Section Image
Andrew McElhinney buyer's agent for 8 Baylies Way, Edgartown, MA - sold for $700,000
Sold $700,000
Andrew McElhinney buyer's agent for 12 Bellevue Rd, Oak Bluffs, MA - sold for $875,000
Sold $875,000

Andrew McElhinney

Osterville MA
5.0stars, 1 Review
Compass Massachusetts, LLC
9 Closed Sales
$16.5M Total Value
$700K - $6.4M Price Range
$1.8M Average Price
Prior 5 years

About Andrew

Andrew is a Martha's Vineyard native who is eager to share his expertise with those looking to call the island their home. He joined the real estate industry in 2017 and continues to grow his success each year. Andrew has handled many sales during his eventful career, including one of the most significant sales in Edgartown in 2020. As well as the sale of the iconic Cagney Estate, the 70-acre real estate assemblage in Chilmark that once belonged to the '40s movie star Jimmy Cagney. Andrew prides himself on his strong island connections and has been a tremendous local source to his clients.

Andrew is a member of the Massachusetts Association of Realtors and the Cape and Island Association of Realtors. In his free time, Andrew is an avid golfer and enjoys spending summer days on the water in his boat.
Home Types: House, Lot/Land
Years of Experience: 8

Transaction History

Buyer Deals

Total Deals 1
Total Value $1,226,500
Average Sale Price $1,226,500

Buyer Deals

Total Deals 3
Total Value $4,176,500
Average Sale Price $1,392,167
Price Range $700K - $2.3M

Seller Deals

Total Deals 2
Total Value $2,425,000
Average Sale Price $1,212,500
Price Range $900K - $1.5M

Buyer Deals

Total Deals 7
Total Value $14,036,500
Average Sale Price $2,005,214
Price Range $700K - $6.4M

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Andrew's Listings and Deals

Awards and Designations

  • NAR - National Association of Realtors

Andrew's Reviews

5.0stars, 1 Review

7/27/20Cecelia DeGregorio

Google Review

Andrew was profession, punctual and a pleasure to work with! Andrew is extremely knowledgeable about the Vineyard and was able to answer my questions in a timely manner. I would absolutely recommend Andrew to future buyers or sellers. He is the quintessential resource for everything Martha’s Vineyard.

Agent License: Massachusetts 448014564
Agent Photo

Andrew McElhinney

(508) 684-5363
(508) 684-5363

Nearby Homes