NOT LISTED FOR SALE

5 Tuthill Dr Shelter Island, NY 11964

Shelter Island Neighborhood

Estimated Value: $1,166,162

1.6 Acres
$728,851 Price per Acre
69,696 Sq Ft Lot

Last Sold October 22, 2021

Last sale price $920,000

Est. 27% increase in value since last sale

Current estimated payment $6,496/month

316 Days on Market

Highlights

  • Water Views
  • Paddocks
  • Fenced
  • Beach Access
  • Partially Wooded Lot
  • Level Lot

About This Lot

As of October 2021

Exceptional & rare opportunity to build in a coveted & desirable setting on Tuthill Drive on Big Ram Island. A 1.6 acre partially cleared parcel awaits your custom built home with year round water-views of Coecles Harbor. A short distance to Reel Point, bay beaches & The Ram's Head Inn is just up the street.

Last Agent to Sell the Property

Linda Mccarthy

Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty Brokerage Phone: 631-749-1155 License #10401210583 Listed on: 08/04/2020

Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Last Buyer's Agent

Non Member

NonMember

Property Details

Property Type

  • Land

Est. Annual Taxes

  • $3,313

Lot Details

  • 1.6 Acre Lot
  • Fenced
  • Level Lot
  • Cleared Lot
  • Partially Wooded Lot

Schools

  • Shelter Island Elementary And Middle School
  • Shelter Island High School

Additional Features

  • Water Views
  • Beach Access
  • Paddocks
  • Sewer Not Available

Listing and Financial Details

  • Legal Lot and Block 2 / 1
  • Assessor Parcel Number 0700-011-00-01-00-002-000

Property Details

Property Type

Land

Est. Annual Taxes

$3,313

Lot Details

0

Listing Details

  • Property Type: Land
  • Property SubType: Unimproved Land
  • Attribution Contact: 631-749-1155
  • Special Features: None
  • Property Sub Type: LotsLands

Exterior Features

  • Waterfront Features: Beach Access
  • Fencing: Fenced
  • Road Frontage Type: City Street, Private Road
  • View: Water, Other
  • View YN: Yes
  • FloodZoneReportYN: 0
  • RoadFrontageLength: 102

Utilities

  • Sewer: None
  • Water Source: None

Schools

  • Middle School: Shelter Island School

Lot Info

  • Lot Size Acres: 1.6
  • Lot Size Area: 1.6
  • Lot Dimensions: 1.6
  • Lot Size Sq Ft: 69696
  • Lot Size Units: Acres
  • Lot Features: Wooded, Views, Cleared, Level, Part Wooded
  • Parcel Number: 0700-011-00-01-00-002-000
  • Zoning Description: Residential
  • Horse Amenities: Paddocks
  • Lots: 1
  • ResoLotSizeUnits: Acres
  • MinimumPlotSize: 1.6

Rental Info

  • Available Date: 2021-08-13

Tax Info

  • Tax Annual Amount: 3313.01
  • Tax Block: 1
  • Tax Lot: 2
  • Tax Map Number: 0700-011-00-01-00-002-000

MLS Schools

  • Elementary School: Shelter Island School
  • High School: Shelter Island School
  • Middle School District: Shelter Island

Ownership History

Date Name Owned For Owner Type

Purchase Details

Listed on
Aug 4, 2020
Closed on
Oct 22, 2021
Sold by
Caccese Andrea L
Bought by
Rogers Paul
Seller's Agent
Linda Mccarthy
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Buyer's Agent
Non Member
NonMember
List Price
$920,000
Sold Price
$920,000
Current Estimated Value
$1,166,162

Home Financials for this Owner

Home Financials are based on the most recent Mortgage that was taken out on this home.
Estimated Appreciation
$246,162

Purchase Details

Closed on
Oct 21, 2005
Sold by
Barth William A
Bought by
Caccese Andrea L
Source: Public Records

Range of Values:

Collateral Analytics

Collateral Analytics Collateral Analytics AVMs (Automated Valuation Model) employ a number of statistical approaches combined with neighborhood-specific comparable selection guarantees the most up-to-date and precise valuations.

Not Available

Collateral Analytics does not have data for the current month. Please view the chart for historical values.

ICE

ICE Mortgage Technology ICE Mortgage Technology’s AVM (Automated Valuation Model) is a state-of-the-art online residential property valuation tool that provides a quick and accurate estimate of the value of almost any home in the U.S.

Not Available

ICE Mortgage Technology does not have data for the current month. Please view the chart for historical values.

First American

First American First American Data & Analytics’ next-generation AVM combines unrivaled data assets with a blended ensemble of valuation models to produce highly accurate, reliable valuations you can trust.

Not Available

First American does not have data for the current month. Please view the chart for historical values.

Quantarium

Quantarium Quantarium’s valuation service, repeatedly proven the industry’s most accurate and comprehensive, is supercharged with a self-learning and auto-tuning AI engine that continually becomes smarter and more accurate as it processes daily inputs from the industry’s leading RE data lake.

Not Available

Quantarium does not have data for the current month. Please view the chart for historical values.

Average Value
Not Available
List Price
Sold Price
Create a Home Valuation Report for This Property
The Home Valuation Report is an in-depth analysis detailing your home's value as well as a comparison with similar homes in the area

Home Values in the Area

Source: Public Records

Average Home Value in this Area

Source: Public Records

Purchase History

Date Buyer Sale Price Title Company
Rogers Paul -- None Available
Rogers Paul -- None Available
Caccese Andrea L -- John R Lynch
Caccese Andrea L -- John R Lynch
Source: Public Records

Property History

Date Event Price Change Sq Ft Price
10/22/2021 10/22/21 Sold $920,000 -3.2% --
06/16/2021 06/16/21 Pending -- -- --
12/01/2020 12/01/20 Price Changed $950,000 +3.3% --
08/04/2020 08/04/20 For Sale $920,000 -- --
Source: OneKey® MLS

Tax History Compared to Growth

Source: Public Records

Tax History

Year Tax Paid Tax Assessment Tax Assessment Total Assessment is a certain percentage of the fair market value that is determined by local assessors to be the total taxable value of land and additions on the property. Land Improvement
2023 $1,703 $534,300 $534,300 $0
2022 $3,363 $534,300 $534,300 $0
2021 $3,315 $534,300 $534,300 $0
2020 $3,259 $534,300 $534,300 $0
2019 $3,259 $0 $0 $0
2018 $3,213 $558,600 $558,600 $0
2017 $3,213 $538,900 $538,900 $0
2016 $2,962 $486,300 $486,300 $0
2015 -- $486,300 $486,300 $0
2014 -- $473,100 $473,100 $0
Source: Public Records

Agents Affiliated with this Home

  • Linda Mccarthy

    Seller's Agent in 2021

    Linda Mccarthy

    Daniel Gale Sotheby's

    (631) 749-1155

    22 in this area

    22 Total Sales

    Linda Mccarthy
    Section Image

  • N

    Buyer's Agent in 2021

    Non Member

    NonMember

See All Agents

Map

Source: OneKey® MLS

MLS Number: KEY3239682

OneKey® MLS

APN: 0700-011-00-01-00-002-000

New York Suffolk County Shelter Island 11964 Shelter Island

5 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island, NY

This home is located at 5 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964 since 04 August 2020 and is currently estimated at $1,166,162. 5 Tuthill Dr is a home located in Suffolk County with nearby schools including Shelter Island School.

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.

OneKey® MLS The data relating to real estate for sale or lease on this web site comes in part from OneKey® MLS. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Ten-X are marked with the OneKey® MLS logo or an abbreviated logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker.
IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Copyright 2025 OneKey® MLS. All rights reserved.

Nearby Homes