North Bay Shore
North Bay Shore, NY, offers proximity to Great South Bay and Downtown Bay Shore's shopping and dining. The area has ranch homes on quarter-acre lots, pocket parks, and easy access to Deer Park LIRR station and local beaches.
Average Value
$621K
List Price
$435K - $849K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
7 Listings
Patchogue
Patchogue, NY, 70 miles from NYC, has a revitalized downtown with shops and eateries, beach access, and Fire Island ferries. The Patchogue Theatre hosts various performances. Patchogue-Medford High School is highly rated.
Average Value
$611K
List Price
$269K - $1M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
36 Listings
Baywood
Baywood, Long Island offers quiet suburban living with modest homes on spacious lots. Residents enjoy nearby parks, Edgewood Oak Brush Plains State Forest trails, and Tanger Outlets Deer Park for shopping and dining.
Average Value
$607K
List Price
$488K - $869K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
9 Listings
Bay Shore
Bay Shore, NY, is a revitalized waterfront community on the Great South Bay. The town has a bustling downtown with diverse dining and shopping, ferries to Fire Island, and highly rated schools in the local school district.
Average Value
$604K
List Price
$288K - $799K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
19 Listings
North Amityville
North Amityville, NY is a diverse hamlet near Long Island's South Shore. Bolden Mack Park hosts community events. The Copiague and Farmingdale school districts are highly rated. Nearby villages provide dining and shopping.
Average Value
$603K
List Price
$244K - $831K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
16 Listings
Medford
Medford, NY, a Long Island hamlet 60 miles from Manhattan, provides access to South Shore beaches and Patchogue's vibrant downtown. The area features diverse housing and parks like Twelve Pines for outdoor recreation.
Average Value
$590K
List Price
$356K - $909K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
31 Listings
Flanders
Flanders, NY, is a coastal community near the Hamptons with beachside living and low taxes. The Big Duck is a notable landmark. Riverhead High School is highly rated. Hubbard Park offers outdoor recreation.
Average Value
$595K
List Price
$363K - $1.7M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
9 Listings
Central Islip
Central Islip, NY, a Long Island suburb, offers modestly priced homes and good transit. It features sports facilities, shopping centers, and nearby Connetquot River State Park Preserve. Crime risk aligns with the national average.
Average Value
$581K
List Price
$318K - $850K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
51 Listings
Selden
Selden, NY features tree-lined streets and diverse dining. Homes from the 1960s-70s have spacious yards. Stagecoach Elementary and Seldon Middle School are highly rated. Selden Dog Park offers outdoor recreation for residents.
Average Value
$589K
List Price
$410K - $791K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
24 Listings
North Patchogue
North Patchogue, NY, has a tranquil lakeside setting near Long Island's South Shore. Canaan Lake offers kayaking and fishing. The area is close to Patchogue's arts scene and has lower crime risk than the national average.
Average Value
$566K
List Price
$249K - $751K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
7 Listings
Coram
Coram, NY, a historic Long Island hamlet, has homes and condos near parks like Diamond in the Pines. It offers diverse dining and easy Manhattan access. The area has highly rated schools and lower crime risk than average.
Average Value
$575K
List Price
$209K - $911K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
74 Listings
Northampton
Northampton, NY, 80 miles from NYC, blends lakeside living with nature preserves. Near Riverhead's amenities and Long Island's Wine Trail, it features Wildwood Lake and diverse housing. Riverhead High School has high ratings.
Average Value
$561K
List Price
$465K - $823K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
2 Listings
Ridge
Ridge, NY, offers peaceful living near North Shore beaches and state forests. Residents enjoy Rocky Point Pine Barrens and Lake Panamoka. The area features tree-shaded homes and 55-plus communities. Longwood schools are respected.
Average Value
$560K
List Price
$247K - $1.2M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
48 Listings
Sound Beach
Sound Beach, NY, offers beach bungalows and modern homes along Long Island Sound. Points of interest include Scott’s Beach and Robert Miner Park. Rocky Point schools are highly rated, and the area has a low crime risk.
Average Value
$560K
List Price
$310K - $959K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
9 Listings
Rocky Point
Rocky Point, NY, on Long Island Sound, features private beaches, hiking trails, and dining like Sea Basin. It enjoys a lower crime rate than the national average and has highly rated schools.
Average Value
$553K
List Price
$206K - $991K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
32 Listings
Wyandanch
Wyandanch, NY is revitalizing with new housing and retail. The Long Island Rail Road station provides Manhattan access. Wyandanch Village features dining and an ice rink. Nearby are Tanger Outlets and Robert Moses State Park.
Average Value
$548K
List Price
$337K - $755K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
20 Listings
North Bellport
North Bellport, NY is a diverse hamlet near Bellport Bay with affordable homes. It offers easy access to highways, LIRR, and Bellport Outlets. Tony Gazzola Park and nearby Wertheim Wildlife Refuge provide outdoor recreation.
Average Value
$525K
List Price
$315K - $856K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
22 Listings
Shirley
Shirley, NY, is a waterfront hamlet on Long Island's South Shore. It offers affordable coastal living with access to Bellport Bay and Fire Island. The area features fishing piers, beaches, and the Wertheim Wildlife Refuge.
Average Value
$530K
List Price
$385K - $853K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
70 Listings
Gordon Heights
Gordon Heights, NY is a wooded hamlet between Middle Island and Coram. It offers large lots, diverse housing, and golf course views. Residents enjoy Bartlett Pond Park and an annual Children's Parade & Family Celebration.
Average Value
$525K
List Price
$336K - $925K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
9 Listings
Mastic
Mastic, NY, is a waterfront community near the Hamptons. The Forge River offers boating, while Smith Point Beach provides summer entertainment. William Floyd School District has highly rated schools. Crime risk is low.
Average Value
$496K
List Price
$342K - $807K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
35 Listings
Middle Island
Middle Island, NY offers suburban living with spacious properties. Enjoy Prosser Pines Nature Preserve, highly rated Longwood schools, and nearby rail stations for commuting. Annual carnival events enhance community spirit.
Average Value
$499K
List Price
$206K - $848K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
30 Listings
Mastic Beach
Mastic Beach, NY, a coastal hamlet on Long Island, is undergoing revitalization. Osprey Park offers crabbing and fishing. The area has highly rated schools, including William Floyd High, and is safer than the national average.
Average Value
$446K
List Price
$300K - $700K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
44 Listings
Bridgehampton
Bridgehampton, NY, blends small-town charm with beaches, farmland, and historic windmills. The Hampton Classic is a major annual event. The area has highly rated schools and lower crime risk than the national average.
Average Value
$3.25M
List Price
$1.6M - $75.8M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
66 Listings
Huntington
Huntington, NY, blends waterfront living with a vibrant downtown. It has harbor access, beaches, and a bustling Main Street with shops and The Paramount Theatre. Heckscher Park hosts events. The area has highly rated schools.
Average Value
$1.10M
List Price
$425K - $2.5M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
27 Listings
Fishers Island
Fishers Island, NY, is a tranquil retreat in Long Island Sound. Pristine beaches and hiking trails dot this scenic island. A renowned golf course and limited seasonal businesses cater to visitors. Crime risk is lower than average.
Average Value
$1.95M
List Price
$1.4M - $6.5M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
2 Listings
Showing Results 101 - 125, Page 5 of 6
Copyright © 2026 CoStar Group
