5

Middlebury, NY Homes for Sale

Section Image Section Image
  • /50

    $279,900

    • 3 Beds
    • 1.5 Baths
    • 1,224 Sq Ft

    417 East Rd, Wyoming, NY 14591

    Welcome to 417 East Road! Situated on just shy of an acre, this beautifully maintained ranch in Wyoming offers the ease of one-level living with exceptional indoor and outdoor spaces designed for everyday comfort and entertaining. The newer kitchen features granite countertops, breakfast bar with three seats, newer appliances (2022), and opens to the main living areas, creating a functional

    Agent Photo

    Kelly Roche

    Listing by RE/MAX Plus

    417 East Rd, Wyoming, NY 14591
  • /34

    $280,000

    $280K PRICE INCREASE
    • 4 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 2,211 Sq Ft

    484 Bank Rd, East Bethany, NY 14054

    Welcome to your own slice of country paradise! Situated on 2 beautiful acres, this spacious 4-bedroom, 2-bath home offers the perfect blend of comfort, space, and outdoor enjoyment. Move-in ready and mostly updated throughout, this property is ideal for those looking for a home they can enjoy from day one while still having the opportunity to add their own personal touches over time.Outside,

    Adrienne Wright Listing by WNY Metro Roberts Realty

    484 Bank Rd, East Bethany, NY 14054
  • /20

    $99,900

    • 3 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 2,328 Sq Ft

    25 N Academy St, Wyoming, NY 14591

    Great opportunity in the Village of Wyoming. This colonial style is over 2300 in square feet and has so much potential. The property offers 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms with the possibilty of a 4th bedroom or office. The home sits on a 2.14 acre lot that backs to a wooded area for privacy. Spacious kitchen with plenty of cabinets and a walk-in pantry. 1st floor laundry room. Upstairs offers 2

    Gloria Magin Listing by RE/MAX Plus

    25 N Academy St, Wyoming, NY 14591
  • /50

    $99,000

    • Land
    • 3.99 Acres
    • $24,812 per Acre

    71 S Academy St, Middlebury, NY 14591

    Exceptional 4-acre parcel on the edge of Wyoming Village, home of the AppleUmpkin festival, and just steps away from Wyoming School. The centerpiece of this lovely piece of property is the historic barn! It was originally used to process wheat, with a door on either side that would be opened wide to blow away the chaff! More recently it was a successful antique store. With electric and a gas

    Grace Worthington Listing by NextHome Brixwood

    71 S Academy St, Middlebury, NY 14591
  • /43

    $194,900

    $5K PRICE DROP
    • 3 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,692 Sq Ft

    56 Main St, Wyoming, NY 14591

    Charming Turnkey Home at 56 Main Street, Wyoming, NY – Modern Comfort Meets Classic Appeal. Discover this beautifully completely renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home that blends modern upgrades with small-town charm. Perfectly located on Main Street, this move-in-ready gem offers effortless living in a peaceful Wyoming setting. Step inside to an inviting open-concept layout where the living, dining,

    Robyn Sansone Listing by WNYbyOwner.com

    56 Main St, Wyoming, NY 14591

Why Live in Middlebury

Middlebury, New York, located 15 miles north of Batavia, is a small town with a rich history dating back to 1812. The town centers around the village of Wyoming, known for its historic buildings like the First Baptist Church and First Presbyterian Church of Wyoming. The community is characterized by its close-knit atmosphere, where residents often know each other across generations. The area features a mix of historic single-family homes with farmhouse or Colonial-inspired designs, featuring covered porches and detached garages, as well as more secluded properties with ample land, barns, or stables. Wyoming Village Park serves as a community hub with a playground, basketball court, and a pavilion for events like the annual Christmas tree lighting and concerts. For outdoor activities, the 2,500-acre Carlton Hill Multiple Use Area provides hiking, horseback riding, and bird-watching opportunities. Local dining options include the Wyoming Gaslight Market, known for its pizza and beef on weck, and nearby farmstands like Titus Brothers Fruit Stand and Welch’s Farm Market. Residents often travel to Warsaw, seven miles away, for more extensive shopping and dining options. The town also hosts the AppleUmpkin Festival, a popular fall event featuring arts, crafts, and local produce. Middlebury is part of multiple school districts, with students attending Wyoming Central School and moving on to high schools in the area. The town is car-dependent, with State Route 19 providing access to Batavia and Rochester, and the nearest hospital and airport located 7 and 43 miles away, respectively.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average household income in Middlebury, NY?
The average household income in Middlebury, NY is $96K.
What are the most popular zip codes in Middlebury, NY?
The most popular zip codes in Middlebury, NY include 14591, 14054, 14011, 14569 and 14005.
How are the schools in Middlebury, NY?
Middlebury, NY has highly rated public and private schools. Some of the best schools in Middlebury based on Niche Grades are Perry Central High School, Alexander Elementary School and Warsaw Senior High School. Browse all the schools in Middlebury, NY to learn more.
How to Buy a Home How to Finance a Home How to Sell a Home