Golden Horseshoe

Situated in the heart of Colonial Williamsburg, you can enjoy historic charm and spacious homes in gorgeous Golden Horseshoe. History buffs will be enthralled by the significant settlement sites in the area, nature lovers have endless parks and green spaces to explore, and golfers can play their hearts out at the sprawling Golden Horseshoe Golf Club.

“People love Golden Horseshoe for the location,” says Mary McNulty, Realtor with Howard Hanna E. Wood Realtors. “It’s about a mile from downtown Colonial Williamsburg, so very convenient. Another plus is that is actually within the city limits of Williamsburg, so the tax rate is lower compared to James City County. The neighborhood also has nice amenities like pools and tennis courts.”

Golden Horseshoe’s wide, curving streets are lined with paved sidewalks and mature trees. Here, spacious homes with classic architectural styles like colonials, Federals and Cape Cods, as well as newer transitional-style houses, are set back on tidy lots averaging a half-acre. These properties boast manicured lawns, elegant landscaping and long, paved driveways that lead to side entrance garages. In Golden Horseshoe, you can find three to four-bedroom brick transitional-style homes for between $550,000 to $750,000. A Federal or colonial estate with four bedrooms will cost upwards of $1 million. The area is also home to brick townhouse complexes, where a two-bedroom home costs around $300,000. “The market is still very good here,” McNulty says. “I listed a house recently that was priced really well because it was older and had the original roof. I listed it on Friday, and over the weekend, I had 23 showings and 3 offers.”

Kids in Golden Horseshoe attend Matthew Whaley Elementary School, Berkeley Middle School and Lafayette High School, which all belong to the Williamsburg-James City County Public Schools district. This school district receives an overall grade of A- from Niche, with notably high ratings in the categories of teachers, academics, sports and college prep. Lafayette High School, which earns an overall grade of A- from Niche as well, puts a lot of spirit and dedication into its activities and athletics departments. The Lafayette Rams have won several state championships within the past few years in football and cheerleading.

Golden Horseshoe is surrounded by natural beauty and well-maintained public parks. Immerse yourself in nature with a scenic walk on the paved paths or dirt trails of the wooded, 22-acre Redoubt Park, located on Quarterpath Road. Slightly further north on the same road, you’ll find Quarterpath Park, which spans 23 acres and features a playground, softball fields, tennis courts and picnic shelters. If you want a peaceful afternoon by the water, head to College Landing Park, perched on the edge of College Creek. This quiet park is the perfect place to fish, kayak, paddleboard or birdwatch.
Golden Horseshoe Golf Club is a focal point of this area and, in recent years, has been voted “one of America’s 50 Greatest Public Courses” by Golf Digest. The course is surrounded by mature woodlands and boasts 36 walkable holes over two courses.

When hungry, head to Berret's Seafood Restaurant and Taphouse Grill in Merchant’s Square for dinner in a cozy atmosphere. Enjoy offerings like raw oysters on the half-shell, local pork chop or their popular she-crab cakes. When you’re craving something sweet, swing by Blackbird Bakery for a range of freshly baked pastries.

Golden Horseshoe Golf Club is a focal point of this area and, in recent years, has been voted “one of America’s 50 Greatest Public Courses” by Golf Digest. The course is surrounded by mature woodlands and boasts 36 walkable holes over two courses.

Pick up groceries at Harris Teeter on Quarterpath Road. For fresh local produce, baked goods, cheeses and more, don’t miss the Williamsburg Farmer’s Market, held every Saturday morning from early March to late December on Duke of Gloucester Street. For shopping, head to Colonial Williamsburg's Merchants Square for boutiques and cafés. When you’re looking for familiar retailers and big box stores, head 3 miles west on Monticello Avenue to land at stores like Walmart and Old Navy.

Brimming with character, history and amenities, it’s no wonder Golden Horseshoe is a highly sought-after place to call home.

Written By

Sarah Grace Vedomske

Photography Contributed By

Justin Stapp

Video By

Taylor Noll