

About Michael
My Residential Real Estate experience is throughout the Chautauqua Lake region, including Bemus Point and Lakewood, NY.
My Commercial Real Estate (CRE) experience is in Leasing and Sales of Office, Retail, Industrial, Warehouse and Multi-Family.
My approach to real estate sale is highly interactive with the market. To understand the property, zoning and possible uses of a property and develop a modifiable vision that buyers can build on.
Transaction History
- 1 Year
- 2 Year
- 5 Year
Seller Deals
Buyer Deals
Seller Deals
Buyer Deals
Seller Deals
Buyer Deals
Production Over Time
5 Year View
Neighborhoods Michael is Experienced In
Michael's Listings and Deals
Michael's Recent Active Listings
-
$80,000
- Land
- 11 Acres
- $7,273 per Acre
- 0 W Oak Hill Rd
- Unit R1645913
- Ellicott, NY
10 Acres Bordering Moonbrook Country ClubA beautiful and private 10-acre property located along a secluded lane in the Town of Ellicott, bordering the prestigious Moonbrook Country Club. This peaceful setting offers a rare chance to own land surrounded by natural beauty and quiet luxury—perfect for anyone dreaming of a custom home, family compound, or private retreat.The property
Michael McVinney ERA Team VP Real Estate
-
$1,450,000
- 3 Beds
- 4 Baths
- 3,600 Sq Ft
- 5500 Tastor Ln
- Fredonia, NY
This remarkable lakefront estate offers roughly 3.5 acres spread across four parcels with approximately 300 feet of beach frontage, combining privacy, beauty, and modern comfort in one incredible setting. The home now spans more than 3,600 square feet of living space and has been extensively improved inside and out.A newly constructed breezeway connects the garage to the main house, creating
Michael McVinney ERA Team VP Real Estate
-
$80,500
- Land
- 23 Acres
- $3,500 per Acre
- 0 Baker St
- Unit R1631307
- Busti, NY
23 Acres of Scenic Land Just Outside Jamestown, NYDiscover the perfect blend of privacy and convenience with this 23-acre wooded property located just outside the City of Jamestown. Featuring rolling hills and a peaceful natural setting, this land offers endless potential—whether you’re looking to build your dream home, create a private retreat, or enjoy recreational uses like hunting and
Michael McVinney ERA Team VP Real Estate
-
$697,000
- Land
- 150 Acres
- $4,644 per Acre
- 0 W Oak Hill Rd
- Unit R1631195
- Ellicott, NY
Discover over 101 acres of pristine wooded land in Jamestown, just steps from Moonbrook Country Club. This expansive property is filled with hardwoods and features paths that run from the front to the rear, making it easy to explore on foot, ATV, or snowmobile. Abundant wildlife makes it an ideal setting for hunting and outdoor recreation, while the peaceful natural surroundings also offer the
Michael McVinney ERA Team VP Real Estate
-
$99,900
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,549 Sq Ft
- 169 Hallock St
- Jamestown, NY
This home is being offered "As Is." Located on Jamestown’s desirable west side, this vinyl-sided 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers a unique blend of classic charm and modern upgrades. The main floor features hardwood trim and spacious living areas, while the second-floor bathroom is a standout—approximately 85% complete, it's designed as a retreat with a large walk-in shower, sauna, and jacuzzi
Michael McVinney ERA Team VP Real Estate
-
$67,000
- Land
- 19 Acres
- $3,454 per Acre
- 0 Horton Rd
- Ellicott, NY
Discover almost 20 peaceful acres just outside the Village of Falconer, NY—offering the perfect blend of privacy, natural beauty, and convenience. This serene, wooded parcel is ideal for building your dream home, getaway cabin, or recreational retreat. Lots of trees and rolling terrain create a tranquil setting with ample space to explore and enjoy nature.Whether you're looking to build
Michael McVinney ERA Team VP Real Estate
-
$154,000
- Land
- 44 Acres
- $3,500 per Acre
- 0 Garfield Rd
- Jamestown, NY
44 Acres of Wooded Land with Rolling Hills – Jamestown, NY Area Discover 44 acres of natural beauty just outside the City of Jamestown at the corner of Orr Street and Garfield Avenue. This expansive property features a mix of mature trees and rolling hills, creating a peaceful and private setting ideal for a variety of uses. Whether you’re looking to establish a hunting retreat, build your dream
Michael McVinney ERA Team VP Real Estate
-
$99,500
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,572 Sq Ft
- 2567 Bowen Rd
- Kennedy, NY
Located along a quiet country road, this 1,572 sq ft home sits on a spacious and private 1.84-acre lot, offering peaceful rural living with room to grow. The property includes a two-car garage, a separate workshop, and a storage shed—perfect for hobbies, equipment, or extra storage. A covered front porch adds a touch of charm, and the large yard offers endless possibilities for outdoor enjoyment.
Michael McVinney ERA Team VP Real Estate
-
Co-Listing Agent
$175,000
- 3 Beds
- 1.5 Baths
- 2,760 Sq Ft
- 3 Webster St
- Lakewood, NY
This home is in the heart of Lakewood Village. An amazing corner lot totaling over an acre! Enjoy lake views and it's proximity to all the village has to offer. The bones are there and the potential is great to turn this brick ranch home into an amazing property. Over 2700 square feet to play with and room to expand as needed. Currently the home consists of 3br and 1.5 baths with a huge living
Michael McVinney ERA Team VP Real Estate
Awards and Designations
- NAR - National Association of Realtors
Other Experience
Michael's Reviews
11/20/25Shane Costa
Google Review
Friendly, professional, & responsive.
10/23/24Curtis Knight
Google Review
Great experience! Terrific realtor, great guy and very attentive. Will look to Mike for future real estate transactions.
10/23/24Carmel Knight
Google Review
5/3/24Matt Short
Google Review
I had the pleasure of working with Michael McVinney to purchase my dream lake house, and I couldn't be happier with the experience. Mike was incredibly knowledgeable about the local market, attentive to my needs, and always available to answer any questions I had. His professionalism and expertise made the entire process smooth and stress-free. I highly recommend Michael McVinney to anyone looking to buy or sell a property. Thank you for helping me find my perfect lake retreat!
5/2/24Edward A. Sundquist
Google Review
I have worked with Michael on several occasions. He is proactive, thoughtful, and always professional when working with both buyers and sellers. Excellent outcomes for his client. One of the top of the line realtor & broker.
10/4/23MS
Google Review
Michael was so very helpful w/ our buying out of town experience. Very knowledgeable about the areas and helped us chose the right one for our family and our needs. 100% would refer!
9/30/23matthew dinger
Google Review
Very knowledgeable and helpful. Highly recommend Mike!
9/25/23Veronica Johnston
Google Review
Mike has been an amazing realtor. He was able to find the perfect space for me. He even checks in from time to time to see how we are doing!!! I would definitely recommend working with him, and will do so again if I need to!!
8/16/23Scott Dalrymple
Google Review
Mike is true to his word! When he tells you hes going to do something he means it. Mike worked his rear end off for me and was able to find what i was looking for!! Hand down great guy to deal with!! Thanks Mike!!
1/25/23Steve Furdock
Google Review
Michael Represented the seller of a property that our team helped close on last year. He and the buyers agent worked hand in hand for a smooth and easy closing. He was always responsive on his end and was open to talking with us which doesn't . In the real estate space it takes all parties to work together to have an exceptional experience. I would recommend Mike to any and all clients looking to sell or buy real estate. I've been a loan officer for 12 years and New York closings are always trickery but if you have the right team in place they can be the most rewarding. THANK YOU for your expertise.
10/17/21Don Skelton
Google Review
10/8/21Andrew Graziano
Google Review
Michael’s knowledge and connections within the WNY market are a great asset to anyone looking for help in with commercial or residential real estate. Michael is well known for excellent communication and tenacity in negotiation. He has worked harder for us than any broker we have worked with in the past. I would highly recommend Michael to anyone!
9/29/21Peter Johnson
Google Review
Mike has been nothing but professional, diligent, and hard working to help my business partner and I in finding our next multifamily residential investment property. He has outdone himself, and we look forward to continuing to work with him in the future. He has his thumb on the pulse of the market, and continues to be a highly valuable resource. I hope I don't regret blowing this best kept real estate secret weapon! Can't recommend him enough.
8/10/21Denise Skelton
Google Review
6/1/21Mark Wood
Google Review
Mike is ABSOLUTELY AWESOME. Talk about going "above and beyond"!
I live long distance and he went right over to the building I was interested in on SEVERAL occasions to shoot video, virtually walk me around the entire property, met with contractors... everything.
Can't say enough about this guy... do yourself a favour and work with him you won't be sorry!
4/21/21Gregory Vergotz
Google Review
As a client of Michael’s he has shown a great deal of knowledge about the real estate transaction process. He is a professional in every way and has an ability to communicate effectively and promptly.
Michael has exhibited understanding, great listening skills and in my particular situation, empathy regarding my purchasing of this new home after having lived in my current home more than 21 years and having experienced many life changing family and societal events within the past year.
In closing, I highly recommend Michael to you if your in need of a realtor that will partner with you and look out for your best interest in your search for a place to call home.
3/5/21Peter Hamilton
Google Review
Michael McVinney helped me greatly in a land transaction in the Western NY area and I am extremely grateful for his help. I do not think I would have got the same attention from another realtor and his expert advice was paramount in me choosing a place to buy a piece of land where I could build a home....I must attest to his professionalism, sound knowledge of the pitfalls and problems I may have and in the end his advice which I could only describe as'expert advice' at every stage. Thank you Michael and I intend to use your expertise again in building a commercial property on the PA/NY border and hopefully you help me sell it. I would recommend Michael McVinney above for all for his in depth knowledge of the area....without him I would have probably bought in the wrong area and would later suffer the consequences. Thank you Michael.
2/18/21Edward Lawson
Google Review
If you need a real state agent Mike is the guy too call. Very knowledgeable and professional helped me out in more ways then you can imagine.
1/7/21Rick Hodges
Google Review
I have known Mike , for over 15 years , he is the hardest worker I have known, in the years of our business friendship Mike was part owner a small outdoor billboard company He went out every day searching for.land leasing to put up a new billboard, which he did and from that small billboard company it grow for revenge of over a million dollars. He knows Real Estate and I am here to say you will not go wrong with hiring Mike for your next Real Estate transaction.
12/17/20Ethan von Reyn
Google Review
12/17/20charlie smith
Google Review
Michael Mckvinny was a God sent. He not only helped us find exactly what we were looking for he walked us through all closing costs start to finish. If you are in need of extremely professional agent Mike is the man. Give him a call he is the best thanks again Mike
12/8/20Jason Ruhlman
Google Review
Mike has a great deal to offer his clients in both the commercial and residential real estate markets. He is well connected, well grounded and very attentive to his client’s needs/wants. His professionalism, honesty, integrity and humbleness make him a pleasure to work with and he knows how to make things happen and get deals done.
12/3/20Nathan Bailey
Google Review
Mike has gone above what I would expect from a realtor. He communicates well & follows up.
11/11/20carrie fischer
Google Review
I highly recommend Michael McVinney to anyone for their real estate needs. He is focused, responsive, knowledgeable, friendly, honest and gets the job done! He is very client oriented and a skilled negotiator. I would certainly use his services again!
10/5/20Katie McGarry
Google Review
Michael was an expert negotiator and helped us every step of the way!
9/22/20Crown Street Roasting Company
Google Review
Mike's professionalism and knowledge of commercial real estate is unmatched. He was able to find what we were looking for almost immediately. Highly recommended!!
8/27/20AL SCHAUERS
Google Review
Mike is very professional and personable! So nice to have someone you can trust and who keeps you in the loop. Highly recommend!
8/20/20ENG 1530
Google Review
Mike did a great job, I could not have been happier with is professionalism and knowledge! He made me very comfortable about showing me home to potential buyers . I will definitely be calling him again .thank you Mike , for all the hard work and dedication. Tom W
6/28/20Paul Marlinski
Google Review
Michael McVinney has done an amazing job for recruiting new tenants to my building in downtown Jamestown. He is very professional and quick to respond to phone calls and emails, as extensive network of contacts is of great value to someone looking to sell or rent commercial property !!!
2/28/20Mary Lee Lindros
Google Review
I plan to place my home on the market. Upon meeting with Michael I found him to be very professional and knowledgeable with regard to real estate. I understand he does very well in the Commercial end of real estate as well. I will feel comfortable and have complete trust in him with regard to the process of selling my home.
2/26/20Jerod Zahn
Google Review
There is only one person I’ll share my commercial business with and that is Michael. He’s the most knowledgeable agent in the commercial industry!
12/14/19janet calabrese
Google Review
Mike is a great and professional realtor. He pays attention to what you want and goes the extra mile to help. Very experienced!
12/14/19Amber F.
Google Review
I would recommend Mike McVinney to anyone who is looking for an honest, responsive, and extremely professional agent. When we were looking for the perfect property, he offered suggestions that we would not have considered. His ability to think outside the box lead us to exactly what we were looking for! Thank you Mike!! We LOVE our new place!
12/14/19Mark Calabrese
Google Review
I have always appreciated how Mike does business. If you are looking for focused attention from someone that deems their integrity to be a point of focus, Mike will take good care of you. If one is buying or selling, his knowledge of today's market is as good as it gets. Id highly recommend him. At very least, see for yourself. You will not be disappointed !
12/12/19Darin Souza
Google Review
Michael McVinney was great. As an out of state business, I didn't have a lot of time to search for property. Mike made sure we had a full day of showings scheduled, as well as a tour of the area, we wrapped it up in 2 days. I highly recommend Mike for your real estate needs.
11/22/19Christopher Knight
Google Review
I met Michael this past year and we have purchased some property. Terrific knowledge of the market and of real estate. Mr. McVinney has been instrumental in both the purchase and rehab phases. His construction knowledge is a huge bonus. He goes the extra to make things happen. Always available and very accommodating, I am more than willing to recommend Mike.
4/13/19William Loomis
Google Review
Mike and I have been friends and business associates for the past 18 years. We have been in business together and worked together on other projects. He is extremely hard working, dedicated and committed to every job/work he’s done. If you are looking for a true professional, you’ve found it in Mike.
4/3/19shaunah rudny
Google Review
Mike has been great help to our first home buying search process, he has been informative and eased the stress that comes with such a large purchase!
8/28/18William Prieto
Google Review
I've worked with Mike McVinney on numerous projects from Pennsylvania through New York and I can state, without reservation that Mike is incredibly hard working and one of the most creative deal makers I have ever worked with. He is solution focused, and a consummate professional.