2964 Noyack Rd Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Set on a shy acre, this renovated cedar-shake traditional brings together classic Hamptons style and contemporary luxury living. Originally built in the late 1700s and beautifully reimagined in 2005, the home blends timeless architecture with thoughtfully updated interiors for effortless year-round living. The home offers 3,700 +/- sq. ft. of luxury living space with a total 5 bedrooms, 4 full baths, 2 half baths, detached 2-car garage, heated pool, and a legal guest apartment. The traditional floor plan flows with ease as sunlight pours in through nearly floor-to-ceiling windows, warming elegant spaces anchored by 3 fireplaces. A graceful curved staircase and period accents hint at the home's rich history while adding unmistakable charm. Designed for entertaining, the well-equipped chef's kitchen features a Viking stove, generous island, and dual dining rooms-perfect for both intimate dinners and weekend gatherings. Four bedrooms, including a private primary suite, offer serene retreats upstairs. Outdoors, the 40'x20' heated pool takes center stage, surrounded by multiple seating areas ideal for long Hamptons afternoons. A separate guest apartment offers one bedroom, two baths, and a high-end kitchen for guests or rental income. 2 car garage. Every detail feels intentional, blending historic character with modern sophistication. A rare opportunity to own an authentic piece of East End history, updated for the way you want to live today.Renovations and restorations shine, thanks to the efforts of previous owners Anna and Detlef Pump, founders of Loaves & Fishes and master stone mason, respectively. Detlef worked on many historic restorations throughout the Hamptons, while Anna's vision for Loaves & Fishes remains ubiquitous with the Hamptons lifestyle and is now operated by their daughter, Sybille.