavern.
Sickles Park in Shrewsbury has state of the art tennis courts
Bring the kids to play at Sickles Park in Shrewsbury
Sickles Park in Shrewsbury is a great place to meet up with friends
1/3
Major retailers and restaurants fill the town’s commercial hub
Despite being a small town, Shrewsbury has plenty of shopping within its own borders, including two shopping centers. The largest of these, an outdoor mall called The Grove, features major retailers like Banana Republic, Sephora and Chico’s. The neighborhood is also home to several major places to grab groceries, from a Trader Joe’s to a ShopRite, in addition to a few popular local restaurants. Kick off a long day of shopping with breakfast at Americana Diner or finish off your day with a delicious dinner at Albariño Tapas & Wine Bar. This wealth of shopping options ensures that most of your shopping needs can be taken care of just a few minutes from home—with none of the workarounds that are often the downsides of other small towns.
Meet your friends at the Grove in Shrewsbury
A creative and educational store for children is at the Learning Express in Shrewsbury.
1/2
Commuters benefit from trains, ferries and highway access
When residents want a little bit more excitement, Shrewsbury is also ideally located to provide it. “You can get to the beach in under 10 minutes,” Fernandes says. “You need to commute, you can get to the Parkway in under 10 minutes. If you need public transportation, you have the train, the New Jersey transit, that takes you into the city or wherever else you need to go, eventually. We have the commuter ferry that you get to that’s in Highlands to go into the city. A lot of great neighboring towns.”
Video By
Jonathan Bradley
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
David Herchakowski,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Shrewsbury, NJ sell after 19 days on the market compared to the national average of 58 days. The median sale price for homes in Shrewsbury, NJ over the last 12 months is $967,500, up 13% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
You will find this 5 bedroom, 4 bath house an entertainer's dream with an expansive deck and backyard fire pit on a 100 x 150 beautifully landscaped property. The 1st floor offers a bright living room, dining room and updated kitchen with a center island. 3 bedrooms, 2 baths and convenient laundry room are on the 2nd floor. Occupying its own 3rd floor private level, the impressive primary bedroom
MARA BROWNDORFHeritage House Sotheby's International Realty
Exceptional offering in the heart of Shrewsbury, this expansive residence delivers over 4,500 sf of beautifully proportioned living space designed for comfort, flexibility & effortless entertaining. Interior features generous living areas, a practical & inviting layout & versatility to accommodate today's lifestyle whether you need space for extended family, home office or guest quarters. 6 BRs
Don't miss this 3 BR, 3 full bath 2 level detached home in The Enclave at Shrewsbury. Beautifully laid out with open floor plan. Hardwood floors throughout, Living room with gas FP and a slider to very private custom paver patio w/gas grill and electric awning. Backs to woods. Primary BR with sitting area, tray ceiling, full bath and huge walk in closet. 2nd BR on first floor with full bath right
Charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath ranch in a prime location just 1 mile from downtown Red Bank and the NJ Transit train station, with easy access to beaches just 16 minutes away. This home features a bright living room with fireplace, dining room, updated kitchen with granite counter tops and stainless steel appliances, and a full basement with high ceilings and sheetrock already in place--offering
Beautiful 3 bedroom, 3.5 bath End Unit Townhome in The Ivy with 2 car garage, walk out finished lower level with full bath & patio. Spacious & Open floor plan is great for entertaining. Home boasts center island kitchen with ss appliances , granite countertops & slider to large deck. Family room with fireplace, hardwood floors & so much more!
Ask for Specials! Shrewsbury Arms Apartments is a charming community of garden apartments situated in its own park-like setting. Built with quality construction, we are proud to offer convenience, value, and airy floor plans. We are now offering beautiful upgraded units with brand new vinyl flooring, stainless steel appliances, granite counter tops and more! Heat and hot water are included in
Luxury Annual Rental! Available July 2026. Located in the highly sought-after Parkers Creek community at Historic Fort Monmouth, this stunning townhome, built in 2025, offers luxury coastal living in one of Monmouth County's most exciting waterfront communities. Nestled along the banks of Parkers Creek, this vibrant ''Eat, Play, Live'' community is adjacent to the future Netflix headquarters, the
Kelly FernandesHeritage House Sotheby's International Realty
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
