$302,216Average Value$184Average Price per Sq Ft64Homes For Sale
Nature and country living in Lake County’s Umatilla
River otters, alligators, and tortoises are just a few of the new neighbors that residents will make when moving to Umatilla. Commonly referred to as the “gateway to the Ocala National Forest,” this neighborhood gives residents quick access to the second largest nationally protected forest in the state. Being so close to more than a million acres of wilderness and natural springs, it’s not surprising that Umatilla’s motto is “nature’s hometown.” “It’s really country living out here,” says Realtor Kelly LaFave with eXp Realty. “There’s a few shops and businesses, but it’s really all about the country life in Umatilla.”
Aerial view of colorful kayakers on Lake Umatilla.
Sunsational Farms has tractor rides through the orchards a kids favorite in Umatilla.
1/2
Umatilla residents have easy access to nature
There are plenty of ways to get outdoors in Umatilla, with over a dozen lakes surrounding the community, offering boating and fishing year-round. There are also several community parks in the area, including Cadwell Park. This dog-friendly park near Lake Umatilla has a play area, basketball court and shaded picnic areas. Gateway Skate Park has a quarter pipe and bank on the sides of a fun box. North Lake Community Park is a sprawling recreational facility that features basketball, tennis, and volleyball courts. There are also softball, soccer, and baseball fields.
Residents enjoy fishing on Lake Umatilla for the day.
A skateboarder sharpens skills at Cadwell Park in Umatilla.
1/2
Midcentury homes and contemporary waterfront stunners
Peppered with ponds and nestled around Lake Umatilla, this small town is brimming with midcentury and Craftsman-inspired homes. Houses have colorful exteriors, decorative trim and typically cost between $400,000 and $600,000. For a contemporary home with scenic waterfront views, buyers can check out homes along Lake Umatilla. There are newer contemporary bungalows and new traditional homes, costing between $300,000 and $800,000. These homes tend to have more spacious backyards, and some even include private boat ramps.
Colorful single-story home from the 70s with decorative trim contrasting shutters retro windows and carports in Umatilla.
Docks attached to contemporary two-story and ranch-style homes with waterfront views along Lake Umatilla.
1/2
A charming small town with local businesses
The heart of Umatilla offers a small town with a simple lifestyle. Sunsational Farms is a local landmark. It’s also a spot residents frequent for fresh produce and the occasional frozen treat. Residents can shop at the Antique Mall, a rustic barn filled with vintage furniture and memorabilia. Readers will love the Umatilla Public Library, which hosts poetry readings, flash fiction contests, and reading programs for young children. For a bite to eat, Greg’s Haystax is a family-owned and operated diner that is known for its hospitality and heaping portions. Another favorite is Bear’s Beans and Bagels, the local coffee shop. When residents want to stock their pantry, there is a Publix and a Winn-Dixie just 4 miles south in Eustis. Eustis is also home to the nearest medical center, AdventHealth Waterman Hospital. “Eustis is where most residents the action,” LaFave says. “There are waterfront restaurants and shops, and it’s close to Mount Dora, which is known for its huge art festivals.”
The Antique Mall is a rustic barn that’s filled with vintage furniture and memorabilia in Umatilla.
Interior of Greg’s Haystax a family-owned and operated diner that is known for its hospitality and heaping portions in Umatilla.
1/2
Students attend Lake County Schools
Education begins for students at Umatilla Elementary School, which has an overall B grade on Niche. The school hosts the Extended Learning Center, a before and after-school educational program. Students then filter into Umatilla Middle School, which has a B-minus grade on Niche. The school offers half a dozen athletic options, a STEM club, and a television production team. Students at Umatilla High School, which has a C-plus on Niche, can partake in specialized extracurriculars, like the aviation club and fishing club.
Umatilla Middle School is a public school located in Umatilla.
Brick building of Umatilla High School is a public school located in UMATILLA.
1/2
Easy access to the rest of Central Florida
Central Avenue runs through the heart of Umatilla, connecting residents north to Jacksonville and South to Orlando, where residents will find Orlando International Airport. There are a few bus stops along North Central Avenue, but most residents will need a car to get around. The road can also connect residents to Florida’s main attractions: beaches and theme parks. Aside from Ocala National Forest, Umatilla is within 20 miles of Seminole State Forest and Esmeralda Marsh Conservation Area. Leave the lakes behind and go thrill-seeking, as Walt Disney World Resorts and Universal Studios are less than 50 miles away. Those wanting sand and sun will enjoy being within 50 miles of Daytona Beach. With its central location, small-town conveniences and abundance of lakes, Umatilla offers both natural wonders and convenience.
Aerial view of Umatilla a city in Lake County Florida known as the gateway to the Ocala National Forest.
The LakeXpress offers public transportation across Lake County and Umatilla.
1/2
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Rex Hunter,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Umatilla, FL sell after 77 days on the market compared to the national average of 52 days. The median sale price for homes in Umatilla, FL over the last 12 months is $316,250, up 2% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Nestled on over 9 acres of serene countryside, this concrete block home offers endless possibilities. The residence features a brand-new metal roof and provides a solid foundation for customization with just a little TLC. The expansive property is bordered by large pastures, creating a peaceful and private setting. A 40' x 60' pole barn offers abundant space for storage, equipment, or future
**Take advantage of special financing + Flex Funds on quick move-in homes** The Lynwood offers charming exterior with stone accent on the front of the home. convienant powder room , open kitchen with large kitchen island featuring natural stone countertop & LED showcase light in the 9'4" ceiling. The master retreat bedrooom is convienanetly located on the first floor of the Lynwood. Light taupe
Stephanie MoralesTHE REALTY EXPERIENCE POWERED BY LRR
**Take advantage of special financing + Flex Funds on quick move-in homes** Discover this exceptional 2 story home situated on a beautiful oversized corner homesite, ready for July 2025 move-in! Included features: Front Multi-Gen Bedroom with space as a living room or game room area has many uses; a covered entry; a spacious great room; A beautiful kitchen, white 42"" cabinets, quartz
Stephanie MoralesTHE REALTY EXPERIENCE POWERED BY LRR
Are you searching for peace, quiet, and a personal retreat to call home — or perhaps the ultimate little McRanch vacation getaway? This truly one-of-a-kind 1.24-acre paradise offers you that rare opportunity. Tucked deep in the heart of the forest, this property comes with more than just land and structures — it comes with a lifestyle. Featuring a completely renovated. 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom stilt
Surrounded by beautiful canopy oak trees and sitting on 2.38+/- acres this beauty is now available for its new family to enjoy. Built in 2020, this home offers 1920 square feet of living space with 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The open-concept kitchen, living room, and dining room create a spacious feel, perfect for family gatherings. The kitchen features ample storage and a generous island, ideal
Explore the potential of this versatile .11-acre lot located in the tranquil Forest Lake Campsites in Umatilla. With dimensions of 50x100, this property offers a compact yet ample space for building a mobile home or a small family residence, courtesy of its R4 mixed-use zoning. This designation not only enhances its appeal by allowing for various residential options but also makes it an ideal
38207 Sabal Way in Umatilla offers comfortable living in a quiet neighborhood setting. This inviting home features a spacious layout designed for both functionality and comfort, with plenty of natural light throughout. The property includes a well-appointed kitchen, generous living areas, and comfortable bedrooms, making it ideal for everyday living. Outside, you’ll find a yard perfect for
Beautifally maintained home that has been recently updated.Light-filled home with an open living space and a functional layout. Spacious bedrooms. Large fenced in back yard with a screened in patio. Convenient to schools and shopping. Small pets only and non-smoking.
Enjoy a turnkey, beautiful NEWLY BUILT single-family residence at 89 Fairway Cir in Umatilla’s coveted in Twin Lakes Estates a beautful 55+ gated community. This spacious 4-bedroom, 2-bath home boasts fresh interior paint throughout. The open-concept kitchen shines with NEW stainless steel appliances, gleaming granite countertops, and a center island perfect for meal prep or casual dining. Relax
Walk Score® measures the walkability of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
