Old Field
Old Field, NY, is a coastal village known for its lighthouse and water views. This small community offers waterfront living and outdoor activities. Nearby are highly rated Paul J. Gelinas Junior High and Ward Melville High School.
Average Value
$1.88M
List Price
$1M - $6.7M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
2 Listings
Explore Brookhaven
Central Fire Island
Central Fire Island in Fire Island offers pristine beaches and LGBTQ-friendly communities. The area is safer than the national average, with unique attractions like the Sunken Forest and highly rated Bay Shore schools nearby.
Average Value
$1.52M
List Price
$546K - $4.2M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
29 Listings
Bellport Village
Bellport Village, NY, is an artistic community on Long Island's south shore. It has two private beaches, including one on Fire Island. The historic district features galleries and boutiques. The schools have favorable ratings.
Average Value
$1.42M
List Price
$579K - $9.8M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
6 Listings
Belle Terre
Belle Terre, NY, is an exclusive gated village on Long Island's north shore. This affluent enclave features historic estates, a private beach, and access to Port Jefferson's highly rated schools and vibrant dining scene.
Average Value
$1.41M
List Price
$698K - $9M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
6 Listings
East Moriches
East Moriches, NY, is known for boating on Moriches Bay and hiking at Terrell River County Park. Dining options line Montauk Highway. The area has highly rated schools and a crime rate lower than the national average.
Average Value
$900K
List Price
$574K - $2.5M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
15 Listings
East Setauket
The historic hamlet of East Setauket, sometimes called Setauket—East Setauket is perched on the Long Island Sound waterfront. The community is famous for its connections to the American Revolution, from the Battle of Setauket to being home to the Culper Spy Ring, whose intelligence turned the tide of the war. Today, this history is displayed
Average Value
$878K
List Price
$215K - $1.9M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
13 Listings
Eastport
Eastport, NY, a quiet suburb west of the Hamptons, features a historic downtown and waterfront activities on Seatuck Cove. The hamlet offers boating, fishing, and beach access. It has lower crime risk than the national average.
Average Value
$843K
List Price
$614K - $2.4M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
8 Listings
Shoreham
Shoreham, NY is a coastal village with beaches and parks. The Tesla Science Center and Rocky Point State Pine Barrens Preserve are key attractions. Shoreham-Wading River Central School District has highly rated schools.
Average Value
$831K
List Price
$578K - $1.7M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
2 Listings
Miller Place
Miller Place, NY, a suburban hamlet 74 miles from Manhattan, features tree-lined streets and diverse housing. Residents enjoy Miller Place Beach and Cordwood Landing County Park. The area has lower crime risk than average.
Average Value
$803K
List Price
$518K - $1.8M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
26 Listings
Port Jefferson
Port Jefferson, NY, is a coastal village with maritime history. It features highly rated schools, a vibrant harbor area with shops and bistros, and beaches. A LIRR station connects this charming community to Manhattan.
Average Value
$803K
List Price
$469K - $2.7M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
9 Listings
Brookhaven
Brookhaven feels very different from many of Long Island’s busy, crowded suburbs. Although the hamlet covers nearly 6 square miles, a wildlife refuge and wetlands consume a good amount of this space. Its population density is roughly 550 people per square mile — more than three times less than the neighboring North Bellport, which has about 1,950
Average Value
$798K
List Price
$560K - $3.5M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
6 Listings
Blue Point
Blue Point, NY, is a waterfront hamlet on the Great South Bay. This tight-knit community shares highly rated schools with Bayport. Residents enjoy Corey Beach, water activities, and a renovated library in a former convent.
Average Value
$793K
List Price
$525K - $1.4M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
1 Listing
Stony Brook
Stony Brook, NY combines education and history with its university and historic village center. The Long Island Museum and Avalon Nature Preserve are key attractions. Top-rated schools serve this low-crime-risk area.
Average Value
$783K
List Price
$411K - $1.6M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
17 Listings
Mount Sinai
Mount Sinai, NY blends small-town charm with waterfront living. Cedar Beach offers recreation, while Heritage Center Park hosts community events. Highly rated schools attract families to this hamlet 64 miles from Manhattan.
Average Value
$780K
List Price
$419K - $1.7M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
13 Listings
Center Moriches
Center Moriches, NY, is a waterfront community on Long Island's South Shore. It offers boating access to Moriches Bay, a lively downtown with street fairs, and scenic Terrell River County Park. Crime risk is comparatively low.
Average Value
$778K
List Price
$523K - $4.5M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
21 Listings
Manorville
Manorville, NY, features large wooded properties and peaceful streets. Residents enjoy hiking in the Long Island State Pine Barrens and visiting the Game Farm Wildlife Park. The area has lower crime risk than the national average.
Average Value
$750K
List Price
$151K - $1.4M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
39 Listings
Lake Grove
Lake Grove, NY, is a close-knit village near Lake Ronkonkoma. It features highly rated schools in the Sachem Central School District. Residents enjoy Lake Ronkonkoma County Park and Smith Haven Mall for shopping and dining.
Average Value
$744K
List Price
$517K - $1.3M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
13 Listings
Lake Ronkonkoma
Lake Ronkonkoma, NY, surrounds Long Island's largest freshwater lake. This community has convenient transit, highly-rated Sachem schools, lakeside recreation, dining at Island Lake Diner, and karaoke nights at Parsnip Lake House.
Average Value
$681K
List Price
$440K - $1M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
22 Listings
Moriches
Moriches, NY, is a quiet waterfront community with boating on the Forge River. Schools include Moriches Elementary and William Floyd High School. Montauk Highway hosts local shops and dining, with events in nearby Center Moriches.
Average Value
$669K
List Price
$429K - $1M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
10 Listings
Centereach
Centereach, NY, 56 miles from NYC, offers affordable housing near Stony Brook University and Smith Haven Mall. It has low crime risk, highly rated schools, Percy B Raynor Memorial Park, and the Middle Country Public Library.
Average Value
$653K
List Price
$488K - $1.1M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
38 Listings
East Patchogue
East Patchogue, NY is a laid-back hamlet on Long Island's South Shore. It features Mirimar Beach and Swan Lake River Preserve. The area has lower crime risk than the national average and includes Victory Christian Academy.
Average Value
$640K
List Price
$430K - $1.1M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
26 Listings
Terryville
Terryville, NY, near Port Jefferson, features highly rated schools like Clinton Avenue Elementary and Comsewogue High. The area offers local events, easy commuting via Port Jefferson station, and recreation at Spy Ring Golf Club.
Average Value
$636K
List Price
$422K - $959K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
11 Listings
Yaphank
Yaphank, NY, offers a quiet rural feel with outdoor recreation along Carmans River and Southaven County Park. The area has highly rated schools in the Longwood district. Major highways provide easy commuting access.
Average Value
$634K
List Price
$415K - $994K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
24 Listings
Farmingville
Farmingville, NY is a quiet Long Island suburb with Cape Cod and ranch-style homes. It features Thomas Muratore Park and local restaurants. The area has highly rated schools and is safer than the national average.
Average Value
$633K
List Price
$450K - $1.1M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
12 Listings
Port Jefferson Station
Port Jefferson Station, NY, blends community spirit with coastal charm. This hamlet offers family-owned eateries, popular events, and beach access. Highly rated schools and the nearby Long Island Rail Road add to its appeal.
Average Value
$625K
List Price
$423K - $911K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
3 Listings
Showing Results 1 - 25, Page 1 of 2
Copyright © 2025 CoStar Group
