Mary St George

Penn Yan NY

5.0stars, 9 Reviews

Real Broker NY, LLC

62 Closed Sales

$20M Total Value

$60K - $1.5M Price Range

$321.9K Average Price

Prior 5 years

About Mary

As a seasoned lakefront specialist in the Finger Lakes of NY and the nearby area, providing home-buyers and sellers with professional, responsive and attentive real estate services, she works with sellers and buyers of real estate on their terms. Mary and Chantel Kincaid work as a team with Real Broker NY LLC. Mary lives on Keuka Lake and has an intimate knowledge of most of the Finger Lakes. She is a Past President of the Women’s Council of Realtors, a past board member of her real estate board and served on numerous committees at both the local and state level such as technology, fair housing, BAR committees and Resort Second Home Property Specialist committee. She is on the board at Camp Cory a YMCA camp and member of Profound a business mastermind group. She loves to cook, spend time with her grandchildren and travel. You will find her driving around with her trusted companion Cooper, her pet doodle. If you want an agent who'll really listen to what you want in a home or need an agent who knows how to effectively market your home so it sells, give me a call! I'm eager to help and would love to chat with you about your real estate goals.

Home Types: House, Lot/Land, Manufactured, MultiFamily, Commercial

Years of Experience: 21

Education: Monroe Community College

Transaction History

1 Year
2 Year
5 Year

Seller Deals

Total Deals

Total Value

$3,494,000

Average Sale Price

$291,167

Price Range

$63K - $800K

Buyer Deals

Total Deals

Total Value

$972,000

Average Sale Price

$324,000

Price Range

$260K - $435K

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Total Deals

Total Value

$6,372,999

Average Sale Price

$335,421

Price Range

$63K - $1M

Buyer Deals

Total Deals

Total Value

$2,413,500

Average Sale Price

$301,688

Price Range

$180K - $435K

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Total Deals

Total Value

$11,253,299

Average Sale Price

$321,523

Price Range

$24K - $1M

Buyer Deals

Total Deals

Total Value

$8,705,900

Average Sale Price

$322,441

Price Range

$40K - $1.5M

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Mary is Experienced In

Mary's Open Houses

$399,000 Open Sat 11AM - 1PM
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,585 Sq Ft
3118 Lake To Lake Rd

Stanley, NY
Well-maintained 3 bedroom, 2 full bath ranch built in 2007 and owned by the original owner, situated on a spacious 3-acre lot just minutes from Canandaigua and Geneva. The home features first-floor laundry, a bright kitchen with access to a rear deck perfect for grilling, and an attached 2-car garage with epoxy floors. The partially finished basement offers additional living space along with a

Mary St George Real Broker NY, LLC

Mary's Recent Active Listings

$184,999
- Land
- 1.38 Acres
- $134,057 per Acre
1 Red Cedar Falls Ln

Starkey, NY
Build your dream home or vacation retreat on this premium building lot overlooking Seneca Lake! This NYS Certified subdivision offers peace of mind with a fully approved building site, completed perc test, septic plans on file, and commercial water available. The lot includes a roomy lean-to, perfect for storing boats and gear. Enjoy approximately 100 ft of shared waterfront, complete with a

Mary St George Real Broker NY, LLC

Co-Listing Agent

$164,999
- Land
- 1.35 Acres
- $122,221 per Acre
2 Red Cedar Falls Ln

Starkey, NY
Lot 2 at Red Cedar Falls Lane combines 1.35 acres of elevated beauty with the serene sounds of nearby waterfalls, offering a setting that’s as peaceful as it is picturesque. As one of the largest lots in this thoughtfully designed 11-lot community, it provides both privacy and panoramic Seneca Lake views—the perfect backdrop for your Finger Lakes dream home.One of just nine lots with deeded

Mary St George Real Broker NY, LLC

Co-Listing Agent

$194,999
- Land
- 1.12 Acres
- $174,106 per Acre
3 Red Cedar Falls Ln

Starkey, NY
Lot 3 at Red Cedar Falls Lane offers a stunning build-ready setting for your Seneca Lake dream home. Perfectly situated within an 11-lot lakeside community, this parcel combines expansive lake views, sunset exposure, and a peaceful natural backdrop—all just minutes from the Seneca Wine Trail. As one of nine lots with deeded lake access, Lot 3 includes access to about 89 feet of shared shoreline

Mary St George Real Broker NY, LLC

Co-Listing Agent

$304,999
- Land
- 1.02 Acres
- $299,019 per Acre
5 Red Cedar Falls Ln

Starkey, NY
Lot 5 at Red Cedar Falls Lane captures the essence of Seneca Lake living, offering sweeping, elevated lake views and a peaceful setting within a boutique 11-lot community. This parcel combines serenity, scenery, and well-planned community features—perfect for your lake-home vision. As one of nine lots with deeded lake access, Lot 5 provides access to about 89 feet of shared shoreline, complete

Mary St George Real Broker NY, LLC

Co-Listing Agent

$204,999
- Land
- 1.01 Acres
- $202,969 per Acre
6 Red Cedar Falls Ln

Starkey, NY
Enjoy a front-row seat to Seneca Lake, paired with something truly special—serene lake views and the calming sound of waterfalls from the nearby ravine. It’s one of the few lots in the development that delivers both a stunning visual and peaceful natural ambiance, making it the ideal setting for a retreat or year-round residence. Lot 6 includes deeded lake access to 89 feet of shared shoreline,

Mary St George Real Broker NY, LLC

Co-Listing Agent

$334,999
- Land
- 1.03 Acres
- $325,242 per Acre
7 Red Cedar Falls Ln

Starkey, NY
Lot 7 at Red Cedar Falls Lane offers some of the most breathtaking views in the entire development—wide, elevated, and perfectly positioned to showcase Seneca Lake’s beauty. Whether you’re envisioning a modern retreat or a timeless cottage, this lot provides the ideal backdrop to bring your dream home to life. Located within the boutique 11-lot Red Cedar Falls community, Lot 7 is one of just nine

Mary St George Real Broker NY, LLC

Co-Listing Agent

$1,950,000
- 3 Beds
- 6 Baths
- 6,240 Sq Ft
114-116 Main St

Unit 114

Penn Yan, NY
Historic charm meets refined living in this fully renovated mixed-use building in downtown Penn Yan, minutes to Keuka Lake. The property offers a polished first-floor commercial space ideal for boutique retail or office, with private living spaces above. The first residential level features soaring windows, hardwood floors, and a custom chef’s kitchen with a large island, walk-in pantry, and

Mary St George Real Broker NY, LLC

$229,000
- 4 Beds
- 3.5 Baths
- 2,186 Sq Ft
6176 Lake St

Cayuga, NY
Historic 1860s Home with Lake Views in the Village of CayugaOverlooking the sparkling waters of Cayuga Lake, this charming circa 1860 home in the historic Village of Cayuga is full of character and potential. Offering 2,186 sq ft of living space, this 3+ bedroom home is rich with ornate original detail, tall ceilings, and timeless craftsmanship.Enjoy the beauty of lake living from the

Mary St George Real Broker NY, LLC

$669,000
- 3 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,894 Sq Ft
5397 Buck Settlement Rd

Bath, NY
Welcome to a true nature lover’s paradise! This two-story home with a walk-out lower level offers almost 3,000 square feet of warm, woodland-inspired living space surrounded by 50 managed acres of QDMA-certified forest with miles of trails and abundant wildlife. The home features 3+ bedrooms, 2 full baths, and a convenient water closet in the lower level.Step inside to find a kitchen that’s

Mary St George Real Broker NY, LLC

Awards and Designations

Five Star Agent
NAR - National Association of Realtors
ABR - Accredited Buyer Representative
RSPS - Resort & Second-Home Property Specialist
SFR - Short Sale & Foreclosure Resource

Other Experience

Distressed Properties, First Time Home Buyers, Foreclosures, Investments, Luxury Homes, Military Families, New Construction, Property Management, Senior Communities, Short Sales, Timeshares, Veteran Programs

1/28/23Rebecca Lascari

Google Review

We had such a great experience with Mary! She was responsive to all of our questions and extremely helpful throughout the purchasing process. She went above and beyond to make everything easy for us. We plan on continuing to use Mary for our future purchases. Thanks, Mary!

10/9/22Squirrel Mom Callaway

Google Review

Mary was very patient, hardworking, and experienced with our lake real estate sale. She always was in contact very helpful to ease the stress of closing. She knows alot of contacts to ensure a successful sale.

4/10/22Mary feicht

Google Review

Mary is amazing!! She helped us sell our house when Covid restrictions were still pretty much in effect. Her insight and suggestions were invaluable in getting us multiple offers and top dollar for our home. The professional photos that she ordered were incredible! Mary is very professional, knowledgeable and patient. She is competent and respectful of other realtors and their clients while still remaining unyielding in protecting and meeting her own clients wishes and best interests. We highly recommend Mary! She is definitely the best! And her Instagram posts are surely entertaining as well!!

Agent License: New York #10301203939

Mary St George

(315) 325-8266

Real Broker NY, LLC

(315) 325-8266

Homes for Sale by City

Mary St George

About Mary

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Mary is Experienced In

Mary's Listings and Deals

Mary's Open Houses

Mary's Recent Active Listings

Awards and Designations

Other Experience

Mary's Reviews