37 Gardiners Bay Dr Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island NeighborhoodAbout This Home
Within close proximity to sandy Hay Beach, this immaculate 4 bedroom, 4 bath cedar shingled three-level modern has the spirit of living in a birds nest with sliding glass doors and porches everywhere overlooking cherry trees and wrap around deck, bay breezes blow throughout gently. The kitchen is a chef's delight, with granite counters, maple cabinets, Viking stove, Monogram refrigerator, Bosch dishwasher, and sliding doors to an outdoor BBQ connected to nearly unlimited propane. The first floor has two bedrooms with exotic sea grass floor coverings and skylights with shades and shared full bath. The second floor has a TV room / study with two balconies with scenic views, a spacious master suite with spa like bath and full bath in hall. The lower level is above grade, featuring a media room which is also convertible to a full bedroom with adjacent full bath. The grounds are sequestered and lovely, with a far-eastern influence. The heated Gunite pool has mahogany decking and lush bamboo gardens, sound system controlled through remote to the home and river stone paths. Gardiner's Bay Country Club just off the yard and sounds of the beach. With a popular rental history, this home has it all for a wonderful Summer vacation! [[Rental Registration # 2024-L-0019]]
Home Values in the Area
Average Home Value in this Area
Property History
| Date | Event | Price | Change | Sq Ft Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 07/19/2025 07/19/25 | Off Market | $39,000 | -- | -- |
| 06/22/2025 06/22/25 | For Rent | $39,000 | 0.0% | -- |
| 05/19/2025 05/19/25 | Off Market | $39,000 | -- | -- |
| 04/03/2025 04/03/25 | For Rent | $39,000 | 0.0% | -- |
| 12/27/2024 12/27/24 | Off Market | $39,000 | -- | -- |
| 11/29/2024 11/29/24 | For Rent | $39,000 | 0.0% | -- |
| 11/29/2024 11/29/24 | Off Market | $39,000 | -- | -- |
| 11/08/2024 11/08/24 | Price Changed | $39,000 | +8.3% | -- |
| 10/27/2024 10/27/24 | For Rent | $36,000 | -- | -- |
Tax History Compared to Growth
Map
- 27 Country Club Dr
- 61 Gardiners Bay Dr
- 64 N Cartwright Rd
- 2460 Shipyard Ln Unit 5G1
- 3345 Cedar Ln
- 2500 Maple Ln Unit 14
- 2500 Maple Ln Unit 10
- 1845 Shipyard Ln
- 2060 Shipyard Ln
- 250 Osprey Nest Rd
- 10 Stirling Cove
- 435 Maple Ln
- 2400 Bay Ave
- 123 Sterling Ave Unit 8
- 151 Bay Ave
- 3a/3b Pandion Rd Unit 3a/3b
- 162 Central Ave
- 600 Shipyard Ln
- 1117 Cedar Ln
- 155 Manor Place
- 37 Gardiners Bay Dr
- 3 3 Gardiners Bay Dr
- 20 Gardiners Bay Dr
- 57 Gardiners Bay Dr
- 0 Gardiners Bay Dr
- 62 Country Club Dr
- 36 Gardiners Bay Dr
- 43 Gardiners Bay Dr
- 60 Country Club Dr
- 58 Country Club Dr
- 45 Gardiners Bay Dr
- 30 Gardiners Bay Dr
- 36 Dr
- 56 Country Club Dr
- 42 Gardiners Bay Dr
- 39 Country Club Dr
- 48 Gardiners Bay Dr
- 28 Gardiners Bay Dr
- 44 Gardiners Bay Dr
- 54 Country Club Dr