Nick McNeely
F.C. Tucker Company
(463) 223-8244
160 Total Sales
3 in Holy Cross
$269K - $358K Price Range
1409 E New York St Indianapolis, IN 46201
Holy Cross NeighborhoodEstimated Value: $403,993
3
Beds
2
Baths
1,856
Sq Ft
$218/Sq Ft
Est. Value
Highlights
- Updated Kitchen
- Deck
- Wood Flooring
- Mature Trees
- Traditional Architecture
- 2-minute walk to Highland Park Playground
About This Home
As of May 2026Located in the heart of Holy Cross, this 3-bedroom, 2 full bath home with a rare 2-car garage combines historic character with thoughtful updates in one of downtown Indianapolis' most desirable neighborhoods. Original features stand out throughout, including 10' ceilings, beautiful pocket doors, exposed brick, a cozy sunroom, and striking entryway pillars that create a warm first impression. Natural light fills the home and highlights the hardwood floors and comfortable living areas. The spacious dining room is perfect for hosting, and the large exterior deck extends your entertaining outdoors. The primary bedroom offers great natural light and a generous walk-in closet. Nearly all mechanicals have been updated within the last six years, providing added peace of mind. An unfinished basement offers flexible use and plenty of storage. Enjoy easy access to Mass Ave, Bottleworks District, the Monon Trail, Highland Park, King Dough, 3 Dolls Bakery, Natural State Provisions, Futuro Pizzeria, and more, making it easy to enjoy the best of downtown living.
Last Agent to Sell the Property
Smith Family Realty Brokerage Email: paula@smithfamilyrealtyindy.com License #RB14044338 Listed on: 04/01/2026
Co-Listed By
Smith Family Realty Brokerage Email: paula@smithfamilyrealtyindy.com License #RB18001638
Create a Home Valuation Report for This Property
The Home Valuation Report is an in-depth analysis detailing your home's value as well as a comparison with similar homes in the area
Home Details
Home Type
- Single Family
Est. Annual Taxes
- $3,750
Year Built
- Built in 1900
Lot Details
- 5,793 Sq Ft Lot
- Mature Trees
Parking
- 2 Car Detached Garage
Home Design
- Traditional Architecture
- Brick Exterior Construction
- Block Foundation
- Vinyl Siding
Interior Spaces
- 2-Story Property
- Wired For Data
- High Ceiling
- Paddle Fans
- Entrance Foyer
- Formal Dining Room
- Attic Access Panel
- Unfinished Basement
Kitchen
- Updated Kitchen
- Electric Oven
- Microwave
- Dishwasher
- Disposal
Flooring
- Wood
- Carpet
- Laminate
- Ceramic Tile
Bedrooms and Bathrooms
- 3 Bedrooms
- Walk-In Closet
Laundry
- Laundry on main level
- Dryer
- Washer
Home Security
- Smart Thermostat
- Carbon Monoxide Detectors
- Fire and Smoke Detector
Outdoor Features
- Deck
- Enclosed Glass Porch
Utilities
- Forced Air Heating and Cooling System
- Heating System Uses Natural Gas
- Electric Water Heater
- Water Softener is Owned
- High Speed Internet
Community Details
- No Home Owners Association
- Arsenal Park Subdivision
Listing and Financial Details
- Tax Lot 45
- Assessor Parcel Number 491006161013000101
- Seller Concessions Not Offered
Ownership History
We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.
Date
Name
Owned For
Owner Type
Purchase Details
Listed on
Apr 1, 2026
Closed on
May 12, 2026
Sold by
Lee Hayley and Lee Patrick F
Bought by
Seller's Agent
Paula Smith
Smith Family Realty
Buyer's Agent
Jared Ruth
@properties
List Price
$400,000
Sold Price
$405,000
Premium/Discount to List
$5,000
1.25%
Views
50
Current Estimated Value
Home Financials for this Owner
Home Financials are based on the most recent Mortgage that was taken out on this home.
Estimated Appreciation
-$1,007
Avg. Annual Appreciation
-0.67%
Original Mortgage
$405,000
Outstanding Balance
$403,756
Interest Rate
5.88%
Mortgage Type
New Conventional
Estimated Equity
$237
Purchase Details
Listed on
Mar 4, 2021
Closed on
Apr 8, 2021
Sold by
Dietrick Robert
Bought by
Krause Hayley J and Lee Patrick F
Seller's Agent
Kristin Glassburn
@properties
Buyer's Agent
Paula Smith
Smith Family Realty
List Price
$340,000
Sold Price
$346,000
Premium/Discount to List
$6,000
1.76%
Home Financials for this Owner
Home Financials are based on the most recent Mortgage that was taken out on this home.
Avg. Annual Appreciation
3.14%
Original Mortgage
$328,700
Interest Rate
3.05%
Mortgage Type
New Conventional
Purchase Details
Listed on
Jul 2, 2016
Closed on
Aug 29, 2016
Sold by
Windeck Matthias Stephan and Graener Katharina Regina
Bought by
Dietrick Robert
Seller's Agent
Mariam Rahmani
In Place
Buyer's Agent
Connor Simonson
F.C. Tucker Company
List Price
$210,000
Sold Price
$213,000
Premium/Discount to List
$3,000
1.43%
Home Financials for this Owner
Home Financials are based on the most recent Mortgage that was taken out on this home.
Avg. Annual Appreciation
11.10%
Original Mortgage
$202,350
Interest Rate
3.48%
Mortgage Type
New Conventional
Purchase Details
Listed on
May 29, 2014
Closed on
Jun 11, 2014
Sold by
Strong Kenneth F and Strong Bridget R
Bought by
Windeck Stephan Matthias and Graene Katharina Regina
Seller's Agent
James Smock
F.C. Tucker Company
Buyer's Agent
Mariam Rahmani
In Place
List Price
$154,900
Sold Price
$152,900
Premium/Discount to List
-$2,000
-1.29%
Home Financials for this Owner
Home Financials are based on the most recent Mortgage that was taken out on this home.
Avg. Annual Appreciation
16.26%
Purchase Details
Closed on
Jun 25, 2009
Sold by
Sklorenko Mark B
Bought by
Strong Kenneth F and Strong Bridget R
Home Financials for this Owner
Home Financials are based on the most recent Mortgage that was taken out on this home.
Original Mortgage
$129,609
Interest Rate
4.86%
Mortgage Type
FHA
Purchase Details
Closed on
Dec 13, 2006
Sold by
Werle Joseph W and Werle Patricia J
Bought by
Sklorenko Mark B
Home Financials for this Owner
Home Financials are based on the most recent Mortgage that was taken out on this home.
Original Mortgage
$53,995
Interest Rate
11.5%
Mortgage Type
Adjustable Rate Mortgage/ARM
Home Values in the Area
Average Home Value in this Area
Agents Specializing in Holy Cross, IN
-
Nick McNeely
-
Jennifer Overett
Jennifer Overett
eXp Realty LLC
(463) 209-6729
38 Total Sales
1 in Holy Cross
$200,000 Price
-
Molly Lawless
Molly Lawless
F.C. Tucker Company
(855) 695-8242
113 Total Sales
1 in Holy Cross
$540,000 Price
-
Jerry Gemmecke
Jerry Gemmecke
F.C. Tucker Company
(317) 666-6502
242 Total Sales
1 in Holy Cross
$600,000 Price
-
Kevin Elson
Kevin Elson
eXp Realty LLC
(833) 715-1562
230 Total Sales
1 in Holy Cross
$385,000 Price
-
Randy Myers
Randy Myers
Indiana Real Estate Alliance,
(463) 209-6931
40 Total Sales
1 in Holy Cross
$168,000 Price
Purchase History
We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.
| Date | Buyer | Sale Price | Title Company |
|---|---|---|---|
| -- | Chicago Title | ||
| Krause Hayley J | $346,000 | None Available | |
| Dietrick Robert | -- | First American Title | |
| Windeck Stephan Matthias | -- | Stewart Title Company | |
| Windeck Stephan Matthias | $152,900 | Stewart Title Co | |
| Strong Kenneth F | -- | None Available | |
| Sklorenko Mark B | -- | None Available |
Source: Public Records
Mortgage History
We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.
| Date | Status | Borrower | Loan Amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| Open | $405,000 | ||
| Closed | Krause Hayley J | $328,700 | |
| Previous Owner | Dietrick Robert | $202,350 | |
| Previous Owner | Strong Kenneth F | $129,609 | |
| Previous Owner | Sklorenko Mark B | $101,500 | |
| Previous Owner | Sklorenko Mark B | $53,995 |
Source: Public Records
Property History
We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.
| Date | Event | Price | List to Sale | Price per Sq Ft | Prior Sale |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 05/12/2026 05/12/26 | Sold | $405,000 | +1.3% | $218 / Sq Ft | |
| 04/11/2026 04/11/26 | Pending | -- | -- | -- | |
| 04/01/2026 04/01/26 | For Sale | $400,000 | +15.6% | $216 / Sq Ft | |
| 04/08/2021 04/08/21 | Sold | $346,000 | +1.8% | $127 / Sq Ft | View Prior Sale |
| 03/06/2021 03/06/21 | Pending | -- | -- | -- | |
| 03/04/2021 03/04/21 | For Sale | $340,000 | +59.6% | $125 / Sq Ft | |
| 08/29/2016 08/29/16 | Sold | $213,000 | +1.4% | $78 / Sq Ft | View Prior Sale |
| 07/10/2016 07/10/16 | Pending | -- | -- | -- | |
| 07/02/2016 07/02/16 | For Sale | $210,000 | -- | $77 / Sq Ft |
Source: MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative®
Tax History
We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.
| Year | Tax Paid | Tax Assessment Tax Assessment Total Assessment is a certain percentage of the fair market value that is determined by local assessors to be the total taxable value of land and additions on the property. | Land | Improvement |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | $3,599 | $319,900 | $46,800 | $273,100 |
| 2024 | $3,835 | $313,100 | $46,800 | $266,300 |
| 2023 | $3,835 | $313,300 | $46,800 | $266,500 |
| 2022 | $3,948 | $320,200 | $46,800 | $273,400 |
| 2021 | $3,298 | $274,400 | $46,800 | $227,600 |
Source: Public Records
Agents Affiliated with this Home
-
Paula Smith
Seller's Agent in 2026
Paula Smith
Smith Family Realty
(317) 690-2524
1 in this area
193 Total Sales
-
Melissa Smith
Seller Co-Listing Agent in 2026
Melissa Smith
Smith Family Realty
(317) 691-1875
1 in this area
132 Total Sales
-
Jared Ruth
Buyer's Agent in 2026
Jared Ruth
@properties
(317) 650-6826
1 in this area
19 Total Sales
-
Angelica Brewer
Buyer Co-Listing Agent in 2026
Angelica Brewer
@properties
(317) 531-1958
2 in this area
141 Total Sales
-
Kristin Glassburn
Seller's Agent in 2021
Kristin Glassburn
@properties
(317) 513-4251
12 in this area
201 Total Sales
-
MR
Seller's Agent in 2016
Mariam Rahmani
In Place
Map
Source: MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative®
MLS Number: 22091291
APN: 49-10-06-161-013.000-101
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website.
Listings courtesy of MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative® as distributed by MLS GRID.
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID
Nearby Homes
- 1421 E New York St
- 1417 E Vermont St
- 342 N Arsenal Ave
- 1337 Marlowe Ave
- 1329 Marlowe Ave
- 1206 E New York St
- 1302 E Vermont St
- 1521 Marlowe Ave
- 215 N Arsenal Ave
- 215 N Arsenal Ave
- 1205 Sturm Ave
- 231 N Summit St
- 1417 E Michigan St
- 1605 E Ohio St
- 224 Dorman St
- 452 N State Ave
- 223 Dickson St
- 1829 E Marlowe Ave Unit 3
- 1831 E Marlowe Ave Unit 2
- 210 N State Ave
- 1407 E New York St
- 1405 E New York St
- 1413 E New York St
- 1403 E New York St
- 1417 E New York St
- 1401 E New York St
- 241 N Oriental St
- 1410 E New York St
- 1423 E New York St
- 1406 E New York St
- 1416 E New York St
- 1420 E New York St
- 1402 E New York St
- 1418 E New York St
- 1425 E New York St
- 1427 E New York St
- 1321 E New York St
- 1422 E New York St
- 242 N Oriental St
- 1406 Marlowe Ave
Your Personal Tour Guide
Ask me questions while you tour the home.